119
June 17th, 1940
Bordeaux, provisional Senate offices - The man moves forward with a determined pace. In his wake, loaded with a voluminous briefcase of files, the man who has been his faithful chief of staff for almost seven years remains silent. It is because he knows his boss's character and that, from experience, he knows that it is better not to upset him when he puts on the face he has right now - even more scowling than usual! The only Republican guard on duty has just enough time to wake from his torpor of this hot afternoon to announce the visitors, before both of them enter the office.
Since they knew each other, when they were both in the service of a great man, whose memory, in these difficult times, serves as their guide, Jules Jeanneney has seen Georges Mandel go through many states. But now... The Minister of the Interior tries to contain the flood of emotions which invades him to respect the propriety which requires an interview with the President of the Senate, especially in the presence of Max Brusset, his chief of staff. But a real switch appears. After the usual politeness and the refreshment offered in the preamble, Mandel seems to abandon his usual restraint.
- I have just come from a meeting with the President of the Council and several ministers. As you know, we have tried to arrest seditious people who might have followed the Ma...who might have followed Philippe Pétain. In particular, the authors of this... this rag which appeared the day after the meeting at Cangé.
- Yes, I learned it. Only Bonnet and Bergery fell through the net. We must believe that Laval, Flandin, and Déat benefited from warnings or... friendships in high places...
- Friendships!" interrupts Mandel. You mean complicities of an unsuspected gravity. It is not a question of manifestations of renunciation or weaknesses of character as you and I regret that we meet them too often in the corridors of the Government, this one or the previous one for that matter, and even in the Headquarters. It is nothing less than treason!
- Explain yourself," said Jeanneney, giving Brusset a worried look.
- Bergery was indeed arrested and is currently under guard. His papers, or what was left of them, have been inspected by the Sûreté... (He catches his breath.) In addition to their perjured declaration, Bergery seemed to have taken it into his head to draft a motion intended for his party or his parliamentary group, perhaps even the entire Chamber!
Brusset intervenes: "It is not so much this destination as... (Mandel glares at him, he straightens.) I mean, the content is just as disturbing."
The president of the Senate puts on a wary face. What could have put Mandel in such a state? The latter takes out of his pocket a sheet of paper that has obviously been crumpled and more or less unfolded.
- I quote: "This is how a head of government, Minister of National Defense for five years, with the complicity of the leaders of the major parties, the presidents of the two assemblies and
the highest magistrate of the Republic, with the complicity also of journalists enslaved by the government or corrupted by foreigners, has been able to declare unconstitutionally a war that he had been unable to prepare! Or again: "In the middle of a military disaster, two foreign policies have recently clashed. Reynaud's policy aimed at withdrawing from
England, with the hope that the latter, helped perhaps by the United States, could not reconquer continental Europe, obtain a negotiated peace in the naval and air fields. Negotiated in the interests of the British and their supporters! The other policy, that advocated by Marshal Pétain, proposed a form of collaboration with the Latin powers and Germany itself, to establish a new continental order. Here again, ignoring all constitutionality, this solution was forbidden to us by bellicose hands that dared to arrest the most glorious of our patriotic figures! Collaboration! Collaboration! This is pure and simple treason, yes!
- We knew the pacifist intentions of most of the signatories of the appeal launched
a few days ago," says Jeanneney, giving himself time to reflect by breaching this open door. It also allows him to digest the information, but Mandel has the impatience of brilliant people who can't stand it when their audience doesn't gallop at the same pace as him. In his mind, the matter is settled. But he still has to waste precious time
to get his message across, he thinks...
- These "pacifists" [the word is practically spat out] have thrived only too much in this "Liaison Committee against the war" [1] housed in the very heart of Parliament! How many senators were there among them?
- It is not the prerogative of Parliament to prohibit its members from having a opinion, Minister. It is even contrary to our Constitution," articulates Jeanneney, emphasizing each of his words to indicate to his friend of thirty years that he had gotten a little carried away.
- That's not what I meant..." begins Brusset, who doesn't even finish his sentence, interrupted by incendiary looks from both Mandel and Jeanneney. The presence of the chief of staff, in charge of carrying the files found in Bergery's belongings and which prove the shenanigans of Bergery and his accomplices, curbs a little the exchanges between the two friends. His intervention nevertheless calms the tension that has been building up for a month with the dramatic events that shake the country and do not seem to stop. Jeanneney resumes, but with respect for decorum.
- Finally, what do you expect from me, within the limits of my prerogatives, Mr. Minister of the Interior?
- Bergery and Bonnet are under arrest. Laval, Flandin and Déat are on the run, I don't know where, but they could still have supporters. They still have some. Who knows if the latter will not get agitated and try a... a coup? We can't let that happen. Not now.
- What should be done? A meeting of the Houses? A new vote of confidence?
- Certainly not! This would be the best forum to allow all these defeatists to express themselves in broad daylight. Especially since the military situation is going to deteriorate further...
And we will have to leave Bordeaux for Toulouse soon. First of all, we should put the members of this Committee against the war under arrest. Then...
- The arrest of Marshal Pétain, even if concealed as much as possible, has not been without provoking some emotion, whether in the Senate or in the Chamber. I had again very recently
recently had the opportunity to talk about it with Herriot. If the call by Laval and company was shocking, the attempts to arrest them made some people cringe... It is a 70-year old Republic that we have. It is a venerable age [that of Jeanneney...] and that is what gives it its strength. But it is also an age when one does not like to be pushed around too much. I agree with you, I will concede that the Government has finally got the vigor that many people were expecting. Just three weeks ago, how many of us still believed in it? Reynaud? He was still torn between our advice and that of that... of his late mistress. You and I, of course - but in total, very little indeed. That we could attempt this Sursaut, as many people call it, is already
is already almost miraculous, even more so than the successful recovery on the Marne during the Other War. But if, at the time, the Tiger was able to cut through defeatists of all stripes, it is also because the front was located precisely on the Marne. In our case, the front line will soon be the shores of the Mediterranean. The situation is much more dramatic and I think that it must lead us to a greater prudence. What we are about to experience has hardly any precedent in history. This is why my dear Georges, if the turnaround that you have led in the administrations has been as spectacular as it has been fast, I think that I should be a little more careful with my esteemed colleagues...
- But in Blois, the Chamber and the Senate assured us of their support! in a voice that was nevertheless calmed by the reference to Clemenceau, which always has an effect.
- Edouard Herriot, in the name of the Chamber of Deputies, and myself, as president of the Senate, have indeed promised their support to... the political and military inflexion desired by Reynaud's cabinet, says Jeanneney, more constitutional than the Constitution. But faced with a glance from Mandel, who tells him that he knows the verbal stratagems of his former colleague alongside the Tiger, he decides to get to the point. We have assured you of our support, and the Chambers having voted confidence in the Reynaud cabinet have already given their confidence in him to lead the current war. However, we will not allow the executive power to neglect the legislative power, at the risk of breaking the constitutional balance.
- You are playing with words! To hell with the law courses! I don't care what the Faculty thinks of it!
- But, Georges, what do you want in the end? Jeanneney screams in a calculated way. His abrupt familiarity seeks to pique Mandel, who generally prefers to keep a certain distance from all his interlocutors, even those he has known for three decades. With good reason, Mandel remainssilent for a few moments, and Jeanneney resumes: "You want to arrest all those who do not go our way - I advise you not to do so. But you don't want the Chambers to be convened for all that, for fear that Laval's accomplices among the senators and Bergery among the deputies might make announcements that would negate the government's action. I speak of the Constitution and in return I get jeers! What do you expect from Parliament, Mr. Minister of the Interior? I mean, in conformity with its field of action defined by..."
- Yes, I understand. Yes, I understand. Thank you. Mandel looks at his interlocutor with the knowing air of those who have been seeing each other for a long time and know each other's excesses by heart. He continues: "What we want to avoid is that if we neglect the parliamentarians too much, once the Army and the Government have been moved, someone with bad intentions could try to gather a quorum and disown us. But for the moment, a vote in Parliament is out of the question... Not with everything that is going on, not when the admirers of Pétain are laying siege to his hospital room, waiting for a resurrection and a truly miraculous word.
- I understand, Minister. The leading figures of the parliamentary groups, in the Senate as well as in the Chamber, are going in our direction. Herriot and I did not wait to discover to discover Bergery's activities to start preparing the groundwork. I will ask Marin to come. He is in charge of relations with the Parliament, after all... We will meet tonight to agree on a common action plan. We need to launch a joint action plan at the level of the different groups, since this cannot be done at the level of the Parliament. A call to follow the government in its... déménagement. Its Grand Déménagement even! I don't know which journalist said in an editorial this morning.
"Grand Déménagement" - the term causes Mandel to chuckle, the equivalent for everyone else of an amused smile.
- And so we will be able to counter the defeatist opposition... Brusset murmurs in an attempt to try to remind them that he exists. The two pairs of eyes pointed in his direction make him immediately regret having tried.
- Good formula," Jeanneney reassures him, a little paternalistic. Then he turns to Mandel, as if to conclude and move on: "The groups will meet in Toulouse at the call of their leaders, the matter is settled. But, speaking of opposition...Daladier? Really?"
- I know your opinion of the man... And on his action when he was President of the Council, but... Mandel tries to justify, although he shares his friend's opinion.
- Of his action! Of his inaction, rather! It would take a government tightened around five or six strong and especially active ministers! That's what I've always thought these last few months and it is what it was necessary to do! Under Daladier or under the first Reynaud ministry!
- Yes, but things are going in the right direction! The direction that should have been followed for a long time
long time, it is true...
- It was about time! But the rumors that ran all April and until early May about the previous President of the Council and on... other personalities will not have escaped the ears of Mr. Minister! [2]
- It was only rumors," replies Mandel. Then, after a heavy silence that does not convince Jeanneney: "Better that he be inside than outside.
- Hmm... Let's hope that this team will last the distance. And so does our President of the Council...
- I know he's not the one who was necessarily in your favor in spring...
- Indeed. I think that Herriot would have been preferable. We would have gained in romantic harangue. Perhaps not necessarily in energy, in continuity or even simply in
faith! But anyway... Since you didn't want to go anyway... [knowing wink]. I feared that Reynaud, although willing, would be caught up in the pressures of his dubious entourage. Fortunately, fate proved me wrong... By a small margin, but it proved me wrong.
After having meditated for a long time on the blows of fate that France has known these last few days, the former director of cabinet and the former under-secretary of state under Clemenceau's presidency, both rise simultaneously to greet each other, each still having much to do so that France can continue... to continue the war.
[1] The "Liaison Committee against the War" was a group of parliamentarians of about fifteen members in which, during the Drôle de Guerre, supporters of Joseph Caillaux, such Montigny, could exchange with deputies of the far right, such as Tixier-Vignancour, and with patent pacifists of the SFIO: Brunet, Rives... Frightened by the continuous rise of his influence, Edouard Daladier thought he saw the work of Pierre Laval - the future would show that he was probably right.
[2] From the fall of the Daladier ministry, at the end of March, and until the end of May, the Chamber and the Senate were full of insistent rumors affirming that the Bull of the Vaucluse sought to retrieve the Presidency of the Council, helped in this by... Pierre Laval, to whom he would have entrusted the Foreign Affairs in order to get along with Italy, and by Marcel Déat, for the Economy! If rumors remain rumors, Marcel Déat, in his Memoirs written after the war in exile, was to confirm the information - but his sincerity is open to question. In any case, many parliamentarians had taken this possibility at face value.
Bordeaux, provisional Senate offices - The man moves forward with a determined pace. In his wake, loaded with a voluminous briefcase of files, the man who has been his faithful chief of staff for almost seven years remains silent. It is because he knows his boss's character and that, from experience, he knows that it is better not to upset him when he puts on the face he has right now - even more scowling than usual! The only Republican guard on duty has just enough time to wake from his torpor of this hot afternoon to announce the visitors, before both of them enter the office.
Since they knew each other, when they were both in the service of a great man, whose memory, in these difficult times, serves as their guide, Jules Jeanneney has seen Georges Mandel go through many states. But now... The Minister of the Interior tries to contain the flood of emotions which invades him to respect the propriety which requires an interview with the President of the Senate, especially in the presence of Max Brusset, his chief of staff. But a real switch appears. After the usual politeness and the refreshment offered in the preamble, Mandel seems to abandon his usual restraint.
- I have just come from a meeting with the President of the Council and several ministers. As you know, we have tried to arrest seditious people who might have followed the Ma...who might have followed Philippe Pétain. In particular, the authors of this... this rag which appeared the day after the meeting at Cangé.
- Yes, I learned it. Only Bonnet and Bergery fell through the net. We must believe that Laval, Flandin, and Déat benefited from warnings or... friendships in high places...
- Friendships!" interrupts Mandel. You mean complicities of an unsuspected gravity. It is not a question of manifestations of renunciation or weaknesses of character as you and I regret that we meet them too often in the corridors of the Government, this one or the previous one for that matter, and even in the Headquarters. It is nothing less than treason!
- Explain yourself," said Jeanneney, giving Brusset a worried look.
- Bergery was indeed arrested and is currently under guard. His papers, or what was left of them, have been inspected by the Sûreté... (He catches his breath.) In addition to their perjured declaration, Bergery seemed to have taken it into his head to draft a motion intended for his party or his parliamentary group, perhaps even the entire Chamber!
Brusset intervenes: "It is not so much this destination as... (Mandel glares at him, he straightens.) I mean, the content is just as disturbing."
The president of the Senate puts on a wary face. What could have put Mandel in such a state? The latter takes out of his pocket a sheet of paper that has obviously been crumpled and more or less unfolded.
- I quote: "This is how a head of government, Minister of National Defense for five years, with the complicity of the leaders of the major parties, the presidents of the two assemblies and
the highest magistrate of the Republic, with the complicity also of journalists enslaved by the government or corrupted by foreigners, has been able to declare unconstitutionally a war that he had been unable to prepare! Or again: "In the middle of a military disaster, two foreign policies have recently clashed. Reynaud's policy aimed at withdrawing from
England, with the hope that the latter, helped perhaps by the United States, could not reconquer continental Europe, obtain a negotiated peace in the naval and air fields. Negotiated in the interests of the British and their supporters! The other policy, that advocated by Marshal Pétain, proposed a form of collaboration with the Latin powers and Germany itself, to establish a new continental order. Here again, ignoring all constitutionality, this solution was forbidden to us by bellicose hands that dared to arrest the most glorious of our patriotic figures! Collaboration! Collaboration! This is pure and simple treason, yes!
- We knew the pacifist intentions of most of the signatories of the appeal launched
a few days ago," says Jeanneney, giving himself time to reflect by breaching this open door. It also allows him to digest the information, but Mandel has the impatience of brilliant people who can't stand it when their audience doesn't gallop at the same pace as him. In his mind, the matter is settled. But he still has to waste precious time
to get his message across, he thinks...
- These "pacifists" [the word is practically spat out] have thrived only too much in this "Liaison Committee against the war" [1] housed in the very heart of Parliament! How many senators were there among them?
- It is not the prerogative of Parliament to prohibit its members from having a opinion, Minister. It is even contrary to our Constitution," articulates Jeanneney, emphasizing each of his words to indicate to his friend of thirty years that he had gotten a little carried away.
- That's not what I meant..." begins Brusset, who doesn't even finish his sentence, interrupted by incendiary looks from both Mandel and Jeanneney. The presence of the chief of staff, in charge of carrying the files found in Bergery's belongings and which prove the shenanigans of Bergery and his accomplices, curbs a little the exchanges between the two friends. His intervention nevertheless calms the tension that has been building up for a month with the dramatic events that shake the country and do not seem to stop. Jeanneney resumes, but with respect for decorum.
- Finally, what do you expect from me, within the limits of my prerogatives, Mr. Minister of the Interior?
- Bergery and Bonnet are under arrest. Laval, Flandin and Déat are on the run, I don't know where, but they could still have supporters. They still have some. Who knows if the latter will not get agitated and try a... a coup? We can't let that happen. Not now.
- What should be done? A meeting of the Houses? A new vote of confidence?
- Certainly not! This would be the best forum to allow all these defeatists to express themselves in broad daylight. Especially since the military situation is going to deteriorate further...
And we will have to leave Bordeaux for Toulouse soon. First of all, we should put the members of this Committee against the war under arrest. Then...
- The arrest of Marshal Pétain, even if concealed as much as possible, has not been without provoking some emotion, whether in the Senate or in the Chamber. I had again very recently
recently had the opportunity to talk about it with Herriot. If the call by Laval and company was shocking, the attempts to arrest them made some people cringe... It is a 70-year old Republic that we have. It is a venerable age [that of Jeanneney...] and that is what gives it its strength. But it is also an age when one does not like to be pushed around too much. I agree with you, I will concede that the Government has finally got the vigor that many people were expecting. Just three weeks ago, how many of us still believed in it? Reynaud? He was still torn between our advice and that of that... of his late mistress. You and I, of course - but in total, very little indeed. That we could attempt this Sursaut, as many people call it, is already
is already almost miraculous, even more so than the successful recovery on the Marne during the Other War. But if, at the time, the Tiger was able to cut through defeatists of all stripes, it is also because the front was located precisely on the Marne. In our case, the front line will soon be the shores of the Mediterranean. The situation is much more dramatic and I think that it must lead us to a greater prudence. What we are about to experience has hardly any precedent in history. This is why my dear Georges, if the turnaround that you have led in the administrations has been as spectacular as it has been fast, I think that I should be a little more careful with my esteemed colleagues...
- But in Blois, the Chamber and the Senate assured us of their support! in a voice that was nevertheless calmed by the reference to Clemenceau, which always has an effect.
- Edouard Herriot, in the name of the Chamber of Deputies, and myself, as president of the Senate, have indeed promised their support to... the political and military inflexion desired by Reynaud's cabinet, says Jeanneney, more constitutional than the Constitution. But faced with a glance from Mandel, who tells him that he knows the verbal stratagems of his former colleague alongside the Tiger, he decides to get to the point. We have assured you of our support, and the Chambers having voted confidence in the Reynaud cabinet have already given their confidence in him to lead the current war. However, we will not allow the executive power to neglect the legislative power, at the risk of breaking the constitutional balance.
- You are playing with words! To hell with the law courses! I don't care what the Faculty thinks of it!
- But, Georges, what do you want in the end? Jeanneney screams in a calculated way. His abrupt familiarity seeks to pique Mandel, who generally prefers to keep a certain distance from all his interlocutors, even those he has known for three decades. With good reason, Mandel remainssilent for a few moments, and Jeanneney resumes: "You want to arrest all those who do not go our way - I advise you not to do so. But you don't want the Chambers to be convened for all that, for fear that Laval's accomplices among the senators and Bergery among the deputies might make announcements that would negate the government's action. I speak of the Constitution and in return I get jeers! What do you expect from Parliament, Mr. Minister of the Interior? I mean, in conformity with its field of action defined by..."
- Yes, I understand. Yes, I understand. Thank you. Mandel looks at his interlocutor with the knowing air of those who have been seeing each other for a long time and know each other's excesses by heart. He continues: "What we want to avoid is that if we neglect the parliamentarians too much, once the Army and the Government have been moved, someone with bad intentions could try to gather a quorum and disown us. But for the moment, a vote in Parliament is out of the question... Not with everything that is going on, not when the admirers of Pétain are laying siege to his hospital room, waiting for a resurrection and a truly miraculous word.
- I understand, Minister. The leading figures of the parliamentary groups, in the Senate as well as in the Chamber, are going in our direction. Herriot and I did not wait to discover to discover Bergery's activities to start preparing the groundwork. I will ask Marin to come. He is in charge of relations with the Parliament, after all... We will meet tonight to agree on a common action plan. We need to launch a joint action plan at the level of the different groups, since this cannot be done at the level of the Parliament. A call to follow the government in its... déménagement. Its Grand Déménagement even! I don't know which journalist said in an editorial this morning.
"Grand Déménagement" - the term causes Mandel to chuckle, the equivalent for everyone else of an amused smile.
- And so we will be able to counter the defeatist opposition... Brusset murmurs in an attempt to try to remind them that he exists. The two pairs of eyes pointed in his direction make him immediately regret having tried.
- Good formula," Jeanneney reassures him, a little paternalistic. Then he turns to Mandel, as if to conclude and move on: "The groups will meet in Toulouse at the call of their leaders, the matter is settled. But, speaking of opposition...Daladier? Really?"
- I know your opinion of the man... And on his action when he was President of the Council, but... Mandel tries to justify, although he shares his friend's opinion.
- Of his action! Of his inaction, rather! It would take a government tightened around five or six strong and especially active ministers! That's what I've always thought these last few months and it is what it was necessary to do! Under Daladier or under the first Reynaud ministry!
- Yes, but things are going in the right direction! The direction that should have been followed for a long time
long time, it is true...
- It was about time! But the rumors that ran all April and until early May about the previous President of the Council and on... other personalities will not have escaped the ears of Mr. Minister! [2]
- It was only rumors," replies Mandel. Then, after a heavy silence that does not convince Jeanneney: "Better that he be inside than outside.
- Hmm... Let's hope that this team will last the distance. And so does our President of the Council...
- I know he's not the one who was necessarily in your favor in spring...
- Indeed. I think that Herriot would have been preferable. We would have gained in romantic harangue. Perhaps not necessarily in energy, in continuity or even simply in
faith! But anyway... Since you didn't want to go anyway... [knowing wink]. I feared that Reynaud, although willing, would be caught up in the pressures of his dubious entourage. Fortunately, fate proved me wrong... By a small margin, but it proved me wrong.
After having meditated for a long time on the blows of fate that France has known these last few days, the former director of cabinet and the former under-secretary of state under Clemenceau's presidency, both rise simultaneously to greet each other, each still having much to do so that France can continue... to continue the war.
[1] The "Liaison Committee against the War" was a group of parliamentarians of about fifteen members in which, during the Drôle de Guerre, supporters of Joseph Caillaux, such Montigny, could exchange with deputies of the far right, such as Tixier-Vignancour, and with patent pacifists of the SFIO: Brunet, Rives... Frightened by the continuous rise of his influence, Edouard Daladier thought he saw the work of Pierre Laval - the future would show that he was probably right.
[2] From the fall of the Daladier ministry, at the end of March, and until the end of May, the Chamber and the Senate were full of insistent rumors affirming that the Bull of the Vaucluse sought to retrieve the Presidency of the Council, helped in this by... Pierre Laval, to whom he would have entrusted the Foreign Affairs in order to get along with Italy, and by Marcel Déat, for the Economy! If rumors remain rumors, Marcel Déat, in his Memoirs written after the war in exile, was to confirm the information - but his sincerity is open to question. In any case, many parliamentarians had taken this possibility at face value.