Scenario 2 - In this ATL, the all 24 qualified to USA '94 were exactly the same than in OTL....the background story, this time, Argentina with Bilardo again is the same...
FIFA WORLD CUP USA '94...BILARDO'S COMEBACK....
Real frontpage after Colombia's victory over Argentina in WCQ 1994 -september 1993
After 0-5 defeat against Colombia, Alfio Basile’s persistence as Argentina National Team manager became a blur matter. If Argentina doesn’t qualify to FIFA World Cup USA ’94, all previous victories - Copa America 1991 &1993, King Fahd Cup 1992 (now Confederations cup) 1993 Artemio Franchi Cup victory against last euro Champion, Denmark and that 33 invictus matches – would became useless and a mere acnecdotic. The major scandal facing an elimination would be a bigger failure than the sum of all triumphs.
AFA chairman, Julio Grondona, didn’t want to fire Basile. Until that time, and from 1974, argentinian managers started and ended all their contracts, 4 years, and even in dark moments, like Bilardo previous 1986, all contracts were respected. But media was furious, and people as well, argentina’s largest sport magazine – “El Gráfico” - put a black frontpage with a title in white “SHAME!” , and 1986 and 1990 was still so fresh to be outsted from a WCQ , “Coco” Basile was in danger, with AFA president support, but no one else, it was less than a year to the World Cup, and little time to play offs ahead against Australia. Besides, the favourite manager of mass and media, Daniel Passarella, was still Maradona’s nemesis, and Maradona promised to be at Play offs, so he was discharged. But Maradona was antagonist of Basile and captain at his absense, Oscar Ruggeri as well. But it was in a less degree.
So, with a leap into unknown, or a jump of faith, Grondona left AFA comitee (it means the 1° and 2° division club votes), to decide…they decided to dismiss Basile. So Grondona covered himself of not to be the responsible for that decision ( a hoax, because nothing was made without Grondona consenment) . So, emergency declared, little time for play offs against Australia, Passarella in a black list, Carlos Bianchi, 1993 champion with Velez, didn’t show interest, so an experienced manager was called again, Carlos Bilardo agreed to retake his place in Argentina National Team, but only signed until “the end of world cup, and then I will be retired, this time for real” (1)
Despite mass media support, like “El Gráfico” or Canal 13 Clarin Group, Bilardo had a tremendous back up, but was not people’s favourite, because everybody had in mind the horrible games played by Argentina prior World Cup and now he had little time for experimentations, so he focused in Australia.
Many Basile’s favourite names didn’t return, but many new local revelations, even praised by Bilardo himself as sport commentator were cited, Ferrocarril Oeste Df Roberto Ayala (recently transfered to River Plate), Df Pablo “morrón” Rotchen and midfield Gustavo Lopez (both from Independiente) experienced Boca Juniors defender Carlos McAllister, independiente midfield Perico Perez, mf Leonardo Astrada, Gustavo Zapata, df Hernan Diaz and local sensation Ariel “burrito” Ortega(all three from River Plate) .
Of course, well known stars, and Bilardo’s well known, went on, like “cholo” Simeone (Bilardo called up him in 1988-89, when he was only 18 years old ) and Oscar Ruggeri. Another “european” well known, like Roberto Nestor Sensini and Abel Balbo (both weren’t called by Basile prior 0-5) were called by Bilardo, as well as 1990 WC player Jose Basualdo, and Alejandro Mancuso both from Velez, and defenders Fernando Cáceres and Nestor Fabbri, but in his first controversial decision, he didn’t call up to Fernando Redondo (Bilardo called up him in 1989, when he was in Argentinos Juniors, but he said no because he was studying but then, a month later he was sold to a spanish club, and he went away without hesitate), but he would eventually be called up for the World Cup. He was a well known of Bilardo’s aides, because he was sparring of national team before and part of national youth team in mid ‘80s as well as Caceres.
Of course Gabriel Batistuta was called without a shadow of doubt.
Maradona hired a chinese nutritionist (2) and he regained his Spain 1982 weight althought lack of football, and signing for Newell’s Old Boys, but always Maradona, and with Bilardo madly working during days of week with local players, and travelling abroad to explain the other players the things he wanted (3). Eventally, Argentina beated Australia, the game Argentina displayed had Bilardo’s mark, far defensive than Basile, not let the rival to play, but much better treatment of the ball so, far offensive than 1990, because of the quality of players. And the trauma for the 1988 australian victory 4-1 against Bilardo’s Argentina was finally buried.
Caniggia was banned due drug tested, but Bilardo assured to press he would call him for USA 1994, but meanwhile the attack line was Maradona&Balbo–Batistuta, with Ariel Ortega entering into the last minutes like victory 3-1 against Germany in december 1993 (4). This time, wth a few months only for work, Bilardo used all his experience to use tactics he felt sure were the right one, no space for deep experimentations. Friendlies previous to USA ’94 had good results, the game displayed didn’t leave margin for concerns, but everyone agree they were no brillant, like 1-1 against Brazil in Recife, on april 1994 (and without Diego) or victory 3-1 against Chile in Santiago, 1-0 victory in Quito against Ecuador, victory 3-1 against Morocco in Salta, Argentina, 1-0 against Croatia and 2-0 against Austria (5)
Maradona, after a meeting with Bilardo and Grondona, in december 1993, commited to play all the remaining season, it means until May 1994, with Newell’s, and both would intercede to Newell’s president because the misunderstood that damped Maradona staying in the club, although Diego didn’t honoured his word and went away on april 1994 (6). Nothing could avoid his verbal attacks against Pele, Havelange and Blatter.
After leaving Newell’s, Maradona started to train in Ezeiza, for a delighted Bilardo, who will have him plenty of time, so with his personal trainer “el ciego” Signorini, and AFA trainers, profe Etcheverria, Dr Madero, and Bilardo himself, he pursuit his finest shape for the World Cup, as they did in 1986-90. (7)
So, USA 1994 would start, Abel Balbo would go to the bench, and attacking line up will be Maradona- Caniggia – Batistuta (8)
Argentina's round Robin (9) (10)
That result changed a lot the round of 16, because the best four 3rd places, were...
So, according to FIFA, for WC 1994, if the best four best 3rd places were from groups A, B. E, F...the Round of 16's would be 1º GROUP A vs 3º Group E / 1º Group B vs 3° Group A /1º Group C vs 3° Group B /1st Group D vs 3°Group F(11)...so the rest of the story is well known...
Maradona vs Greece - USA '94
Argentina’s headlines, and press was delighted, fans were plenty of illusion, “Ole” sport newspaper entitled “Narigón del Siglo”, when Argentina qualified to Round of 16. So, there was another miracle, Brazil, at Parreira’s orders, was playing a “bilardism football”
In second round, it means from Round of 16 until final, they were all 90 minutes victories, but all for minimun differences. Midfield became the key( with Redondo, Mancuso or Jose Basualdo, Perico Perez, Simeone and Maradona) , defense became tighter. Maybe the worst match was against Belgium, when Maradona did play with some injure (and manager Bilardo replacing Caniggia with Balbo, due a severe injure that left him away of the World Cup (12) ), but Argentina won the same.
Against Spain and Brazil, matches was like chess made, that’s why result were so short. Bilardo and Javier Clemente, and Bilardo and Carlos Parreira played in similar ways, and that reflexed in the struggle for midfield
--- ----- ----- ----
(1) Grondona never wanted Bilardo to resign after 1990, and it was well known he wanted him back, during the first years and beyond after he went away
(2) Absolutely true
(3) Like he did in 1984, very different from Basile, a lazy but lucky one, who in OTL, called players but didnt’t have time to work along, and didn’t prepare time for that.
(4) It was 2-1, Argentina used several local players, except for Balbo. This victory used as a parallel of 1-3 victory in Stuttgart, in 1984 european tour of Argentina nat’l team, who gave a lot of breath to Bilardo at that time
(5) Actually Argentina lost 2-0 this friendly, played in Recife, Brazil… the game was so poorly played by Argentina and his defense was so lame, that many wondered what was doing Basile with his job, or if he was really keen on job. Against Chile was 3-3, with a lame defensive attitude, as well against Ecuador, Argentina lost 1-0. The result against Morocco was like that. Against Croatia, was 0-0 and the match against Austria was suspended.
(6) He actually went away from Newell’s during southern summer of 1994 amidst a scandal, maybe Grondona intervention or a more commited argentina’s national team manager would have been useful to avoid a precipitation of that crisis. Basile wasn’t that man.
(7) Basile and aides, perhaps for ignorance, perhaps Maradona didn’t trust them at all, so they didn’t have any kind of control over Maradona’s preparation, and one of their effects was…Ephedrine. But he went to a field in countryside (La Pampa) to train, but lesser amout of days
(8) Basile in OTL 1994 put Balbo as some kind of “offensive midfield” who made him inaccurate to score and he was not able to mark anybody as well. He scored against Romania, and played putting more heart and effort than efficience.
(9) Goycochea was into the line up until early 1994, but manager Basile, because his old friend Pedro Marchetta, Independiente Manager, asked him for Luis Islas as titular GK, put Goyco into the bench. If you watch all goals Argentina received in WC 1994, Islas had plenty of fails which allowed rivals to score against him.
(10)But the world cup, well.. there was a slightly result that changed everything. Because there was no ephedrine affair in Maradona, Argentina played against Bulgaria in “normal” conditions, and manager, being other than Bilardo instead of Basile, made different tactics maneuvers to control Stoichkov, Sirakov, Balakov, etc…
The day Argentina lost 2-0 against Bulgaria, was the same day Maradona was forbade to keep on playing World Cup, Argentina's team could get over the huge blow of that...at minute 26, Caniggia got injured, and the world Cup was over for him as well...Bulgaria didn't play better than Argentina, had 2 goal situations, two errors from Argentina's mid and last line, specially at Stoichkov goal...and Sirakov goal at minute 92, which allow Bulgaria to went on...if the match would have ended seconds before...Bulgaria would have been eliminated...this happened here.
So, in this ATL, Argentina locked midfield, and result was victory 2-0 against a mediocre Bulgaria. (when you watch that game in OTL you can see the negative effects of the early Maradona suspension, that the went to sleep at 6 am and that they felt unprotected...if the best player in the world didn't have the right protection by AFA, because of ephedrine, what can be expected for the rest)… and a 1-0 against Nigeria, no mistakes in defense but more cautious on attact...that sole goal by Greece at last minute, made Bilardo's obsession to tighten defense and midfield against powerful Nigeria...
(11) According to FIFA, for WC 1994, if the best four best 3rd places were from groups A, B. E, F...the Round of 16's would be 1º GROUP A vs 3º Group E / 1º Group B vs 3° Group A /1º Group C vs 3° Group B /1st Group D vs 3°Group F(2)...so the rest of the story is well known... but if they were best third places from A,D,E,F...Round of 16 matches would be the way it were in OTL...
(12) Caniggia as in OTL would have his injure and got replace by Balbo, and would lost the rest of the World Cup (in OTL with his, he had for 3 weeks recovery, so he would never could be into the line up even in Argentina would have reach the final in OTL 1994)