How could be Polish borders after World War II as it would be justice for allied country?
I think that it could be by more power of Churchill and Roosevelt during peace conferences.
Basic argument is that Poland shouldn't have less surface that in 1939 i.e. 389 000 sq. km.
My proposition:
In east Poland receives rayons of Grodno (counties Grodno, Wołkowysk, Szczuczyn), Brześć (Brześć, Prużana, Kobryń), Wołyń (Włodzimierz, Kowel, Luboml, Horochów) and some part of East Galicia (Lwów voivodeship, western past of Stanisławów [Skole, Stryj, Dolina, Rohatyn, Żydaczów, Kałusz] and Tarnopol voivodeships [Kamionka, Radziechów, Brody, Przemyślany, Złoczów]). These terrains were mentioned in Sikorski Line. Grodno and Lwów were centers od Polish culture, petroleum of Drohobycz and gas of Daszawa were necessary for Polish industry, Brześć was also necessary due to railway line north-south Białystok-Brześć-Kowel-Lwów.
But Poland has to give for Soviets easter part of Galicia with cities Stanislawow and Tarnopol due to railway line Jaremcze-Jasina to Subcarpathia (to control Czechoslovakia and Hungary) and cities Lida and Wilno due to also railway lines to Lithuania, in fact Poles were 80%, but this terrain was set into Poland illegal in 1920 as "Central Lithuania" (Churchill mentioned it), so we had very little chance to save it.
In north Poland receives more part of East Prussia with Konigsberg (Królewiec), but except for a little northern part with Klaipeda and Tylża (Tilsit), i.e. counties Niederung, Tilsit, Ragnit, Pilkallen, Stalluponnen), which was first demanding of Soviets in early 1943. These territories, as ethnically Lithuanian in 10-15%, are transferred to Lithuanian SRR. Klaipeda (renamed Kaliningrad) and Tilsit have special laws for Russian army, as in real Sevastopol in Crimea.
Poland shouldn't receive whole East Prussia due to weaken of demandin of Germans expelled, who would have not Poland and Russia as sides, but only Poland.
In western, Poland receives terrais west of Oder-Nisse line, as Lusatian counties (Kamenz, Bautzen, Lobau, Hoyerswerda, Cottbus, Rothenburg, Spremberg, Lubben) and county Calau with 5,5% Polish minority, Lubusz land as historical Polish (Lebus and Beeskow-Storkow) and whole mouth of Odra river (Randow, Ueckermunde, Usedom).
Also western border would be similar to this from 11th century during reign of Bolesław I Chrobry.
Map of propositions
https://zapodaj.net/483846bceae15.jpg.html
I think that it could be by more power of Churchill and Roosevelt during peace conferences.
Basic argument is that Poland shouldn't have less surface that in 1939 i.e. 389 000 sq. km.
My proposition:
In east Poland receives rayons of Grodno (counties Grodno, Wołkowysk, Szczuczyn), Brześć (Brześć, Prużana, Kobryń), Wołyń (Włodzimierz, Kowel, Luboml, Horochów) and some part of East Galicia (Lwów voivodeship, western past of Stanisławów [Skole, Stryj, Dolina, Rohatyn, Żydaczów, Kałusz] and Tarnopol voivodeships [Kamionka, Radziechów, Brody, Przemyślany, Złoczów]). These terrains were mentioned in Sikorski Line. Grodno and Lwów were centers od Polish culture, petroleum of Drohobycz and gas of Daszawa were necessary for Polish industry, Brześć was also necessary due to railway line north-south Białystok-Brześć-Kowel-Lwów.
But Poland has to give for Soviets easter part of Galicia with cities Stanislawow and Tarnopol due to railway line Jaremcze-Jasina to Subcarpathia (to control Czechoslovakia and Hungary) and cities Lida and Wilno due to also railway lines to Lithuania, in fact Poles were 80%, but this terrain was set into Poland illegal in 1920 as "Central Lithuania" (Churchill mentioned it), so we had very little chance to save it.
In north Poland receives more part of East Prussia with Konigsberg (Królewiec), but except for a little northern part with Klaipeda and Tylża (Tilsit), i.e. counties Niederung, Tilsit, Ragnit, Pilkallen, Stalluponnen), which was first demanding of Soviets in early 1943. These territories, as ethnically Lithuanian in 10-15%, are transferred to Lithuanian SRR. Klaipeda (renamed Kaliningrad) and Tilsit have special laws for Russian army, as in real Sevastopol in Crimea.
Poland shouldn't receive whole East Prussia due to weaken of demandin of Germans expelled, who would have not Poland and Russia as sides, but only Poland.
In western, Poland receives terrais west of Oder-Nisse line, as Lusatian counties (Kamenz, Bautzen, Lobau, Hoyerswerda, Cottbus, Rothenburg, Spremberg, Lubben) and county Calau with 5,5% Polish minority, Lubusz land as historical Polish (Lebus and Beeskow-Storkow) and whole mouth of Odra river (Randow, Ueckermunde, Usedom).
Also western border would be similar to this from 11th century during reign of Bolesław I Chrobry.
Map of propositions
https://zapodaj.net/483846bceae15.jpg.html
Last edited: