Blue Skies in Camelot: An Alternate 60's and Beyond

Wait so Harold Holt didn't go missing in TTL? How interesting. Since he was Prime Minister for much longer than in OTL how was his tenure in office? Did he have any problems with John Gorton, William McMahon and John McEwen? I assume he was still "all the way" with the US in Vietnam? Also did Holt ever meet Lyndon Johnson in TTL?
 
Last edited:
Pop Culture 1975
1975 in Pop Culture - Is This The Real Life; Is This Just Fantasy?

SKQya0VlxkyOlHCCzu9jukIeFBHfbP_g0tBo31CXLt7UddPblq-DLXbEBO5xxecMyMnoDei07fEKGAmLjMYH43oA4cwFOis31mMRAuyCAeI9vdR8MfRs1OFLkC4-OmnIMMMSSyRE

Above: Her Majesty, Queen set the world on fire by becoming one of the hottest rock acts in history with their third studio album, A Night at the Opera this year.​


Billboard’s Year-End Hot 100 Singles of 1975 (Top Ten):

  1. “Annie’s Song” - John Denver

  2. “Kung Fu Fighting” - Carl Douglas

  3. “Fox on the Run” - The Sweet

  4. “Bohemian Rhapsody” - Queen

  5. “Ballroom Blitz” - The Sweet

  6. “Dollar Bill Blues” - Townes Van Zandt

  7. “Killer Queen” - Queen

  8. “Stand By Me” - The Beatles

  9. “Rock & Roll All Nite” - KISS

  10. “Boogie On” - Stevie Wonder

News in Music

February 21st - The Beatles released their fifteenth studio album, Photograph, to mixed reviews but wide commercial success. Critics praised Ringo and George’s increased contributions, including the album’s hit title track, but accused John and Paul of “phoning it in on this one”. Given John’s increasingly political attitude and Paul devoting most of his time to family life with wife Jane Asher and their children, as well as running the increasingly powerful Apple Records, many question whether it is time for the Beatles to call it quits and move on to other projects, though they predict a “lucrative career” for Ringo and George if this does happen.


Track Listing - Title - Songwriter(s) - Lead Vocalist

  1. “Photograph” - Harrison/Starr - Ringo

  2. “Jet” - Lennon/McCartney - Paul

  3. “You” - Harrison - George

  4. “Mind Games” - Lennon/McCartney - John

  5. “Whatever Gets You Thru the Night” - Lennon/McCartney - John & Paul

  6. “Tired of Midnight Blue” - Harrison - George

  7. “Always on the Run” - Lennon/McCartney - Paul

  8. “Scared” - Lennon/McCartney - John

  9. “You’re Sixteen” - Cover - Ringo

  10. “World of Stone” - Harrison - George

  11. “Nightmare #9 (This One is Real)” - Lennon/McCartney - John & Paul

  12. “Stand By Me” - Cover - John

March 2nd - Paul McCartney and his wife, Jane Asher, welcomed their second child, a daughter named Penelope or “Penny”, into the world.


March 21st - Beginning in Detroit, Michigan, Alice Cooper introduces an elaborate horror stage show to promote his album, Welcome to My Nightmare. It becomes an overnight sensation.


April 7th - Ritchie Blackmore plays his final live show with Deep Purple before joining with singer Ronnie James Dio to form a new band, Rainbow.


April 24th - Former Creedence Clearwater Revival frontman and lead guitarist John Fogerty has his first major solo success with the single “We the People” - a politically charged protest song criticizing the Bush administration for its harsh economic policies. The single even reaches the coveted #1 spot on Billboard, something CCR had never managed.


i8uCZBEDSupN0xLXABOEWn87waF5ZxFofVK86d7ITVR9Y-xnM1iWp5zThA49akETW4bf7AxFKQtlskKDmmfOK2PBHxMyYoXhnisqBN3Kwp59uQJWNBbXOslpsy0T-F9CxQe-CDpl


May 1st - The Rolling Stones open their North American tour in Baton Rouge, LA. The show marks their first official live show with new rhythm guitarist Chris Dreja, formerly of the Yardbirds.


May 10th - Stevie Wonder performs for 125,000 people in front of the Washington Monument as part of the Human Kindness Day festivities.


June 20th - The Artistics, a new art rock group led by David Byrne and Chris Frantz, play their first show in New York City.


June 30th - Cher and KISS frontman Gene Simmons are married in a Las Vegas hotel suite. That same day, the Jackson 5 left Motown for CBS Records, but are forced to change their name to “The Jacksons” as Motown owns the “Jackson 5” name. Jermaine Jackson remains with Motown as his brothers break their contract, causing him to be replaced by youngest brother, Randy Jackson on bass.


i97H4vhScspqgYVX2QHYH5ZdrWSdFlvpBba4l69hjMeAoakUzzth0TH-nFMaTRjzS94rmiKTsxufRS5T2Sry5vt34vIVkieEwo72cGVTyXjr0OIrVFePqDyGkHv3xpHV24Jovxnq
PJGaiwq-VYPDqnJGUrdt-hKwKtCwDgDTEstXtssIBq4P4xmyYfFbb3Mc027_mgP-MI8fSw_ovoFhu51lLCV9p26fZrlAOUqIviL7wQn9v9oSrewSNENdyOkLs9nKbYylFMwpbnNa


July 4th - The Senate of the State of Texas declares the Fourth of July “Willie Nelson Day”, as more than 70,000 fans visit Liberty Hall for the third annual picnic and country rock show headlined by Texans Townes Van Zandt and Willie Nelson himself.


August 4th - Robert Plant, lead singer of legendary rock band Led Zeppelin and his wife, Maureen, are tragically killed in a car accident while vacationing on the Greek island of Rhodes. Stunned, the world of Rock pays tribute to the fallen icon and the remaining three quarters of Led Zeppelin are forced into an early retirement due to the loss. They were only days shy of Robert Plant’s 27th birthday. Nonetheless, his status as a “God of Rock” would only grow in the decades following his death, and gather a cult following around him and the band he left behind.


D_sAtGVRuOLlW7OCRdBq1sflxZSdgaPnnhdwKNnvhJvwTyezIwgNZSMa4dU7LvcTfIuzitzPkXL2x-HQKlMg-i7dQU3x_HDBCI0PcNe51WTWLGaAYhGZQ1gWPN6_IIthaLU0KgMp

RIP Robert & Maureen Plant (1948 - 1975)


September 15th - Pink Floyd release their eighth studio album, Wish You Were Here. Though the title track was actually written for Syd Barrett, their friend who tragically lost his mind through over-experimentation with LSD, Roger Waters added a last minute dedication to the album’s press - “In loving memory of Robert Plant - a dearly departed friend.”


October 7th - Elvis Presley releases “Promised Land”, a funky Rock cover of Chuck Berry’s hit song from 1965, scoring himself yet another number one hit. He, Ann Margret, and their daughters Lucille Marie and Anna Regina are named “America’s Family” in a headline story by Life Magazine.


October 9th - KISS earn free publicity for themselves by playing the homecoming dance of Cadillac High School in Cadillac, Michigan.


October 11th - Bruce Springsteen appears on the covers of both Time and Newsweek on the same week.


November 6th - The Sex Pistols play their first concert at St. Martin’s School of Art in London, UK.


December 25th - Heavy Metal Bassist Steve Harris forms the band Iron Maiden, taking their name from a medieval torture device mentioned in The Man in the Iron Mask.


December 31st - Elvis Presley breaks the record for largest indoor concert attendance as he fills the Pontiac Silverdome and plays a concert attended by more than 78,000 screaming fans. Rolling Stone declares, “Even as he nears his 41st birthday, Presley still cannot help but ooze sex appeal, charisma, and a seemingly endless stream of top quality Rock N Roll. Long live the King!”


Tz_jSrOL9u13q7SNy38TqxEV0iLVNscT-3QW6y-YrdOnf6W3m8O4p92vw0mMzrdjDyTpll3r0nfl8ZKGd2wEUcsXQvrCFYwpwVydS-VR5ZNdK6MGAHRnhaQ9__dtXF7A9q4jZArE


1975 in Film - The Year’s Biggest


Jaws - Thriller. Directed by Steven Spielberg, based on Peter Benchley’s 1974 novel, and starring Roy Scheider, Robert Shaw, and Mark Hamill. The film which practically invented the modern Hollywood notion of a “blockbuster”, Jaws was also the film which launched Steven Spielberg’s career, arguably making it possible for him to direct 1977’s Superman and thereafter spawn the Superhero film as we know it. Jaws redefined the way movie goers saw special effects, was renowned for its score by the immortal John Williams, and confirmed Mark Hamill’s status as one of the premiere rising stars in the film business. A hit in its most straightforward form, Jaws quickly became the highest grossing movie of all time; it would not hold this distinction for long...


The Rocky Horror Picture Show - Musical/Horror/Comedy; Directed by Jim Sharman and starring Tim Curry and Susan Sarandon. The cult classic to define all forthcoming cult classics, Rocky Horror is a hilarious, beautiful tribute to the Sci-Fi and horror films of the 1930’s, 40’s, and 50’s, while also being a film about fluid sexualities, Rock N Roll, and doing the Time Warp, again. Though initially deemed “too explicit” for mainstream audiences, it nonetheless became the year’s second highest grossing picture and would be a mainstay of midnight viewings across the world for decades to come.


One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest - Comedy/Drama. Directed by Milos Forman, based on the 1962 novel by Ken Kesey, and starring Will Sampson as “Chief Bromden” and Star Trek alumnus Leonard Nimoy as Randle McMurphy, a role he originally played onstage during the play adaptations broadway run in the late 60’s and early 70’s. Though Nimoy was initially seen as an “unusual” choice for the part, Father-son producers Kirk and Michael Douglas were won over by his screen test, in which he managed to shatter his “type casting” as a reasonable, logical character, like Spock. The film became one of the defining performances of Nimoy’s career, and made him one of the most celebrated actors in the country. The film would eventually sweep at the Oscars, winning 5 Academy Awards: Best Adapted Screenplay; Best Lead Actress for Louise Fletcher (who played the infamous Nurse Ratched and beat out Ann Margret, who was nominated for her role in Tommy); Best Director; Best Picture; and Best Lead Actor for Leonard Nimoy.


Px2qPixUN2xFpGJHaAP9jfjmcKR538mZKU96zqq9mJ9D2HmPvcVj8kuf_pCmL0Ybo9cM3eV_3vyxM-Zft9a1moqtI8jMJ3DzXv9_viW93v2u_u0yLgS_GkNecnZX7rvFmqqsUi0n


Monty Python and the Holy Grail
- Independent Comedy. Written, Directed, and Performed by the Pythons (Graham Chapman, Terry Jones, Terry Gilliam, John Cleese, Michael Palin, and Eric Idle); Holy Grail would initially not be too big of a deal at the box office. Its legacy however, is undeniable. In the decades since its initial release, the film has become one of the most popular comedy films of all time, and served as a gateway for the Pythons and Gilliam especially into the world of feature length cinema.


News in Television and Film, Throughout the Year


January 3rd - The original run of Jeopardy! Ends after almost 11 years and 3,000 episodes on NBC.

January 6th - Wheel of Fortune airs its inaugural episode on NBC’s daytime schedule with host Chuck Woolery and assistant Susan Stafford.


March 26th - The film version of The Who’s Tommy premieres in London.


May - Having begun working on a script for Star Wars, a space fantasy film he hoped would be his masterpiece just after wrapping up American Graffiti in 1973, Director George Lucas formed Industrial Light and Magic with his wife, Marcia. The company is designed to handle special effects for the new film as it enters development.


September 30th - The Muhammad Ali - Joe Frazier title fight from the Philippines (“The Thrilla in Manila”) is sent via satellite to the United States and shown on HBO.


October 21st - NBC broadcasts the now legendary 12-inning long sixth game of the 1975 World Series between the Boston Red Sox and the Cincinnati Reds. The game ends with Red Sox catcher Carlton Fisk's home run to send the series to a climatic seventh game. In what has now become an iconic baseball moment, the NBC left-field camera caught Fisk wildly waving his arms to his right after hitting the ball and watching its path while drifting down the first base line, as if he was trying to coax the ball to "stay fair". The ball indeed stayed fair and the Red Sox had tied the Series. (According to the NBC cameraman Lou Gerard, located inside the left field wall scoreboard, cameramen at the time were instructed to follow the flight of the ball. Instead, Gerard was distracted by a rat nearby, thus he lost track of the baseball and instead decided to capture the image of Fisk "magically" waving the ball fair). The game would go on to be ranked Number 1 in MLB Network's 20 Greatest Games of all time.


November - Sony introduces the Betamax video recorder in the United States, which comes in a teakwood console with a 19" color television set and retails for approximately $2,500.


November 23rd - Sneak Previews premieres in the United States, launching the careers of Film Critics Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert.


1975 in Sport


Super Bowl IX - The Pittsburgh Steelers, led by Quarterback Archie Manning go 28 - 7 against the Minnesota Vikings.
The following section was provided by @AndyWho:

The Shift of the Draft

Ask where the fates of two of the NFL’s most notorious franchises (as well as many others) had their fates changed, and one would simply look back to the 1970 NFL Draft to chart the beginning.

The talk of the town that draft was over the top quarterback prospect in Terry Paxton Bradshaw (of Louisiana Tech) and out of the many teams with poor records, the Pittsburgh Steelers and Chicago Bears were tied 1-13 each. Settling the matter, the NFL Commissioner decided to leave the fate of the first overall pick to a coin flip. Other teams, ranging from the Green Bay Packers to the New Orleans Saints (Bradshaw’s fan team) attempted to cash in draft picks for a shot at the top pick (In a last second twist of fate, the Saints rescinded their trade of the 1973 1st round pick in exchange for further second rounders, along with the already offered 1st round picks).

With the stage set, the two teams chose their side; the Bears with heads, the Steelers with tails. Ed Rooney, upon allowing the decision to be called mid-air, thought he had the flip in the bag.

And then…heads.

The Bears, elated with the realization, would go first overall and pick up the blonde bombshell from Shreveport (thanks to the shift, they would also pick up offensive guard Doug Wilkerson) and go on to set up a quiet, but promising season with Bradshaw sitting out the season while Jack Concannon. Following that 6-8 season, Bradshaw would begin for the Bears in 1971 to a decent, but sacked start of tied seasons, record sack numbers for Bradshaw, and some struggles of 7-7, 6-8, 5-9, 4-10, and 4-10 again. While the defense-strong team has been helped to that end, the addition of RB Walter Payton has given life for the Bears, posting a 8-6 record in 1975 and, with the build of pieces from OT Lionel Antoine to FB Roland Harper, begin a strong push for the Chicago Bears around their rocket arm QB in the hunt for the 1976 season.

The Steelers, devastated at the sudden turn of luck, would look ahead for the season as they traded the second overall pick to New Orleans in exchange for some trades, picking up CB Mel Blount, WR Ron Shanklin, and S Jake Scott. However, thanks to the ‘70 trade, the Steelers would get a starting QB in Archie Manning and FB John Riggins in a back-to-back draft pick in the first round alone. With the stability and team unifying around Manning, the hard-luck Steelers went from 3-11 in 1970 to 5-9 in 1971 and then, by 1972 (after gaining FB Franco Harris), going 11-3. While a stunning team, the Steelers seem to have suffered a bout of hard luck in the 1972 AFC Divisional when a perceived touchdown by Harris was instead ruled an illegal reception and a turnover to Oakland. The game, forever regarded as the “Immaculate Deception” was the cause of the Three Rivers Riot in Pittsburgh that saw damage and several injuries, but became the chip on the shoulder for the team as they would grow in 1973, 1974 and 1975. Much like Bradshaw, 1976 seems to be the year for Manning to finally overcome and win Pittsburgh a title. Even if it meant to getting some shine on TV alongside his DE Ed O’Neil.

As for the Saints, they would make a small victory in the end after finding tanking seasons under Phipps. Trading the QB to Houston, the Saints would make good on the effort with drafting hometown star Bert Jones and G John Hannah, but would have a long way to go with a team that found themselves still stuck in a rut and a stable, but flailing offensive line.

All in all, the day of the draft in 1970 would forever change the fate of two key franchises and set up one on a different path. Now, with Terry Bradshaw and Archie Manning in altered fates for the both of them, the two quarterbacks may end up in the Super Bowl before too long.

OOC: Thank you to AndyWho for this wonderful addition to the TL! :D

Baseball

World Series - In what is widely described as “the greatest World Series of all time”, the Boston Red Sox barely edge out the Cincinnati Reds in Game 7 to break the “Curse of the Bambino” and win their first championship in 56 years.


NBA Finals


The Golden State Warriors win 4 games to 0 over the Chicago Bulls.


Hockey - The Stanley Cup


The Buffalo Sabres defeat the Philadelphia Flyers, 4 games to 2.


Time Magazine’s Person of the Year - “American Women” - Represented by First Lady Barbara Bush, Associate Justice Carla Hills of the Supreme Court, Billie Jean King, Carol Sutton, Susan Brownmiller, Shirley Chisholm, and Senator Shirley Temple Black. With the ratification of the ERA as the 27th Amendment and naming of the first female Supreme Court Justice, it seems that women are finally on the road to equality.


zDJVSQ9AoY9Vw5Z-HtLmwfW5FgUDN38sL8EVs445JTMbVHl2T7deZK7QumsGwDj8kgylFboxkQ92cxmd4_neYNLwGBRsn5DJwmh1QWKUsedYZ5WdJbmIE_uB8MyQuRTeN_KxkBQk


Other Headlines, Throughout the Year


The Suez Canal re-opens for the first time since the Six Day War.


The “Green March” Occurs in Morocco.

350,000 unarmed Moroccans crossed the border into the Spanish controlled area of the Western Sahara demanding the return of Moroccan Sahara Desert following the death of Spanish Dictator Francisco Franco.


Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi is convicted of electoral corruption, but Remains in Office due to her widespread popularity.


ctAT4Pdj49rYQyxNZ1E3tZQkyUtX_f01gOMMVeLU-1__OaooT7Jsa657igmbmNHYjvPG38dxlLcLmj2-YahCc7QLpqIYHyU-2tcvY1c0aMTxj1gxNMPU4b4oeaMZJsTrdO3_j6Z0


Inspired by Bill Gates and Paul Allen of new company Microsoft, Atari technicians Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak join up with Xerox to work at the Xerox Palo Alto Research Center, known as Xerox PARC. There, they will develop the world’s first modern personal computer in 1976.


j_4AqrMzr0NGiwltonJQfizmwnA2P2cmFUGrPalMG0pOO9wQC5ZODoulUZpyTIUDiJcaVOM_KxBWigFbkXwLwrDssGYU3QrxgSctREtb6RPhX_TmsGwR_74AUjjHjAAT582La_dA
If7srOKLuritwcMRud1wvwffJ9D414g5DoXD51rc7nmRQfOWJy643MMunHS833_tE1vp2uk6Y5-SnThqV6T8CqfqCryQ6Gx2VzQeL3YLnYZ_VRss7JpKch5I3cWc0r1v26tFnjl5


Motorola Obtains a Patent for the first portable telephone.


Next Time on Blue Skies in Camelot: To Boldly Go to a Galaxy Far, Far Away...
 
Last edited:
Shame to see Robert Plant go… Led Zeppelin would probably be considered one of “those 70s bands” now.
Super Bowl IX - The Pittsburgh Steelers, led by Quarterback Archie Manning go 28 - 7 against the Minnesota Vikings.
Archie getting a ring makes me happy! Him not doing it for New Orleans makes me cry inside. XD
World Series - In what is widely described as “the greatest World Series of all time”, the Boston Red Sox barely edge out the Cincinnati Reds in Game 7 to break the “Curse of the Bambino” and win their first championship in 56 years.
Wow, Boston winning it all almost 30 years early? Definitely a bit surprising!
 
So the car crash that inspired "Achilles' Last Stand" IOTL kills Robert Plant? RIP; guess Bonzo survives then?

Chris Dreja instead of Ronnie Wood as part of the Stones, nice. Will Photograph be known as the Beatles' 70s version of Beatles For Sale then?

Also, A Night at the Opera is Queen's third album ITTL? Which one did they skip?
 
RIP, Robert Plant; you had a good run...

Archie Manning is at least winning Super Bowls ITTL; his sons, I suspect, will have a lot to live up to...

Glad that Boston won the World Series...

Also glad the ERA passed...

Interesting alternate casting for Jaws and One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest...

Like that Townes Van Zandt is still going strong...

Good pop culture update and waiting for more, of course, @President_Lincoln...
 
I’ll admit, and please don’t take this the wrong way @President_Lincoln as I love this timeline, but I actually kind of winced when I read Mark Hamill’s name on the Jaws cast. Maybe it’s just me, but it’s honestly starting to reach a point where I'm having difficulty being able to suspend my disbelief personally at the idea of Hamill, and arguably Carrie Fisher as well for that matter, still being cast in Star Wars as Luke and Leia, due to the success they currently have in 1976, and the fact they were both in American Graffiti (the later of which, them being in American Graffiti, is something I admittedly strongly don’t think you should have done and actively wish you would retcon).

People forget that Star Wars, up until it’s success, was often regarded as little more than a B-Movie by everyone as it was being made. I mean, Harrison Ford barely got the role in OTL due to the fact that George Lucas wanted fresh unknown faces and people that weren’t in American Graffiti to play the roles, and even then he was only able to get in because George asked him to come and help with the auditioning and he was so good he got the role.

Realistically though, in ITTL, Carrie and Hamill, due to their fame and them being in ITTL American Graffiti, would probably mean that neither would audition or be asked by George to audition for Star Wars, and I think there’s only so much you can excuse by saying it’s the result of the butterfly effect. The fame both have also gotten from Jaws and the Snow Princess respectively feels like it’s be a final nail in the coffin for George asking them to audition for Star Wars. They could probably get away with having been in Jaws and Snow Princess and still audition for Star Wars if they hadn’t starred in American Graffiti, but honestly I can’t see it with both, which sucks as I was really hoping ITTL Star Wars would keep Hamill, Carrie, and Fords as Luke, Leia, and Han, since almost every alternate timeline always changes them and this is the one timeline where it now makes the most sense to change them.

So yeah... I hope you don’t mind that bit of criticism on my part, but I felt it needed to be said.

Anyways, on a side note, I hope you realize that you’ve effectively killed ITTL’s Jack Nicholson’s career before it even began. One Flew Over The Cuckoos Nest was his big break out role, and by removing it, the likelihood of him getting cast in the Shining seems next to nil.
 
Last edited:
Loving it!! Can't wait to see what you will do with Star Wars! I'm glad the King is still rocking and rolling! I wonder if The Beatles will still break up in this timeline? (more peacefully this time)
 
I’ll admit, and please don’t take this the wrong way @President_Lincoln as I love this timeline, but I actually kind of winced when I read Mark Hamill’s name on the Jaws cast. Maybe it’s just me, but it’s honestly starting to reach a point where I'm having difficulty being able to suspend my disbelief personally at the idea of Hamill, and arguably Carrie Fisher as well for that matter, still being cast in Star Wars as Luke and Leia, due to the success they currently have in 1976, and the fact they were both in American Graffiti (the later of which, them being in American Graffiti, is something I admittedly strongly don’t think you should have done and actively wish you would retcon).

People forget that Star Wars, up until it’s success, was often regarded as little more than a B-Movie by everyone as it was being made. I mean, Harrison Ford barely got the role in OTL due to the fact that George Lucas wanted fresh unknown faces and people that weren’t in American Graffiti to play the roles, and even then he was only able to get in because George asked him to come and help with the auditioning and he was so good he got the role.

Realistically though, in ITTL, Carrie and Hamill, due to their fame and them being in ITTL American Graffiti, would probably mean that neither would audition or be asked by George to audition for Star Wars, and I think there’s only so much you can excuse by saying it’s the result of the butterfly effect. The fame both have also gotten from Jaws and the Snow Princess respectively feels like it’s be a final nail in the coffin for George asking them to audition for Star Wars. They could probably get away with having been in Jaws and Snow Princess and still audition for Star Wars if they hadn’t starred in American Graffiti, but honestly I can’t see it with both, which sucks as I was really hoping ITTL Star Wars would keep Hamill, Carrie, and Fords as Luke, Leia, and Han, since almost every alternate timeline always changes them and this is the one timeline where it now makes the most sense to change them.

So yeah... I hope you don’t mind that bit of criticism on my part, but I felt it needed to be said.

Anyways, on a side note, I hope you realize that you’ve effectively killed ITTL’s Jack Nicholson’s career before it even began. One Flew Over The Cuckoos Nest was his big break out role, and by removing it, the likelihood of him getting cast in the Shining seems next to nil.

@Nerdman3000,

Thank you for your honesty regarding how you felt about these casting changes/decisions on my part, as well as for your thorough analysis and reasoning. I am deeply sorry that these choices caused you to finally be unable to suspend your disbelief and seem to have hurt the direction of TTL in your eyes as a whole. Generally with the Pop Culture elements in Blue Skies, I strive to pursue changes I think would be interesting or thought provoking, and possibly lead to cool future developments and so on. In the case of these casting decisions, I understand your criticisms and believe that they are valid, especially regarding George Lucas' desire to work with relatively unknown actors for Star Wars. If I may, before I conclusively decide to retcon anything, I would like to take a second to explain why I (at least initially) thought the choices could work or might be interesting...

Because Star Trek was able to complete its full run ITTL and was quite popular and successful, I thought it only made sense that Leonard Nimoy (as one of the show's biggest stars) would get a chance to shine and be cast in big time film roles. IOTL, Nimoy did play the role of McMurphy on Broadway in the play adaptation of Kesey's novel, so I do not see why something similar could not have happened here. In line with this thinking, I thought giving Nimoy the chance to play McMurphy in the film would possibly be a cool alternative take on the character. It would give Nimoy the chance to break his type-casting and possibly provide him with the opportunity to play more varied characters in the future. As for your concern regarding Jack Nicholson's career, ITTL Nicholson already had his "big break out role" in 1971's The Exorcist as Father/Dr. Damien Karras. I mentioned this during the update concerning that film's production, as well as the 1973 Pop Culture update. I firmly believe that Nicholson will still be a successful film star and leading man ITTL, and I could even see him still getting cast as Jack Torrence, given his experience in the Horror genre. On that note, I respect your criticism, but on this point, I must respectfully disagree.

I believe your feelings about the Star Wars castings are fair, and I apologize again for them. In my mind, I thought maybe Lucas could learn early on to develop closer relationships with his actors by working with them across multiple projects and cultivating their creative strengths with his, rather than just doing his own thing and replacing them so that his vision always won out in the end. I hoped that perhaps if Lucas was more open to collaboration throughout his entire career, perhaps Star Wars' development ITTL could be more fruitful and less divisive than it has (at times) been IOTL. I also have to admit that perhaps this was the result of some "rule of cool" thinking on my part. I'm a big fan of Hamill, Fisher, and Ford. Maybe I just wanted them to be in more films together; the inner nerd in me slipping out, I guess. I was hoping Hamill could become a major star ITTL, and Fisher could avoid some of her struggles with addiction ITTL, given her strong career trajectory and eventual marriage to Christopher Reeve here.

Again, I appreciate your honesty. I am currently trying to think over and process everything you have said and decide whether or not to issue the retcon. As always, I love hearing your thoughts and critiques, and you especially @Nerdman3000 have contributed so much to TTL. This has definitely struck a chord with me.

Thank you again.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for your honesty regarding how you felt about these casting changes/decisions on my part, as well as for your thorough analysis and reasoning. I am deeply sorry that these choices caused you to finally be unable to suspend your disbelief and seem to have hurt the direction of TTL in your eyes as a whole. Generally with the Pop Culture elements in Blue Skies, I strive to pursue changes I think would be interesting or thought provoking, and possibly lead to cool future developments and so on. In the case of these casting decisions, I understand your criticisms and believe that they are valid, especially regarding George Lucas' desire to work with relatively unknown actors for Star Wars. If I may, before I conclusively decide to retcon anything, I would like to take a second to explain why I (at least initially) thought the choices could work or might be interesting...

You have nothing to apologize for. Ultimately this is your timeline, and you have the final say on everything. I still consider it overall to be a masterpiece, and honestly, my complaints about Hamill and Fisher are minor in the grand scheme of things, and not even that could hurt your direction of the TTL as a whole in my eyes. The only reason the Hamill/Fisher thing bothers me a bit is due to the fact I have quite a bit of deep knowledge on the making of Star Wars - Episode IV: A New Hope, and Lucas was kind of famously vocal as to the reasons for his casting decisions.

Because Star Trek was able to complete its full run ITTL and was quite popular and successful, I thought it only made sense that Leonard Nimoy (as one of the show's biggest stars) would get a chance to shine and be cast in big time film roles. IOTL, Nimoy did play the role of McMurphy on Broadway in the play adaptation of Kesey's novel, so I do not see why something similar could not have happened here. In line with this thinking, I thought giving Nimoy the chance to play McMurphy in the film would possibly be a cool alternative take on the character. It would give Nimoy the chance to break his type-casting and possibly provide him with the opportunity to play more varied characters in the future. As for your concern regarding Jack Nicholson's career, ITTL Nicholson already had his "big break out role" in 1971's The Exorcist as Father/Dr. Damien Karras. I mentioned this during the update concerning that film's production, as well as the 1973 Pop Culture update. I firmly believe that Nicholson will still be a successful film star and leading man ITTL, and I could even see him still getting cast as Jack Torrence, given his experience in the Horror genre. On that note, I respect your criticism, but on this point, I must respectfully disagree.

I'll admit, I completely forgot about him being cast in the ITTL Exorcist. So your indeed right that he likely would still be famous and could still be cast in the Shining. :)

I believe your feelings about the Star Wars castings are fair, and I apologize again for them. In my mind, I thought maybe Lucas could learn early on to develop closer relationships with his actors by working with them across multiple projects and cultivating their creative strengths with his, rather than just doing his own thing and replacing them so that his vision always won out in the end. I hoped that perhaps if Lucas was more open to collaboration throughout his entire career, perhaps Star Wars' development ITTL could be more fruitful and less divisive than it has (at times) been IOTL. I also have to admit that perhaps this was the result of some "rule of cool" thinking on my part. I'm a big fan of Hamill, Fisher, and Ford. Maybe I just wanted them to be in more films together; the inner nerd in me slipping out, I guess. I was hoping Hamill could become a major star ITTL, and Fisher could avoid some of her struggles with addiction ITTL, given her strong career trajectory and eventual marriage to Christopher Reeve here.
I suppose I understand your points, and I'm happy the positives these changes will lead to for Carrie and Hamill ITTL. However I do think there should at least be some kind of in-world explanation mentioned perhaps in the next chapter for why Lucas decided to be more open to collaboration ITTL.
 
I suppose I understand your points, and I'm happy the positives these changes will lead to for Carrie and Hamill ITTL. However I do think there should at least be some kind of in-world explanation mentioned perhaps in the next chapter for why Lucas decided to be more open to collaboration ITTL.
It could be something not entirely in his hands. IIRC the reason he cast Alec Guinness was that the studio told him he needed at least one big-name actor in the cast. If he decides to go with Toshiro Mifune for Obi-Wan he might be able to placate the studio by casting Hamill and Fisher. As for why Hamill would do it, well Mark might very well be sold on the idea of playing a space hero like Buck Rodgers. He might be willing to take what might be seen as a step back careerwise on the logic that Jaws gives him a bit of wiggle room to take a few projects because they sound fun over big-name efforts.
 
Noooo! Robert Plant is dead! The long trail of musicians deaths continues! And now Gene Simmons is married to Cher! Poor thing, what has he done to deserve this?
 
I see the 27 Curse has taken another artist! RIP Mr Plant!

Hello Queen! 2 Billboard hits of the year? Def impressive. Want to see Freddie and Elvis performing together @President_Lincoln please...

Nimoy breaking his stereotype is fantastic- look forward to reading what else he is in. Wonder how Shanter took Nimoy’s Oscar win?

Isn’t it time for the first Star Trek conventions? Or have they already started ITTL?

Thing about Star Wars OTL was it was taken as a B movie, who’s to say ITTL it won’t be taken as a more serious drama with some serious stars in expected to do Big Things in the box office. Lucas, under pressure turns to those around him for help leading to that collaboration President_Lincoln mentioned.
 
All caught up - what a terrific timeline you’ve written!

If I can be so bold as to propose a replacement for LBJ in the Senate - Ben Barnes, a young, up and comer in Texas who in OTL was derailed by scandal.
 

AeroTheZealousOne

Monthly Donor
Loved the update, nice seeing Townes Van Zandt sharing a stage and the Beatles still kickin' it into the 1970s! Disappointed that Robert Plant is dead, you butterflied his 1988 album (and the contents of one side of my dad's old mixtapes labeled Now and Zen) but I will say like Bob Dylan you left almost all of his other hits intact so I can't really be mad at this. Disappointed, perhaps, but c'est la vie.

I hope Jeopardy! makes a comeback sometime in the '80s, I personally am quite a fan of the show but I should really find some time to watch the old Art Fleming episodes.

Finally, had "Annie's Song" stuck in my head a week or two ago. It's one of the few songs I can actually sing on-key.

Loved the update, as always.
 
Top