On the sidelines – Great Game in Mindanao
At the same time as he pressed the final preparations for the defense of Corregidor, MacArthur was engaged in what Rudyard Kipling would no doubt have called his personal "Great Game".
Without any instructions to that effect from Washington and without informing his superiors, MacArthur ordered General Wainwright, that he had sent to command the defense of Mindanao (the Visayas, as we have indicated, having been abandoned), to enter into negotiations with the native Moros living on the island.
………
The Moros had always refused Spanish domination. Until the end of this one (i.e. until the 1890s), the colonizers barely controlled the coast of the territory. After the arrival of the Americans, two major conflicts had pitted the Moros against the new dominant power. It had taken very tough clashes for peace to reign on the island of Mindanao. Throughout the region and throughout the US Army, the military prowess of the Moros was highly respected. General “Black Jack” Pershing was to describe the defense of Bud Bagsak by the Moros in 1913 as the fiercest fighting he had ever seen. About ten thousand Moros, men, women and children, the entire population of the sector, had entrenched themselves on the mountain of Bud Bagsak. Perhaps a third were combatants (although it was claimed that the women took part in the fighting and that two hundred of them were actually killed). Of these 3,500 defenders, at least 1500 were killed in the terrible four-day battle between them and the 8th American Infantry Regiment, supported by two companies of Filipino Scouts and artillery.
………
Although they had remained calm since that time, or perhaps precisely because they had remained so, they could stand in the way of Japanese ambitions to control Mindanao.
This is why MacArthur had asked General Wainwright to seek an agreement with the Moros, under which he could give them the arms and ammunition which the American-Filipinos did not need, to use against the Japanese. . But MacArthur's instructions included another clause, the enforcement of which by Wainwright nearly resulted in him being court-martialed after the war.
MacArthur had ordered government funds in Mindanao and all available gold and securities to be distributed to the Moros as gifts. Wainwright followed these instructions, believing that MacArthur simply wanted to grease the hand of the Moros chiefs.
But the Moros themselves interpreted this act quite differently, a difference exacerbated by the poor communication between the two partners.
The Moros were Muslims, and were familiar with the custom of levying a jizyah, or poll tax, on “infidels” in exchange for protection. Moro leaders in the interior of Mindanao therefore came to believe, during the negotiations, that the US Army troops did indeed want to obtain their protection in exchange for tribute. It is believed today that this was precisely MacArthur's intention, as a far-sighted orientalist. In this way, he knew that the sense of honor of the Moros would oblige them, once the agreement was concluded, to wage a guerrilla war against the Japanese and to protect the American troops when all organized resistance had collapsed on Mindanao.
The understanding of Moro psychology that enabled MacArthur to achieve his ends was essentially based on a very strong personal interest in the Orient, in the broadest sense. He had received an excellent education and took particular pride in his knowledge of Asian cultures in general. There was little in the way of cultural twists and turns that he was unaware of in the whole expanse of Asia. The depth of this knowledge was recognized even by his worst enemies as one of the character traits that could allow MacArthur to play, in certain circumstances, a political rather than a military role.
The time for such a role came in early 1942, and MacArthur used his knowledge to best serve American interests at the time. No doubt the fact that he was not authorized to do so and that he certainly exceeded the limits of his authority could have legitimately exposed him to condemnation if he had survived the war. This was not the case and others had to bear the consequences of the actions he ordered, for better or for worse.
In fact, the agreement concluded between Wainwright and the Moros meant that the latter fiercely resisted the Japanese throughout the war, that they sheltered twenty thousand American and Filipino soldiers on their territory, helped them in their fights and enabled them to avoid to be slaughtered or captured. Until the liberation of the Philippines, almost all of Mindanao was a hotbed of guerrilla warfare. The Japanese were never able to truly control the island; all they could do was send in heavily armed columns which set out from the ports on the coast and ravaged the Moros villages in the interior of the island before falling back. The ports themselves were constantly harassed, and the Japanese were compelled to maintain a garrison on Mindanao beyond what they had hoped for – which was clearly MacArthur's aim.
It was his ultimate victory.
………
But for the United States, the problems began after the war, when the Moros claimed that gifts given to them by a US Army official (Wainwright) in recognition of their supremacy over Mindanao demonstrated that the ancient Sultanate of Sulu had been officially legitimized by the government of the United States of America. Therefore, continued the Moros, the said government could not support the claims of the government of the Philippines on the territory of the Sultanate. This disagreement was at the origin of the Moros' guerrilla war against the Philippine government, which has never really stopped for more than half a century, the Moros always finding a foreign power interested in supporting them in a more or less veiled way. .
Immediately after the war, when the Moros first expressed their position, the American government was painfully surprised (especially since, at the time doing everything possible to have its British, French and Dutch allies grant independence to their colonies, he did not want to be accused of allowing Filipinos to exercise colonial rule over Mindanao). Inquiries and controversies raged for several years, until the guilt for this state of affairs was placed on MacArthur himself - but the latter had long been beyond the reach of any punishment for what remains the most original of his efforts to defend the Philippines.
At the same time as he pressed the final preparations for the defense of Corregidor, MacArthur was engaged in what Rudyard Kipling would no doubt have called his personal "Great Game".
Without any instructions to that effect from Washington and without informing his superiors, MacArthur ordered General Wainwright, that he had sent to command the defense of Mindanao (the Visayas, as we have indicated, having been abandoned), to enter into negotiations with the native Moros living on the island.
………
The Moros had always refused Spanish domination. Until the end of this one (i.e. until the 1890s), the colonizers barely controlled the coast of the territory. After the arrival of the Americans, two major conflicts had pitted the Moros against the new dominant power. It had taken very tough clashes for peace to reign on the island of Mindanao. Throughout the region and throughout the US Army, the military prowess of the Moros was highly respected. General “Black Jack” Pershing was to describe the defense of Bud Bagsak by the Moros in 1913 as the fiercest fighting he had ever seen. About ten thousand Moros, men, women and children, the entire population of the sector, had entrenched themselves on the mountain of Bud Bagsak. Perhaps a third were combatants (although it was claimed that the women took part in the fighting and that two hundred of them were actually killed). Of these 3,500 defenders, at least 1500 were killed in the terrible four-day battle between them and the 8th American Infantry Regiment, supported by two companies of Filipino Scouts and artillery.
………
Although they had remained calm since that time, or perhaps precisely because they had remained so, they could stand in the way of Japanese ambitions to control Mindanao.
This is why MacArthur had asked General Wainwright to seek an agreement with the Moros, under which he could give them the arms and ammunition which the American-Filipinos did not need, to use against the Japanese. . But MacArthur's instructions included another clause, the enforcement of which by Wainwright nearly resulted in him being court-martialed after the war.
MacArthur had ordered government funds in Mindanao and all available gold and securities to be distributed to the Moros as gifts. Wainwright followed these instructions, believing that MacArthur simply wanted to grease the hand of the Moros chiefs.
But the Moros themselves interpreted this act quite differently, a difference exacerbated by the poor communication between the two partners.
The Moros were Muslims, and were familiar with the custom of levying a jizyah, or poll tax, on “infidels” in exchange for protection. Moro leaders in the interior of Mindanao therefore came to believe, during the negotiations, that the US Army troops did indeed want to obtain their protection in exchange for tribute. It is believed today that this was precisely MacArthur's intention, as a far-sighted orientalist. In this way, he knew that the sense of honor of the Moros would oblige them, once the agreement was concluded, to wage a guerrilla war against the Japanese and to protect the American troops when all organized resistance had collapsed on Mindanao.
The understanding of Moro psychology that enabled MacArthur to achieve his ends was essentially based on a very strong personal interest in the Orient, in the broadest sense. He had received an excellent education and took particular pride in his knowledge of Asian cultures in general. There was little in the way of cultural twists and turns that he was unaware of in the whole expanse of Asia. The depth of this knowledge was recognized even by his worst enemies as one of the character traits that could allow MacArthur to play, in certain circumstances, a political rather than a military role.
The time for such a role came in early 1942, and MacArthur used his knowledge to best serve American interests at the time. No doubt the fact that he was not authorized to do so and that he certainly exceeded the limits of his authority could have legitimately exposed him to condemnation if he had survived the war. This was not the case and others had to bear the consequences of the actions he ordered, for better or for worse.
In fact, the agreement concluded between Wainwright and the Moros meant that the latter fiercely resisted the Japanese throughout the war, that they sheltered twenty thousand American and Filipino soldiers on their territory, helped them in their fights and enabled them to avoid to be slaughtered or captured. Until the liberation of the Philippines, almost all of Mindanao was a hotbed of guerrilla warfare. The Japanese were never able to truly control the island; all they could do was send in heavily armed columns which set out from the ports on the coast and ravaged the Moros villages in the interior of the island before falling back. The ports themselves were constantly harassed, and the Japanese were compelled to maintain a garrison on Mindanao beyond what they had hoped for – which was clearly MacArthur's aim.
It was his ultimate victory.
………
But for the United States, the problems began after the war, when the Moros claimed that gifts given to them by a US Army official (Wainwright) in recognition of their supremacy over Mindanao demonstrated that the ancient Sultanate of Sulu had been officially legitimized by the government of the United States of America. Therefore, continued the Moros, the said government could not support the claims of the government of the Philippines on the territory of the Sultanate. This disagreement was at the origin of the Moros' guerrilla war against the Philippine government, which has never really stopped for more than half a century, the Moros always finding a foreign power interested in supporting them in a more or less veiled way. .
Immediately after the war, when the Moros first expressed their position, the American government was painfully surprised (especially since, at the time doing everything possible to have its British, French and Dutch allies grant independence to their colonies, he did not want to be accused of allowing Filipinos to exercise colonial rule over Mindanao). Inquiries and controversies raged for several years, until the guilt for this state of affairs was placed on MacArthur himself - but the latter had long been beyond the reach of any punishment for what remains the most original of his efforts to defend the Philippines.