America's Silver Era, The Story of William Jennings Bryan

Chapter XXVII, Blunders
800px-War_in_Morocco_Death_of_Spanish_general_Margallo.JPG

By the fall of 1916, it most were convinced that the Triple Alliance would win the war. France was facing a two-front war, with Germany not very far from Paris. Russia’s grand offensive failed to knock Austria-Hungary out of the war. And now Japan and the Ottoman Empire were taking advantage of Russian weakness. Kaiser Wilhelm, Emperor Franz-Josef, and King Alphonso, along with Sultan Abdul Hamid and Emperor Taisho were confident that the war would end within a year. Morale was dropping among the Entente powers, in both the soldiers on the front and the people back home. However, the fall of 1916 would see two major blunders from two of the members of the Alliance. Predictions that the war would end within a year would turn out to be as groundless as predictions that Operation Poseidon would force Austria-Hungary to surrender.


-Excerpt from The World's War, Ludwig Faerber, Globe Books, 2015.

After Poseidon, the front lines in Europe became more stable, both in France and in Eastern Europe. In Africa, the Alliance was at a clear disadvantage and was losing. The German colonies in the Pacific were also being picked off one-by-one. It was in Anatolia and East Asia that the Alliance was gaining ground. The Russian Far Eastern Fleet was no match for the Japanese Navy. Japanese troops stationed in Korea attacked Vladivostok as well as Russian positions in their sphere of influence in China. Japan only declared war on Russia, and stated that it had no quarrel with Britain and France. Some in Britain advocated remaining at peace with Japan, but eventually Britain and France declared war. The Ottomans quickly overran the outnumbered Russian forces in the lands annexed during the Balkan Wars. The Ottoman war effort was motivated by revenge.

In May Spanish forces had tried and failed to capture the Southern French city of Foix. Spain had also lost most of its territory in North Africa to French and Moroccan troops. Its African colonies further south were taken by France. Of all the Alliance powers, Spain was clearly doing the worst. Spain’s decision to try to reconquer some of its North African territory is considered by most military historians to be a severe miscalculation. On August 20, Spanish troops captured the port of Tangier. Tens of thousands of conscripts were then sent in as reinforcements to Ceuta, the remaining Spanish stronghold in North Africa. Tetouan fell in early September. At Larache, Spanish troops encountered heavier resistance, but the town was taken on September 20. Then in October, the British and French Navies fought Spain at the Strait of Gibraltar. The Spanish fleet was outnumbered and outgunned; it lost three armored Cruisers and several other ships. The Entente Navy from that point forward effectively blocked Spanish forces in Morocco from receiving supplies or reinforcements from Spain. The Spanish troops in Africa were effectively stranded.

330px-Kaid_Sarkash_%28Riffian_leader%29_1924.jpg

(Moroccan troops armed with captured Spanish weapons)

After the Ottomans quickly drove the Russians out of Anatolia, they advanced into the Caucasus where Russia had much easier time defending. The Ottoman government then determined to get revenge in the Balkans. On August 29, the Ottoman Empire declared war on Serbia, hoping to force Austria-Hungary to invade the Balkan nation from the North. But to the Sultan’s dismay, Austria-Hungary and Germany both declared that “The war between the Serbs and the Turks is not part of the war between the Triple Alliance and the Entente.” The Turks invaded in September, but the Serbs held strong, making the Ottoman invaders pay for every inch in blood. The entire Balkan region turned against the Ottomans. Greece declared war on the Ottoman Empire on September 9. Bulgaria declared its complete independence from the Ottoman Empire on the 19th. Albania was in revolt as well. Constantinople itself was under threat from both the Russian Black Sea Fleet and the Bulgarians invading from the North. The Ottomans began to fill their capital with whatever soldiers they could spare.

-Except from The Dying Man of Europe, the Ottoman Empire in the 20th Century, Debora Nestani, Harvard Press, 2018.

In North Africa, the stranded Spanish soldiers continued to fight, hoping that they would eventually be resupplied and reinforced. This never happened. Moroccan forces were bolstered by the arrival of French colonial troops, and they attacked the Spanish relentlessly. Larache fell on October 25. Spanish forces retreated to Tangier and Ceuta, building as many defenses as they could before the enemy arrived. In November, British Indian troops took Gibraltar back from Spain. Around the same time, across the Atlantic, San Juan fell to French, Cuban, and Canadian troops, ending Spain’s control over Puerto Rico. Portugal, enticed by the promise of land from Spain and Germany’s colonial empires, declared war on the 20th. Many in Spain began to agitate for peace. On November 30, Tangier fell to Moroccan and French West African troops aided by British Naval bombardment. On December 13, the Spanish garrison at Ceuta surrendered. Tens of thousands of Spanish soldiers would spend the rest of the war in prison camps in the deserts of North Africa.

Back home, the Spanish public was furious. Protests erupted in all of Spain’s major cities. Propaganda leaflets were dropped from Entente planes. Most of these leaflets contained messages pleading with the Spanish people to not be “pawns in the Kaiser’s game.” Spain now faced the possibility of an invasion from both France and Portugal. There were also rumors that the Entente was planning an invasion from North Africa. While some in the German government were concerned that Spain might surrender, Kaiser Wilhelm stated in private that “Whether Spain surrenders or continues to fight, it makes little difference. It will only affect the length of the war, not its outcome.” Despite Allied blunders, Kaiser Wilhelm and most of the German high command believed that the Alliance would win the war. They believed that these were merely setbacks.

Meanwhile, Ottoman troops put up a brave fight at Skopje, but were outnumbered by Serbian, Greek, and Albanian troops. The city fell on October 10. Britain and France made short work of the Ottoman forces in Libya. Persia declared war on the Ottoman Empire on the 11th. The Ottomans realized how desperate their situation and called for help from the Triple Alliance. But the Triple Alliance was not in a great position to help. Austro-Hungarian diplomats tried to persuade some of the Balkan states to make peace, but it was to no avail. On October 25, The Bulgarians arrived at Constantinople and put the great city under siege. A smaller Greek contingent was supposed to help but it didn’t come. The Greeks wanted to be the ones who took the city. The Bulgarian attack on Constantinople failed and Bulgaria blamed Greece. Both nations wanted the honor of taking the “Queen of Cities.” The fragile alliance between Bulgaria and Greece fell apart when Bulgaria declared war on December 1, 1916. The Ottoman Empire was given a reprieve.
 
Any predictions on who will win the Great War? The 1916 Presidential Election? The main candidates are William Jennings Bryan, Ben Tillman, Theodore Roosevelt, and Robert La Follette. Both parties will have various favorite sons at the convention as well.
 
Any predictions on who will win the Great War? The 1916 Presidential Election? The main candidates are William Jennings Bryan, Ben Tillman, Theodore Roosevelt, and Robert La Follette. Both parties will have various favorite sons at the convention as well.
Whatever POTUS gives us a CP win...
 
Any predictions on who will win the Great War? The 1916 Presidential Election? The main candidates are William Jennings Bryan, Ben Tillman, Theodore Roosevelt, and Robert La Follette. Both parties will have various favorite sons at the convention as well.

I honestly can't even try and call it from a lineup like that.
 
Chapter XXVIII, The Return of William Jennings Bryan
A sinister agenda is being advanced in the halls of power in this country. The American people want peace but there are people working day and night to bring us into a war that does not concern us. The war is being framed as a battle between freedom and tyranny, but that is a lie. The war began as a dispute over colonial possessions. It is a war of empires, not republics. One group of empires is engaged in a quest to expand their possessions at the expense of another group of empires. It is a contest to determine which empire will be the largest and wealthiest. Do not be fooled, there are no higher principles at stake here. We as Americans, we as Christians, must oppose this unnecessary war and pray for peace.

-William Jennings Bryan, Speech to the Democratic National Convention in Indianapolis, Indiana, June 28, 1916

In 1904 the precedent set by George Washington when he declined to seek a third term was broken. William Jennings Bryan attempted a third term, but was unsuccessful. But his decision would encourage others to do the same. Grover Cleveland died before the 1908 election and it was unlikely that he would seek a third term at that late in time anyway. George Dewey failed in his bid for a second term, and retired from politics entirely after leaving the executive mansion. Theodore Roosevelt was the next man in a position to seek a third term, which he did. Then, the only other living person to already serve two terms decided to do the same. Of course, there were those in both parties who sought to prevent both men from doing so.

-Excerpt from America's Silver Age, Edward S. Scott, Patriot Publishers, 2017.

In the Republican Party, various candidates stepped up to challenge Theodore Roosevelt. But the only one with a large enough organization backing him was Robert La Follette. La Follette was the GOP nominee in the disastrous 1904 election and was Roosevelt’s Postmaster General during his first term. He was a fierce critic of Roosevelt’s foreign policy in Latin America and Asia and opposed moves from the president trying to force America into the war in Europe. Despite the fact that America was not at war, the war would be the issue of utmost importance at the convention. Roosevelt gave a defense of the Entente’s cause. He claimed that the Entente was defending freedom and Democracy against authoritarianism. He used the example of France, a free country, being invaded by Germany and Spain. Robert La Follette retorted that the Entente also included Russia, a nation that shouldn’t be considered “free.”

Senator Benjamin Tillman believed that 1916 would be more favorable for him than 1912. Tillman took a position against the war, but not nearly as unequivocally as La Follette or Bryan. When Bryan went on a speaking tour denouncing Roosevelt’s foreign policy Tillman knew that he was preparing for a Presidential run. And he knew that he was at a huge disadvantage; he had to formulate a plot to counter Bryan’s appeal. He would attack Bryan for breaking Washington’s precedent, “Two terms were good enough for Washington; does Bryan think himself to be a better President than the father of our country?” That wouldn’t be enough though. He combined this with campaigning to Bryan’s left in some areas, saying that he would fight the influence of corporations in politics even more than the ex-president. He also doubled down on racial rhetoric. He advocated for federally-enforced segregation and the repeal of the 14th and 15th amendments. In his speech at the convention he began yelling and many delegates described him as sounding like an “unhinged, raving lunatic.”

Bryan, for his part, stated that he was in favor of states’ rights and avoided the issue of race altogether at the convention. He argued for the creation of a national organization to help farmers, which he advocated on the 1904 campaign trail. He laid out a plan to get electricity to rural areas, a message that certainly resonated among Southerners. He also made mention of tariffs, an issue that many Democrats were still passionate about. But in his speech to the Democratic National Convention in Indianapolis, he spent most of his time condemning the war in Europe. He then responded to criticism that he was abandoning Washington’s precedent by claiming that he was the one who was upholding Washington’s legacy (he quoted Washington’s address where he condemned “entangling alliances).” The speech was compared by some to his Cross of Gold Speech 20 years earlier and it won him the nomination.

egp.pg.007.jpg

(William Jennings Bryan leaving the convention hall)

At the Republican convention in New York, Robert La Follette was facing an uphill battle. Most of the delegates favored Roosevelt and everyone knew it. La Follette still managed to have a respectable showing, winning the Wisconsin delegation handily. He also won the delegations from Montana and Washington. Some delegates from other states supported him as well. But when the first ballot was finished, it wasn’t even close. He conceded but did not endorse Roosevelt. Many of his supporters launched a write-in campaign that would do very well in Wisconsin in November. As for Roosevelt, he was optimistic, but not overly so. He had the advantage of incumbency and he had a superb organization behind him. However, he also recognized that William Jennings Bryan was a much tougher opponent than George Dewey or Ben Tillman.
 
I'm writing two updates on the war outside of Europe so you can know everything that has happened up to the the election. Then you'll get the election.
 
Chapter XXIX, A War of Empires
The Great War was truly a world war. It started with a dispute in China involving two European powers. Though the main focus of the war was always in Europe, every continent would be affected in some way. The people living in the colonies of the competing European powers would not be able to escape the effects of the war. Millions of Africans, Indians, Canadians, Australians, and many others would fight and die far away from home. The war in the colonies intensified as nations like the Ottoman Empire, Morocco, the Boer Republics, Japan, and others joined the war. The Great War was also important in that it showed some of the early signs of resistance to European Imperialism.

-Excerpt from The World's War, Ludwig Faerber, Globe Books, 2015.

The War in the Americas went decisively to the Entente. The Spanish Naval forces there were quickly thrashed by France and Britain. Puerto Rico held out until October 26, 1916, at which point Spain’s presence in the Caribbean was limited to a small number of ships that were given a safe haven in Nicaragua’s ports (which they had been given since early in the war). These ships would raid Entente trade routes. Britain declared war on Nicaragua on November 14. In December British and Cuban troops captured Puerto Cabezas. Nicaraguan and Japanese soldiers would fight Britain and Cuba in the small Central American nation for the rest of the war.

In Africa, the war was less lopsided, but the Entente still held the advantage. Germany and Spain were on the defensive with the exception of the ill-fated Spanish campaign in Morocco. The only Alliance colony in Africa that held out was German West Africa. Ottoman-owned Libya lasted for only months after that country’s entrance into the war. However, the Entente war effort was hindered by rebellions against British and French rule. Small-scale revolts broke out all over French West Africa throughout 1916, but they were quickly suppressed. In Sudan, the story was different. In August of 1916, thousands of Sudanese led by Osman Digna took up arms against Britain. While the British authorities were convinced that the Ottomans were behind this, it was never proven. They waged a guerilla war that tied down British troops that could have gone to fight in Europe.

330px-%D8%B9%D8%AB%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%86_%D8%AF%D9%82%D9%86%D8%A9.jpg

(Osman Digna)

The Orange Free State and Transvaal declared war on Britain in October of 1916. Tensions had been high between the Boer Republics and Britain for decades and war had only been narrowly averted. But now the Boers were eager to seize upon British weakness in the region. British South African troops were mostly sent to fight Germany in other parts of Africa. Afrikaner soldiers quickly took land from the British in South Africa and Rhodesia. When Portugal joined the war not long after, the Boer Republics were surrounded. On December 1, Portuguese troops captured Lobamba with help from local Swazis. The victory was short-lived as a larger Boer force captured the city on the 15th. After this point, the South African front became mostly a stalemate.

Soldiers from the British colonies featured prominently in the fight against the Ottoman Empire. The British attacked from three directions. A small contingent fought alongside Greece in Europe. Another force invaded Palestine from Egypt. British troops also fought alongside Persia in Mesopotamia. This force consisted of mainly Indian and ANZAC soldiers. On October 13, they fought the Ottomans at Basra. The Ottomans, though heavily outnumbered, inflicted high casualties upon the Entente attackers. The city fell on the 28th and it was hailed as a great victory in the press, especially in Australia and New Zealand. Many were convinced that the collapse of the Ottoman Empire was imminent. Such predictions turned out to be premature. The Mesopotamian Campaign, though it had its share of triumphs, was characterized by poor planning and high casualties.

330px-Hodsons_Horse_France_1917_IWM_Q_2061.jpg

(Indian Cavalry)
 
Chapter XXX, War in the Far East
battleofyalu.jpg

In June of 1915, the Guangxu Emperor spoke to China’s legislature. He gave a speech calling for China to remain neutral. After some debate, a clear majority in the Chinese Congress backed the emperor’s proposal. Factions supporting both sides were present and argued for Chinese entry into the war, but they were unsuccessful. From 1915 to the end of the war, the Qing Dynasty remained officially neutral. But unofficially, China was very much involved in the war. Though they would not serve in official Qing uniforms, there were people in China who fought for both sides. Neutrality did not stop China from making an impact on the war.


-Excerpt from The World's War, Ludwig Faerber, Globe Books, 2015.

At the onset of the war the vast majority of the Chinese public favored neutrality. China supported Spain’s claims to Aichow over France, but did not want to go to war over it. There was much more sympathy for the Alliance than there was for the Entente. Anti-Russian sentiment was high, especially in the north. Bandits in Manchuria attacked Russians, but that had been going on since before the war began. As far as the government was concerned, war was a bad idea. The country was barely holding together as it was, and entering the war on one side would allow the other side to take advantage of internal divisions within the country.

Fighting took place on Chinese soil while China itself stayed on the sidelines. France captured Aichow and Britain captured Tsingtao early in the war. France and Britain hired a small number of Chinese mercenaries in 1915, mostly from their own spheres of influence. However, one hundred Tibetans also fought for Britain. They were sent to fight the Germans in New Guinea and were later transferred to France to fight in the Pyrenees as they were thought to be natural mountain soldiers. As all of this was happening, the Chinese military continued to focus on modernization. After Japan entered the war, the number of Chinese who volunteered to fight skyrocketed.

Japan, like China, had come to be uneasy with Russia’s presence in the Far East. The two countries nearly went to war in 1902 over influence in China. Many Chinese hated Japan after the Sino-Japanese war but others, like Sun Yat-sen and Song Jiaoren, admired it as a model for modernization and a counter to Russian ambitions. Shortly after the Japanese declaration of war against Russia, Japan and the Qing Dynasty signed a secret treaty. Japan would take all of Russia’s sphere of influence in Manchuria, but would let Russia’s sphere of influence elsewhere in Northern China revert back to Qing control. Japanese troops were also allowed to move through Northern China. Japan was provided with intelligence about Russian forces in their concessions. Thousands of Chinese joined the Imperial Japanese Army in special regiments, including the famous biographer Jiang Jieshi.

330px-Battle_of_Tsingtao_Japanese_Landing.jpg

(Japanese soldiers attacking by sea)

Japanese troops in Korea captured Vladivostok in July. Then, the Japanese army moved north, capturing Russian towns and cities with ease. Russia attempted to put a stop to Japanese aggression at the small town of Dalnegorsk. Russian soldiers were ordered to stand their ground until reinforcements from the West arrived. 70,000 Russians in the area fought heroically against over 200,000 Japanese soldiers. The town fell on August 30. Japan did not advance much further due to weather and supply issues. Meanwhile, Japan quickly drove Russia out of China. Pro-Japanese Mongolian fighters went into Siberia and raided Russian supply lines. Russia was furious at China for allowing Japan to operate in Northern China and some called for war. However, most agreed that this would be a mistake.

While Japan’s standing in China was improving, not all were happy. On August 4, one thousand veterans of the Sino-Japanese War demonstrated against Japan in Beijing. Anti-Japanese sentiment was widespread. The pro-Entente movement was led by Sa Zhenbing, an Admiral who fought in the Sino-Japanese War. Some British officials suggested supporting a coup in China to put Sa Zhenbing, or someone similar, in power. Prime Minister Asquith and British General Hubert Gough opposed the plan out of fear that it would backfire. Admiral Sa claimed in the 1940s that he was never contacted by the Entente and never would have went through with such a plan. The pro-Entente movement was unable to mobilize much public support and many politicians perceived as being pro-Entente were voted out in the 1916 elections.

330px-Sak_Deng-bing2.jpg

(Sa Zhenbing)

Japan was winning the war against Russia. The Japanese government wanted to only fight Russia, not the rest of the Entente. This proved to be unrealistic and Japan soon found itself at war with Britain, France, and later Portugal. The combined Entente Naval forces were able to overpower Japan and some in the Japanese government wondered if entering the war was a mistake. British agents stirred up trouble in Korea, but it failed to inspire a large anti-Japanese revolt. ANZAC and French Indochinese troops also launched an invasion of Formosa. They would quickly get bogged down on the island and the fighting there was fierce and lasted until the end of the war.
 
A timeline where China and Japan work together is extremely rare, and yet this is a scenario where I could see it happening. Now, will they stay cordial after? Probably not, but a man can dream. Go Alliance! Knock those frogs off their perch!
 
Top