DBWI: Have Greco-Roman paganism go extinct

Despite centuries of persecution by Christians, a few hundred thousand people still cling to Greco-Roman paganism, either in small rural communities scattered across the Meditteranean or part of the community of "Hellenes" in Persia/Mesopotamia (OOC: Something akin to the Parsis of India), so, what if Greco-Roman paganism fully went extinct during the Christianization of the Roman Empire? What PODs could have resulted in a scenario where Greco-Roman paganism went extinct, then?

OOC: Basically a scenario where Greco-Roman paganism went the way of Zoroastrianism instead of fully dying out.
 
What about the followers of the cult of Jesus? It seems like they wer about to hit critical mass in the third century. Then Diocletian happened.
 
Prevent the collapse of Rome. The Anarchy of the Third Century allowed major divisions in the Christian Church to form, including the Great Schism. This disunity allowed heresies and foreign religions to persist in fringe regions—another good example are the Zamolxians in Dacia.
 
Some scholars have argued that if the peoples of Europe had remained mostly Christian and not become Muslim, the remaining pagans would have eventually been absorbed into Christianity as the Christian priests were willing to appropriate pagan customs and even deities (as "saints") which of course Muslims aren't. They gave a few examples of this already happening before the Arab conquests. Ironically the remaining Christian communities are in the same position as the Pagan, Jewish, and Parsi ones in hanging on as minorities in a Muslim world.
 
So, how do we avoid the creation of the "Hellenes" community in Persia and Mesopotamia, then?

Get rid of the Muslim conquests in Europe, I guess. A lot of Hellenes—not to mention Christians, clergy and the like—fled to Persia to escape the suppression of the Caliphate in Yunanistan and Anatoliyah.
 
Get rid of the Muslim conquests in Europe, I guess. A lot of Hellenes—not to mention Christians, clergy and the like—fled to Persia to escape the suppression of the Caliphate in Yunanistan and Anatoliyah.

That, or just prevent the Ummyadi-Ibadi schism, or at least the rise of a substantial Ibadi political power in the Kajarite Caliphate (or some other dynasty adopting the sect) in the region. The mysticism elements and willingness to syncrate elements of the old Polytheistic faiths as high Jinn, Archangels, and the like and thereby massively expanding the definition of People of the Book are really what allowed these sorts of cult communities to hold on. I mean, they did make Zeus into the Angel of Storms and therefore a herald of Allah's. A proper Ummyadi/Sunni dynasty would have never allowed that kind of thing
 
That, or just prevent the Ummyadi-Ibadi schism, or at least the rise of a substantial Ibadi political power in the Kajarite Caliphate (or some other dynasty adopting the sect) in the region. The mysticism elements and willingness to syncrate elements of the old Polytheistic faiths as high Jinn, Archangels, and the like and thereby massively expanding the definition of People of the Book are really what allowed these sorts of cult communities to hold on. I mean, they did make Zeus into the Angel of Storms and therefore a herald of Allah's. A proper Ummyadi/Sunni dynasty would have never allowed that kind of thing

The Kajarites let that inclusiveness persist among the Yunani clergy in an attempt to pacify the non-Muslims and prevent the rise of the sort of fifth column that doomed Ummyadi Africa, at least according to al-Hasan. Of course, it backfired when said clergy supported Ismail Niqeforah in his rebellion over the foreign Kajarites...
 
Seems like a thread in poor taste considering the middle eastern movements to destroy them in the last few decades.
 
Last edited:
The Kajarites let that inclusiveness persist among the Yunani clergy in an attempt to pacify the non-Muslims and prevent the rise of the sort of fifth column that doomed Ummyadi Africa, at least according to al-Hasan. Of course, it backfired when said clergy supported Ismail Niqeforah in his rebellion over the foreign Kajarites...

Well, it's not like that didn't become a pattern for the Persian-Mesopotamian region: few dynasties could manage the juggle the complex politics of the religious mosaic of its thousand and one cults, despite the surprising ability of the region to keep coming out of its political turmoils more or less intact each time (albet under new management). Maybe if the Ummayads had stayed in Damascus or moved to, say, Egypt as opposed to relocating to Constantinople, they'd have been able to keep their geopolitical focus on Africa and the east long enough to prevent the overstrech that lead to the Crisis of 275 after the Revelation, keeping the Caliphate united long enough to mend their schism?

Sure, it might slow down the expansion of the Faith into Europe, giving Christianity time to stabilize itself and perhaps convert the Saxon-Norse Wodenites, Pict Erieian and Cymeric Druids, the Baltic Romuva, and other followers of the Native European religions to get some much needed support for the Bishop of Rome, as well as allow them to focus on blunting the Islamic invasions without the constant drain of resources in protecting the north. Is that worth the payoff of a more unified Faith in the heartland? Or do you think the conversion of even more populations to the God of Abraham would lead to a further discrediting of polytheism in general? Islam is, after all, pretty unique in its recognition of only one true God if we consider it compared to other globally notable religions, even if it is the largest out of all of them.
 
So, what do you think of the fact the Hellenes are amongst the wealthiest communities in Persia and Mesopotamia?

Considering that by specifying the "Hellenes" you artificially exclude the generally less educated and poorer Olympians from the rural parts, it's a reflection of the higher proportion of the population living in the economic hub/ high income regions around the Baghdad metropolis than others. That, and the general abuse of the Legacy system by the School of Bussiness by Olympian youth to perpetuate their over representation in the financial industry and higher paying fields of Acadamia. I dislike that out of a philosophical objection to the idea of getting easier acceptance to a program as well as lower tuition merely because you are getting the same degree your father did.
 
I think you would need to prevent the works of Marcellus Sabinus, who helped organize and codify the traditions and beliefs of the Greco-Romans, who created more organization, and established the several schools of thought. Without that cohesion, it might've died out due to disorganiztion and the higher popularity of Christianity (and later Islam).
 
Top