Beyond the town of Gettysburg

My knowledge of ACW is limited at best, but I am enjoying this TL a lot.

Most Gettysburg related TLs that I have been able to find, are Confederate victory types, which then lead into ever greater Confed-wanks. Here however, situation is rather different. Union is on the attack, and while it may end up bloodily repulsed, with losses favouring the Confederates to a much greater degree, I still do not see this being a CSA victory. Lee is blind, Stuart is not coming back until late afternoon I believe, and his line of supply and retreat has just been barely held, as Union attacked rather ferociously.

This attack might bleed the AotP some more, but to be brutally honest, Union can actually replace their casualties, Vicksburg is going to surrender on the 4th, and while AoNV might end up stronger then it was IOTL 1864, that just means that war might last a bit longer, and that Grant will have a bit bloodier time then he did OTL.
 
It looks Hood is going to get the heroic death that was denied to him IOTL, where he was instead was torn to pieces. Or maybe he'll just be torn to pieces again and end up as "war-torn, love-forsaken John Bell Hood" as Civil War Journal calls him.
 
While I do not know if Imboden was aware of the word it was in some use by the ACW.

paranoia (n.)
"mental disorder characterized by systematized delusions of more or less definite scope," 1848 (earlier paranoea 1811), from Greek paranoia "mental derangement, madness," from paranoos "mentally ill, insane," from para- "beside, beyond"

Very likely, but it still wouldn't be used in that way in that time period.
 
Not my boy Hood!
Hey, if Hood dies in this time line with great honor, he'll never have been promoted past his level of competence. Hood was an awesome brigade commander and a pretty good division commander. Corps or Army command was well beyond him. So in this TL he may well have all kinds of fanboys speculating, what if Hood survived and was given an Army command ;)
 
Confeds might be better off without Hood, lest we forget how he threw away his army attacking Sherman around Atlanta. Not to mention Lee was also quite offensively minded, and while he did win (until Gettysburg at least), his victories did come at quite a price, like in the 7-days Campaign and elsewhere. I might be mistaken, but Lee did have higher casualties then Grant, at least until the Overland Campaign, when you put their carrers side by side.

It is a derail, but does anyone know TL where CSA stays on the defensive or something along these lines.
 
That sounds like an oxymoron.

Right?
These days though, it can be more profitable to have CSR policies for multinationals because of things like the Indigenous Indian mountain mine thing.

My final paper for that class was on FIFA and boy was it a doozy haha.
 
Chapter 21
Chapter 21

July 4, 1863, 11:30 a.m.
Confederate right flank
South of Cashtown, Pennsylvania

Major General John Sedgwick, in his tightly tailored uniform, slowly but surely felt like being in an oven. He emptied the last remnants of lukewarm water in his water bottle in a single draw while listening to the steadily decreasing volume of fire in his front line.

The course of the battle was far from satisfactory. He had hoped for a quick follow up after the successful flank attack and the consistent retreat of the entire enemy front line. His central division under Wright had rushed forward enthusiastically and had made up dozens of yards until the unexpected and furious counterattack had hit the men like a sledgehammer.

Naturally, not least because of the confusing course of the front, the majority of his units had oriented themselves to the noise of the battle and thus to the place of the most fierce resistance. Both flank divisions had therefore been magically drawn into the stand up fight in the middle.

With time and the increasing exhaustion of the men, who after all had been marching since dawn and had already been in combat for hours, the attacks on the remaining island of Confederate defenders had become increasingly uncoordinated and got stuck despite overwhelming superiority. Several times, individual brigades had approached the rebel position to bayonet length, but each time had been thrown back with heavy losses. The Centre Division had suffered the comparatively heaviest losses. A few days later, after the evaluation of the battle reports, Sedgwick was to learn that a total of nine individual charges had failed in his section of the front that morning.

The rebels were now almost circularly surrounded, ironically forcing the northerners to slow their fire in order to avoid hitting their own troops on the other side of the cordon.

The sudden silence that enveloped the battlefield from one moment to the next was interrupted by the call "White Flag".

It was a young man with the rank insignia of a major, who finally stepped out of the battle smoke, accompanied by a simple soldier with a white rag. His face, like his uniform, was blackened by gunpowder, but the fierce battle did not seem to have robbed him of his dignity. With a good dose of self-confidence and as if it were a matter of course he approached Sedgwick, ignoring the bunch of blue-clad officers surrounding him, each of whom outranked him nonetheless. He stopped in front of the corps commander, tightened his tired shoulders and saluted silently.

Sedgwick returned the gesture, mustered the man briefly and then addressed him. "Major, what can I do for you?"

"General sir, I'm asking about the terms under which I can surrender my unit."

Again a brief moment of silence. It seemed extremely unorthodox for Sedgwick to accept surrender at regimental level, but he had been impressed by the doggedness of the Confederate resistance against his will.

"Very well, Major. I expect your men to lay down their arms and strike down their flag. You fought bravely and I am happy to allow your officers to keep their swords and sidearms as long as they are unloaded."

"Sir, these terms are honorable. I present you hereby with our surrender."

After the conventions had been complied with, it was evident that a burden fell from the man's shoulders. He staggered slightly and it was foreseeable that he could hardly stand on his feet from exhaustion.

"Major?" Obviously Sedgwick still had a question to ask. "Which regiment do you command?"

For a moment the man seemed stunned until he answered.

"General sir, my name is Major John Bane of the 4th Texas and I am the senior officer of the Texas Brigade who can still stand. The couple hundred men there behind me in the fog, that's what's left of my brigade."
 
Last edited:
Confeds might be better off without Hood, lest we forget how he threw away his army attacking Sherman around Atlanta. Not to mention Lee was also quite offensively minded, and while he did win (until Gettysburg at least), his victories did come at quite a price, like in the 7-days Campaign and elsewhere. I might be mistaken, but Lee did have higher casualties then Grant, at least until the Overland Campaign, when you put their carrers side by side.

It is a derail, but does anyone know TL where CSA stays on the defensive or something along these lines.
True - Hood had useless arm after Gettysburg, left his leg at Chickamauga. On his record as Johnston's successor- where did he leave his brain?
 
Sorry for taking longer to finish the last chapter, my mind was occupied with work, got a deadline in my way.

True - Hood had useless arm after Gettysburg, left his leg at Chickamauga. On his record as Johnston's successor- where did he leave his brain?

For an unorthodox perspective on Hood and his perfomance as army general, I recommend Stephen Hood's "John Bell Hood: The Rise, Fall, and Resurrection of a Confederate General". Although being a bit biased (family connection), the author makes some compelling cases.
 
Only good reason to oppose the re naming of bases named after Confederate Generals is the fine service both Hood and Bragg rendered the Union cause as Army Commanders.
 
Dear audience, I do hope not do disappoint you, but I will be changing the narration mode to a more history-booky style. This is due to a little mental blockade concerning narrative writing, which has slowed the process in the past. I like my TL too much to abandon it. Updates will be coming quicker now, starting with tomorrow.
 
Top