1: Starting with the lowest of low-hanging fruit, eh? Well, I hope that the later episodes have more original scenarios.If FART wasn't preoccupied with bullying comic book stores over carrying the story of a crossdressing boy who fights crime, perhaps they would've noticed the innuendo in Fish Police's debut episode, The Long Fin of the Law, in which Inspector Gill narrates his capture of "dangerous fingerling-harasser" John Perchfalusi.
- The Chicago Tribune
John Ritter is fine as the voice of Inspector Gill, but he's no Bob Hoskins.
- The Miami Herald
Parents tuning in to Fish Police expecting something more akin to The Little Mermaid should hold off until Disney brings the real Little Mermaid to Fox's Saturday Morning lineup in September.
- The Boston Globe
Not great, but at least it wasn't as mean spirited as George Liquor.
- The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
It's good that there is some competition popping up on network television, but CBS is the last place you'd expect to see a Simpsons wannabe.
- The Los Angeles Times
Fish Police is not the best. Nor is it the worst. But it's a start. Now if CBS can option Shezow from Dark Horse....
- The Seattle Post-Intelligencer
If I were Steve Moncuse, I would be concerned, but not too worried about the way Fish Police is turning out on CBS.
- The Washington Post
2: Now, if we were to add a sea bunny slug as the star of a show-within-a-show in Fish Police, then maybe we'd talk.
3: It's understandable that they would believe that at first, given the design choice. Seriously, those fish look like the missing link between the merpeople like Ariel and the sealife like Flounder. Just saying.
4: Let me be real with you. Foodfight is less mean-spirited than George Liquor. Chicken Little is less mean-spirited than George Liquor. I'd come up with another comparison, but you get what I'm trying to say here.
5: Well, if I were to play devil's advocate, Disney did supply CBS with some primetime shows before and during The Disney Channel's IOTL.
Herbie, the Love Bug (TV series) - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org
Small & Frye - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org
Gun Shy (TV series) - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org
Zorro and Son - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org
7: Behold. All the prior reactions above in a nutshell.