History Learner
Banned
I read the eight paragraph and I agree with McPherson, and victory by word count isn't a thing
Then by all means, make your points, just saying I'm wrong doesn't make it so. And sure, victory by word count isn't a thing but that wasn't your original contention, was it?
"Only you've been arguing that the Japanese would push the Americans back into teh sea, and not really supporting you case beyond claiming it was supported."