Alternate Matches for the Romanovs (Emperors, Empresses, Grand Dukes and Duchesses)

Ehm... Happy New Year!, could someone propose a consort for Elizabeth I of Russia?
PD: It's for a story, plese...

Happy New Year yourself. Who Elizabeth marries would probably depend who marrying her/when she's marrying.
Pyotr wanted her to wed a prince of Hesse-Homburg (or his brother), and then switched it up to a prince of Holstein.
Ekaterina I wanted her to wed this guy.
Under Anna's reign, when Anton Ulrich of Brunswick came to Russia to marry Anna Leopoldovna, Anton's brother, Ludwig Ernst, arrived with him, with the intention of marrying Elizabeth with Courland as her dowry.

Then, let us not forget the insane ideas that Pyotr had to wed his bastard daughter to either Louis XV, Louis, duc d'Orléans or James III of England.
 
Name of Czar: Nicholas II
Name of possible consort:
Mathilda-Marie Feliksovna Kschessinskaya
Why the marriage plans foundered OTL: Nicholas's father liked her personally. Nicholas wanted someone his father detested - he married Alexandra.
Results. Mathilda would not have hemophilia. She was a rational woman - there is a story where she backed down a drunk Cossack still dressed in her toe-shoes. She would have guided Nicholas into a constitutional monarchy and would have been far better loved than the OTL by the Russian people.

The marriage failed because of the succession rules: while it was possible to marry a commoner, the children would not be on a line of succession (as was the case with the 2nd marriage of Alexander II). Not to mention that the wife would not be an empress (in the cases of "inappropriate" but approved marriages of the Grand Dukes their wives were getting the princely titles but did not become "Imperial Highness").

It is quite unclear why would Matilda be a proponent of the constitutional monarchy or to be considered as anything but a public insult on all levels. Ah, yes, her being Polish would not be exactly a ticket to the universal love if one keeps in mind a high level of Polonophobia in Russia of that time.

However, taking into an account Matilda's activities in OTL, it can be assumed that she may ...er.... consolidate the imperial family (if schedules of the visits are created and maintained properly): in her memoirs I lost track of the sets of the Grand Dukes which had been her "friends" at each specific moment but it looks like none of them had a problem with not being a single recipient of her favors. :p
 
Name of Czar:
Name of possible consort:
Why the marriage plans foundered OTL:
Results of a successful marriage into Russia:
(note, this doesn't necessarily mean that the marriage itself is successful, simply that the tsarevich and the princess get married).

Looking forward to your responses

Why not reverse the question by finding suitable husbands?

Anna, widowed duchess of Courland, marries illegitimate son of King August II, Hermann Moritz Graf von Sachsen (or in French Maurice de Saxe). In OTL the marriage fall apart by 2 reasons: 1st, Catherine I was afraid that this would strengthen the Polish position in the Duchy (or perhaps somebody told her so because she was not exactly the brightest apple on any tree) and 2nd, Menshikov decided that it will be a good idea to became a ruler of the (semi-)independent state and screwed things up to a degree that required a prolonged and not 100% successful patching of the situation.

Maurice was liked by a local nobility (of both genders; it seems that within a short stay in the duchy he managed to became very familiar with a considerable number of the local females) and Anne liked him as well. So let's assume that Catherine does not object and keeps "Danilovich" at bay (difficult but quite possible: he was recalled after fiasco in Courland instead of being backed up by a military force as he demanded). So we have a happy couple living in a relative misery for a couple of years (Anne as a duchess was really poor but perhaps the local nobility would agree to spare some cash for Maurice) and then Peter II is dead and Supreme Privy Council has to address a succession crisis. Let's also assume that there are no children in that marriage and almost definitely Maurice is not playing any noticeable role in governing the Duchy just because these functions had been taken out of his wife's hands.

In OTL Anne was an attractive figure because she was not married and looked as one who is going to be easily manipulated but even if she is married other options do not look more attractive.

Peter's grandson (future Peter III) means continuation of the Holstein-oriented policy which, during the reign of Catherine I resulted in a dangerous cooling of the relations not just with Denmark but also with the Brits and Dutch (and in Sweden position of the pro-Russian party became rather shaky as well).

Catherine of Mecklenburg-Schwerin lived in Russia with her daughter but never was officially divorced and there was a fear that influence of her husband could get Russia into one more trouble (in OTL Peter I backed him up with the troops against his subjects but was forced to evacuate the troops under international pressure).

Praskovya Ivanovna was married to a general prince Ivan Dmitriev-Mamonov which would be considered inappropriate (to be married to a subject was a "no-no" for a Russian tsarevna).

Elizabeth Petrovna seemingly did not generate at that point any noticeable enthusiasm.

So let's assume that Anne is chosen just because all other options are not better and the fact that Anne is childless speaks in her favor. So far Maurice is mostly known for his "non-governmental" interests and is not considered as being a clear and present danger. Anna is given "conditions" limiting her future powers but upon arrival to Russia finds out that "we the people" (aka nobility in general and especially the Guards) prefer absolutism. So she is an absolute monarch with her consort (who is not an emperor) just being one of the greatest military minds of his time.... In OTL the #1 military figure in Anne's Russia was Munnich - a talented engineer and a good military organizer and reformer but not a very good (if reasonably lucky) general. Even his seemingly successful campaigns against the Crimea and Ottomans ended up as strategic flops due to the huge unnecessary losses, logistical problems, etc. Now, with Maurice being in charge of the campaigns, Russia may end up with a much earlier annexation of the Crimea and perhaps occupation of Bessarabia. What could happen after Anne's death is quite interesting because, unlike Munnich, Maurice was a figure that could endear himself to the Guards. Well, how about him marrying Elizabeth?
 
However, taking into an account Matilda's activities in OTL, it can be assumed that she may ...er.... consolidate the imperial family (if schedules of the visits are created and maintained properly): in her memoirs I lost track of the sets of the Grand Dukes which had been her "friends" at each specific moment but it looks like none of them had a problem with not being a single recipient of her favors. :p

I'm just thinking how that "non-exclusiveness" can lead to all sorts of paternity questions about any kids born of said union.

Why not reverse the question by finding suitable husbands?

Anna, widowed duchess of Courland, marries illegitimate son of King August II, Hermann Moritz Graf von Sachsen (or in French Maurice de Saxe). In OTL the marriage fall apart by 2 reasons: 1st, Catherine I was afraid that this would strengthen the Polish position in the Duchy (or perhaps somebody told her so because she was not exactly the brightest apple on any tree) and 2nd, Menshikov decided that it will be a good idea to became a ruler of the (semi-)independent state and screwed things up to a degree that required a prolonged and not 100% successful patching of the situation.

Maurice was liked by a local nobility (of both genders; it seems that within a short stay in the duchy he managed to became very familiar with a considerable number of the local females) and Anne liked him as well. So let's assume that Catherine does not object and keeps "Danilovich" at bay (difficult but quite possible: he was recalled after fiasco in Courland instead of being backed up by a military force as he demanded). So we have a happy couple living in a relative misery for a couple of years (Anne as a duchess was really poor but perhaps the local nobility would agree to spare some cash for Maurice) and then Peter II is dead and Supreme Privy Council has to address a succession crisis. Let's also assume that there are no children in that marriage and almost definitely Maurice is not playing any noticeable role in governing the Duchy just because these functions had been taken out of his wife's hands.

In OTL Anne was an attractive figure because she was not married and looked as one who is going to be easily manipulated but even if she is married other options do not look more attractive.

Peter's grandson (future Peter III) means continuation of the Holstein-oriented policy which, during the reign of Catherine I resulted in a dangerous cooling of the relations not just with Denmark but also with the Brits and Dutch (and in Sweden position of the pro-Russian party became rather shaky as well).

Catherine of Mecklenburg-Schwerin lived in Russia with her daughter but never was officially divorced and there was a fear that influence of her husband could get Russia into one more trouble (in OTL Peter I backed him up with the troops against his subjects but was forced to evacuate the troops under international pressure).

Praskovya Ivanovna was married to a general prince Ivan Dmitriev-Mamonov which would be considered inappropriate (to be married to a subject was a "no-no" for a Russian tsarevna).

Elizabeth Petrovna seemingly did not generate at that point any noticeable enthusiasm.

So let's assume that Anne is chosen just because all other options are not better and the fact that Anne is childless speaks in her favor. So far Maurice is mostly known for his "non-governmental" interests and is not considered as being a clear and present danger. Anna is given "conditions" limiting her future powers but upon arrival to Russia finds out that "we the people" (aka nobility in general and especially the Guards) prefer absolutism. So she is an absolute monarch with her consort (who is not an emperor) just being one of the greatest military minds of his time.... In OTL the #1 military figure in Anne's Russia was Munnich - a talented engineer and a good military organizer and reformer but not a very good (if reasonably lucky) general. Even his seemingly successful campaigns against the Crimea and Ottomans ended up as strategic flops due to the huge unnecessary losses, logistical problems, etc. Now, with Maurice being in charge of the campaigns, Russia may end up with a much earlier annexation of the Crimea and perhaps occupation of Bessarabia. What could happen after Anne's death is quite interesting because, unlike Munnich, Maurice was a figure that could endear himself to the Guards. Well, how about him marrying Elizabeth?

Finding suitable husbands was never out of the question, I just wasn't sure if it would be taken seriously. However, I like the idea of a Wettin Russia and Courland though. Not to mention I'd love to see what de Saxe is going to do with the Russian army.
 
I'm just thinking how that "non-exclusiveness" can lead to all sorts of paternity questions about any kids born of said union.

This was a confusing part in the book: it seems that all of the current "friends" were quite happy is a possibility of being a father even in the cases when they were most probably were not. At least the child clearly was not spoiling the happy relations.


Finding suitable husbands was never out of the question, I just wasn't sure if it would be taken seriously. However, I like the idea of a Wettin Russia and Courland though. Not to mention I'd love to see what de Saxe is going to do with the Russian army.

Finding suitable husbands was a big part of Peter's "imperial" program. He was trying very hard to turn Baltic Sea into the Russian lake, hence Mecklenburg and Holstein marriages. Of course, the whole idea was slightly too much on a moronic side (the same can be said about many of Peter's ideas in the area of a foreign policy): it was somewhat similar to the Pragmatic Sanction in reliance upon connections and agreements instead of a solid military power. To achieve his goal Peter would need a navy powerful enough to deal with the Danish and capable of standing up to the combination of the Danish-British-Dutch navies (obviously, the Brits would not be sending their whole fleet to the Baltic Sea but still). This was practical impossibility even just because of absence of money: existing military expenses already were amounting to 80 - 90% of a budget and, with country's economy being thoroughly destroyed by his reforms, there was no way of getting amounts of money needed for such a massive naval buildup. The only way around was to rearrange the foreign policy in such a way that the Brits and the Dutch would prefer to side with him and not with Denmark (I have no clue what he would have to do except for trying to make Russia the greatest British trade partner).

Soon after his death Russian foreign policy had been readjusted by vice-chancellor Osterman by establishing a lasting Austro-Russian alliance. Still, inheritance was there: Peter III was planning Russian war with Denmark over Shlezwig.
 
Top