Let's assume the Nazi attempt to take over the Bavarian government was much better organized and prepared. How much traction does this newborn movement have circa 1924-25? Where does a decade earlier Nazi start at government lead?
... As I have said before, if an author in the late twenties wrote a fiction piece that described the Holocaust as people were really killed, that book would be banned in many places, the author's sanity would be questioned and the world did not treat insane people very well in those years.
So, can the nazi party of 1924 gain further traction from controlling the Bavarian government, or does real capability derive from the conditions of 1930-33?
Would the Nazi appointees and toughs now deputized by the Bavarian government become the civil authority in all parts of Bavaria, for instance, the Palatinate, which was occupied by French troops at the time?
How ?Let's assume the Nazi attempt to take over the Bavarian government was much better organized and prepared. ...
In control of the government by 1925: wouldn't they (Nazis) then be seen as the cause of (or failure to stop) the great depression, and would not the Weimar Republic have had a chance to revitalize itself and become the economic answer? ...
How ?
Sry, but IMHO the Beerhall-putsch to succeed is simply ASB.
Pls remember :
-The by Hitler 'thought of' supporting him regular 'strong men' - v- Kahr, Lossow, Seßler, Killing _ were 'hijacked' by Hitler the evening og 9th November only.
-As soon as they came free they renounced their pressed(?) support for Hitler or rather Ludendorff as the figurehead and ordered the police to fire at them.
-The Nazis let enough members of the regular bavarian goverment flee to keep the 'regulat' goverment alive
-The Nazis had to get virtually ALL of their members and esp. SA-Bulies to Munich to pull off even this limited action (where from they hoped for the numbers to march against Berlin ? ... )
-The Reichswehr were NOT Hitlers friend. Just a fortnight ago the Nazi-press had deeply insulted v.Seeckt, at this point not only the leader but more or less the 'owner' of the Reichswehr.
Also : Hans v.Seeckt had 'just' got orders from Ebert at 29th Oktober for Saxony and at 6th November for Thuringia for 'Reichsexecution' whjich meant take-over of power by the Reichswehr by force in this countries of the german realm.
At 9th November the Reichswehr stooid fully armed and activated in Thuringia ... just in the way from Munich to Berlin ...