Eisenhower in the Pacific: Part 1 The Shoestring Warriors of Luzon

Up to the author, but no reason why Eisenhower can't end up as supreme commander in Europe. He will certainly have more credibility from the start.

In the absence of MacArthur is there a strong advocate for a strategy focused on retaking the Philippines? If not, the Southwest Pacific Area, while a Theater Command is really fairly small. Make nice with the Australians, defend New Guinea and the supply routes. Oh, an perhaps even agree with the standing war plan (Orange).
 
Better morale means less likely to panic or become combat ineffective due to stress.

Also letters, and there remembered words, will function as light and an anchor in the effing grim and dark times to come; and as a beacon of hope that maybe they'll be granted a chance to go home to the letter writer.
 
...

(1) I don't know about OTL, but I wonder if ITTL those Philippine nurses will also be evacuated before the rock falls. If not is it "racism" or are the Filipino nurses volunteering to stay hoping to avoid the excesses white/European nurses would be subject to.

In the Japanese world view the Japanese had a superiority complex with Chinese and an inferiority complex with Westerns. For example in Malaya Malay-Malayans in the Volunteer Defence Corps units which were disbanded before the surrender were not rounded up into POW camps, as to the Japanese as they were neither Westerners or Chinese. On the other hand Chinese-Malayans in the Volunteer Defence Corps unit were massacred - mainly Sook Ching with circa 50,000 plus.

So Filipino nurses volunteering to stay I would suggest have a better chance of post-surrender treatment than Chinese or Western servicewomen.
 
The author has already given us a clue about this.
(Hint: It's in the title of the thread).

additional authors note: This will be the first of three stories about the role of General Eisenhower in the Pacific War before his departure in late 1943 to take command of Allied Forces Europe. An alternate path but one I think his unique personality and abilities would have placed him. He was simply better than anyone in World War II at forming disparate national military forces into a team and his selection in my opinion was the best decision Marshall ever made.

You had me for a while, had to go back and see if I remembered correctly.
 
The Second Bombardment
The Lull May 15-May 21
The Japanese are forced to call a short halt to their full scale bombardment as ammunition has to be moved up, a number of guns have worn out from continuous firing, and the malarial epidemic has reached its peak, with many guns operating with half or less of their gun crews and those that are not sick are exhausted. Only the Kondo Detachment continues its nightly harassment shelling, while the Japanese Army Air Force continues its daily bombing efforts. Little actual damage is inflicted on either Fort Mills or Fort Hughes but counter battery efforts by the mortars of Battery Way and Battery Geary continue to be unsuccessful in silencing the Japanese harassment attacks. The Americans do try an experiment, firing several 12 inch mortar rounds at a particularly large Japanese air raid in hopes that the fuses can be adjusted to inflict a nasty shock on the Japanese. This effort however fails due to technical reasons and is not attempted again. With one of the 3 inch antiaircraft batteries wiped out (Battery Denver), and with radar and many of the spotting stations damaged or knocked out, fire is becoming less effective against the Japanese raids, although at least 60 Japanese bombers have been shot down by Harbor Defense Command since the start of the war. This slackening of American effectiveness is noted however and the bombardment plan for the next stage of the battle is adjusted accordingly.


The 2nd Bombardment May 21-24
The commanding general of the 7th Artillery Command orders the 75 mm guns to remain silent this time, as they are only drawing fire and doing little effective work. His 105 mm guns are given a general area bombardment mission, with the goal of knocking out communications and preventing day time movement and repairs. His heavier guns are given the mission of silencing gun positions, with the 150 howitzers and guns targeting known and identified antiaircraft batteries, while the 240 mm howitzers concentrate on the American 12 inch guns and mortars.

The air bombardment is also modified. The medium bombers are switched to night attacks with the goal of harassment and keeping the Americans busy while landing craft are moved to Marivelles and Cavite from Subic Bay since a small gap in the minefield between Bataan and Corregidor has finally been created. The light bombers are ordered to press their attacks on Fort Hughes, which needs to be neutralized, and the Kondo Detachment is given the day time mission of knocking out its antiaircraft guns.

The bombardment is ferocious and inflicts terrible damage. The most catastrophic is a 240 mm round that penetrates an already badly beat up magazine at Battery Geary and sets off a massive explosion that wipes out all but one of the eight 12 inch mortars (leaving only an old M1896 operational) and killing or wounding most of the battery personnel. But while not as spectacular, the constant shelling knocks out the guns of Battery Smith (12 inch) Battery Crockett (12 inch guns), Battery Morrison (6 inch), Battery Chicago (3 inch AA), Battery Rock Point (155 semi-fixed), Battery Stockade (155 semi-fixed), Battery Grubbs (10 inch) and all but one of the mortars of Battery Way. Only Battery Malinta (a single 8 inch gun which has remained silent to this point and under cover), a few 155 guns and a pair of mortars remain operational. Over half of the 3 inch antiaircraft guns are damaged beyond repair or destroyed, and the targeting systems for the antiaircraft command have all been damaged beyond repair as well.

Meanwhile the Japanese take the opportunity to move their landing craft at night and begin final preparations for an assault.
The Japanese still do not get things all their own way. A lucky hit from Battery Geary destroys an artillery ammunition dump that sets off a chain reaction that also takes out the crews of an entire battery of 105 mm guns, while other occasional lucky hits add to the Japanese casualties, including a 12 inch HE round from Battery Way that wipes out an entire Japanese battalion aid station, killing or wounding the staff and all their patients.

The battery personnel from the knocked out guns of Fort Mills and Fort Hughes are reorganized into provisional infantry companies, and as only a few 155 guns and the 14 inch guns are still active on Fort Hughes, most of that island fort now consists of beach defense troops. The provisional infantry companies on Fort Mills are formed into a beach defense battalion and take over the defense of Bottomside from the Marines, who are moved inside Malinta Hill to form another reserve.


Final Softening Up
On May 25, the Japanese shift their fire. The heavy guns concentrate on Malinta Hill, as the Japanese are convinced that if it can be destroyed the Americans will surrender. Even 400 pound shells can not penetrate through the hill and the tunnels survive, although dust is heavy and by accident the 8 inch gun of Battery Malinta is damaged beyond repair. The lighter 105 and now the 75 mm guns open fire on likely American defensive positions on Tailside and Bottomside, while the heaviest two bombing raids of the campaign, involving nearly every Japanese Army aircraft on Luzon, plasters both islands, and as American antiaircraft fire has become markedly less effective. However a few low level attacks suffer unexpected casualties from a withering barrage of heavy machine gun fire and several Japanese light bombers are shot up, with four crashing into the ocean. The remaining American batteries are ordered to remain silent however, as General Moore is expecting the Japanese to make their amphibious assault soon, within at least another 48 hours, based on the experience of Fort Frank.
 
authors note: Effects of this bombardment are historical. The weight of Japanese fire was massive, with those 240 mm howitzers being particularly devastating and very accurate.

OTL the Americans failed to assigned the crews of the knocked out guns any specific assignment, leaving them only assigned to local defense. In this more proactive timeline, they are given a more useful mission.

At this point the Americans have 4 infantry battalions (1 Cavalry, 1 Marine, 2 Infantry) as a reserve, plus 4 dedicated beach defense battalions and an emergency reserve of 2 battalions of construction engineers who can act as light infantry. The OTL garrison had a reserve of exactly 1 battalion of Marines (who were mostly sailors and air force personnel acting as infantry) so the upcoming assault is going to face a far more capable defense.

The communications problems however remain unchanged, and at this point only a few phones are working (and only for short distances) and all other communication is by runner.

The Americans do however, unlike OTL, have a good supply of star shells for their 4.2 inch mortars (brought in by submarine some weeks ago) and a large number of flares. OTL they only had a few searchlights that still worked and a bare mininum of flares. They also didnt have any armored vehicles, while TTL they have a platoon of tanks and another platoon of halftracks with 75 mm guns, as well as a number of Boys Anti Tank rifles that Ike borrowed from the Australian Army and had sent to General Moore.
 
authors note: Effects of this bombardment are historical. The weight of Japanese fire was massive, with those 240 mm howitzers being particularly devastating and very accurate.

OTL the Americans failed to assigned the crews of the knocked out guns any specific assignment, leaving them only assigned to local defense. In this more proactive timeline, they are given a more useful mission.

At this point the Americans have 4 infantry battalions (1 Cavalry, 1 Marine, 2 Infantry) as a reserve, plus 4 dedicated beach defense battalions and an emergency reserve of 2 battalions of construction engineers who can act as light infantry. The OTL garrison had a reserve of exactly 1 battalion of Marines (who were mostly sailors and air force personnel acting as infantry) so the upcoming assault is going to face a far more capable defense.

The communications problems however remain unchanged, and at this point only a few phones are working (and only for short distances) and all other communication is by runner.

The Americans do however, unlike OTL, have a good supply of star shells for their 4.2 inch mortars (brought in by submarine some weeks ago) and a large number of flares. OTL they only had a few searchlights that still worked and a bare mininum of flares. They also didnt have any armored vehicles, while TTL they have a platoon of tanks and another platoon of halftracks with 75 mm guns, as well as a number of Boys Anti Tank rifles that Ike borrowed from the Australian Army and had sent to General Moore.

Great story. The island surrendered May 6 OTL, they might last another month before surrendering
 
May 25 Landing on Corregidor (Map)
landing on Corregidor.jpg
 
Best bet to remove some of the troops from the equation is to shoot at the landing craft as they approach, probably with machine guns.

Those troops will be Helpless considering they can't really fire back.
 
Cargo Submarines (older mine layers converted to cargo duties(arrive at Rabual on June 5)
Argonaut
Barracuda
Bass
Bonita
can carry up to 125 fully equipped combat troops, 5 rubber boats and their support weapons and equipment or up to 250 passengers (by hot bunking) or up to 60 tons of cargo

A couple of notes here:

For accuracy's sake, of these four boats only Argonaut was built as a minelayer. The other three were fleet type submarines and did not have special mine laying gear.

Argonaut,
although old at this time was in relatively good shape and would have made a decent cargo boat. The B-boats were even older than Argonaut and by this time they were thoroughly worn out. The engines were shot, the riveted hulls leaked oil like a sieve, they were slow divers, and they handled like a laden coal barge when submerged. Just to make these boats safe to take to sea under peacetime conditions would have required extensive and expensive work, work that would have been very hard to justify with all of the brand-new Gato class boats rolling off the ways. They would have been extremely dangerous to their own crews and the likelihood of losing them to operational accidents before they even got to the war zone would have been high. The crews would have viewed taking them into combat with the same level of trepidation as you would sticking your arm into a meat grinder.

But, as the old saying goes, "Desperate times call for desperate measures". That definitely applies to using the B-boats for these runs. God help the crews.
 
A couple of notes here:

For accuracy's sake, of these four boats only Argonaut was built as a minelayer. The other three were fleet type submarines and did not have special mine laying gear.

Argonaut,
although old at this time was in relatively good shape and would have made a decent cargo boat. The B-boats were even older than Argonaut and by this time they were thoroughly worn out. The engines were shot, the riveted hulls leaked oil like a sieve, they were slow divers, and they handled like a laden coal barge when submerged. Just to make these boats safe to take to sea under peacetime conditions would have required extensive and expensive work, work that would have been very hard to justify with all of the brand-new Gato class boats rolling off the ways. They would have been extremely dangerous to their own crews and the likelihood of losing them to operational accidents before they even got to the war zone would have been high. The crews would have viewed taking them into combat with the same level of trepidation as you would sticking your arm into a meat grinder.

But, as the old saying goes, "Desperate times call for desperate measures". That definitely applies to using the B-boats for these runs. God help the crews.

Their deficiencies are why it took some yard time before they were even sent to the Pacific

Assuming they (the B boats) survive, they will not be in the Pacific very long before being sent to some Australian breakers yard so that their steel can be more usefully employed

But yes indeed, desperation indeed to use the B boats (which spent OTL Pacific War as training boats, and not long at that)
 
Best bet to remove some of the troops from the equation is to shoot at the landing craft as they approach, probably with machine guns.

Those troops will be Helpless considering they can't really fire back.

The OTL Japanese landing saw about 30% losses in the first wave, nearly 70%!!! losses in the 2nd wave, but in spite of that, roughly half the landing craft were still operational after dawn and about 2,000 troops were ashore and more or less functional, including some light artillery and tanks

Which was just enough

This landing is facing similar firepower from the shore defenses but a much more capable counterattacking force is available

The historical landing was between Infantry and North Point

The Bottomside Landing was planned for the second night but was cancelled after the brutal losses in the initial landing in OTL
 
They land right in the teeth of two arty units. Two units that have 600-700 men waiting for them. They land in two waves and i guess half the numbers on each. The Japanese are going to be bloodied
 
The OTL Japanese landing saw about 30% losses in the first wave, nearly 70%!!! losses in the 2nd wave, but in spite of that, roughly half the landing craft were still operational after dawn and about 2,000 troops were ashore and more or less functional, including some light artillery and tanks

Which was just enough

This landing is facing similar firepower from the shore defenses but a much more capable counterattacking force is available

The historical landing was between Infantry and North Point

The Bottomside Landing was planned for the second night but was cancelled after the brutal losses in the initial landing in OTL
The Americans are also on the high ground too....
 
Top