Earlier Old World settlement of Greenland

What if centuries before the vikings Old World Iron Age settlers managed to set foot on Greenland shore and settle there. It was a warm periode after all. Would it have been possible nautics and logistics wise ? Could we see maybe a colonisation from the British Isles or the Basque region via island for example ? Maybe even a Punic expedition ? How would sich a settlement have looked Like ? Would it be possible to reach Newfoundland ?
 
Last edited:
Could we see maybe a colonisation from the British Isles via island for example ?

Seeing as there were Irish settlers in Iceland before the vikings (probably), it is possible. But it would be a tiny stream of people, so few that there probably wouldn't be any archaeological evidence. None of the British polities had the population, government structure or peace needed to undertake anything resembling colonization at the time.

Maybe even a Punic expedition

No. It's too cold, too far away and I doubt that the Punic agricultural package would work well that far north.

Not to mention that there are still Greenlandic natives at this point- either the independence II culture or the Dorest depending on when the discovery occurs.
 
I think a butterfly from a failed or smaller Roman Empire could be continued nautical innovation among the Atlantic Celts, which could see them get the technology to to colonize the North Atlantic earlier than OTL from Britain.

Due to the early nature of the POD and the lack of written historical record, it's a little hard to say specifically what these settlements would look like and what cultural changes will drive them. Perhaps a lack of Roman conquest in the British Isles results in a high population, and we see people emigrating looking for farmland. Perhaps a monastic religion like Buddhism or an alt-Christianity takes root eventually in Northern Europe, which sees monks looking for isolated land on which to create abbeys and hermitages.

If you have the technology to jump to southern Greenland, you have the technology to reach Newfoundland. Of course, the trip would be very dangerous and would be made rarely or only with dire necessity. I can see the need to gather timber becoming important for an alt-Greenland colony, and without the economic pressure to harvest walrus ivory as tribute for the Catholic Church, more resources and time may be spent on going to the New World for timber than IOTL.
 
Top