You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly. You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
alternatehistory.com
I've set up an article in the wiki concerning this idea, and think it mitigates discussion. I do recall a lot a few people who are just used over and over again as Presidents. Sometimes, I think it's reasonable because there's a lot behind some folks that says they could have or even should have become President. Other times, I think it's just because they're a known name and/or people don't invest time into researching other people.
So what alternate history Presidents are overused to the point where they've become cliche? I don't want to invite a free for all where every Jefferson, Nixon, and Truman (get it?) is listed, so I mean truly cliche.