AHC/WI - India

No explanation is needed, just tell the impacts if this was the map of India -
latest
 
From what I can see this is smaller then OTL British India as there is no Burma although you have added Afganistan. Why would the British empire give up their hold in South East Asia for Afganistan?
 
no, this is modern day india map, just tell me how it will effect the world
the rest of afghanistan looks like this
with an independent eastern and northern afghanistan
latest
 
This is the Before 1900 forum, so I was assuming you was asking what would it be like if the British had more of a Western plans for their colonization of India.

Modern day post go into Post 1900, and that previous map was unclear as to how much of Afghanistan was taken by TTL India and there was no inclination of a split Afghanistan

In other words "MORE" explanation is needed!
 

Don Quijote

Banned
Do you have any other ideas which don't involve an unlikely Greater India? Do the Afghans want to be Indian? Do the Pakistanis want to be Indian? India does not have to be united, you could come up with an equally interesting AHC or WI about India without the obsession with a superstate.
 
No explanation is needed

You need to explain how India became like that, because everything is related to everything else, so if India is changed, the world is changed. If modern-day India includes Afghanistan and the Pakistans, you need to explain why and how, or we won't know how to respond.
 
You need to explain how India became like that, because everything is related to everything else, so if India is changed, the world is changed. If modern-day India includes Afghanistan and the Pakistans, you need to explain why and how, or we won't know how to respond.
He did write ahc,so it's our job to make it happen for some reason.
 
Last edited:
India isn't 90% hindu ... Especially with Bactria and the Indus region. There are Muslims, Christians, Jains and even Buddhists in such an India!

Perhaps with a POD around the Battle of Talas? If the Chinese win the religious makeup of Bactria at the least could be considerably different to say the least.

That being said, with regard to the OP, the only answer I have for your question I'm afraid is another question. Namely "How did TTL's India get those borders in the first place?" Once with that information, it will be easier to answer your question.
 
Top