I have read a fair number of the Civil War Alternate History, but I was wondering which do the people on this site consider the best. If attention is any signal, then TL 191 seems to be the answer, but I have also heard some pretty harsh critiques on them.
Interestingly enough, most of the complaints tend to gravitate towards alternate events decades AFTER the Confederacy winning, instead of the process that leads to actual victory. In TL-191, there are some gaps between September 1862-November 1862 (including the Pre-1880s and Pre-1910s) that are never addressed, if not briefly mentioned.
I've always thought that it would have been a real treat if there was a daily/weekly/yearly record of just HOW exactly the South was able to win and continue to successfully function. The jumps in the timeline were a missed opportunity, in my opinion.
To answer your question, I am only familiar with TL-191 and it ranks up pretty high for me. The only other ones I've seen/read are the mockumentary
C.S.A.: The Confederate States of America and one timeline on this site.
Personally I think Shattered Nation by Jeffrey E. Brooks looks like a good read, even if I haven't read it and the author of it was banned from this site.
I didn't know this happened.
What lead to the guy's banning?