Due to how unpopular Hoover was in 1932, the Democrats had an easy win. FDR got the nomination, however Al Smith was second. Let's put a POD with FDR losing the already close 1928 New York gubernational election against Albert Ottinger. While he still runs for president, this butterflies to him losing the nomination to Al Smith, who wins against Hoover but at a smaller margin than FDR IOTL. First off, who'd you think would be his VP? More importantly, what kind of presidency might he have in place of FDR? What kind of challenges might he face against the Republicans in 1936?