Alternate Electoral Maps

Status
Not open for further replies.
Laboratories of Democracy, Part IX (for real this time): Nebraska
Equality Before the Ballot

Nebraska, being perhaps the most quintessentially Middle American state, is a fairly unremarkable place. It's first and foremost an agricultural state, with endless fields of grain and cattle grazing grounds cut across by straight highways and railroad lines that can stretch off to the horizon with no natural features or settlements in sight. Its main urban center is found in Omaha, which is home to the Union Pacific Railroad and Berkshire Hathaway but otherwise fairly nondescript, with all the trappings of your average American city of slightly under a million inhabitants. The state capital of Lincoln, a little over fifty miles to the west, is a solid second in terms of population, with the rest of the state's two million inhabitants spread across its area (though the eastern half is notably more populous than the west).

Politically the state is similarly nondescript. The Republican Party is strong here, and has been strong here for as long as there's been a party with that name. Traditionally it maintained a near-monopoly on state politics, but at roughly the same time as its Minnesota counterpart, the party split. However, in Nebraska it was the urban, liberal wing of the party that walked out, forming the Liberal Party and establishing a credible opposition to GOP hegemony for the first time since Bryan's time. Meanwhile, the western evangelicals and rural interests bolted over to the Liberty Party, and thus the modern one-and-two-half-party system of the state was born. Meanwhile in North Omaha, one of the precious few majority-minority areas in the state (African American in this case), Ernie Chambers has been the state legislature's only Labor member for the past forty years, and is showing no sign of slowing down at age 79.

Nebraska has a unicameral legislature, like quite a few smaller and western states, but is unusual in that it was its upper rather than lower house that was retained when the bicameral system was abolished. So the current legislature is a 49-member body elected in single-member districts by plurality, with no proportional element whatsoever to the system. This has played a large part in keeping the GOP in its state of unassailable hegemony, and even as the opposition parties have carved out niches for themselves, the GOP remains firmly in the majority backed by its unwavering support from the Omaha and Lincoln commuter belts.

y8py3Dr.png


Texas
Washington
Massachussetts
New Hampshire
Georgia
Louisiana
Minnesota
South Carolina
 
Nebraska, being perhaps the most quintessentially Middle American state, is a fairly unremarkable place. It's first and foremost an agricultural state, with endless fields of grain and cattle grazing grounds cut across by straight highways and railroad lines that can stretch off to the horizon with no natural features or settlements in sight.

Prose as purple as the Liberty Party's campaign posters :p
 
Prose as purple as the Liberty Party's campaign posters :p

I actually operate under the assumption that Liberty uses red, white and blue as its campaign colors, I just use purple for them because that's the one that's left after the other parties have been given their obvious ones.
 
I'm not sure I'd call Nebraska undemocratic really - the GOP stays in power because people voted for them, not because they game the system in some way. That makes it a dominant-party system, but it's still a functioning democracy.
 
Laboratories of Democracy, Part IX (for real this time): Nebraska
Equality Before the Ballot

Nebraska, being perhaps the most quintessentially Middle American state, is a fairly unremarkable place. It's first and foremost an agricultural state, with endless fields of grain and cattle grazing grounds cut across by straight highways and railroad lines that can stretch off to the horizon with no natural features or settlements in sight. Its main urban center is found in Omaha, which is home to the Union Pacific Railroad and Berkshire Hathaway but otherwise fairly nondescript, with all the trappings of your average American city of slightly under a million inhabitants. The state capital of Lincoln, a little over fifty miles to the west, is a solid second in terms of population, with the rest of the state's two million inhabitants spread across its area (though the eastern half is notably more populous than the west).

Politically the state is similarly nondescript. The Republican Party is strong here, and has been strong here for as long as there's been a party with that name. Traditionally it maintained a near-monopoly on state politics, but at roughly the same time as its Minnesota counterpart, the party split. However, in Nebraska it was the urban, liberal wing of the party that walked out, forming the Liberal Party and establishing a credible opposition to GOP hegemony for the first time since Bryan's time. Meanwhile, the western evangelicals and rural interests bolted over to the Liberty Party, and thus the modern one-and-two-half-party system of the state was born. Meanwhile in North Omaha, one of the precious few majority-minority areas in the state (African American in this case), Ernie Chambers has been the state legislature's only Labor member for the past forty years, and is showing no sign of slowing down at age 79.

Nebraska has a unicameral legislature, like quite a few smaller and western states, but is unusual in that it was its upper rather than lower house that was retained when the bicameral system was abolished. So the current legislature is a 49-member body elected in single-member districts by plurality, with no proportional element whatsoever to the system. This has played a large part in keeping the GOP in its state of unassailable hegemony, and even as the opposition parties have carved out niches for themselves, the GOP remains firmly in the majority backed by its unwavering support from the Omaha and Lincoln commuter belts.



Texas
Washington
Massachussetts
New Hampshire
Georgia
Louisiana
Minnesota
South Carolina
Just curious, but how many states are you planning on doing? All 50? Or are you just doing them until you get bored? Or something in the between?
 
I'd say something in between is closest to the mark – I want to complete the set, but have no real plan for how to do that, and basically do states as the ideas come to me.
 
It is done! New England was a bit more boring than expected unfortunately. Massachusetts and Rhode Island had the GOP, the Greens, and Reform essentially split equally with about 20-21% each causing the Democrats to win both with 37-38% of the state vote. The Reform Party also didn't win Maine, but it was the only state where the winner received under 30 percent of the vote.

I'll post a statewide vote breakdown later. I'm trying to decide what I want to do to calculate the more extreme map. I'm thinking making the popular vote equalized, but not sure if a universal swing or multiplicative would be better. Multiplicative looks like it would effectively flip the system so Reform and Green are the major parties and the Dems and GOP become the minor parties but not sure if the margins would look good enough.

Democrats: 36.80%, 359 EV
Republicans: 33.23%, 176 EV
Reform Party: 19.28%, 0 EV

Green Party: 10.68%, 3 EV

Ivs2yDF.png
 
Here's a three-horse race between Perot (1992), Wallace (1968), and La Follette (1924) on a 1924 map...

WPH8Jaa.jpg


Ross Perot (I-TX)/James Stockdale (I-CA): 288 EVs
George Wallace (AI-AL)/Curtis LeMay (AI-CA): 127 EVs
Robert M. La Follette, Sr. (P-WI)/Burton K. Wheeler (P-MT): 116 EVs
 
It is done! New England was a bit more boring than expected unfortunately. Massachusetts and Rhode Island had the GOP, the Greens, and Reform essentially split equally with about 20-21% each causing the Democrats to win both with 37-38% of the state vote. The Reform Party also didn't win Maine, but it was the only state where the winner received under 30 percent of the vote.

I'll post a statewide vote breakdown later. I'm trying to decide what I want to do to calculate the more extreme map. I'm thinking making the popular vote equalized, but not sure if a universal swing or multiplicative would be better. Multiplicative looks like it would effectively flip the system so Reform and Green are the major parties and the Dems and GOP become the minor parties but not sure if the margins would look good enough.

Democrats: 36.80%, 359 EV
Republicans: 33.23%, 176 EV
Reform Party: 19.28%, 0 EV

Green Party: 10.68%, 3 EV

This map works surprisingly well as a map for Clinton/Gore winning a third term in 2000.
 
Laboratories of Democracy, Part IX (for real this time): Nebraska
Equality Before the Ballot

Meanwhile in North Omaha, one of the precious few majority-minority areas in the state (African American in this case), Ernie Chambers has been the state legislature's only Labor member for the past forty years, and is showing no sign of slowing down at age 79.

Ernie Chambers. I laughed XD
 
Laboratories of Democracy, Part IX (for real this time): Nebraska
Equality Before the Ballot

Nebraska, being perhaps the most quintessentially Middle American state, is a fairly unremarkable place. It's first and foremost an agricultural state, with endless fields of grain and cattle grazing grounds cut across by straight highways and railroad lines that can stretch off to the horizon with no natural features or settlements in sight. Its main urban center is found in Omaha, which is home to the Union Pacific Railroad and Berkshire Hathaway but otherwise fairly nondescript, with all the trappings of your average American city of slightly under a million inhabitants. The state capital of Lincoln, a little over fifty miles to the west, is a solid second in terms of population, with the rest of the state's two million inhabitants spread across its area (though the eastern half is notably more populous than the west).

Politically the state is similarly nondescript. The Republican Party is strong here, and has been strong here for as long as there's been a party with that name. Traditionally it maintained a near-monopoly on state politics, but at roughly the same time as its Minnesota counterpart, the party split. However, in Nebraska it was the urban, liberal wing of the party that walked out, forming the Liberal Party and establishing a credible opposition to GOP hegemony for the first time since Bryan's time. Meanwhile, the western evangelicals and rural interests bolted over to the Liberty Party, and thus the modern one-and-two-half-party system of the state was born. Meanwhile in North Omaha, one of the precious few majority-minority areas in the state (African American in this case), Ernie Chambers has been the state legislature's only Labor member for the past forty years, and is showing no sign of slowing down at age 79.

Nebraska has a unicameral legislature, like quite a few smaller and western states, but is unusual in that it was its upper rather than lower house that was retained when the bicameral system was abolished. So the current legislature is a 49-member body elected in single-member districts by plurality, with no proportional element whatsoever to the system. This has played a large part in keeping the GOP in its state of unassailable hegemony, and even as the opposition parties have carved out niches for themselves, the GOP remains firmly in the majority backed by its unwavering support from the Omaha and Lincoln commuter belts.

y8py3Dr.png


Texas
Washington
Massachussetts
New Hampshire
Georgia
Louisiana
Minnesota
South Carolina
These are always great. Keep it up!
 
voľby.PNG

2016 Slovakia elections, if Slovakia would use the majority system as in UK with 150 constituencies.
Red: SMER-SD, Robert Fico, 89 Seats (Social democrats, populist)
light green: SaS+OLANO , Richard Sulík, 32 seats (eurosceptic liberals, populists)
dark green: SMK , Gyula Bárdos, 12 seats (Hungarian minority interests)
orange: Most-Híd, Béla Bugár , 5 seats (Hungarian-Slovak relations improvement, liberals)
turquise: SNS, Andrej Danko, 4 seats ("soft" nationalist)
dark blue : KDH, Ján Fígeľ, 2 seats (Christian democrats)
dark blue-green: ĽSNS, Marian Kotleba, 2 seats (real nationalists)
 
View attachment 280731
2016 Slovakia elections, if Slovakia would use the majority system as in UK with 150 constituencies.
Red: SMER-SD, Robert Fico, 89 Seats (Social democrats, populist)
light green: SaS+OLANO , Richard Sulík, 32 seats (eurosceptic liberals, populists)
dark green: SMK , Gyula Bárdos, 12 seats (Hungarian minority interests)
orange: Most-Híd, Béla Bugár , 5 seats (Hungarian-Slovak relations improvement, liberals)
turquise: SNS, Andrej Danko, 4 seats ("soft" nationalist)
dark blue : KDH, Ján Fígeľ, 2 seats (Christian democrats)
dark blue-green: ĽSNS, Marian Kotleba, 2 seats (real nationalists)

I'm always happy to see maps of countries that aren't in the Anglosphere, this is no exception.

The minority parties does make Slovakia a surprisingly "vibrant" (although slightly depressing) party system even with FPTP.
 

Wallet

Banned
Laboratories of Democracy, Part IX (for real this time): Nebraska
Equality Before the Ballot

Nebraska, being perhaps the most quintessentially Middle American state, is a fairly unremarkable place. It's first and foremost an agricultural state, with endless fields of grain and cattle grazing grounds cut across by straight highways and railroad lines that can stretch off to the horizon with no natural features or settlements in sight. Its main urban center is found in Omaha, which is home to the Union Pacific Railroad and Berkshire Hathaway but otherwise fairly nondescript, with all the trappings of your average American city of slightly under a million inhabitants. The state capital of Lincoln, a little over fifty miles to the west, is a solid second in terms of population, with the rest of the state's two million inhabitants spread across its area (though the eastern half is notably more populous than the west).

Politically the state is similarly nondescript. The Republican Party is strong here, and has been strong here for as long as there's been a party with that name. Traditionally it maintained a near-monopoly on state politics, but at roughly the same time as its Minnesota counterpart, the party split. However, in Nebraska it was the urban, liberal wing of the party that walked out, forming the Liberal Party and establishing a credible opposition to GOP hegemony for the first time since Bryan's time. Meanwhile, the western evangelicals and rural interests bolted over to the Liberty Party, and thus the modern one-and-two-half-party system of the state was born. Meanwhile in North Omaha, one of the precious few majority-minority areas in the state (African American in this case), Ernie Chambers has been the state legislature's only Labor member for the past forty years, and is showing no sign of slowing down at age 79.

Nebraska has a unicameral legislature, like quite a few smaller and western states, but is unusual in that it was its upper rather than lower house that was retained when the bicameral system was abolished. So the current legislature is a 49-member body elected in single-member districts by plurality, with no proportional element whatsoever to the system. This has played a large part in keeping the GOP in its state of unassailable hegemony, and even as the opposition parties have carved out niches for themselves, the GOP remains firmly in the majority backed by its unwavering support from the Omaha and Lincoln commuter belts.

y8py3Dr.png


Texas
Washington
Massachussetts
New Hampshire
Georgia
Louisiana
Minnesota
South Carolina
Can you do Tennessee?
 
Top
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top