Another plausibility check: Gonzalo Pizzaro becomes King of Peru?

Emperor Charles V then appointed Blasco Núñez Vela as Peru's first viceroy in 1544. Núñez introduced the New Laws, which were framed by Bartolomé de las Casas to protect the indigenous peoples. Many of the conquistadors living in Peru were against these laws since they could no longer exploit the natives. This prompted Gonzalo Pizarro and Francisco de Carvajal to organize an army of followers with the intent of suppressing the New Laws. Many conquistadors turned against the Viceroy and joined Gonzalo's side, as his surname provided an effective rallying point. The rebel army defeated Núñez in 1546 at Añaquito near Quito. Although some, such as Carvajal, advised Gonzalo to proclaim himself King of Peru and to disown any further claim by the King of Spain to the land, Gonzalo refused.

Over the following months, however, the support for Gonzalo diminished when the King's new representative, Pedro de la Gasca, arrived with the intention of offering pardon and repealing the New Laws. Most of Gonzalo's army deserted him just before the crucial battle at Sacsayhuamán (in Spanish Jaquijajuana), near Cusco, that would determine the fate of the conquest. No longer supported with an army against the King's new representative, Gonzalo Pizarro surrendered and was beheaded by the royal forces at field of battle, being the last of the Pizarro brothers to die a violent death (with Hernando dying of high age in Spain some three or six decades later).

What if Gonzalo Pizarro accepted? There's no doubt that he was popular amongst the men and could potentially transform Peru into his own independent kingdom. The question that I really want to ask is can he maintain enough support that Pedro de la Gasca's offers of pardon wouldn't make a dent in his forces?
 
I think there's a small possibility he might win. The Spaniards in Peru obviously were against the New Laws which basically protected the Indians from being treated like garbage.
 
Something Philip will learn shortly and react to, just as he did OTL. Simply put, there's no way that Spain is going to let someone get away with this.
 
Something Philip will learn shortly and react to, just as he did OTL. Simply put, there's no way that Spain is going to let someone get away with this.

Would you think that the Spaniards would accelerate measures to centralize control over their colonial empire in the Americas?
 
Top