I assure you that our critiques are all in good nature, after all, what is the point of coming to AH.com other than to learn? I, personally, am waiting to see what the Hell the date is before I attempt to criticize this. Although, in all fairness, it does seem incredibly ASB for the US to surrender like that, no matter the timeframe. Atlanta isn't that important of a city, and atom-bombing US soil is just going to strengthen the resolve of the US resistance (which will be viscous thanks to that pesky 2nd Amendment of ours).
And on slightly-related note. How would the NY Times have knowledge of Nazi plans to bomb Boston? The Nazis are insane but they aren't stupid enough to leak their plans to the point where even enemy newspapers somehow know about them.