DBWI: Jewish State in the Middle East

Is there a possibility to have a Jewish State in Palestine? It was a suggestion in 1945 but the Arabs got the upperhand and had their Palestinian state. Palestine turning Communist did cause a mass exodus of non-Communists causing the Jewish population to decline just below a fifth of the total population.

What would a Jewish Palestine look like? More developed than Palestine? Or would the Arab Armies take Israel out before it could be created? The Jewish population was 39% or something close like that in 1945.
 
I can't see that being possible. Arabs are not going accept Jewish state there. Perhaps some autonomous Jewish republic is possible but even that seems implausible. Even if Jewish state would had been founded it would had crushed during next twenty years.
 
If you had a Jewish state which survived, the world would not have had the problem of the DP camps for an initial population of 1.5 million Jews permanently displaced by the war. It took over 20 years before the populations of these camps were resettled given the reluctance of most of the world to accept any Jewish refugees.
 
They wouldn’t survive a decade, there’s just too much opposition to a Jewish State in the Middle East. What would they even do? Occupy the Sinai? Not only that, but it would certainly create a refugee crisis from Palestinians being displaced.
 
I disagree with the other answers, as long as they had enough backing from foreign powers, they could survive.
 
You want a second holocaust? Because that's how you get a second holocaust. You put all the jews in a small place surrounded by people who don't like them very much (to put it mildly)...

I disagree with the other answers, as long as they had enough backing from foreign powers, they could survive.
Who though? The Soviets? Stalin was busy purging the jews from his government and country. The US? They got enough shit all over the world to deal with. UK/France? Their imperialist era were behind them by that point. China? With what force projection and money?

So who's left?
 
Perhaps if their energies had been diverted to building such a state they would not have so completely destroyed Europe. Who would have thought the old libel of poisoning the wells would come back to bite Christian Europe in the ass so thoroughly?
 
Perhaps if their energies had been diverted to building such a state they would not have so completely destroyed Europe. Who would have thought the old libel of poisoning the wells would come back to bite Christian Europe in the ass so thoroughly?

Oh Din... not this conspiracy theory again. Look, POST (Pillars of Samson's Temple) are a radical extremist organization, and not represenative of the Faith as a whole. The Athrax attacks of 75 and 88 were indeed horrible, but the stock market shocks that followed were the natural results of the shutdown of transportation and bussiness closures, not Jewish bankers manipulating prices.
 
Is there a possibility to have a Jewish State in Palestine? It was a suggestion in 1945 but the Arabs got the upperhand and had their Palestinian state. Palestine turning Communist did cause a mass exodus of non-Communists causing the Jewish population to decline just below a fifth of the total population.

What would a Jewish Palestine look like? More developed than Palestine? Or would the Arab Armies take Israel out before it could be created? The Jewish population was 39% or something close like that in 1945.
That is ASB, they were a minority and ran way at the first issue and the commie jews(and even few come from SU as techinicans) knew antagonize arabs is suicde, what you propose is like a reverse holocaust now against the arabs, iirc there is not like 5% to 10% top of permanent jews? even since the fall of SU, palestine mostly live like a social democracy thanks religious tourism
 
A Jewish State in that war-torn area? No thanks! The Jews are doing fine in the former territory of Kimberley. Why replacing a calmed place with a friendly island neighbour with psycopath leaders? I've lost the count of how many times Syria, Egypt and Saudi Arabia have fought.
 
Top