The
1872 Columbian Presidential Election was held on July 19, 1872. Incumbent President
Susan B. Anthony was defeated by
Lucrecita Mott following a contentious electoral battle. The 1872 shares the distinction along with the
1950 Columbian Presidential election to be determined in the bicameral chambers of both the lower
National Assembly and the upper
Universal Congress, and is noted for the only result in which the President and Vice President came from different parties.
Incumbent President Susan B. Anthony enjoyed strong support among the poor farming communities of the deep south, though there was strong contention between herself and Vice President
Elizabeth Cady Stanton, who disagreed as to the role that women ultimately played in Columbian society. The largest of these issues was the
military draft proposal. The Anthony administration never gave too strong a leaning either in supporting the move or opposing it, instead attempting to focus on social issues such as the
abolishment of child labor and the advancement of
prohibition.
However, in their attempts to remain neutral on the issue of the draft, it enraged a very vocal group of women that came together under the
Conservative Peace Alliance. They nominated the Former
Collector of the Port of New York Lucreita Mott. To balance the ticket, the nominating committee selected Frances Willard, who agreed to the vice-presidential slot.
Famed civil war nurse, botanist and scientist
Clara Barton was chosen unanimously by the female delegates to the
Colombian Reconciliation Association, whose main complaints were a need to bolster
civil-war era pensions for the female soldiers and their male spouses. They advocated a moderate racial policy where black women would be gradually integrated, and wished to continue the ongoing
Self-Constructive Movement within the former states of the
Daughter's Patriotic Federation, whose succession sparked the
Second Columbian Civil War. In a bold move, Barton was persuaded by a more progressive wing of the CRA to the choice of african-american Josephine Ruffin. It was hoped that Ruffin's presence on the ticket would drive up votes in minority areas, though this proved to have a limited effect.
Finally, there was the rowdy and ill-tempered
Pioneer Women of Colombia, derided as
"nothing more than a bunch of restless illiterates", at least in private letters from President Anthony to a longtime friend. Following
many scuffles, confusing votes and numerous riots within the PWC, they nominated the first man in the history of Columbia,
George Francis Train, whose controversial racial views it was hoped, would draw away potential supporters within the South and Midwestern Columbia. The Party's coffers, already deep in the red, also had another, more desperate ploy that Train's rumored considerable financial fortunes would be enough to save the party from the intense threat of female mercenaries and debt collectors. While Train did promise to contribute "significantly", upon his death it was revealed that he only spent a fraction of his actual wealth to the PWC's coffers, instead taking the investment "fees" of the PWC and simply
running off with it. In order to at least have some female representation on the ticket, Anthony, who was drunk during the closing hours of the convention, shouted out that Stanton would be "tolerable." While it had been laughed off as a joke, when Anthony sobered up, he seriously pursued either Stanton or thought to pick PWC chairman
Charles Guiteau. Deciding to balance the ticket, he tentatively sent her a telegraph, and was even more surprised when she accepted his proposal.
During the general campaign, much to the detriment of Anthony, the Conservatives spoke again and again of the military draft, arguing that Anthony's silence on the issue was tantamount to numb acquiescence to violence and the glorification of war. However, the Conservatives were met with a stiff choice, speak out agaisnt the popular soldier's pensions that the CRA was bringing up constantly, or stay silent and risk the same attacks levied on Anthony onto Mott? They opted to pick a middle approach, applauding the sacrifice of the soldiers while condemning the millionaires, war profiteers and murderers in an attempt to appease that powerful voting group. The Conservatives soon recoiled at the loss of their more radical pacifist wing, who split off and formally agreed to endorse the rough and ready PWC.
By the time of the election, the results were unclear on the first few hours, but as states were called, it came to the realization that no-one garnered an outright majority. Mott managed to carry
North Carolina, a traditionally solid CEF state, while the drunken efforts of the PWC saw just
Ohio,
Ross and
Tubman vote for them. As the nation settled in for a contingent election, backroom deals were already being played out. Barton promised the Ohio delegation enough funds for those bridges they wanted across
Lake Inferior. Mott, for her part, openly bribed the entire state delegation of
Arkansas, telling them to deliver this to the North Carolinians and she would see to it that the Self-Constructive Movement
was ended upon her inauguration into the Pink House. While Anthony would have been actively bribing and dealing, she came down with a nasty case of Tuberculosis, and so embarked throughout the August to December period on a Presidential covered wagon train to the Great Plains, where it was hoped the fresher air would help her out.
By the time the
National Assembly met in December, many of Anthony's southern allies abandoned her in favor of Mott. Barton's efforts netted her a solid support of the northern states and managed to bribe 5 of the 8 national assembly members from the Great Plains delegation to enable the vote-en-bloc to swing her way. However, it wasn't enough for Barton or Anthony. The loss of southern support was too much for the incumbent, who now had no path to win. Then the efforts came down in stopping Mott from garnering enough state delegations ( 13 minimum). While they were able to chat at length with Missouri, a nervous representative switched his vote from Barton to Mott, turning that delegation, previously 3 Mott, 3 Anthony 1Barton into 4 Mott and 3 Barton, giving her the en-bloc votes of Missouri and the minimum of 13 needed to be elected President.
The
Vice Presidential race was decided in the Senate. As it was the top three candidates, this meant that the corrupt pennies poured into Train and Stanton's campaign were wasted. The Senate's choices were Willard, Catt or Ruffin. There had been whispers of Anthony's poor health, spurred on by
sensationalist stories about Anthony almost about to pass away, with some reporters even openly reporting on her "disappearance into the great plains". These rumors, as much as the senators at the time would have liked to dismiss, leaned heavily into their decision making for the
Vice President. Willard was rejected owing to personal affairs regarding several senators, with her shutting down of several businesses owned by wealthy members of the political elite. Catt was too confrontational , stemming from her history as the former
Investigative Secretary of Columbia, and wished to retain much distance between them and the numerous crimes the house of representatives was being squeezed into, which would paint the senate just as bad. So, at an eleventh hour, in a smoke filled room, the senators came to the reluctant concurrence on Josephine Ruffin. As the southern senators violently protested at an african-americans being vice president, they were, for once, voted out by the rest of a tired senate, who simply wished to get to the business of the country.
And so, one of the most contentious, confusing and often times unforgettable elections in modern Columbian history came to a close.