alternatehistory.com

This question has been asked previously on this board, most notably here in a poll where William Slim narrowly won over Montgomery. But that was eight years ago. A new debate is warrented I say.

After a breif discussion with Jim Smitty in another thread I thought we might have a debate regarding this matter.

So what makes a good general the best?

I usually look for certain qualities, offensive and defensive capabilites, logistics, how the general handles a retreat and how he handles the rank and file.
Top