DBWI: The "Fab Five" - Best Group of Players on a Single Team in MLB History?

Has there been a better group of players in the last 50 years than the "Fab Five" that were in Milwaukee in the 1980s:
2B Paul Molitor (1978-2000): Set the all-time record for hits with 4,311, and also stole 1,071 bases in his career.

SS Robin Yount (1973-1995): Probably the dominant offensive player with the Brewers from 1979 to 1995, hitting 437 home runs and stealing 403 bases.

RF Dale Murphy (1977-1978 Braves; 1979-1997 Brewers): Hit 503 home runs.

3B Cal Ripken (1981-2000): Best known for not missing a game in the major leagues from Opening Day 1981 to the end of the 2000 season, but also had 3,411 hits and 463 home runs.

CF Rickey Henderson (1979-1990 Brewers, 1991-1996 A's, 1997-2000 Yankees, 2001-2004 Brewers): Played center field, left field, DH, and even first base for the Brewers over his career. He stole 1,064 bases in his career.

All five eventually made the Hall of Fame. So, how does Milwaukee's Fab Five compare with other teams in MLB history? Was this team better than Murderer's Row, or the Mantle-Berra teams of the 1950s and 1960s?
 
The Berra-Mantle Yankees don't hold a candle to this Brewers dynasty. For one thing, the Yankees did not have any bona fide base stealers during the 1950s-1960s much less anyone wh could consistently hit for power AND steal bases.

Also, the Yankees of that era lived and died with starting pitching. Can you name a single star closer from that team? When Harvey Kuenn became the Brewers manager in 1981, he decided to call Rollie Fingers from the bullpen to pitch in the ninth inning and save the game. Prior to pitching in Milwaukee, Fingers would often enter games as early as the fifth inning and pitch the last four innings to get the save. Kuenn's decision to bring In Fingers in the ninth inning to get the save probably extended his career by five more years. The other teams saw the results and decided to wait until the ninth inning to bring on it's star relievers.

Can you imagine Fingers getting 55 saves in 1984 and still coming into the game in the fifth or sixth inning?
 
Top