Coalition Powers choose to punish France

What may have happened if the Coalition powers after Waterloo had decided to punish or cut down France instead of restoring French territory (and indeed letting them keep some of their annexed territory)? What territories may have been removed from France? How would this further have altered relations between the Coalition members (especially since there were some serious tensions between some of them)?

Were there any people present at negotiations who were in favor of weakening or dismantling France?
 
None of the great powers even had a border with France, except Prussia after gaining the Rhineland (and then only barely). Which makes carving French territory up not very interesting to anyone important since they don't gain anything from it. And then there's some second stringers actually did border France, but can't really make a case for taking more land.
 
What may have happened if the Coalition powers after Waterloo had decided to punish or cut down France instead of restoring French territory (and indeed letting them keep some of their annexed territory)? What territories may have been removed from France? How would this further have altered relations between the Coalition members (especially since there were some serious tensions between some of them)?

Were there any people present at negotiations who were in favor of weakening or dismantling France?

The British I believe were definitely in favour of crippling France.
Dismantling is out of the question, not only does it just not fly, but it's damn near impossible. France doesn't want to break, and they can't force that; even with Napoleon defeated, France can still wage war maybe not effectively but she's not going to down easy. France will be dragged down kicking and screaming before they get butchered by the Regional Powers.

Sure, the conquests can be lopped off, there's no maintaining those, but core France isn't something they'll go for. Should they actually attempt to break apart France, war will happen again and Europe will once more band together to fight the giant but afterwards once France is truly exhausted and beaten, they may just try peace. Or they'll immediately start taking advantage of each other, I don't know I'm not a scientist.
 
What may have happened if the Coalition powers after Waterloo had decided to punish or cut down France instead of restoring French territory (and indeed letting them keep some of their annexed territory)? What territories may have been removed from France? How would this further have altered relations between the Coalition members (especially since there were some serious tensions between some of them)?

Were there any people present at negotiations who were in favor of weakening or dismantling France?

If they take any core french land from before the revolution. There going to threating the rule of french new king
 
Thy could take all the colonies they returned to Frace which would economically hurt France. Also they could give some land (not a lot) to Sardinia and the same for Spain and the Netherlands.
 
What may have happened if the Coalition powers after Waterloo had decided to punish or cut down France instead of restoring French territory (and indeed letting them keep some of their annexed territory)? What territories may have been removed from France? How would this further have altered relations between the Coalition members (especially since there were some serious tensions between some of them)?

Were there any people present at negotiations who were in favor of weakening or dismantling France?

They did do this to an extent. Whereas the 1814 treaty allowed France to keep the new territory it had in 1792, the 1815 treaty took it away, and added a new 700 million-franc indemnity to pay. Additionally, France had to cover the cost of the Coalition troops who would occupy the country until the indemnity was paid off. The only annexed territory France ended up keeping were two tiny enclaves (Montbéliard and the Comtat Venaissin) which really couldn't have been defended by any foreign state.

The Coalition could have perhaps gone further, but their ultimate purpose had been to restore the House of Bourbon to the French throne, and to be overly punitive would seem to undercut Louis XVIII's legitimacy and could have led to further unrest.
 
Last edited:
Top