DBWI: WI the Cleveland Browns don't select Donovan McNabb in 1999?

Howdy.

As most sports fans know, in the 1999 NFL Draft, with the first pick, the expansion Cleveland Browns selected...Donovan McNabb, quarterback from Syracuse. But it nearly didn't happen. The Browns were considering Tim Couch, who would go to with the Minnesota Vikings with the 11th pick, but decided on McNabb at the last minute.

So, WI the Browns didn't pick McNabb and instead picked Tim Couch? Among other things, this likely butterflies away the infamous "Philly Robbery" where the Eagles traded their pick, running back Ricky Williams, to the New Orleans Saints for their entire 1999 draft class and the first, second, and third rounds of their 2000 draft class.

And, if you're a Dallas fan, you don't need me to tell you how that turned out--Dallas paid for that for the entire decade, as the Eagles used it to select Dante Culpepper, Joey Porter, and LaVar Arrington, among others. Those draft picks led to the most success the Eagles have had in their existence, even in the days when Bert Bell owned the team, with five Super Bowl wins (three in a row), six appearances, and 9 appearances in the NFC championship game in the 2000s and early 2010s...

It wasn't until the Cowboys selected Andrew Luck with the first pick in the 2012 NFL Draft that their luck, so to speak, finally began changing...
 
Last edited:
It wasn't until the Cowboys selected Andrew Luck with the first pick in the 2012 NFL Draft that their luck, so to speak, finally began changing..
0-16, outanking the Lions, something shouldn't be possible.

If anything McNabb was the guy needed for the brown awful o-line, till his retirement he was always running for his life,


infamous "Philly Robbery
Why is called this over ditka folly, eagles truly wanted Ricky but that offer was so good to pass.
 
The Browns would wind up ruining Couch instead of ruining McNabb like in OTL. I mean, it's called the Factory of Sadness for a reason.

Either way, as long as the Cowboys suck, I'm happy.
 
McNabb should be a Hall of Famer for getting to the playoffs in 2003, the only time he played 16 games. Sad that he had to retire because of injuries.

Worst part for the Browns is their one good season caused them to miss out on the 2004 draft class. The Steelers got Rivers, the Giants got Eli, and the Bills got Losman. Only the Raiders screwed up by drafting that drunk idiot from Miami of Ohio.
 
McNabb should be a Hall of Famer for getting to the playoffs in 2003, the only time he played 16
Yeah the year he torched the Patriots defense in playoffs just to choke badly vs colts.


Worst part for the Browns is their one good season caused them to miss out on the 2004 draft class. The Steelers got Rivers, the Giants got Eli, and the Bills got Losman. Only the Raiders screwed up by drafting that drunk idiot from Miami of Ohio.
Hey Matt Schaub in the browns was decent... before injuries forced him to retire too
 
Top