Alternate Academy Awards

Exactly what is says on the tin, Academy Awards that were never awarded.

Best Picture (1998): Saving Private Ryan

Best Actress in a Leading Role (2000): Ellen Burstyn as Sara Goldfarb in Requiem for a Dream (second Best Actress victory)

Best Adapted Screenplay (1994): Frank Darabont for The Shawshank Redemption

Best Picture (1996): Fargo

Inb4 Citizen Kane, but keep it going.
 
55th Academy Awards (April 11th, 1983).


Best Picture: Tootsie

Best Director: Sydney Pollack (for Tootsie)

Best Actor: Dustin Hoffman (for Tootsie)

Best Actress: Jessica Lange (for Frances)

Best Supporting Actor: Robert Preston (for Victor/Victoria)

Best Supporting Actress: Glenn Close (for The World According To Garp)
 
Last edited:
Best Picture:
1939 - Grand Illusion (1)
1941 - Citizen Kane (3)
1942 - The Magnificent Ambersons (4)
1945 - Double Indemnity (5)
1953 - Singin' in the Rain (6)
1959 - Vertigo (7)
1960 - Some Like It Hot (8)
1965 - Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb (12)
1969 - 2001: A Space Odyssey (14)
1974 - Last Tango in Paris (15)
1977 - Taxi Driver (16)
1980 - Apocalypse Now (17)
1981 - Raging Bull (18)
1984 - The Right Stuff (19)
1989 - The Last Temptation of Christ (23)
1991 - Goodfellas (24)
1994 - Pulp Fiction (25)
1996 - Heat (27)
1998 - L.A. Confidential (28)
2000 - Being John Malkovich (30)
2001 - Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (32)
2003 - The Pianist (33)
2006 - Brokeback Mountain (34)
2011 - Toy Story 3 (35)

Best Director:
1939 - Jean Renoir(1)
1940 - Frank Capra(2)
1941 - Orson Welles (3)
1942 - Orson Welles (4)
1945 - Billy Wilder (5)
1959 - Alfred Hitchcock (7)
1960 - Billy Wilder (8)
1961 - Alfred Hitchcock (9)
1962 - Federico Fellini (10)
1963 - Federico Fellini (11)
1965 - Stanley Kubrick (12)
1967 - Michelangelo Antonioni (13)
1969 - Stanley Kubrick (14)
1974 - Bernardo Bertolucci (15)
1977 - Martin Scorsese (16)
1980 - Francis Ford Coppola (17)
1981 - Martin Scorsese (18)
1984 - Ingmar Bergman (20)
1985 - Akira Kurosawa (21)
1987 - David Lynch (22)
1989 - Martin Scorsese (23)
1991 - Martin Scorsese (24)
1994 - Krzysztof Kieślowski (26)
1996 - Michael Mann (27)
1998 - Gus Van Sant (29)
2000 - M. Night Shyamalan (31)
2011 - David Fincher (36)

(1) In a long run, it stand the test of time.
(2) Gone With the Wind was a "producer's movie".
(3) No explanation needed. :p
(4) Butterfly effect of ATL 1941 Academy Awards.
(5) Ditto (1).
(6) Ditto (3).
(7) Ditto (3).
(8) Ditto (1).
(9) Wilder's The Apartment is good. But Hitchcock's Psycho is a seminal work.
(10) Jerome Robbins and Robert Wise over Fellini! Are you kidding?:p
(11) Ditto (10) (sort of).
(12) Ditto (1).
(13) Ditto (1).
(14) Ditto (3).
(15) Higher artistic value than OTL winner.
(16) Ditto (15).
(17) Ditto (3).
(18) Ditto (3).
(19) I like this movie.:D
(20) Ditto (10) (sort of).
(21) Ditto (1).
(22) Ditto (1).
(23) Ditto (3).
(24) Ditto (3).
(25) Forrest Gump (and also The Shawshank Redemption for that matter) is the movie tailor make for the philistine taste AMPAS voters! :mad:
(26) Ditto (25).
(27) Ditto (1).
(28) Titanic is just an "Anti-Casablanca".:p
(29) Ditto (27).
(30) IMHO more daring than American Beauty, should have win Best Original Screenplay as well.
(31) Ditto (1).
(32) Ditto (15).
(33) Ditto (15).
(34) Ditto (1).
(35) I believe in long run, it will stand the test of time.
(36) Ditto (35)
 
Jonathan Kan said:
Best Picture:
1965 - Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb
1969 - 2001: A Space Odyssey
1974 - Last Tango in Paris
:confused::confused:
Jonathan Kan said:
Best Picture:
1980 - Apocalypse Now
:rolleyes:
Jonathan Kan said:
Best Picture:
1984 - The Right Stuff
Improbable, IMO, but I agree.
Jonathan Kan said:
Best Picture:
1994 - Pulp Fiction
The only one I agree with & actually has a chance of winning.
Jonathan Kan said:
Best Picture:
1998 - L.A. Confidential
Considering this was essentially two films,:rolleyes: it really should be co-nominated, & lose both times...but not to Titanic.:eek:


Best Picture 1941: "Citizen Kane" One of the best films that will ever be made.
Best Picture 1944: "The Ox-Bow Incident"
Best Picture 1945: "Double Indemnity"
Best Picture 1953: "High Noon"
Best Picture 1954: "Stalag 17"
Best Picture 1955: "The Caine Mutiny" (if only to deny that SOB Kazan:mad:)
Best Picture 1961: "Psycho"
Best Picture 1962: "Judgement at Nuremberg"
Best Picture 1963: "Becket"
Best Picture 1970: "Butch Cassidy & the Sundance Kid"
Best Picture 1971: "M*A*S*H"
Best Picture 1975: "Chinatown"
Best Picture 1977: "Network" (How hard could it be to beat "Rocky"?:rolleyes:)
Best Picture 1985: "A Soldier's Story"
Best Picture 1988: "Broadcast News"
Best Picture 1990: "Pulp Fiction" (Beats "Forest Gump" all hollow.:rolleyes: I'm tempted to tie it with "Quiz Show", which was strong, too.)
Best Picture 1996: "The Usual Suspects"
Best Picture 1998: "L.A. Confidential" (but only because "Titanic" was so awful:eek:)
Best Picture 2000: "The Insider"
Best Picture 2001: "The Contender"
Best Picture 2001: "Road to Perdition"
Best Picture 2006: "Good Night, and Good Luck"
Best Picture 2008: "Michael Clayton"


Best Director 1954: Hitch, "Rear Window"
Best Director 1961: Hitch, "Psycho"
Best Director 1961: Peter Glenville, "Becket"
Best Director 1968: Norman Jewison, "In the Heat of the Night"
Best Director 1971: Robert Altman, "M*A*S*H" (Scott still gets "Best Actor" for "Patton")
Best Director 1975: Roman Polanski, "Chinatown"
Best Director 1977: Sidney Lumet, "Network"
Best Director 1983: Wolfgang Petersen, "Das Boot"
Best Director 1985: Roland Joffe, "The Killing Fields"
Best Director 1990: Peter Weir, "Dead Poets Society"
Best Director 1995: Quentin Tarantino, "Pulp Fiction"
Best Director 1996: Ron Howard, "Apollo 13" (Anybody that can make it so suspensful when I know the outcome deserves it.:cool::cool:)
Best Director 1998: Curtis Hanson, "L.A. Confidential" (but only because "Titanic" was so awful:eek:)
Best Director 2001: Ang Lee, "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" (not a fan of wire fu)
Best Director 2008: Tony Gilroy, "Michael Clayton"

Best Actor 1945: Fred MacMurray, "Double Indemnity"
Best Actor 1962: Peter O'Toole, "Becket"
Best Actor 1969: Peter O'Toole, "The Lion in Winter"
Best Actor 1977: Peter Finch, "Network"/John Wayne, "The Shootist" (tie)
Best Actor 1980: Peter Sellers, "Being There"
Best Actor 1981: Peter O'Toole, "The Stunt Man"

Best Actress 1969: Katherine Hepburn, "The Lion in Winter" (no tie with Streisand...)
Best Actress 1974: Glenda Jackson, "A Touch of Class"/Tatum O'Neal, "Paper Moon" (How in hell you get nom'd for "Best Supporting" when you're in damn near every shot is beyond me...:eek::eek::confused::confused:) Makes this the first ever tie.

Best Supporting Actor 1955: Fred MacMurray, "The Caine Mutiny" (MacMurray as a bad guy is awesome.)
Best Supporting Actor 1968: Sidney Poitier, "In the Heat of the Night" (It is outrageous he never even got nominated for it.:eek::eek:)
Best Supporting Actor 1970: Jack Nicholson, "Easy Rider"
Best Supporting Actor 2002: Tom Hanks, "Road to Perdition" (Probably the best performance of his career.)
 
Last edited:
Best Picture:

1990: Goodfellas

1994: Pulp Fiction

1998: Saving Private Ryan

2001 and 2002: Lord of the Rings

2008: Gran Torino
 
Best Picture:
1939 - Grand Illusion (1)
1941 - Citizen Kane (3)
1942 - The Magnificent Ambersons (4)
1945 - Double Indemnity (5)
1953 - Singin' in the Rain (6)
1959 - Vertigo (7)
1960 - Some Like It Hot (8)
1965 - Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb (12)
1969 - 2001: A Space Odyssey (14)
1974 - Last Tango in Paris (15)
1977 - Taxi Driver (16)
1980 - Apocalypse Now (17)
1981 - Raging Bull (18)
1984 - The Right Stuff (19)
1989 - The Last Temptation of Christ (23)
1991 - Goodfellas (24)
1994 - Pulp Fiction (25)
1996 - Heat (27)
1998 - L.A. Confidential (28)
2000 - Being John Malkovich (30)
2001 - Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (32)
2003 - The Pianist (33)
2006 - Brokeback Mountain (34)
2011 - Toy Story 3 (35)

Best Director:
1939 - Jean Renoir(1)
1940 - Frank Capra(2)
1941 - Orson Welles (3)
1942 - Orson Welles (4)
1945 - Billy Wilder (5)
1959 - Alfred Hitchcock (7)
1960 - Billy Wilder (8)
1961 - Alfred Hitchcock (9)
1962 - Federico Fellini (10)
1963 - Federico Fellini (11)
1965 - Stanley Kubrick (12)
1967 - Michelangelo Antonioni (13)
1969 - Stanley Kubrick (14)
1974 - Bernardo Bertolucci (15)
1977 - Martin Scorsese (16)
1980 - Francis Ford Coppola (17)
1981 - Martin Scorsese (18)
1984 - Ingmar Bergman (20)
1985 - Akira Kurosawa (21)
1987 - David Lynch (22)
1989 - Martin Scorsese (23)
1991 - Martin Scorsese (24)
1994 - Krzysztof Kieślowski (26)
1996 - Michael Mann (27)
1998 - Gus Van Sant (29)
2000 - M. Night Shyamalan (31)
2011 - David Fincher (36)

(1) In a long run, it stand the test of time.
(2) Gone With the Wind was a "producer's movie".
(3) No explanation needed. :p
(4) Butterfly effect of ATL 1941 Academy Awards.
(5) Ditto (1).
(6) Ditto (3).
(7) Ditto (3).
(8) Ditto (1).
(9) Wilder's The Apartment is good. But Hitchcock's Psycho is a seminal work.
(10) Jerome Robbins and Robert Wise over Fellini! Are you kidding?:p
(11) Ditto (10) (sort of).
(12) Ditto (1).
(13) Ditto (1).
(14) Ditto (3).
(15) Higher artistic value than OTL winner.
(16) Ditto (15).
(17) Ditto (3).
(18) Ditto (3).
(19) I like this movie.:D
(20) Ditto (10) (sort of).
(21) Ditto (1).
(22) Ditto (1).
(23) Ditto (3).
(24) Ditto (3).
(25) Forrest Gump (and also The Shawshank Redemption for that matter) is the movie tailor make for the philistine taste AMPAS voters! :mad:
(26) Ditto (25).
(27) Ditto (1).
(28) Titanic is just an "Anti-Casablanca".:p
(29) Ditto (27).
(30) IMHO more daring than American Beauty, should have win Best Original Screenplay as well.
(31) Ditto (1).
(32) Ditto (15).
(33) Ditto (15).
(34) Ditto (1).
(35) I believe in long run, it will stand the test of time.
(36) Ditto (35)

Best Picture:
2012 - Hugo (37)

Best Director:
2012 - Terrence Malick (38)

(37) Ditto (15), and a much more sincere tribute to silent movies.
(38) Ditto (35).
 
Top