DBWI: What if the CSA lost the Great War?

Wouldn't it be more accurate to ask if the Allies lost the Great War? It was a team effort after all.

For one thing there wouldn't be a Second Great War, or if there would it might just be radicalised Allies that kick it off rather than the Nazis and the Remembrists.

I guess the secession of those states from US wouldn't occur, which would mean a weaker CSA; a lot of border states joined it after the war after all. I can't imagine them seceding without the USA's radicalisation and loss in the SGW.
 
Wouldn't it be more accurate to ask if the Allies lost the Great War? It was a team effort after all.

For one thing there wouldn't be a Second Great War, or if there would it might just be radicalised Allies that kick it off rather than the Nazis and the Remembrists.

I guess the secession of those states from US wouldn't occur, which would mean a weaker CSA; a lot of border states joined it after the war after all. I can't imagine them seceding without the USA's radicalisation and loss in the SGW.

OOC: Why would the Nazis ally with the U.S.? Would make far more sense if they buddied up with the Confederates, if they were anything like OTL.....
 
OOC: Why would the Nazis ally with the U.S.? Would make far more sense if they buddied up with the Confederates, if they were anything like OTL.....

OOC: Going from the books and what Turtledove originally intended, the USA would become even more radically militarist and irredentist than before the Great War. I figured it'll be another case of parallelism that the series is famous for.
 
Wasn't there a TL someone did a while back where the Central Powers won? Iirc Jake Featherston (a man with no political ambition) became a remembrist (or "freedomite") dictator, (essentially a Southern Fried McSweeney) and engaged in genocide against the CSA's black population (even though he treated the black soldiers under his command the same as if they'd been white or Hispanic) Also London got nuked along with Norwich and Brighton.

Thought it was ok myself, though others had issue with it.
 
Top