alternatehistory.com

"Far-reaching" as in, "how global would it be ?"

This topic has been discussed several time in this site. Indeed, all of those discussions were solidly focused on Iberian Peninsula, and naturally so, for indeed survival of a good-sized muslim part of Iberian Peninsula alone will make significant change in moderate term, and certainly very enormous butterflies in the long term. However, I don't think people has discussed the changes produce by this PoD in both immediate in a century-long terms. I've noticed several interesting things that all of us might had unfortunately missed it.

For starter, we'll be talking within the time frame of 13th century, when maybe quite many events decisive in shaping of OTL history happened. For example : Mongols. Mongol invasion brought destruction to much of Eurasia, including the seat of Caliphate in Baghdad. IOTL, it resulted in the refuge of the seat to Egypt, under the custody of the Mamluk regime, which while by then received the status as the defender of the Caliph, it didn't seem to have the power nor the prestige to gain general recognition by the rest of Islamic World as Islam's capital(CMIIW though). Also that, possibly (and personally I'm not sure myself) due to impact brought by Mongol destruction and maybe also the following oppression of muslims under Ilkhanate regime before the later converted to Islam, boundaries between Sunnism and Shiism fell into a clear blurriness, explaining OTL religious attitudes of the Ottomans before they ran into the Safavids. Talk about Ottomans, along with Anatolian Beyliks. Basically, what would the presence of an Islamic power that also claimed over Caliphacy effect all those conditions ? Even if they were far off and basically quite alien to the Mashriqi, even a pessimism would seems to contribute a thing. Also IIRC, at their peak Almohad sovereingty strecthed east as far as Barca(Cyrenacia, if you know the region better under that name) .

Talk about territory, we also are oblivious of the nature of Almohad Empire. Especially since they fell into rabid decline after the defeat at Las Navas de Tolosa, which crushed their back bone, and they soon lost nearly all their other domains elsewhere. With their power pre-Navas de Tolosa retained, what would become of the overall development of the Almohad Empire, especially territorial wise ? Certainly that the Almohads will be primarily spending their sweat on Iberian Peninsula. So, what's next ? Will they be able to retain their African holdings(indeed their base was in Africa) or the focus into Iberian Peninsula will inevitably result in setback elsewhere ?

Also, south of Almohads, it seems that Mali Empire wouldn't be butterflied away (again, CMIIW). Simple question would be about what and how many differences be resulted from the coexistence of both Mali and Almohad Empires ? Will they be friendly or rivals etc ? If they would be friendly, will this affect Islam in Mali Empire, knowing Mali Kings IOTL were often quite zealous in promoting Islam within their domains ?

As for a thing in the north, north of Spains, there was also this.

Anything else I've missed ?
Top