informationfan
Banned
Hi,
if the entente had tried this, it had more or less these consequences
a.) the entente try to violate the right of the germans to live in one country - so any "war guilt"-surplus is lost. The usa will not accept this violation of human rights - so if the brits and french do it - they need to send a lot troops.. they lack any morale justification, no holocaust or a wrong ideology (like the nazis) exist. So no - they can do it, but it will cause civil war in these new nations... the people in them understand perfectly, why they (the enemy) do it. so you can expect something like the irish uprising, multiplied with 10-100... any government that support this crime will be killed, from left and right and even "peaceful" centralistic people will just destroy anything. so the brits and french will run away as fast as they can... they will loose more as they reach
b.) by doing this they elliminate any chance to get some money - money they need to payback to the usa... so if they do it, they have to spent a lot money (for troops) they lack and they get no money they need.
to summarize: if they do this, they will be defeated much earlier, with the loss of credibility in the whole world (so for example in india the peaceful countermovement will be replaced by an agressive partisan war, so india will go down and be lost 20-25 years earlier for great britain)
the brits and french go bankrupt and fall down because they cannot pay back the money to the usa and they are bound to the new nations in central europoe
they also create a zone of hate - the germans will refight in the first second they can - france and - if they are mad enough to do similar - belgium go down, if their economy crashes (this will happen for sure) and germany can reunify...
the usa will not support the brits and french in this scenario... so i really want to know how they can save their butt
if the entente had tried this, it had more or less these consequences
a.) the entente try to violate the right of the germans to live in one country - so any "war guilt"-surplus is lost. The usa will not accept this violation of human rights - so if the brits and french do it - they need to send a lot troops.. they lack any morale justification, no holocaust or a wrong ideology (like the nazis) exist. So no - they can do it, but it will cause civil war in these new nations... the people in them understand perfectly, why they (the enemy) do it. so you can expect something like the irish uprising, multiplied with 10-100... any government that support this crime will be killed, from left and right and even "peaceful" centralistic people will just destroy anything. so the brits and french will run away as fast as they can... they will loose more as they reach
b.) by doing this they elliminate any chance to get some money - money they need to payback to the usa... so if they do it, they have to spent a lot money (for troops) they lack and they get no money they need.
to summarize: if they do this, they will be defeated much earlier, with the loss of credibility in the whole world (so for example in india the peaceful countermovement will be replaced by an agressive partisan war, so india will go down and be lost 20-25 years earlier for great britain)
the brits and french go bankrupt and fall down because they cannot pay back the money to the usa and they are bound to the new nations in central europoe
they also create a zone of hate - the germans will refight in the first second they can - france and - if they are mad enough to do similar - belgium go down, if their economy crashes (this will happen for sure) and germany can reunify...
the usa will not support the brits and french in this scenario... so i really want to know how they can save their butt