AHC: Union loses Antietam, wins ACW and frees slaves

Solroc

Banned
Not at all. I don't think it's what he'd do, but that's my interpretation and should be considered nothing more than an opinion. Its not as if your reasoning for otherwise is at all unsound. Ultimately the question you need to answer for the sake of plausibility is "what does McClellan think Lee will do?"

If he - rightfully or otherwise - thinks Lee will march on Philadelphia, and he's not ordered to block Lee's road to Washington (and possibly even if he is - this is McClellan we're talking about, and this might be a time Bad McClellan shows up with a vengeance) - he'll act accordingly.

But that concern about the capital is something to keep in mind - whether or not McClellan is specifically concerned about it, Lincoln certainly is. And he will react accordingly.

You've mentioned a PM discussion with him, so I presume he's already given some comments.

And since I've already volunteered (in effect)...looking forward to helping polish your ideas still further. :D

Got it. Think like McClellan.

I still have the conversation (I don't delete pm's unless they're flame or trolling), so maybe you could help with the other ideas I pursued.
 
Got it. Think like McClellan.

That might hurt. More seriously - no more than how you'll need to think like Lee or Lincoln or anyone else. Just remember to keep in mind how he thought and why. The usual AH stuff.

The point is just that as long as its appropriate for him, whether I or anyone else would have picked that particular course if we were the ones writing it instead of you is irrelevant. Not that I mind you using my ideas, but its your timeline. You get to decide, don't take me arguing I know what I'm talking about as implying you don't when it comes to these things.

I still have the conversation (I don't delete pm's unless they're flame or trolling), so maybe you could help with the other ideas I pursued.

Of course.

P.S. No intent to be confusing between current post and the one you're responding to is present. Honest.
 

Solroc

Banned
That might hurt. More seriously - no more than how you'll need to think like Lee or Lincoln or anyone else. Just remember to keep in mind how he thought and why. The usual AH stuff.

The point is just that as long as its appropriate for him, whether I or anyone else would have picked that particular course if we were the ones writing it instead of you is irrelevant. Not that I mind you using my ideas, but its your timeline. You get to decide, don't take me arguing I know what I'm talking about as implying you don't when it comes to these things.



Of course.

P.S. No intent to be confusing between current post and the one you're responding to is present. Honest.

Heh, okay then. As long as it made sense in the minds ofvthe players involved.

Awesome.

And don't worry, there's no confusion. Let me send you a pm.
 
Top