like the opposite thread (we haven't had one of these in a while) post here your gold silver bronze and honorable mention
Gold - Field Marshal Model... Kiev, Mars, Kaments and East Prussia, the guy was flat out a brilliant armored commander... and was one of the very few to counsel Hitler that Kursk was doomed to be a fiasco (and he should get bonus points for calling off the offensive immediately upon his troops failing to break through.
Silver - Henri Petain, one of the few generals in WW1 who gave even the smallest crap about his men. Along with Fayolle thrashed Germans instead of being thrashed himself... his later dirty politics aside the guy was a good commander; and his 1917 counterattack at verdun, and his restoration of order following the mutinies make him a close runner up
Bronze - Monty, the best British general since Wellington... was able to defeat an enemy who for the most part made excellent use of highly defensible terrain, whilst keeping his own losses low... was nearly perfectly tailored to take advtange of British strategic edges in combat; not perfect by any measure but the man won when everyone else before him failed big time
Honorable mention - Erwin Rommel... the highly favorable kill/booty ratio's speak for themselves