A lot of these are much too complex for an aircraft roundel. They have to be easily recognizable at a glance from a distance. "Wait, is there a ring of crowns in there, or stars?"
Good points. This, of course, begs the question of the color scheme of Yakutian roundels: during the Second Sino-Japanese War they'd have to look immediately recognizable from the Japanese ones; then after the war they may have to be changed in order to avoid any confusion with the Soviet ones.So it's always worth bearing in mind when designing roundels what wars the country in question fought with its air force, which countries were its allies and which its enemies - this will strongly influence the design of its roundel.
I like the stylized design, which IMHO fits the aforementioned requirements. What does everyone think?Here's two:
A set of roundels I made for an ASB setting. It shouldn't be too hard to figure out which countries they belong to.
For the US symbol, I like it. I think it might eventially be simplified with the multiple vertical stripes cut down to just two (red/white) or three (red/white/red). A single star in the blue field might work.
I like the two (?) confederate designs, which embody an "Allied" type roundel with the St Andrews cross superimposed without stars (I'm assuming you have a TL-191 idie in mind). I've always thought hypothetical CSA insignia that replicates all the individual stars is to complex to be realistic in the long run. Not sure what the roundel with the red St Andrews cross is. An alternate CSA?
I too think the diamond has been under-used as an alternative roundel shape. However, if you are imagining an alternate history with Bourbon France, Russia, and a non-prussian Germany as allies (which the similar shape implies), you've got some creative PoD'ding to do.
Hm, interesting idea. I might add a white border around it as well.
The other one was supposed to be the United Kingdom.
If so, I'd use the red horizontal English cross, not the St' Andrews style
France isn't Bourbon in this scenario; I just added the fleur-de-lis because it looked cool. I'll probably remove it for simplicity's sake. The one on the end is supposed to be Belgium, although the TL does feature a non-Prussian Germany. All powers are aligned because these are for an ASB TL where Martians invade during the 1860s.
, although the TL does feature a non-Prussian Germany. All powers are aligned because these are for an ASB TL where Martians invade during the 1860s.
Yet somehow they have airplanes to put insignia on? Or does somethng like the "Worldwar" stalemate happen and hold for another 100 years?
THAT'S your realism gripe?!
That said, humans were working on flying machines before the world wars, and as soon as they were invented governments tried to weaponize them. Humans are going to develop air forces with or without a world war - especially when they're fighting against little green men who can fly!
If so, I'd use the red horizontal English cross, not the St' Andrews style
Yet somehow they have airplanes to put insignia on? Or does somethng like the "Worldwar" stalemate happen and hold for another 100 years?
THAT'S your realism gripe?!
That said, humans were working on flying machines before the world wars, and as soon as they were invented governments tried to weaponize them. Humans are going to develop air forces with or without a world war - especially when they're fighting against little green men who can fly!
Not if those little green men are flying supersonic rocket planes armed with lasers and nuclear weapons. We won't get the chance to develop aircraft if they invade in mid 19th century.
I suppose a lot depends on how the OP imagines the Martian (another realism problem of course) invasion, their own technology, and initial sucess.
I have to say, the US Army one is very slick looking.