End of Nazism without war

Assuming that there had never been a second world war and Nazism continued until the late 40s or early 50s when, finally, the irresponsible Nazi economic policies and the world boycott made it succumb and democracy returned without a military occupation, as Would German society have dealt with that? Would Nazism be such a taboo topic in Germany today? Would student protests in '68 occur in the same way?
 
The atrocities committed by the Nazi regime would ensure that it'd always be taboo in some format, however I think you'd potentially see more attempts to whitewash history as seen in Chile with Pinochet or Franco's Spain. I think you'd probably see more socially conservative parties doing well in Germany, particularly as the children of the Hitler Youth grow older, and you may even see some pen glorification of Nazism on the German right as seen in Italy with Mussolini and fascism.
 
In OTL German economy was already almost collapsing just before WW2. So whole regime hardly is going survive much longer. And I am not sure if Germany would become totally international pariah. Without WW2 there hardly is Holocaust altough life of Jews would be still hard and very restricted. But world probably wouldn't care that. Holocaust was that which pretty effectively killed antisemitism.
 
In OTL German economy was already almost collapsing just before WW2. So whole regime hardly is going survive much longer. And I am not sure if Germany would become totally international pariah. Without WW2 there hardly is Holocaust altough life of Jews would be still hard and very restricted. But world probably wouldn't care that. Holocaust was that which pretty effectively killed antisemitism.
Except the logical conclusion--indeed, the only "right" conclusion to Hitler and his supporters--to Nazism was the complete annihilation of Judaism. The Holocaust definitely still happens, even if it will bankrupt and collapse the entire regime. Because that was their end goal, the only way forward they could see.
 
Even if there was no WW2 there probably would be smaller wars around the world in which Germany would have take part somehow. An example: Spanish Civil War. Three-polar world with Fascism, Communism and Democratic countries would be difficult to predict which two system would find them aligned against the third in the "bush wars".
 
This is very feasible without WW2, fascism isn't durable the way a communist regime is. Right-wing dictatorships, even one-party fascist states, rarely survive the death of their founder. Italian Fascism's lack of mass support and popular mobilization was readily apparent after the invasion of Sicily and the Grand Council's suspension of Mussolini. Franco's Spain died with him, and Pinochet stepped down after a referendum. Cuba's communist party is nowhere near being overthrown, and the same goes for the communist parties in China, Laos, and Vietnam.

Nazi Germany had a planned economy even more unwieldy than the USSRs, I doubt it would've survived a decade of peace. The Nazis stuck to the gold standard way longer than everyone else in order to re-arm. Foreign exchange was the area where industrialists and the Nazis clashed most often, rearmament threatened to crowd out exports and prevent a return to international trade after the post-depression recovery. Unless Ludwig Erhard becomes Fuhrer as a nazi Deng Xiaoping analogue, the regime doesn't last past the 70s at most.


 
Assuming that there had never been a second world war and Nazism continued until the late 40s or early 50s when, finally, the irresponsible Nazi economic policies and the world boycott made it succumb and democracy returned without a military occupation, as Would German society have dealt with that? Would Nazism be such a taboo topic in Germany today? Would student protests in '68 occur in the same way?

Have the Allies defend Czechoslovakia, that means the Germans don't gain access to the sizable industry, equipment, and gold reserves of the country. With this Hitler feels a war must be delayed for several more years longer than OTL and eventually the German economy collapses due to bad budget management focused on rearmament of the army. A right-wing, maybe Fascist, government would be put into power and Hitler would probably be forced into a quiet life, he would probably refuse and be killed. Most of the army and industrialists would remain in power however many of Hitler's political lackeys, people like Himmler, Hess, Bormann, etc, would be ousted. Allies would probably sense Germany's weakness and seize on it and try to force them liberalize.


Sad Hitly.jpg
 
Last edited:
Even if there was no WW2 there probably would be smaller wars around the world in which Germany would have take part somehow. An example: Spanish Civil War. Three-polar world with Fascism, Communism and Democratic countries would be difficult to predict which two system would find them aligned against the third in the "bush wars".

If there are a crop of smaller wars I think you will see more naval battles. There will also be less Washington naval treaty style agreements and Japan will have built an even better Navy. There will also be less technical advances and medical studies would likely have stagnated in post WWI... I think you are looking at a spread of Nazism and a near total exticntion of anyone the Nazis declared non-Aryan
 
Top