Garibaldi doesn't invade Sicily and Napoli

I am reading "The pursuit of Italy" by David Gilmour and he mentions in the book that Paolo Rossi, a former minister of education, said to him once that Garibaldi shouldn't have invaded Sicily and Napoli.

My question is, how do you think Italy (and the rest of Europe) would turn out if Garibaldi, for whatever reason does not go to Sicily?
 
Likely 'Italy' as we know it would have stayed strictly a northerly entity- with neither Sicily nor the Papal States [the last major holdout] being joined despite having a [somewhat]common language- and there would have been no Mussolini in the next century since the concept of Italy being a united nation destined to revive the Roman Empire would have unthinkable.
 
Last edited:
I suspect that if Garibaldi doesn't invade Sicily and Naples then the Papal States won't be seized by the North Italian state, which I guess is really just an enlarged Piedmont-Sardinia? Though as its king, Victor Emmanuel, assumed the title of "King of Italy" in February 1860, a few months before Garibaldi invades Sicily, I assume the northern state still calls itself 'Italy' as some stage.

I am just guessing here but I am not convinced that Cavour will feel like launching an invasion of either the Papal States or Sicily/Naples? It has been a long time since I studied Italian Unification at school but I always had the feeling that whilst he was pro-active on the unification in the North, in the South he was just reacting to Garibaldi's actions ;)

I wonder if a knock-on might be the northern state doesn't enter the Austro-Prussian War in 1866?
 
Well, the economy of the Two Sicilies will be far better off as a result of not being taken over. I suspect this will lead to Italian and Sicilian mentalities being cemented as different from each other.
 
The Kingdom of the two sicilies was on the verge to become a failed state and the Papal state existed only with the help of French troops...so at least the Bourboun Monarchy risk to implode and in this case Sardinian troops will occupy at least to block any movement deemed too radical.

Rome will be always the objective of any italian goverment, is too important.
 
Top