It was there, but changed the wording to make it more clear-'prison unto their natural life' was my way of trying to say life imprisonment in the style of the bill.
Virginia: castration for men; facial mutilation or life imprisonment for women
Goergia: the same
Maryland: fine
New Jersey and Pennsylvania: life imprisonment
New York: ?
Also, consider that castration is very dangerous and will result in many deaths (though, I don't think authorities will care much, given the conditions in prisons back then.