AHC: Soviet Siberia and White European Russia

Is this possible in or around the Russian Civil War to have the Communists retreat to Siberia and have an independent Communist Siberia and the rest being controlled by the whites?

If so, how will this world turn out?

I realize this is probably ASB but I just wanted to see what people would say

EDIT: I know this belongs in after 1900 but I don't know how to change it
 
Is this possible in or around the Russian Civil War to have the Communists retreat to Siberia and have an independent Communist Siberia and the rest being controlled by the whites?

If so, how will this world turn out?

I realize this is probably ASB but I just wanted to see what people would say

EDIT: I know this belongs in after 1900 but I don't know how to change it

ASB is about right; Siberia was held by the Whites during the Civil War.

Also note that when the Reds consolidated control of European Russia, they had no trouble clearing the Whites out of Asian Russia. Basically, Asian Russia had a small fraction of the population and industry (especially if one excludes the Central Asian area, now dubbed "the 'Stans").

So basically, whoever got Euro Russia was going to get the rest.
 
Reds controlled big cities of European Russia and Whites Siberia, so not plausible. And Communism was more workable in urban areas. And even if Reds would get Siberia, how they could get that as viable nation? Them wouldn't have any foreign support. It would collapse soon and Whites would take that.

And you can send post to moderators and ask this thread transfer to correct forum.
 
Option 1: Russia devolves into warlordism. This way the European entities may be too distracted by each other to take out Siberia.

Option 2: Siberia becomes a puppet state or ally of some other power. Options may include a resurgent China, or a Germany which won WWI and allies itself with Red Siberia to weaken postwar Russia.
 
Top