AHC: Prussia keeps its partition

JJohnson

Banned
With a PoD after 1795, have Prussia keep New East Prussia and South Prussia to the present day. Germany must still exist and not be the 'bad guy' in any world wars that may occur, and is not a repressive regime. Poland should still exist, but be based on Galicia and the rest of the eastern second Polish Republic borders, capital of Lublin or Lviv.
 
Pretty Easy, either they jump against the french revolutions early, thus premepting napoleon, or they keep neutral till russian campaign fails and they attack napoleon in his way back to france.

The rest is pretty difficult, unless we got austria wanting to be more 'german' and thus prussia keeping their partitions lans plus galicia and austria winning the rhineland.
 
With a PoD after 1795, have Prussia keep New East Prussia and South Prussia to the present day. Germany must still exist and not be the 'bad guy' in any world wars that may occur, and is not a repressive regime. Poland should still exist, but be based on Galicia and the rest of the eastern second Polish Republic borders, capital of Lublin or Lviv.

It is almost impossible to have Prussia not being the bas guy. Prussia intrisically was the bas guy, with its militaristes and colonialistic mindset.

Germany was not a problem in itself. It was a peaceful, enlightened people. It is when Prussia took the lead in Germany that It turned all Germany into a deadly threat for all its neighbours.

It is not by chance that, when Germany was rebuilt after WW2 and after reunification, the name of Prussia was dumped. There is no land of Prussia although Brandeburg or lower Saxony or north Rhineland-Westphalia were parts of the kingdom of Prussia. Prussian militarism and its colonialism directes against other european people were a curse for Germany ad well ad for the rest of Europe.
 
It is almost impossible to have Prussia not being the bas guy. Prussia intrisically was the bas guy, with its militaristes and colonialistic mindset.

Germany was not a problem in itself. It was a peaceful, enlightened people. It is when Prussia took the lead in Germany that It turned all Germany into a deadly threat for all its neighbours.

It is not by chance that, when Germany was rebuilt after WW2 and after reunification, the name of Prussia was dumped. There is no land of Prussia although Brandeburg or lower Saxony or north Rhineland-Westphalia were parts of the kingdom of Prussia. Prussian militarism and its colonialism directes against other european people were a curse for Germany ad well ad for the rest of Europe.
In WWI,there was no bad guy.
 
Last edited:
Germany won't be the "bad guy" if they win any world wars that occur. I could think of lots of way to paint France and Britain and especially Russia (either Tsarist or Soviet) as the bad guy in either World War (not that I necessarily believe them personally).
 
In WWI,there was no bad guy.

That's a point of view. Now ask the belgians, french, serbians, british, americans if there was no bas guy in WW1. And although that agree that It was necessary to come over and reconcile, and that their governments had their own faults, many of them have a different opinion.
 
Top