DOWN THESE MEAN STREETS: Accounts of alternate crime, mystery & thriller adaptations.🕵️‍♂️

[WhovianHolmesianChap]

And Then There Were None (2024)
An MGM film
Directed by Doug Liman
Written by John Logan
Adapted from the novel by Agatha Christie
Music by Marco Beltrami
Cinematography by Roman Vasyanov

CAST:

• Phil Lombard (Benedict Cumberbatch): A laidback bounty hunter.
• Vera Clay (Lashana Lynch): A pensive marketing governess.
• Bill Blore (John Carroll Lynch): A sarcastic retired cop.
• Doctor Edie "Doc" Armstrong (Hong Chau): A deceptively easygoing surgeon.
• Larry Wargrave (Andy Serkis): A mild mannered judge.
• Tony Rogers (Billy Magnussen): A hard partying merrymaker.
• Admiral Doug "General" MacArthur (Ving Rhames): A gruff military veteran.
• Emily Brent (Indira Varma): An uptight religious activist.
• Evelyn Rogers (Aubrey Plaza): A reserved, icy hotelier.
• Tom Rogers (Paul Walter Hauser): Evelyn's husband, a nervous and neurotic hotel manager.
• Voice of Ewan Owen (John Malkovich): The group's mysterious host.

A taut, modernised dramatisation of the iconic novel.

 

[FalconHonour]

This is more of a family secret novel than a 'crime' one, but I can't get the idea out of my head and I don't know where else to put it, so apologies in advance.

The Forgotten Garden (2019) (based on Kate Morton's book of the same name)

Director: Andrew Adamson
Music by John Lunn
Cast:

• Danielle Macdonald and Penelope Wilton as Nell
• Saskia Kemkers and Hannah Saxby as Cassandra
• Ashley Benson as Lesley
• Eliza Scanlen as Eliza
• Sophie Skelton as Georgiana
• Sasha Pieterse as Rose
• Gwendolyn Christie as Ruby
• Charles Dance as Mansell
• Fiona Shaw as Adeline
• Drew Van Acker as Nathaniel

A BBC/ABC adaptation of Kate Morton's sweeping masterpiece, stretching from Victorian London to 1970s Cornwall and 2008 Brisbane, this star-studded family saga is not to be missed!

 

[Driftless]

And Then There Were None (2024)
An MGM film
Directed by Doug Liman
Written by John Logan
Adapted from the novel by Agatha Christie
Music by Marco Beltrami
Cinematography by Roman Vasyanov

CAST:

• Phil Lombard (Benedict Cumberbatch): A laidback bounty hunter.
• Vera Clay (Lashana Lynch): A pensive marketing governess.
• Bill Blore (John Carroll Lynch): A sarcastic retired cop.
• Doctor Edie "Doc" Armstrong (Hong Chau): A deceptively easygoing surgeon.
• Larry Wargrave (Andy Serkis): A mild mannered judge.
• Tony Rogers (Billy Magnussen): A hard partying merrymaker.
• Admiral Doug "General" MacArthur (Ving Rhames): A gruff military veteran.
• Emily Brent (Indira Varma): An uptight religious activist.
• Evelyn Rogers (Aubrey Plaza): A reserved, icy hotelier.
• Tom Rogers (Paul Walter Hauser): Evelyn's wife, a nervous and neurotic hotel manager.
• Voice of Ewan Owen (John Malkovich): The group's mysterious host.

A taut, modernised dramatisation of the iconic novel.

I have to admit, though it's considered a Christie masterpiece, I never cared for the story. Too grim for my taste, I suppose. Still, you've tapped a great set of actors who can portray characters who aren't what they first appear to be. Kudos!

 

[Wendell]

I have to admit, though it's considered a Christie masterpiece, I never cared for the story. Too grim for my taste, I suppose. Still, you've tapped a great set of actors who can portray characters who aren't what they first appear to be. Kudos!

It does not help that the story has had less polite titles.

 

[WhovianHolmesianChap]

I have to admit, though it's considered a Christie masterpiece, I never cared for the story. Too grim for my taste, I suppose. Still, you've tapped a great set of actors who can portray characters who aren't what they first appear to be. Kudos!

Thanks.

 

[WhovianHolmesianChap]

Agatha Christie: Live On Air (2021)
(4 episodes)
A BBC Radio 4 series

• Three Blind Mice (starring Charlotte Ritchie as Molly Davis and Arthur Hughes as Detective Sergeant Trotter)
• Personal Call (starring Hattie Morahan as Pam Brent and Adam Godley as James Brent)
• Miss Marple Tells a Story (narrated by Celia Imrie)
• Butter in a Lordly Dish (starring Ruth Bradley as Julia Keene and Mark Bonnar as Sir Luke Enderby, KC)
• The Yellow Iris (starring Adrian Scarborough as Hercule Poirot)

Agatha Christie's original radio plays, performed live on air for the first time in decades.

 

[unclepatrick]

And Then There Were None (2024)
An MGM film
Directed by Doug Liman
Written by John Logan
Adapted from the novel by Agatha Christie
Music by Marco Beltrami
Cinematography by Roman Vasyanov

CAST:

• Phil Lombard (Benedict Cumberbatch): A laidback bounty hunter.
• Vera Clay (Lashana Lynch): A pensive marketing governess.
• Bill Blore (John Carroll Lynch): A sarcastic retired cop.
• Doctor Edie "Doc" Armstrong (Hong Chau): A deceptively easygoing surgeon.
• Larry Wargrave (Andy Serkis): A mild mannered judge.
• Tony Rogers (Billy Magnussen): A hard partying merrymaker.
• Admiral Doug "General" MacArthur (Ving Rhames): A gruff military veteran.
• Emily Brent (Indira Varma): An uptight religious activist.
• Evelyn Rogers (Aubrey Plaza): A reserved, icy hotelier.
• Tom Rogers (Paul Walter Hauser): Evelyn's wife, a nervous and neurotic hotel manager.
• Voice of Ewan Owen (John Malkovich): The group's mysterious host.

A taut, modernised dramatisation of the iconic novel.

with the book ending?
or the one from the play?

 

[WhovianHolmesianChap]

I'd like to think book ending, but I dunno if any studios would go for it.

 

[Driftless]

A notion, rather than a fleshed out premise....

A Study in Scarlet(2010)
Loosely based on the introductory book of the Holmes series, with the pre-story set in Australia vs Utah of the US, and the Mormon connection eliminated. The emphasis was more focused on the interplay of personalities of Holmes and Watson, with sarcastic wit helping to carry the dialog.

Cast
Sherlock Holmes - Tom Hiddleston
Dr John Watson - Michael Sheen
Mrs. Hudson - Miriam Margolyes
Inspector Lestrade - Richard E. Grant
Jefferson Hope - Brian Brown


The Sign of Four(2014)
More closely based on the themes of Doyle's novel than the predecessor movie. Still, this movie was character driven as well

Cast
Sherlock Holmes - Tom Hiddleston
Dr John Watson - Michael Sheen
Mrs. Hudson - Miriam Margolyes
Inspector Lestrade - Richard E. Grant
Mary Morstan - Joely Richardson
Major Sholto - Nigel Planer
Jonathan Small - Bernard Hill

I'm thinking Watson's take on Holmes, is that he admires and is clinically fascinated by Holmes genius, but he also recognizes that Holmes arrogance crosses into hubris at times. Holmes is too much accustomed to being the smartest guy in every room (except when with Mycroft*) This version of Watson isn't shy about dropping in sarcastic barbs directed at Holmes when needed.

*I haven't got a Mycroft in mind...

 

[WhovianHolmesianChap]

Good cast.

 

[unclepatrick]

How about Peter CapaldI as Mycroft?