And Hell Followed with Him

Hnau

Banned
The Point-of-Divergence is a much more dangerous Black Death that springs from Central Asia, not a Rice & Salt mix, but definitely closer than its real counterpart. Argue if you wish on how such a fatal disease could never spread as widely or quickly, or that it could never be that virulent, but the premise is that the bubonic plague gets around these limitations. If you research the disease, there is much we don't understand about it and the great epidemic that it caused, so, there are more than enough possibilities.

Oh, yeah, this is my first timeline, so, please see me off well. Thank you for any comments or suggestions you might give. :)

The Black Death in East Asia

1334
The Black Death utterly erases the populace of the Hubei Province in China. The plague claims 99% of the population, nearly six million in numbers. Following the chaos of the plague, only 50,000 stragglers remain in the entire province. Among the dead include a young Xu Shouhui and Chen Youliang, a cloth vendor and a fisherman who in OTL would have become a leader of a major rebellion.

To the Chinese peasants, this appears as an act of the gods, especially so soon after Toghun Temur succeeded to the throne in 1333. Many began to doubt the Khan’s mandate of heaven, leading to greater instability and stronger rogue factions.

1337
El Aiju, son of the recently-deceased warlord El Temur (who was the de facto leader of China for a few years), leads a rebellion against the remaining warlords and the Great Khan Toghun Temür. Bayan, a leading warlord and minister of the Secretariat, attempts to seize more and more of the Khan’s power in attempt to crush the rebellion.

1339
Toghun Temur joins secretly with El Aiju and Bayan’s own nephew, Toghtogha, in order to oust Bayan in a coup. The coup succeeds, with Bayan, the Crown Prince El Tegus and his mother Budashirri, being thrown out of the court. El Aiju sees to it that Bayan is killed, against Toghtogha’s wishes. An internal power struggle sees Toghun Temur having El Aiju banished and Toghtogha becoming a very powerful leader. The Emperor then begins to purge officials that had dominated the administration, which causes more instability.

1340
El Aiju begins rebuilding his power base. His followers begin taking on a religious tone, declaring that the Emperor has lost the mandate of heaven. Toghtogha, with his father Majartai, prove the rebels right by installing a dictatorship of their own much like his uncle.

1346
Emperor Toghun Temur nearly pulls off a coup to oust Toghtogha, however, a rebellion led by salt dealers against the government monopoly forces El Aiju’s alliance to begin a nationwide revolution. Toghtogha becomes extremely more powerful with his war-time dictates.

1347
Followers of the White Lotus and Manichaeism rise up to resist Toghun Temur and Toghtogha as well, under the name of the Red Turban Army, which some other pro-Mongolian rebel warlords resent. The Southern Red Turban Army never rises, with key individuals lost in the Death of 1334, but instead evolves as a disorganized rebellion with Zi Wenjun as its most important leader.

1350
When Toghtogha leads a large army to crush the Red Turban rebels, Toghun Temur launches a long-awaited coup for fear of betrayal. It results in the end of the dictatorship, which the populace is somewhat grateful for, but also a rapid weakening of the central government.

1351
Crown Prince Ayushiridar launches a coup against Toghun Temur. He immediately lends his support towards pro-Mongolian warlords, as well as El Aiju himself, in order to take the Mandate of Heaven. El Aiju, involved in internal power struggles himself to be named the Emperor following victory, decides this is the best chance to take power. Toghtogha attempts to join the alliance, however, Ayushiridar does not trust his record of dictatorship. The splintering factions take to a civil war in the very heart of the empire, in a time of famine, disease and natural disasters, which allows numerous forces to make huge gains against the government.

1352 - 1353
As Ayushiridar begins to consolidate gains in the center of the Empire and push out the loyalists, a second wave of the Black Death strikes central China. Following imperial trade routes, the devastating disease strikes chronologically Suiyuan, Shanxi,and Henan in a blitz that empties all connected population centers. Ayushiridar vainly proclaims that the plague is a sign of the gods that will destroy the rebels and followers of Toghun Temur, to pave his path to attaining the mandate of heaven. However, shortly thereafter, Dadu itself succumbs to the disease, with Red Turban soldiers secreting dead bodies into the center of the city. Ayushiridar refuses to leave, again believing that the plague will destroy only enemies hidden amongst the cities, but dies shortly thereafter, leaving a power vacuum that will once again ignite warfare even amongst the time of disaster. The Black Death stalls in Hubei, still sparsely populated even 20 years after the first outbreak, however it eventually continues its way into Hunan, Jiangxi, then Guangdong and finally Guangxi. The plague strikes some coastal cities and ports, but quarantines and lucky flukes are able to save many on the coastline. The most serious loss is that of Hangzhou, the second most populous city at that time, which falls quickly when it suffers an outbreak in 1353.

The Black Death has cut a huge corridor through China, from the reaches of Inner Mongolia down to the South China Sea. Rats, dogs, ravenous birds and other scavengers dominate emptied cities. Many villages suffer a 100% casualty rate, the only survivors having fled at the soonest notice of trouble. Peasants wander miles and miles searching for others, finding only apocalyptic destruction. The Asian outbreak, along with the civil strife before and after, ultimately leads to the death of 93% of the entire population of the Empire of the Great Khan. A pre-plague population of roughly 60 million in 1333 has dropped to only just a dismal 4 million.

The socio-economic effects can only begin to be analyzed. For years few will brave the corridor of death, effectively isolating east and west China. With the region around Dadu devastated as well, the south Chinese cannot come into contact with the Mongolians more northwards. The problem of significant population differences will affect the face of China forever afterward, with once-small ethnic groups becoming much more powerful, for example the Koreans, who suffered mostly only from ripple effects from the plague. Effects on religion, philosophy, and ideology are very difficult to analyze.

The Black Death in Europe

1346
The Golden Horde khan, Jani Beg, has been leading a siege on the Crimean port city of Kaffa for three years. To his worst luck, however, merchants from East Asia have inadvertently brought the Black Death to the surrounding Mongol armies. As his soldiers fall like flies, Janibeg flees with a small contingent, believing Satan himself to be pouring out of the tiny city. It is believed that a pursuing army that chased the Mongols for two days accidentally took the Black Death into the port city on their return. Genoese traders, who soon discovered the horrible outbreak, began to flee for their lives to destinations in the Mediterranean. Meanwhile, Caffa becomes home to rats, fleas, looters and bodies stacked high against the walls.

1347
Genoese traders bring the Black Death to Trebizond and Constantinople. By autumn, its populations will plummet, deaths taking up to 80%, with much of the remainder becoming refugees on ships ignorant enough to take them. By October, Genoese ships are found grounded on many shorelines throughout the Mediterranean, which were thoroughly looted, helping spread the disease. Some traders, through sheer luck, managed to arrive in various ports, such as Venice, Alexandria, the port city of Messina, Sardinia, and even as far away as Genoa. Nevertheless, the Black Death traveled with them. Another notable incident is the spread of the Black Death through an army which besieged Baghdad, bringing the Black Death deep into the Middle East.

---

To be continued...
 
Damn. That's hell indeed. Will civilization survive anywhere? Ironically, this could help the Aztecs and Incas - the only place where the Black Death can't go.
 

Hnau

Banned
I'm pretty sure that Africa was never affected by the Black Death, and there were areas where it never penetrated: Japan did not suffer any casualties, Poland, Hungary, and the Netherlands all endured the plague much better than other countries. In no text that I have found has India, surprisingly, suffered an outbreak, so they'll be more powerful.
 
I'm pretty sure that Africa was never affected by the Black Death, and there were areas where it never penetrated: Japan did not suffer any casualties, Poland, Hungary, and the Netherlands all endured the plague much better than other countries. In no text that I have found has India, surprisingly, suffered an outbreak, so they'll be more powerful.

Bear in mind that disease history in India is, AFAIK, something of a blank slate; and while Poland et al. weren't effected as much at first, they did get hit in later plagues.
 
Is the plague 80% lethal? 93% of the population dies from the plague and civil unrest. I could imagine starvation and violence killing a significant % of the Chinese population, and you did say that 80% of Constantinople died.

Also, could you more clearly define "Empire of the Great Khan"? Is this just China and its environs (post-breakup of the Empire), or something larger?
 
Nice job. Cool idea, if a bit morbid

Just one nitpick here:
Some traders, through sheer luck, managed to arrive in various ports, such as Venice, Alexandria, the port city of Messina, Sardinia, and even as far away as Genoa.
Messina is on Sicily, not Sardinia
 

Hnau

Banned
I'm sorry, I meant Messina, as well as Sardinia. The plague is about 85% lethal, with some places affected more or less than the others. East Asia suffers more than the rest (indeed, probably the worst in this timeline) because of natural disasters and warfare that not only push up the death toll on their own, but also help spread the disease.

Also, could you more clearly define "Empire of the Great Khan"? Is this just China and its environs (post-breakup of the Empire), or something larger?

The Yuan Dynasty ruled the Empire of the Great Khan, one of the successor states to the Mongolian Empire, which stretched from the around the modern southern borders of China all the way to the territory just north of OTL Mongolia, just above Lake Baikal. It included the Korean Peninsula, but not the western half of modern Xinjiang or the western half of Tibet. A map can be found here.
 
Whoa. Morbid, very morbid indeed.

[Ironically, this could help the Aztecs and Incas - the only place where the Black Death can't go.][/QUOTE]

That's true. With the Old World pushed back a peg, the renaissance and age of exploration as we know it won't happen. But the key phrase is 'as we know it'. It may well happen once Europe and/or the Old World has more or less recovered, but much later, maybe a century or two. Maybe even three if the plague lingers around. :eek:
 

Hnau

Banned
Not sure what to say about multiple plagues. As with OTL bubonic plague, humans will develop a resistance to it, decreasing its intensity, but proportionally to the new percentage. The apocalyptic setting might see changes to the ecosystem, which could have many effects. Let us not forget the brown rat invasion of the world, which would replace the black rat with a less lethal rodent. Then again, brown rats thrived in cities, and here many cities will have to be abandoned...
 
Its very likely that this plauge would terminate marcohistory as we know it , delaying the industrial age for two centuries or more , or even preventing it from ever occuring . For all we know , the social systems that will develop in the centuries following this disaster may be so radically different from the one's we are familiar with , that technology develops on an entirely different developmental track from here on out . This is starting to sound like an Amerindian / African Wank .
 
Population falls to a fifth of its former level. This alone will take centuries to catch up, with medieval growth rates.
 
Thiis Sounds a LOT Liike Harry Turtledove's In High Places ...

The Black Death Kiills 80% of Europe's Population, Siimilar to The European Segment of Thiis Scenario but they are The Only Substantial Casualties ...

It Gets So Bad a Man is Broken Upon The Wheel for Claiming to Be Jesus' Younger Brother, And When The Pope and The Kiing of France are Kiilled in a Church Collapse The Very Next Day the People Fiigure Henri was Telling The TRUTH!

:eek:
 

Hnau

Banned
The Black Death in Europe

1348
January
- Italy: Hungarian King Louis I the Great enters Benevento, Naples, intent on taking the Neapolitan crown in vengeance for his brother’s murder, due to a perceived conspiracy began from Queen Joan I of Naples.
- Balkans: The Black Death is noted to have entered Spalato and Ragusa.

February
- Italy: The Black Death arrives in Pisa, Florence, and Bologna from Genoa. A little later, there are reports of its spread in Siena and Rome. The Tuscany region suffered from some sanguine weakness, with deaths claiming up to 95% of the population in cities such as Florence and Pisa, and 88% in Siena, leaving mere thousands to flee or steal what they can before escaping into the countryside. The two cities are virtually empty.
- France: There are outbreaks in Marseilles, Montpelier, Narbonne, and Carcasonne. Marseilles became the French Florence when, thousands begin dropping dead within a week, leading to 80,000 deaths out of a city numbering 90,000.

March
- Italy: When the pestilence is detected in Milan, the Archbishop orders houses even supposed to be infected to be boarded up, those inside left to die from sickness or slain by soldiers. A policy of further isolation will allow Milan to succeed in repelling the disease, though there is some chaos in the streets with a constant building of paranoia that leads to many false accusations. From Messina, the plague has crossed the countryside of southern Italy into Bari and Naples. Cola di Rienzo, the former revolutionary Tribune of Rome, flees from Naples in the countryside to the north, to take isolation in an Italian monastery.
- France: The Black Death had spread to Avignon, as well as Toulouse and Montauban, towards English-held Bordeaux. With the Pope threatened by malign airs, his clergy isolate him in his manor to lounge between two roaring fires.
- Sicily: Duke-Regent Giovanni names a Catalan duke as the new regent, which sparks a civil war among the trembling plague-stricken populace, between Italians and Catalans.
- Iberia: Mallorcan outbreak noticed. Within a year, 85% of the population will fall dead, tossed into the ocean, leaving only 8,000, either as looters and stragglers or refugees in one place or another who can call themselves Mallorcans.

April
- Italy: Louis I of Hungary moves his armies from Naples back to Hungary, fleeing from the Black Death. To his luck, his soldiers do not bring the plague with them.
- Byzantine Empire: During the ravaging of Constantinople, it is discovered that the young Emperor, John V Palaiologos, has been found dead. His family is safe in hiding in Thrace, where it is deemed that his eldest son, Andronikos IV Palaiologos, eleven days old, is to become the new Emperor. Helena Kantakouzene becomes a regent, and for support against the many political factions fighting for the emptying Constantinople, seeks her father, John VI Kantakouzenos, who had long sought the throne and in 1347 had defeated enough enemies to take the crown in triumph, if only the Black Death had not struck.

May
- Italy: Venice takes measures against the plague, through quarantines of its important islands and allowing ships to only visit isolated islands. Plague-ridden buildings are even sometimes leveled with cannon-fire. The Venetian archipelago is a good place to resist the Black Death, with black rats being poor swimmers, however, Venice is not willing to stop every single ship from entering the city, and so will suffer from repeated devastating outbreaks over the next two years.
- Byzantine Empire: Helena manages to find her father, building a power base in Thrace as well, amid the chaos. He immediately calls for a ceremony that allows him to become regent and joint emperor with the infant emperor, effectively giving him control over the Empire.

June – There is an outbreak in Lyons and Paris, as well as in Weymouth, England, brought by a ghost ship.

July
- Greece: With reports of the Black Death across the continent, the ruling Zealots of Thessalonica use the fear of the plague to consolidate their power, using it as an excuse to kill political and religious opponents, as well as to isolate the city extensively and force refugees to work as slaves to build defenses. Most outsiders are chased away by soldiers.
- Britain: Bristol succumbs to the Black Death. Of its 11,000 pre-outbreak inhabitants, only 1,400 will survive.

August
- France: Bordeaux suffers from an outbreak of the Black Death.
- Italy: The plague has spread throughout Istria from Venice.

September – Pope Clement VI dies after his manor catches afire, from the same flames that were meant to protect him. Rumors circulate that Pope Clement is still alive, that he escaped for a divine purpose. This excuse allows the cardinals a duration of waiting before selecting a new Pope, everyone afraid to leave their safe-houses.

November - The Black Death outbreak is noticed in London. 60,000 of that city's 70,000 will perish.

Non-existent Events
- Greece: The Serbian Empire under Tsar Dusan does not conquer Thessaly and Epirus, out of fear of the plague.

The Black Death generally leaves a mortality rate of 85% in every polity it visits, with some groups hit harder than others. The young die more often from the disease, with elderly individuals well off in terms of isolating themselves against the disease, but not so well off in feeding and providing for themselves. The poor suffer much more than the rich, and in many feudal areas, nobles and lords come out of their castles and manors to discover their masses of laborers and serfs have fallen dead, and the few that remain cannot easily produce enough food for the entire noble family. There are different reactions to this phenomenon, usually the subjugation and overworking of the remaining lower classes, which contributes to the death rate. Others send nobles out to other areas to seek aid, and these individuals find only devastation on the roads, in the villages, and in the cities they come to. Many lose their minds, leading to an increase of murder and suicide. There are some isolated events in which the nobles assist their peasants in producing food, and within a few years these groups will have survived much more healthily than the rest, but no longer ruled by a lord, instead taking up different systems of government, a community republic, in some cases, in others one ruled by the remaining soldiers and warriors. In other areas, the peasants revolt against the nobles, and in many places they succeed to overthrow them. This kind of chaos does not easily lapse into a stable society: after successful revolutions, the township is even more devastated by warfare, they have left their fields in disrepair, a new tyrant names himself lord often-times, and their main fortifications have been weakened or sometimes destroyed. This will leave them very vulnerable to refugees, roaming brigands and the bands of insane ferals that have degenerated into an almost tribal way of life.

Those nobles and kings that succeed against the odds and remain upon their seats of power, especially in capitals of large nations, pretend to continue their rule over their empires, though the transportation and trade network has been horribly damaged. Their territories lapse into small local units while they decide to wait the plague out in hiding.

Many politico-religious organizations use the vacuum of power to build their own isolated kingdoms in the midst of the Black Death, when an outsider is rare and abandoned villages are many. There is a vacuum of power in terms of religion as well, with many charitable priests and bishops exposing themselves to the plague and dying, the only ones left the selfish and isolated clergy that are quickly swept aside. However, these small polities are quick to fall under some kind of trouble. The more successful are the warriors-for-hire, the mercenaries, known as the routiers in France, or the condottieri in Italy. They move amongst the countryside, taking what they can from abandoned population centers, and granting their protection to ones that aren’t. They quickly become what nobles cannot do: provide a power structure that ruthlessly isolates their sphere of power and seeks to purge rebels and brigands. Nevertheless, this lends to totalitarian governments and erratic changes of power, as mercenaries abandon one area for another when the going gets tough.

A more haunting development is that of ferals. Children and teenagers are usually affected the worst, being subjected to horrible experiences, of emptied towns, mountains of corpses, rampant fires, and being left entirely on their own. Though not so noticeable as of yet, throughout the years these survivors will lapse into a feral, insane state of mind, adopting extremely primitive lifestyles and banding together with other ferals into small tribal units. Adults succumb to this as well, even as early as 1348, though they are much less apt to join together with others, possessing a paranoid and irrational streak that sometimes makes them more dangerous than normal brigands.

Most of these phenomena, however, are yet to be seen, as the Black Death has still not done all of its damage, even in areas that it has occupied for a year’s time. A general summary could be provided simply stating that the Black Death had consumed half of the Iberian Peninsula, all islands and coastlines of the Mediterranean, reached across Western Europe towards Paris, had established a beachhead in Britain, and was slowly marching against Eastern Europe after having taken Greece and the Balkans
 
Last edited:

Hnau

Banned
One thing I was very excited about in this timeline was the development of interesting politico-religious orders and organizations seizing power amidst the vacuum. There are some really interesting ones that I discovered in my research, and probably more to be created/discovered.

The Flagellants are an obvious choice. They will arise very strongly in 1349, as Central Europe held much of their power base. A militant religious organization, they have the ability to galvanize a large population, claiming independence from the Church and establishing a strongman to turn to. Much like the Nazis, they blamed the Jews, and with little communication from Avignon, and no Papal Bull supporting the Jews, they will turn cities and towns against their cleanest and least-affected members. They profess independency from the Catholic Church, doubting the need for sacrament, and giving power to their members to grant forgiveness, cause miracles, and sentence all who defy them to death. A more peaceful variant would be the Order of the Cross, strong in the Low Countries, which I hope can eclipse the others, even though this certain order treats bloody rags as relics.

Konrad Schmid is a demagogue who in Thuringia gained quite a following by proclaiming to be Emperor Frederick II resurrected. With the emptied cities providing resources, his followers will not be able to be stopped very easily. He proclaims to have jurisdiction over religious matters and also claims to be a miracle-worker. This organization will probably evaporate in 1369, if not before, when their Judgement Day is observed to be false.

The False Waldemar is also a demagogue who arose in Brandenburg, and in this timeline might not be proved false. He claims to have inherited Brandenburg instead of another Bavarian prince, and found many cities rallying to his personal charisma. Perhaps he succeeds. (Parts of Brandenburg were not affected by the plague, so this area will be one of power afterwards).

I have already mentioned Cola di Rienzo , the self-proclaimed Tribune of Rome who fled in 1347 after people began rising against his authoritarian rule. His desire to rebuild the Roman Empire, with the emperor elected by the people, might just provide a dream the weak and depopulated Italy can latch onto.

If anyone has any other ideas, historical or fictional, for interesting power groups or individuals please suggest them here. Anything could happen with such a dystopian collapse of European civilization.
 
Though some radical groups may gain short-term power, the power vacuum in Europe may eventually snap back to the pre-plague levels. Or perhaps once the plague disappears, an outside group will step in, e.g. Saracens, Mongols, or perhaps citizens of the Kalmar Union that escaped the plague somehow. A Europe split between Saracens, Mongols and neo-Vikings is an enticing possibility, no? :D
 

Hnau

Banned
I don't mean to say radical groups will stay in power for the long-term, but the century after the Great Death will be very strange indeed, definitely some unique things going on in the Old World. Saracens (Arabs, Muslims, you mean?) will be affected equally by the more virulent plague, maybe slightly better off due to isolation in the deserts or away from trade routes, but they'll be hurting.

Mongols are a stretch. The Black Death signalled the doom of the Golden Horde, in OTL, and in TTL it will only happen more quickly. However, I wonder if its successors could find common ground, or if they'll be less affected than the Russian states, and so will be able to reconquer lost territory? Nevertheless, the Mongolian Empires were falling before the Black Death, and they were no less stricken by it.

And the Kalmar Union? Surely some isolated primitive peoples survived much better in the Far North, but those kingdoms fared no better than the rest of the Europeans.

No, the surviving nation-states that have a chance for conquest are not as cliche. Parts of Belgium and the Netherlands, centered around Liege, were unaffected by the plague in OTL, and in TTL the Black Death is only more dangerous to those in OTL who caught it. The Low Countries are in a position to expand their power base significantly. Those who survived in the Pyrenees, the southern French, the Aragonese, and those of Navarre, will help keep their prospective nations from slipping under. Milan, eastern Brandenburg, Bohemia, Silesia, Poland, Lithuania, Galicia, and Hungary are bound to keep enough of a population, thanks to strengthened sanguine groups, to become Great Powers overnight.

In fact, I do see three powers who might have enough force to divide Europe between them: the Holy Roman Empire, utilizing Brandenburg, Milan, and the Low Countries as power centers; a Polish-Lithuanian dyanstic union, if that region continues to head towards the Union of Krewo; and the Hungarian Empire. Then again, anything could happen. I'd much rather keep this timeline dystopic, eerie, and apocalyptic as long as I can to give the Amerindians and African some time to develop.
 
Hnua

One thing that may moderate things. The very lethality of the plague will moderate its later effects. I.e. that the small proportion of survivors will include a much higher proportion of people who have some natural immunity. Coupled with much greater pressure to develop methods of avoiding the plague, such as improved hygiene. Given that population could bounce back much faster if some political and economic stability could be achieved. [Which by your description could be a big problem]. However depending on what groups they are, plus whatever good or bad leaders occur that could have big impacts on the balance of power throughout the affected region.

A so much more lethal plague is likely to mean that areas which escape the initial outbreaks by chance are probably only going to have a brief period of grace. They are likely to be hit more heavily by later outbreaks simply because the vulnerable population hasn't been thinned out already. [Also possibly if leaders of such areas have claimed some role in that earlier escape their period of control is likely to be seriously curtailed.;)]

Steve
 
Top