I was wondering just what it would take for the British RN to adopt the concept of the AFD/Armoured Box carriers earlier then they did IOTL?
Instead of having Ark Royal being what it was OTL, could we have ATL Ark Royal become the first of the British Armoured carriers, as RN comes to an conclusion earlier that "Bomber will Always Get Through" and that having "unarmoured" carrier deck is not worth carrying larger aircraft complement. ITTL, Ark Royal could be something very closely resembling OTL Illustrious Class, and its reduced AC complement could perhaps see it receiving a sister ship or two... In my mind I had an almost exact copy of OTL Illustrious, as Treaties are still in place and British keep to them, though understandably the ships would be somewhat less refined then their OTL counterparts, due to the timeframe in which they are designed and built. It however could make follow on carrier classes more formidable and refined, with perhaps Indomitable or even Audacious class coming into service earlier then IOTL.
A bit of digression, but it would also be a very nice to see just how aircraft procurement and design for the FAA develops if something like this occurs, and would there be any changes of note. Having their modern carrier(s) being more limited in number of aircraft carried, we could see some of the "multirole" designs come into play earlier then IOTL, with things like Blackburn Skua and Fairey Fulmar seeing service earlier, and because of that seeing some improved Marks come about. I do have a soft spot for many of FAA aircraft, and even many hated and ridiculed designs, could become much more useful if they were ordered earlier and went through some improvements. Blackburn Skua, could be "cleaned up" somewhat aerodynamicaly, and with more powerful engine, like Bristol Hercules, would be a much more capable aircraft. Same for the Fairey Fulmar, lighten the airframe, put a heavier weapons fit (like OTL nightfighter variants woth 4x0.50cal) and have a more powerful Merlin variant installed (Merlin 32?) and FAA would end up not with the best Naval Fighter, but at least a better one then they had to do with IOTL.
So, any takers?
Instead of having Ark Royal being what it was OTL, could we have ATL Ark Royal become the first of the British Armoured carriers, as RN comes to an conclusion earlier that "Bomber will Always Get Through" and that having "unarmoured" carrier deck is not worth carrying larger aircraft complement. ITTL, Ark Royal could be something very closely resembling OTL Illustrious Class, and its reduced AC complement could perhaps see it receiving a sister ship or two... In my mind I had an almost exact copy of OTL Illustrious, as Treaties are still in place and British keep to them, though understandably the ships would be somewhat less refined then their OTL counterparts, due to the timeframe in which they are designed and built. It however could make follow on carrier classes more formidable and refined, with perhaps Indomitable or even Audacious class coming into service earlier then IOTL.
A bit of digression, but it would also be a very nice to see just how aircraft procurement and design for the FAA develops if something like this occurs, and would there be any changes of note. Having their modern carrier(s) being more limited in number of aircraft carried, we could see some of the "multirole" designs come into play earlier then IOTL, with things like Blackburn Skua and Fairey Fulmar seeing service earlier, and because of that seeing some improved Marks come about. I do have a soft spot for many of FAA aircraft, and even many hated and ridiculed designs, could become much more useful if they were ordered earlier and went through some improvements. Blackburn Skua, could be "cleaned up" somewhat aerodynamicaly, and with more powerful engine, like Bristol Hercules, would be a much more capable aircraft. Same for the Fairey Fulmar, lighten the airframe, put a heavier weapons fit (like OTL nightfighter variants woth 4x0.50cal) and have a more powerful Merlin variant installed (Merlin 32?) and FAA would end up not with the best Naval Fighter, but at least a better one then they had to do with IOTL.
So, any takers?