alternatehistory.com

hello I've got some ideas on a different Battle of Shiloh to make it a Confederate victory & would like yalls opinion & feedback to see if any are possible & what yall think might happen because of a Union defeat, here they are.

1.) Have General Sherman killed on the first day of the battle. With Sherman dead could General Hardee's troops overrun Sherman's division taking it out of the western flank?

2.) General Johnston not get shot & continue to lead the Confederate Army.



Could these either together or separate let the Confederates defeat Grant at Pittsburgh Landing? & if so what effects would this have on the civil war? Could Grant get replaced? Could the Confederacy keep the Union from cutting it in half? What all could happen?

Thanks ahead for all input.
Top