Alternate WW1 and WW2.

Belarus is far too east, uverwanked Courland makes no sense at all, and the entire scenario is indeed ASB. I mean, the maps look intersting, but... yeah, ASB.
Not Courland, but Latvia. He secede from Lithuania (Before spliting the name was Baltic), after he get back he`s native capital: Riga.
 

Susano

Banned
)I just see I meant Belarus is too far WEST of course, not East. But if "Courland" is Latvia, what is Livonia then?
 
most of east europe in these maps makes no sence what so ewer
is Croatia and Voivodina in one state? what state is that exactly?
what is that big homogenus blob where Serbia and Bosna should be, olnly without Voivodina? kingdom of Montenegro maybe?

the whole WWI just gets pased ower like no big deal, Russia and France beat Germany, Turkey and Austria, it just kind of happens
the fact that Austria could send entire armies to the russian front as they were not needed in Italy is what, not important?

and theres a big grey area in former russian empire territory

what is that?

why would all the nations in the empire support the tzar? especially the poles and the kavkazus people, why would they support the guy in whose name kozaks killed raped and pillaged?
and how come they have an army that rivals the tzars? did their population sudenly jump during the war and aquire winchesters and machine guns?

and during this civil war, what does the tzarist army eat actually?
 
Last edited:
In the otl it cost France, Britaine, America(1918), Russia(before the revolution) and their colonies to bring Germany down. Now only France and Russia this should be a Centrale power Victory timeline.
 
Belarus is far too east, uverwanked Courland makes no sense at all, and the entire scenario is indeed ASB. I mean, the maps look intersting, but... yeah, ASB.
Actually Belarus is located roughly in the same place as in OTL, but it is a tad truncated, doesn't extend as far to the east as in OTL. Also in the last couple of maps in the series, it is shrunk down even more.
 
Well, I had that happen in my TL.
Yes, once you have victorious foreign power cutting conquered land as it see fit, everything is possible. After all, Germans DID give Crimea to Ukraine after Brest-Litovsk. But Solder's scenario assumes internal disintegration and in this situation Crimea could end up Russian, Tatar Khanate or some kind of territory effectively controlled by a foreign power (crumble picker), but not part of Ukraine.
 
Well...

OK, well I must say, I really like the maps themselves! They are very neat and the regional divisions within each country are absolute genius!

Though...the maps that are after the first Europeene are absolutely wonky and do not work at all! Russian would never occupy Romania, as they have never been considered a "close to Russian" race, despite the same religion! It would be more likely that Russia would join with Bolgaria.

I understand the loss of Finland and the Baltic states and "portions" of Kazakhstan(but not all of what has been put on the map!!!) and the Caucuses states. But you cannot possibly think that under a handover of sovereignty to comprising states of the Russian Empire, the Tsar would hand over the Russian north Caucus, or even eastern Belyorus and eastern Ukraine and The Crimea in particular, and area where thousands of Russian lives were lost fighting the Turks!

I feel it more likely Poland would occupy the western portions of Belyorus and Ukraine as these areas are heavily "Polinised"(if that is a word)!

00000serge1914.PNG
 
A little improvement...

I noticed I screwed up the Georgia/Azerbaijan and Russia/Kazakhstan borders slightly...I also figured that maybe Germany would no longer want the Sudetenland from the Czech's.

Here is a little improved version...the extension of the Kaliningrad region into Poland, is a little buffer zone that I reckon Russia should have.

Possible modern Europe.PNG
 

Nietzsche

Banned
I noticed I screwed up the Georgia/Azerbaijan and Russia/Kazakhstan borders slightly...I also figured that maybe Germany would no longer want the Sudetenland from the Czech's.

Here is a little improved version...the extension of the Kaliningrad region into Poland, is a little buffer zone that I reckon Russia should have.
;_;!!

Why does everyone like to strip Prussia from Germany?!
 
;_;!!

Why does everyone like to strip Prussia from Germany?!

Hahaha...the Kaliningrad region was won fair and square by the Soviet Union from Nazi Germany (as were the Kuril Islands from Japan mind you!) What I dont understand though is why Poland was shifted sooo far to the west...I think Poland should be a little more east...even more east than is in my map...to let Germany have more of Silesia and Pomerania...only fair! (I RECKON...dont bombard me with accusations or whatever)
 
Top