Baseball in the Pythagorean Universe 1871-Present

It also did my heart good as a Pirates fan to see Bonds held to only one hit. I thought the simulator would have him go crazy and win the Series almost singlehandedly, since the Giants were the real-life National League champions and the Red Sox weren't even a playoff team. He has only one more chance to win a Series in this universe, and that's the following year, 2003. I'm not going to tamper with the results just to make sure he loses, but if I was ever tempted to do so for the sake of one player, it's him.

I know, years ago in Strat-O-Matic he had a ridiculous world Series in 1993 for the Giantgs for me on the computer, hitting something like .600 with 5 home runs and 13 RBIs or something - I think it was against the White Sox.

If it makes you feel any better, I would sometimes control teams I liked, go to 4-man rotations, etc., and once the Pirates were 15.5 back in late July and in 3rd, the Phillies started a big swoon, and I took over. The Pirates won the division, swept the Braves, and went on to beat the White Sox in 7 a la 1971 (home team wins every game but the last, which Pittsburgh won on the road).
 
From eighty-seven loss team to world champions without most of their stars from the previous three years. Even Jim Leyland couldn't do that!
 
Last edited:
Now it's time for Game 2 of the second 1996 American League Division Series from Yankee Stadium in New York. The date is Wednesday, October 2:

Lineup Changes:

Indians- Kevin Seitzer and Julio Franco switch positions on defense; Seitzer will start at first, while Franco will serve as the designated hitter. Also, Jose Vizcaino will start at second base and bat ninth. This means that Sandy Alomar Jr. moves up to seventh and Omar Vizquel to eighth.

Yankees- Cecil Fielder will be the designated hitter and bat sixth. Also, Jim Leyritz replaces Joe Girardi behind the plate and will bat eighth.

Indians 1st: Kenny Lofton grounded the first pitch of the game into right field for a single, then stole second. After a walk to Seitzer, third baseman Jim Thome stepped to the plate. Here's Bob Costas with the count one ball and one strike:

"The Indians are off to a fast start, which is the best way to get the taste out of their mouths from last night. Jose Mesa faced the media and answered every question put to him, even as they got more and more repetitive, which was a class act on his part. The same was true for (Indians manager) Mike Hargrove. That's not a scene they want to repeat however, as they need this game to even things up heading home to Jacobs Field for the weekend. There you see Lofton at second, and if Hargrove wants to, he can give him the steal sign again, Thome, meanwhile, gets the one-one from Pettitte AND DRIVES IT HIGH AND DEEP TO RIGHT CENTER, WILLIAMS GOES BACK, AT THE FENCE, BUT IT'S OUTTA HERE! 3-0 CLEVELAND RIGHT FROM THE JUMP!...…...Thome hit that one so hard that he broke his bat, as you see him pick up the pieces on his way to the dugout."

Joe Garagiola: "You don't see that too often, for sure. Yep, there goes the bat, but more importantly, there goes the ball over the fence. What power this guy has, Bob."

Bob Uecker: "Pettitte wanted to paint the outside corner with a fastball, but Thome was waiting for him to do just that. He's ore of the great power hitters in the game today, and that swing was effortless. As you said, Bobby, there's no better way to put last night behind you if you're the Indians, and for the second straight game the Yankees will have to come from behind."

Albert Belle followed with a single up the middle, stole second, and moved to third on Franco's grounder to Mariano Duncan at second. But he was stranded there when Pettitte struck out both Manny Ramirez and Alomar swinging to end the inning. The Tribe's evening has gotten off to a fine start thanks to Thome's three-run blast; how will the Yankees counter?

Indians 5th: With one out, Seitzer singled to left. Thome was hit in the shin by a pitch to put two men on, and Belle put the finishing touches on the evening's scoring in grand style. Here's Bob with the count one ball and no strikes:

"Belle's been quiet so far in this series, but with forty-eight home runs and a hundred and forty RBIs on the year, you know he's capable of breaking out at any time. Pettitte's settled down since giving up the homer to Thome in the first, but (Indians starter Orel) Hershiser's only given up one hit through four. It's imperative for Pettittie to hold the Indians where they are until the Yankee bats get going. One ball, no strikes to Belle with Seitzer at second and Thome at first. A check of the runners, not going, and the one-ball pitch is pulled down the line in left, over goes Raines, he's at the fence, and it's a...….FAIR BALL AND A THREE-RUN HOMER FOR BELLE!...….There was uncertainty for a split second until left field umpire Mark Johnson made the home run signal. That's two three-run homers for the Indians tonight, which translates into a 6-0 lead and a pitching change for the Yankees."

Uecker: "I don't know about this one, Bobby. It looked to me like it left the park foul."

Garagiola: "Let's take a look. There you see the ball. Raines going over, and there you see him let up on it. He sure thinks it's foul by a good margin."

Costas: "(Yankee manager) Joe Torre's out of the dugout and all over Johnson, and Raines is right there with him. They're asking for help from the third base umpire Al Clark, and here he comes."

Uecker: "They've gotten Raines out of there, and Torre's getting more heated as time goes on. "

Garagiola: "Clark's refusing to help, and now Torre's really livid! He's gonna get himself tossed if he's not.....there he goes!"

Costas: "It didn't seem like the original call was what upset Torre as much as the refusal of Al Clark to at least offer an opinion. Torre thought it was foul, Raines thought it was foul, our replays showed that it was foul, but regardless the home run stands, the Indians lead 6-0, Torre's out of the game, (bench coach) Don Zimmer's got the Yankee lineup card, and Brian Boehringer's the new Yankee pitcher."

Boehringer retired Franco on a grounder to second and Manny on a fly to Williams in shallow left center, but the Indians have gotten a controversial three-run homer from Belle, and halfway through Game 2 they lead the Yankees 6-0.

As I said earlier, there was no further scoring, mostly thanks to the brilliant pitching of Hershiser. He threw a two-hit shutout, walking just one and striking out five in an ultra-efficient ninety-nine pitches. He gave up a one-out double to Wade Boggs in the first and a walk to Fielder in the second, then retired seventeen New York hitters in a row until he gave up a one-out double to Mariano Duncan in the eighth. He was named Player of the Game by NBC for his efforts.

Final totals: Indians 6-8-0, Yankees 0-2-0.

W- Hershiser (1-0)
L- Pettitte (0-1)

HR- CLE: Thome (1), Belle (1)

The series will shift to Jacobs Field in Cleveland for Game 3 on Friday afternoon. First pitch is scheduled for shortly after 4PM Eastern, with Jimmy Key starting for the Yankees and Jack McDowell taking the ball for the Indians.

Next: We look at Game 3.

Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
Now it's time for Game 3 of the second 1996 American League Division Series from Jacobs Field in Cleveland. The date is Friday, October 4:

Lineup Changes:

Yankees- Derek Jeter moves up to the leadoff spot. Tim Raines moves down to second, and Bernie Williams moves up to third. Cecil Fielder moves up to fourth, and Mariano Duncan moves up to sixth. Paul O'Neill moves down to seventh. Charlie Hayes gets the start at third base and will bat eighth, and Joe Girardi is back behind the plate and will bat ninth.

Indians- Kevin Seitzer and Julio Franco switch defensive positions for the second game in a row: Seitzer will serve as the designated hitter, while Franco plays first base.

Indians 3rd: With one out, shortstop Omar Vizquel faced Yankees starter Jimmy Key. Here's Bob Costas with the count one ball and one strike:

"We haven't heard much from Vizquel offensively in this series, but he's no lightweight with the bat; he hit nine home runs and drove in sixty-four this year. A constant fever pitch from the time the gates opened this afternoon, as the fans here consider the Yankees their top rival, even mores so than the White Sox or any one else in their division. The Indians fell short two years ago in a five-game thriller in the first Division Series, and ever since it's the Yankees to whom the Indians compare themselves, even last year when they were a playoff team and the Yankees weren't. One-one pitch is drilled down the left field line, Raines going over, looking p, he's out of room, AND THIS BALL IS GONE!.....Shades of Wednesday night in the Bronx, but this ball was clearly fair, and the Indians strike first."

Bob Uecker: "No question that this one was fair, and the Indians seem to like pulling the ball in this series. The ball was well-struck by Vizquel, and Raines was so busy looking up and trying to find the ball that he never sees the wall. He only realizes it's there when he runs into it chest-first. He stays on his feet, but this ball's gone, and the Indians have the lead."

Joe Garagiola: "The Yankees can't get a sense of deja vu. They're only down one instead of three like they were in Game 2 when (Jim) Thome homered to give the Indians the lead,, so they have plenty of time to get back in the game and plenty of good hitters in their lineup that can score runs."

Jose Vizcaino followed with a single to left, and Kenny Lofton's single out of Key's reach and up the middle put runners at the corners. After Lofton stole second, Seitzer hit a bouncer to short. Jeter dropped the ball, and by the time he picked it up he had no play at first. Vizcaino scored to give the Tribe a 2-0 lead, and Lofton moved to third. Thome's fly to right center was caught on the warning track by Williams for the second out, which brought Lorton home with the third Cleveland run, Albert Belle then launched a deep fly to left which Raines managed to catch just before running into the wall for the final out. The Indians have drawn first blood thanks to three runs on three hits, a stolen base, and an error, and they lead the Yankees 3-0 after three.

Yankees 4th: Williams led off with a single to left. After Fielder flew to left center, Williams stole second. Tino Martinez grounded a single to right to bring Bernie home and put the Yankees on the board. Duncan's screaming liner was gloved by Franco for the second out, but O'Neill walked to put two men on. Indians starter Jack McDowell struck Hayes out swinging to end the inning with runners still at first and second, but the Yanks have managed a run thanks to two hits, a walk....., and a stolen base. We've played three and a half, and it's Indians 3, Yankees 1.

Here's how Franco's grab of Duncan's liner, our Defensive Play of the Day, was called by Bob:

"A wicked line drive THAT IS GLOVED BY A DIVING FRANCO!...….They may not have football in Cleveland for the moment, but that diving catch by Franco was worthy of Ozzie Newsome in his prime. Two out now for Paul O'Neill."

Indians 4th: Franco led off against Kay. Here's Bob with the count no balls and one strike:

"Franco and Seitzer have gone back and forth throughout this series between first base and the DH spot, and (Indians manager) Mike Hargrove says that he'll keep doing that throughout the postseason to give Franco a day off from defense while keeping his bat in the lineup. The Indians haven't had a steady DH since Eddie Murray was traded back to Baltimore in July, so it's back to the old-fashioned idea of giving a player a day off by letting him be the DH for a day. The one-strike pitch is LINED DEEP TO RIGHT! O'NEILL GOING BACK, HE'S AT THE FENCE, BUT THIS ONE IS GONE!......….Four consecutive home runs over the last two games for the Indians, and they now lead 4-1."

Uecker: "This has to be getting to (Yankees manager) Joe Torre. To beat the Indians, you have to keep them in the ballpark, and the Yankees haven's been doing a very good job of it lately. It hasn't been the guys you'd expect today, with Omar Vizquel and now Julio Franco going deep in place of guys like Belle and Thome, who homered in Game 2."

Garagiola: (Yankees pitching coach) Mel Stottlemyre's going out to the mound to calm Key down a bit. He can't let this game get too much further out of hand; remember, the Indians scored two more runs after Vizquel's homer in the first. If they do that again, they'll put this game out of reach."

Manny Ramirez flew to left center for the first out, but Sandy Alomar Jr. lined a double into the left center power alley. He was stranded at second, as Vizquel bounced to Jeter at short and Vizcaino struck out swinging to end the inning. Franco's dinger has extended the Indians' lead to 4-1 after four.

Indians 5th: Lofton led off by beating out a grounder to short for an infield single. Seitzer's base hit to left center put runners at the corners. The runners held when Thome's liner was gloved by Duncan for out number one, but Belle socked a doble down the left field line. Raines cut it off before it could go into the corner, but Lofton still scored to make it 5-1 Cleveland while Seitzer moved to third. The runners remained at their stations while Franco grounded to short, but Manny's double down the right field line found the corner. Seitzer and Belle both scored, and the Indians led 7-1. Key's day ended at that point; Brian Boehringer came out of the Yankee pen to retire Alomar on a grounder to short. But the Indians have scored three more runs on four hits while Manny was stranded at second. We've played five, and it's Tribe 7, Pinstripes 1.

Indians 6th: Vizquel led off with a bloop single to right center. Vizcaino's lined single to right put runners at the corners, but Lofton popped out to Duncan at second for the first out, and Seitzer flew to center for out number two. Boehringer should have been out of the inning on Thome's comebacker, but it hit off of his glove for an error, which allowed Vizquel to score and made it 8-1 Indians. Belle's high pop to short ended the inning with runners still at first and second, but the Tribe has added a run on two hits and an error, and after six they lead the Yankees 8-1.

Yankees 8th: Williams led off with a base hit to right center. Fielder's single to right center moved Bernie to third, but Martinez's weak fly to shallow right center and Duncan's fly to shallow left produced the first two outs. O'Neill was next, and he lined a double off the wall in center to score Williams and reduce the Yankees' deficit to 8-2. McDowell departed at that point in favor of Paul Assenmacher, whose presence led Torre to send Wade Boggs to the plate to bat for Hayes. Boggs beat out a grounder to short for an infield hit, which brought Fielder home and made it 8-3. Girardi's base hit to left scored O'Neill, and it was now 8-4. Jeter's infield single to third loaded the bases, but Raines took a called third strike to end the inning with the bases still loaded. The Yankees have put a dent in the Indians' lead, sending nine men to the plate and scoring three runs on six hits, but as we go to the bottom of the eighth, it's still Cleveland 8, New York 4.

Yankees 9th: Eric Plunk came in to get the final three outs for the Tribe, but he was greeted by Bernie's base hit to right, Fielder's single to left put runners at the corners, and Andy Fox came in to run for Big Daddy. Martinez's base hit to right brought Williams home, and the Cleveland lead was down to 8-5. With the tying run coming to the plate, Indians manager Mike Hargrove called on Jose Mesa, who hadn't gotten an out during the Yankees' ninth-inning comeback in Game 1. He got two in lightning fashion today, as Duncan forced Martinez on his first pitch, with Fox moving to third, and O'Neill lined to Franco on his second pitch. But Boggs grounded a base hit to right center to score Fox and bring the Yanks to within 8-6, and Darryl Strawberry batted for Girardi and slapped a base hit to right that brought Duncan home and made it 8-7. Jeter had a chance to finish the comeback against a rattled Mesa, and he worked the count to three balls and no strikes. But Mesa reached down deep and fired three straight fastballs past a flailing Jeter to end the game with runners still at first and second. Our final: Indians 8, Yankees 7, and the Indians lead the series two games to one.

Williams was named Player of the Game by NBC in a losing cause. He finished his day four for five and scored three runs.

Final totals: Indians 8-11-2, Yankees 7-17-2.

W- McDowell (1-0)
S- Mesa (1)
L- Key (0-1)

HR- CLE: Franco (1), Vizquel (1)

The series will continue with Game 4 tomorrow afternoon at Jacobs Field. First pitch is scheduled for shortly after 4PM Eastern, with Kenny Rogers pitching for the Yankees and Charles Nagy starting for the Indians.

Next: We look at Game 4.

Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
Bow it's time for Game 4 of the second 1996 American League Division Series from Jacobs Field in Cleveland. The date is Saturday, October 5:

Lineup Changes:

Yankees-
Tim Raines moves back up to the leadoff spot, while Derek Jeter is back in the nine hole. Wade Boggs is back at third base and batting second. Tino Martinez and Cecil Fielder switch places in the batting order; Martinez will bat fourth, while Fielder bats fifth. Marinao Duncan and Paul O'Neill also switch places in the batting order, with O'Neill batting sixth and Duncan batting seventh. Finally, Joe Girardi moves up to eighth.

Indians- Omar Vizquel moves up to second, while Kevin Seitzer moves down to third. Also, Jeff Kent replaces Jim Thome at third base and will bat seventh, which means that Sandy Alomar Jr. moves down to eighth.

Indians 1st: Kenny Lofton led off with a base hit up the middle. Vizquel's base hit up the middle put runners at the coorners, and Vizquel quickly stole second to put two runners in scoring position. Seitzer popped to Jeter at short for the second out, but Yankees starter Kenny Rogers walked Belle to load the bases, then first baseman Julio Franco to force Lofton in and give the Indians a 1-0 lead. Manny Ramirez bounced into a fielder's choice for the second out, with Vizquel coming home to make it 2-0 Cleveland. Kent's grounder to third ended the inning with runners still at the corners, but the Tribe has scored twice to take the lead thanks yo two hits, two walks, a stolen base, and a force play. We've played one in Game 4, and it's Indians 2, Yankees 0.

Yankees 5th: With two out, Raines faced Indians starter Charles Nagy. Here's Bob Costas with the count two balls and no strikes:

"The Yankees had their biggest threat in the third, when they put runners at the corners with two out on a single by Girardi, who then stole second, and a walk to Jeter. Giradi went to third with two out on a fielder's choice, but Williams struck out to end the threat. Now the Yankees looking for a spark here in the fifth with two out, and a two-ball, no-strike count to Raines. The 2-0 pitch is hit hard down the right field line, Ramire going back, he's at the fence, but it's still going AND IT'S GONE!......Tim Raines goes deep here in the fifth to put the Yamkees on the board, and we have yet another homer hit down one of the lines."

Bob Uecker: "These hitters are pull-happy, Bobby, but it's been working for them so far. Raines has a bit of pop in his bat, as he hit nine home runs this year, and he hit that ball very hard. The Yankees are right back in this game."

Joe Garagiola: "That's one of the few balls that the Yankees have hit hard against Nagy in two games. Maybe they're finally getting to him. They better hope so, that's for sure, because they're running out of time."

Boggs walked on five pitches to keep the inning going, but Bernie Williams' liner was gloved by Jose Vizcaino for the third out. Raines homer has put the Pinstripes on the board, but they still trail the Indians 2-1 halfway through.

Yankees 7th: Girardi lined a leadoff single to left. Jeter flew to Lofton in left center for the first out, which brought Raines back to the plate. Here's Bob with the count one ball and one strike:

"Girardi still at first, as the fly ball by Jeter was nowhere deep enough to move him. Infield at double-play depth for the Indians, who still lead 2-1 here in the seventh. The fans here at The Jake are starting to buzz, as the Indians are just eight outs away from a chance to play for their first pennant since 1959. But the Yankees aren't done yet, as the heart of their order is due up at least once more. We'll see how careful Nagy is with Raines after his home run last time up. Nagy checks Girardi at first, nothing happening, and the one-one pitch......high fly ball deep to left, over s Belle, this one's headed toward the foul pole, AND IT BOUNCES OFF! THAT'S A HOME RUN, THE SECOND OF THE DAY FOR TIM RAINES, AND JUST LIKE THAT IT'S 3-2 YANKEES!"

Garagiola: "It seems to me that if Belle got over there a little quicker he might have had a play on this ball. I know he's paid for his bat, but it seemed like he just kind of loped over."

Uecker: "It was hit a little too high for him, Joe. He's not scaling any walls, as big as he is. It was just bad luck that it hit the foul pole, because after it did it was foul by a good twenty to thirty feet before it dropped."

Boggs went down swinging for the second out, and Williams' shallow fly to center ended the inning. But Raines' second homer of the day has put the Yankees in the lead. As we stretch by Lake Erie, it's New York 3, Cleveland 2.

Indians 7th: Lofton lined a leadoff single to right against Yankee reliever Mariano Rivera, but was forced by Vizquel. That brought Seitzer to the plate. Here's Bob:

"Seitzer two for three today, with consecutive singles in the third and fifth. Another one here would put the Indians in serious business with two on, most likely at first and third, and nobody out. Rivera has to watch Vizquel, who stole thirty-five bases in forty-four attempts during the regular season. They'll probably give Seitzer a chance to hit before allowing Vizquel to go, though. Rivera nods to Girardi, takes a quick look at first, now comes home......HIGH LINE DRIVE TO DEEP LEFT CENTER! BERNIE'S BACK, HE'S AT THE WALL, BUT THIS ONE'S OUTTA HERE!.....Seitzer goes deep here in the seventh to get the lead back for the Indians, and you can hear the pandemonium from Pittsburgh to Buffalo."

Uecker: "Rivera's best pitch is that cut fastball we showed you at the top of the broadcast. But if a smart hitter looks for it and times it, he can hit it a long way. Look at Seitzer; he knows this one's gone from the second he hits it."

Garagiola: "I like this Rivera kid, but he may need another pitch to go with that cutter if he wants to be an effective big-league closer."

Sir Mo recovered to strike out both Belle and Franco swinging to end the inning, but Seitzer's two-run blast has put the Tribe just six outs from the ALCS. At the end of seven, it's Indians 4, Yankees 3.

Indians 8th: Manny led off with a base hit to left center. Kent flew to left for the first out, and Alomar's deep fly to left center was caught by Williams in front of the warning track for out number two. Manny then stole second and came home on Vizcaino's base hit to right to put the Tribe up 5-3. Lofton's grounder to first ended the inning, but the Tribe has added a run on two hits and a stolen base. Jose Mesa's coming out of the bullpen to face Duncan, Girardi, and Jeter in the top of the ninth, and he'll be protecting a 5-3 Cleveland lead.

Yankees 9th: Mesa struck out Duncan and pinch-hitter Jim Leyritz (batting for Girardi) swinging on six consecutive pitches, then made Jeter swing and miss twice. Here's Bob with what happened next:

"Mesa has gotten eight consecutive swings and misses here in the ninth. Striking out the side on nine pitches is known as a golden inning; I wonder what nine consecutive wild swings and misses is. Whatever it is, Mesa wants it, and this sellout crowd wants it. Mesa from the stretch, the two-strike pitch......GOT HIM SWINGING, AND THE INDIANS WIN IT!...…..For the first time in thirty-seven years, the Indians will play for an American League pennant; actually, it's the first time that they'll play for it in their history, because there was no such thing as an ALCS in 1959. Regardless, they've eliminated the favorites in the American League, and they'll welcome the Texas Rangers for Game I of the ALCS here at Jacobs Field on Tuesday night.

There's a look at our Player of the Game, Kevin Seitzer, who hit a two-run homer in the seventh against Mariano Rivera to give the Indians the lead for good. He finished his day three for four, and we'll talk to him and a lot of other Indians when we come back from this break. Our final score: the Cleveland Indians 5, the New York Yankees 3, and the Indians have won this series three games to one. Back to Jacobs Field with plenty of interviews and analysis after these messages and a word from your local stations."

Final totals: Indians 5-11-0, Yankees 3-6-0.

W- Nagy (1-0)
S- Mesa (2)
L- Rivera (0-1)

HR- NYY: Raines 2 (2)
CLE: Seitzer (1)

Game 1 of the Amercan League Championship Series is set for Tuesday night at Jacobs Field. First pitch is scheduled for shortly after 8PM on NBC, with Ken Hill starting for the Rangers and Orel Hershiser getting the ball for the Indians.

Before we go, here's our Defensive Play of the Night. It's the top of the sixth with two out, O'Neill at first, and Duncan at the plate. Here's Bob:

"Groundball deep in the hole at third. Kent grabs it near the line, long throw...…..DUG OUT BY FRANCO, AND THE SIDE IS RETIRED!...….Tremendous play by Jeff Kent, and the Yankees leave O'Neill at first. Indians lead 2-1 after six, and we're back after this from your local station."

Next: We look at Game 1 of the ALCS.

Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
Who knows, the curse of Rocky colavito could be over very quickly. This was a Powerhouse Indians offense, the picture was starting to get old other than Nagy though.
 
I think your autocorrect means pitching, Doug. And you're right; with Hershiser and Dennis Martinez as two of their top starters, they may be vulnerable to the Rangers' own superpowered offense. We'll just have to wait and see!

What do you make of a huge chunk of the Yankees dynasty of the nineties falling by the wayside? Two championships in five years is still impressive, but add '94 to what hey had in real life and you come up with four in six years and five in seven, which is approaching the heights they hit in the thirties and fifties. They may still end up the Team of the Decade, but the Braves will have a claim if they can beat either the Brewers or the Twins in '92 when we get there. (1999 is still in play too, but if the Braves win the NL pennant, they'll automatically lose to the Yankees as they did in real life.)
 
Last edited:
Now it's time for Game 1 of the 1996 American League Championship Series from Jacobs Field in Cleveland. The date is Tuesday, October 8:

Weather: 58 degrees, cloudy skies, north-northeast wind at 10 MPH.

Indians 2nd: Manny Ramirez led off against Rangers starter Ken Hill. Here's Bob Costas with the count one ball and no strikes:

"Each team had a hit in the first inning, but (Indians starter Orel) Hershiser got (Rangers catcher Pudge) Rodriguez to bounce into a double play after (center fielder Darryl) Hamilton led off with a base hit. In the bottom of the first, (Indians center fielder Kenny) Lofton singled and stole second, but (Rangers starter Ken) Hill retired the next three batters in order and left Lofton stranded. The Indians turned another double play to end the last half-inning after (Rangers first baseman Will) Clark walked, and now you're up to date. One ball and no strikes to Ramirez, and we're ready for Hill's next pitch...….DRIVEN HIGH AND DEEP TO LEFT CENTER FIELD! HAMILTON ON HIS HORSE, HE'S BACK TO THE FENCE AND LEAPS, BUT THIS BALL IS GONE!.....If you're in a pool at work on who would hit the first home run of what should be a homer-filled series and you had Manny Ramirez, congratulations. The Indians strike first in Game 1."

Bob Uecker: "This wasn't a bad pitch by Hill, but it was met squarely by Ramirez, and those of us who watch him regularly know that any ball that's hit squarely is going to trouble for the other team. This one wasn't one of Manny more breathtaking home runs, as Darryl Hamilton actually tries to make the catch before it goes over the wall in left center, but it's just a bit too high for him to get a glove on."

Joe Garagiola: "If you have an office pool on how many home runs will be hit in this series, try to get a number over thirty. These are two tremendous offensive ballclubs."

First baseman Jeff Kent grounded to short for the first out, and second baseman Jose Vizcaino went down swinging for out number two. Catcher Tony Pena kept the inning going with a single to left, but shortstop Omar Vizquel's foul pop behind first was caught by Clark to retire the side. The Tribe has scored first thanks to Manny's home run, and after two they lead the Rangers 1-0.

Rangers 5th: After two out, second baseman Mark McLemore walked on five pitches. Shortstop Kevin Elster lined a single to left that moved McLemore to third, and Mark came home with the tying run when Hamilton beat out a grounder to short for an infield single. Rodriguez walked to load the bases, but left fielder Rusty Greer grounded to third to retire the side. The Rangers have tied the game thanks to two hits and two walks, but they've also left the bases loaded. Halfway through Game 1, we're tied at one.

Indians 5th: Pena led off with a base hit to left center. Vizquel's single up the middle put two men on, and Lofton whacked a double down the right field line to score Pena and give the Indians a 2-1 lead. Vizquel moved to third on the play, but Hill stranded both runners: designated hitter Kevin Seitzer bounced to short, and both third baseman Jim Thome and left fielder Albert Belle struck out swinging to end the inning. The home squad has taken the lead with a run on three hits, and after five it's Indians 2, Rangers 1.

Indians 6th: Ramirez led off by lining a double into the left field corner. Kent followed with a base hit to left that brought Manny home and put the Indians up 3-1. Vizcaino followed with a bouncer to short that scooted through Elster's legs for an error, allowing Vizcaino to reach. Pena grounded into a 6-4-3 double play, with Kent moving to third. Vizquel walked to put runners at the corners, but Lofton grounded to Clark at first to end the inning. The Indians have added an insurance run on two hits, an error, and a walk, and they now lead the Lewmen 3-1 after six.

That was all the scoring. Clark doubled with one out in the ninth to put the tying run on base and end Indians starter Orel Hershiser's evening, but Jose Mesa retired Rangers third baseman Dean Palmer on a fly to center, then struck out designated hitter Mickey Tettleton swinging to end the game. Our final: Indians 3, Rangers 1, and the Indians lead the best-of-seven series one game to none.

Ramirez and Hershiser shared NBC's Player of the Game honors. Hershiser pitched eight and a third innings, giving up one run on seven hits while walking three and striking out six in a hundred and twelve pitches. Ramirez finished three for four with a homer plus another run scored. A tip of the cap in a losing cause to Hill, who pitched an eight-inning complete game, giving up three runs on nine hits while walking two, striking out seven, and throwing a hundred and seven pitches. Hamilton led the Texas offense, going three for four and driving in the Rangers' only run.

Final totals: Indians 3-9-0, Rangers 1-7-1.

W- Hershiser (1-0)
S- Mesa (1)
L- Hill (0-1)

HR- CLE: Ramirez (1)

This series will continue tomorrow with Game 2 here at Jacobs Field. First pitch is scheduled for shortly after 4PM Eastern, with Bobby Witt starting for the Rangers and Jack McDowell going to the hill for the Indians.

Next: We look at Game 2.

Thoughts?

Note: I have no idea who would have had home field advantage in this series in real life because Major League Baseball used a rotation system at this time. I gave it to the Indians because they had a better regular season record.
 
Last edited:
IMPORTANT NOTICE:

Game 2 of the American League Championship Series that was scheduled for Wednesday, October 9 has been postponed due to rain. It has been rescheduled for Thursday, October 10 with a special early start time of 1PM Eastern so that the game can be played before further inclement weather hits the Cleveland area later in the day. The starting pitchers will remain the same: Bobby Witt for the Rangers and Jack McDowell for the Indians.
 
You're right, it should be pitching. The Braves definitely will have more of a chance to claim that title, they really did in our timeline if they had won in 99. Interestingly, in 1998 the Indians were the only Club to defeat the Yankees in the postseason in even one game. They were up 2-1 on the Yankees in fact before New York came back and won the ALCS four games to two.
 
Yankees-Indians has been a whale of a rivalry in this universe, with the Yankees winning in the '94 Division Series and the '98 ALCS and the Tribe winning the Division Series in '96 and '97. The Indians have an all-time advantage of three series to two so far; they won the ALCS in 2017.
 
Now it's time for Game 2 of the 1996 American League Championship Series from Jacobs Field in Cleveland. The date is Thursday, October 10:

Lineup Changes:

Indians- Julio Franco is back at first base and batting fifth. which moves Manny Ramirez down to sixth. Jeff Kent moves from first base to second base and will bat seventh. Finally, Sandy Alomar Jr. is back behind the plate and will bat eighth.

Weather: 51 degrees, cloudy skies, north wind at 14 MPH. There will be brief rain showers late in the game, but they won't affect play.

Indians 1st: Kenny Lofton led off with a base hit to left center, then stole second. Kevin Seitzer walked to put two men on, but Jim Thome's pop behind first was caught by Will Clark for out number one. That brought Albert Belle to the plate. Here's Bob Costas with the count two balls and a strike:

"It's a raw, windy day here in Cleveland, and it'll be interesting to see how the balls carry. We haven't really had a read on that yet, since neither team took batting practice due to the field conditions. The one thing we know for sure is that Jack McDowell couldn't get his arm loose, so Albie Lopez got an emergency start with something like ten minutes' notice. He gave up a two-out hit to (Rangers left fielder) Rusty Greer in the top of the first, but no further damage was done. Pitch to Belle IS HIT A MILE TO DEEP LEFT CENTER! BACK GOES HAMILTON, AT THE WALL, SHE'S GONE!.....Well, that answers that question, at least as far as Albert Belle is concerned. The Indians lead 3-0."

Joe Garagiola: "I don't think that this proves much except that Albert Belle can hit a baseball far in any kind of weather. This would've been a home run in a snowstorm; look at the height he got. And they're not wasting any time down in the Rangers' bullpen; that looks like Kevin Gross starting to warm up."

Bob Uecker: "The Rangers don't want to fall any further behind, especially with Lopez pitching. He's not fully warmed up yet, and it's a cold day out there, at least by baseball standards. The Texas bats can get to him if the pitching can keep it close."

But Franco grounded a single to left to keep the inning going, and Manny's base hit to left center moved him to third. Kent was next, and he scaled a ball into the left center power alley. Both Franco and Ramirez scored easily, and the Tribe led 5-0. Witt's day was over just like that; Gross retired Alomar on a bouncer to short and Omar Vizquel on a liner to Clark at first, and the inning was finally over. But the Tribe has scored five runs on five hits and a walk, and they lead the Rangers 5-0 after one.

Rangers 2nd: Will Clark led off against Lopez. Here's Bob:

"As Uke said last half-inning, the Rangers' bats are certainly capable of getting to Albie Lopez, but they have to dig out of a five-run hole, and they'll start with Will Clark. who only hit one home run against the White Sox in the Division Series, but had a stretch of ten hits in eleven at-bats over Games 2 and 3. The Rangers have to hope that he hasn't cooled off much over the last two games. First pitch is HIT WELL TO DEEP LEFT! BELLE TAKES TWO STEPS BACK AND WISHES IT BON VOYAGE!...…..One pitch into the second inning, and the Rangers are already on the board."

Uecker: "Lopez got that pitch a bit up and into Will Clark's wheelhouse, and just like hat it was gone; no chance for Albert. Lopez was actually finishing his pregame warmups between innings, so he may be a bit tired; he didn't have any rest between innings."

Garagiola: "That's the danger of being an emergency starter, and it really was an emergency; McDowell was just about ready to go back in from the bullpen when he was scratched. He was almost completely warmed up."

Dean Palmer drew a five-pitch walk to keep the inning going, but Lopez retired the next three hitters in order: Mickey Tettleton went down swinging, Mark McLemore flew to left, and Kevin Elster flew to right center to retire the side. Clark's home run has put the Lawmen on the board, but they still trail 5-1 after an inning and a half.

Indians 3rd: Franco drew a one-out walk, which brought Manny to the plate. Here's Bob with the count two balls and two strikes:

"A reminder that there's no travel day in this series now; we're right back at it tomorrow night at 8PM Eastern from The Ballpark in Arlington. 7:30 PM Eastern on Saturday night for Game 4, and if we need Game 5 on Sunday it comes your way after football at 4:30 PM Eastern. Two and two to Ramirez, with Franco at first and one out. Gross checks Franco, who isn't going, and the two-two pitch IS LINED HIGH AND DEEP TO LEFT! BACK IS GREER, AT THE FENCE, BUT IT'S OUTTA HERE!.....A cold, windy day in Cleveland has produced three absolute bombs, and the home team has two of them and a 7-1 lead."

Garagiola: "The thing is, Bob, none of these are what you would call wind-aided. Sure it helped them go a little further, but they all would have been home runs in any conditions. This one by Ramirez was absolutely lasered. Greer had n chance at this ball and he knew it. Ramirez is already one of the top power hitters in the game, and he'll likely be one for a long time to come."

Uecker: "There you see the wince from Kevin Gross. He made a good pitch, but sometimes even good pitches get hit out of the ballpark."

Kent went down swinging for the second out, but Alomar nearly made it two homers in three batters before his fly to deep left was caught by Greer at the wall to end the inning. The Indians have added two more runs on Ramirez's dinger, and after three it's Indians 7, Rangers 1.

Rangers 4th: With one out, Palmer hit a deep drive to left. Belle lost the ball in the clouds, tried to dive for it too soon, and ended up flat on his face as it skimmed off the top of his glove and bounced away. Palmer pulled in at second, and the official scorer charged a two-base error on Belle. That brought Tettleton to the plate. Here's Bob:

"Belle known mostly for his bat, of course, but he can make the plays in the outfield when he has to most of the time. But this time he didn't, and the Rangers have Palmer at second and Tetlleton at the plate, which means more stress for the starter Lopez. There's Jack McDowell, who we're now told threw up in the bullpen just before he left and was scratched, so it wasn't his arm after all. He's wrapped up in that big blanket, so it's probably a virus, and we'll see how quickly he gets over it. MEANWHILE, TETTLETON LAUNCHES THE FIRST PITCH HE SEES TO DEEP RIGHT CENTER! LOFTON'S AT THE TRACK, TO THE FENCE, BUT THIS ONE'S GONE!......The error does end up hurting the Indians, as Tettleton immediately converts it into two runs via the homer, and it's now 7-3."

Garagiola: "When I woke up this morning and saw how cold it was, I didn't think we'd get one home run, let alone four. And all of them have been absolutely blasted. Here's another no-doubter, and Tettleton's hit more than a few of those this year."

Uecker: Indians pitching coach Mark Wiley's out to talk to Lopez. They really need him to go at least five innings if he possibly can, because there's no day off until Monday now and they need to save that bullpen as much as possible for what figures to be a long weekend in Arlington, where a ball or two has been known to fly out of."

McLemore followed with a lined single to left, but Elster's liner was gloved by Vizquel for the second out, and Hamilton's fly to left was caught safely by Belle for the final out. The Rangers have crept closer thanks to Tettleton's two-run homer, but at the end of three and a half it's Cleveland 7, Texas 3.

Indians 4th: With one out, Lofton slapped a single to right. Seitzer followed with a double over Hamilton's head in center, which brought Kenny home and put the Tribe up 8-3. Seitzer moved to third when Thome flew to the warning track in right center, but was stranded there when Belle popped to Elster at shirt, ending the inning. The Indians add a run on two hits, and after four they lead the Rangers 8-3.

Rangers 6th: Palmer led off with a routine grounder to third, but the ball squirted under Thome's arm for an error, allowing Palmer to reach. Tettleton walked to put two men on, and a wild pitch from Lopez moved the runners up to second and third. Then came McLemore, who hit a high drive to deep left. Belle lost the ball in the cloudy, high sky again, but managed to get a glove on it just before he hit the wall. The impact dislodged the ball, however, and by the time Albert could get himself together, both Palmer and Tettleton had scored, and McLemore was at second via another two-base error. The fans at The Jake booed lustily what they saw as an unnecessarily harsh call, but it stood nonetheless. Meanwhile, Lopez went to the showers in favor of Julian Tavarez, who got Elster to ground to second on his first pitch, with McLemore moving to third. Hamilton's bouncer to short for the second out held him there, but he came home on Pudge Rodriguez's base hit to left center to shrink the Cleveland lead to 8-6. Greer's fly to shallow right center was caught by Lofton to end the inning, but the Rangers have gotten back into the game with three runs on just one hit, one walk, one wild pitch, and a pair of costly errors. We've played five and a half crazy innings, and it's Tribe 8, Lawmen 6.

Indians 6th: With one out, Seitzer dumped a base hit into right center. He moved to second on Thome's grounder to second, and scored when Belle redeemed himself for his errors by lofting a fly ball that fell in among three Rangers in right center for a double. Seitzer came home, and the Indians led 9-6. Franco walked to put two men on, but Manny's grounder to Palmer at third retired the side. The Indians have added a run on two hits, a walk, and a productive groundout, and after six in Game 2 it's Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Fame 9, Southfork Ranch 6.

Rangers 8th: McLemore drew a one-out walk against new Indians pitcher Eric Plunk. Elster's double into the left center power alley brought him home, and it was now a 9-7 game. But Hamilton went down swinging for the second out, and after Pudge walked to put two men on Greer grounded to Kent (who was now playing first with Jose Vizcaino at second) to end the inning. The Rangers have scored a run on two hits, but they've also left runners at first and second. After seven and a half, it's Indians 9, Rangers 7.

Indians 8th: Seitzer lined a leadoff single up the middle. After Thome popped to shirt for the first out, Seitzer was forced by Belle for out number two. Vizcaino's base it to left put two men on, and Manny's single to center scored Belle to put the Tribe up 10-7. Vizcaino moved to third on the play, but Kent's grounder to short ended the inning with runners still at the corners. The Indians have picked up a needed insurance run on three hits, and they now lead 10-7 going to the top of the ninth, where Jose Mesa will face Juan Gonzalez, Clark, and Palmer.

Rangers 9th: Gonzalez grounded a leadoff single to left center. After Clark struck out swinging, Palmer lined a single to center to put two men on. Tettleton was next, and his base hit to left center scored Gonzalez and brought the Rangers back to within 10-8, with Palmer moving to third. Damon Buford came in to run for Tettleton, who was the tying run, at first, but Mesa got McLemore to hit into a game-ending 4-6-3 double play. Our final: Indians 10, Rangers 8, and the Indians lead the series two games to none.

Despite his shaky defense, Belle was named Player of the Game by NBC. He was two for five at the plate with a home run and four RBIs. Ramirez had another great day at the plate as well; he was three for five with his second homer of the series, another run scored, and three RBIs. Tettleton was two for four plus a walk in a losing cause with a home run, another run scored, and three RBIs.

Final totals: Indians 10-15-3, Rangers 8-12-0.

W- Lopez (1-0)
S- Mesa (2)
L- Witt (0-1)

HR- TEX: Clark (1), Tettleton (1)
CLE: Ramirez (2), Belle (1)

The series will shift to The Ballpark in Arlington, Texas for Game 3 tomorrow night. First pitch is scheduled for shortly after 8PM Eastern. with Chad Ogea starting for the Indians and Roger Pavlik pitching for the Rangers.

Next: We look at Game 3.

Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
Now it's time for Game 3 of the 1996 American League Championship Series from The Ballpark in Arlington, Texas. The date is Friday, October 11:

Lineup Changes:

Indians- Omar Vizquel moves up to the leadoff spot. Jose Vizcaino will bat second. Julio Franco will be the designated hitter, with Jeff Kent starting at first base. Sandy Alomar is back behind the plate, and Kenny Lofton is batting ninth. The big news is that Manny Ramirez has caught Jack McDowell's virus and wont's start. Brian Giles will take his place in right field and bat sixth, with Manny coming off the bench only in an emergency.

Weather: 71 degrees, fair skies, southeast wind at 13 MPH.

Indians 2nd: Albert Belle led off against Rangers starter Roger Pavlik. Here's Bob with the count one ball and one strike:

"Just to clarify the Manny Ramirez situation, if he gets in the game at all it'll be as a pinch hitter. We're not sure if he's even able to run the bases. They tried to convince him to stay at the hotel, but he would have none of it. As of now, he plans to play tomorrow night, though that depends on how fast the antibiotics work. One and one on Belle, no score top of the second. One-one pitch...…….DRIVEN HIGH AND DEEP TO LEFT CENTER FIELD! BACK GOES HAMILTON, HE'S AT THE FENCE, BUT THIS ONE'S RIDING OFF INTO THE SUNSET!...….Belle's second home run of the series, and the Indians grab the early lead."

Joe Garagiola: "Ramirez may be sick, but there's nothing at all wrong with Albert Belle. He hit that one about as hard and far as any ball I've seen in the series. Left center here in Arlington's 290 feet, so that ball went well over four hundred."

Bob Uecker: "And so it continues from the last couple of games in Cleveland. The Indians have definitely brought their power bats with them, and the Rangers may need to match them homer for homer, so they can't afford to fall too far behind."

Franco struck out swinging for the first out, but Giles lined a base hit to right. He was forced by Kent, but Alomar beat out a grounder to third for an infield single to put two men on. That brought Lofton to the plate. Here's Bob:

"For those who may be wondering, batting ninth in the American League doesn't necessarily mean that you're the weakest hitter; a lot of managers put a leadoff-type hitter in the nine hole so opposing pitchers can't target that spot for easy outs. Vizquel has hit behind Lofton frequently, though it's usually been in the two hole. Right now a base hit from Lofton could really stake the Indians to a big early lead against Pavlik. Kent at second, Alomar at first, and the first pitch is ABSOLUTELY HAMMERED DEEP TO RIGHT, AND ALL GONZALEZ CAN DO IS WATCH IT LEAVE! A THREE-RUN HOMER FOR KENNY LOFTON, AND IT'S 4-0 CLEVELAND!"

Uecker: "Lofton frequently gets overlooked power-wise in a lineup that includes guys like Belle, Ramirez, and (Jim) Thome, but he hit fourteen home runs this year, so he has some pop in his bat too, and he just showed it. Straightaway right's only 325 feet from home plate here, but this home run wasn't cheap, as Lofton really got all of that ball."

Garagiola: "Matt Whiteside's already starting to loosen up in the bullpen for the Rangers. This could be another bad start for them; remember, (Bobby) Witt only got one out yesterday."

Vizquel's grounder to Will Clark at first ended the inning, but the Tribe has struck for four runs on four hits, including the home runs by Belle and Lofton. After an inning and a half, it's Indians 4, Rangers 0.

Rangers 3rd: With one out, Mark McLemore beat out an infield grounder to short for an infield single, then stole second. After Kevin Elster struck out swinging for out number two, Darryl Hamilton cracked a double off the wall in center to score McLemore and put the Rangers on the board. Pudge Rodriguez bounced to Vizcaino at second to end the inning and strand Hamilton, but the Lawmen have hit the board thanks to a pair of hits, and they trail the Indians 4-1 after three.

Rangers 6th: After two out, Pudge grounded a seeing-eye base hit to left center. Rusty Greer single to right center put runners at the corners, and Juan Gonzalez hit a high fly ball to left. Belle made what appeared to be a sliding catch, but when he got up to show that he'd caught the ball, it was on the ground and he'd been charged with his third error in two games. Pudge scored the second Texas run on the play, and Gonzalez ended up at second while Greer had moved to third. Clark's single to left scored Greer, and all of a sudden the Tribe's lead was cut to 4-3 with Gonzalez at third as the tying run. Ogea struck Palmer out swinging to end the threat, but the Rangers have picked up two runs on three hits and an error while leaving runners at the corners. At the end of six, it's Cleveland 4, Texas 3.

That was all the scoring. The Rangers put runners at the corners again in the seventh against Indians starter Chad Ogea on two walks and a fielder's choice, but Pudge's shallow fly to Giles in right ended the threat. The Indians blew a golden opportunity to add to their lead in the top of the ninth when they left the bases loaded, and the Rangers threatened for the last time in the bottom of the inning when McLemore reached on an infield hit against Jose Mesa with two out. But Elster's foul pop was caught behind first by Kent to end the game. Final score; Indians 4, Rangers 3, and the Indians lead this series three games to none.

Ogea was named Player of the Game by NBC. He pithed eight strong innings, giving up three runs on five hits while walking two and striking out nine in a hundred and nine pitches. Lofton was also considered due to his three-run homer.

Final totals: Indians 4-7-1, Rangers 3-6-0.

W- Ogea (1-0)
S- Mesa (3)
L- Pavlik (0-1)

HR- CLE: Belle (2), Lofton (1)

The series will continue with Game 4 tomorrow night here at The Ballpark in Arlington. First pitch is scheduled for shortly after 7:30 PM Eastern, with Charles Nagy pitching for the Indians and John Burkett starting for the Rangers.

Next: We look at Game 4.

Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
I lost the full recap of Game 4 due to technical difficulties, so here's the one-paragraph version. I hope to be back to normal tomorrow.

Indians 10, Rangers 6 (NBC: Bob Costas, Joe Garagiola, Bob Uecker, Jim Gray; CLE sweeps series 4-0)

The Tribe scored seven runs in the first four innings, then held off a frantic Texas comeback before putting the game and the pennant away. Rangers starter John Burkett lasted just two and two-third innings as the Tribe built a 6-0 lead after two and a half, and a 7-1 advantage after three and a half. Jeff Kent, who started at third, and Kenny Lofton each drove in a pair of runs, and Manny Ramirez had two hits and scored three runs in his return from the flu. But the Rangers scored four in the fourth and one in the sixth against Indians starter Charles Nagy, who pitched six innings and threw a hundred and twenty-two pitches in order to save the Tribe's illness-weakened bullpen. The Tribe finally delivered the knockout blow in the seventh, as Omar Vizquel hit a three-run homer off of Rangers reliever Kevin Gross to put the visitors up 10-6. The final three innings belonged to Dennis Martinez, who made his first appearance of the series a memorable one, allowing just one hit and one walk and striking out the side in the bottom of the ninth to nail down the Tribe's first pennant since 1959. Jose Mesa didn't pitch tonight because of the flu, but he was still named the MVP of the series for earning saves in all three of his appearances.

This is the Indians' tenth American League pennant so far in this timeline.

Final totals: Indians 10-12-2, Rangers 6-9-0.

W- Nagy (1-0)
L- Burkett (0-1)

HR- CLE: Vizquel (1)

Next: We turn to the National League, where the Padres meet the Expos in Game 1 of the first National League Division Series at Olympic Stadium. First pitch on Tuesday, October 1 is scheduled for shortly after 1PM Eastern on ESPN, with Joey Hamilton starting for the Padres and Rheal Cormier pitching for the Expos..

Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
I haven't gotten to that yet, Doug. The Cardinals will face the winner of the Padres-Expos NLDS. If the Padres win that series, they'll automatically be down three games to none against the Cardinals because they were swept in the real-life Division Series between the two teams. An Expos-Cardinals series will start from scratch. The Cardinals have already eliminated the Braves because they won three of the first four games in the real-life NLCS.
 
Top