The most common alternate histories involve the south winning the US Civil War, Germany winning World War I, and Germany winning World War II. I would like you to try to come up with a scenario where all three of those happen.
The most common alternate histories involve the south winning the US Civil War, Germany winning World War I, and Germany winning World War II. I would like you to try to come up with a scenario where all three of those happen.
Is there a reason why people on Alternate History like entertaining TLs where black people and Jews are screwed over even more than in OTL?
Is there a reason why people on Alternate History like entertaining TLs where black people and Jews are screwed over even more than in OTL?
Grimdark can be fun. Also in a fictional sense, often the "bad guys" (used in the general sense before you think I'm saying the Nazis were not Evil) winning can be the more interesting scenario.
If Germany wins the First World War, then there wouldn't be anything like the Second World War as it took place IOTL. For that matter, if the South won the Civil War, then there wouldn't be anything like the First World War as it took place IOTL.
Well, I dunno. You might indeed, without any doubt, be rather correct about OTL's WWII: the Nazis rising up probably would be quite unlikely, even with if a Soviet Union forms at some point.....but, OTOH, I can also point out that there's nothing that says that something similar to our world's WWI, at least, could not end up occurring at some point, over something(maybe it starts over Poland instead of Serbia, for example.....)
The most common alternate histories involve the south winning the US Civil War, Germany winning World War I, and Germany winning World War II. I would like you to try to come up with a scenario where all three of those happen.
If Germany won WWI, the chance of the Nazi's coming to power in Germany is so minuscule, one can only call ASB.
Maybe *somewhat* more likely, but probably not by much. In fact, depending on the circumstances, at least, perhaps if enough things go wrong for Germany after an alternate *WWI(which isn't impossible), it may be actually more likely they could be the ones to go *fascist(even if said *fascists aren't quite the Nazis), than Britain and France doing so even after a loss, without some rather more extraordinary circumstances on *their* end.France (and perhaps Britain?) being taken over by fascists and the German's appearing as one of the "good guys" for once is much more likely.
Why not add Russia winning the Cold War?![]()
Maybe *somewhat* more likely, but probably not by much. In fact, depending on the circumstances, at least, perhaps if enough things go wrong for Germany after an alternate *WWI(which isn't impossible), it may be actually more likely they could be the ones to go *fascist(even if said *fascists aren't quite the Nazis), than Britain and France doing so even after a loss, without some rather more extraordinary circumstances on *their* end.
A defeat of France would have been devastating to the French. Combine the destruction of their opportunity of Revanche, and the immense war reparations and the demilitarization of the Seine and German occupation of a significant portion of the country would be more than enough for a fascist takeover of France. A victorious monarchy in Germany would with their now insane amount of popular support easily crush any fascist and communist opposition.