AHC: Pet Girls

Status
Not open for further replies.

Strawberry

Banned
Who knows? Maid service could potentially devolve into something akin to indentured servitude, and get worse from there. You might have a tradition of selling of second or third daughters to the highest bidder among poorer people, though this seems about as likely as Jonathan Swift's A Modest Proposal.

Jonathan Swift's proposal is more likely, frankly. Not to make this thread even more creepy than it already is, but cannabilism has been known in countries which have experienced famine, (eg, Ukraine).

Pet girls is not going to happen in a world with adult women present. Men have to sleep sometime, as Lorena Bobbit could tell you....
 
The worst part about A Modest Proposal is that a lot of people just don't seem to twig that it's satire. It makes a distressing amount of sense if you take it on its own terms (which was, of course, the point).

By "not necessarily wrong" I mean the practice might have a coherent reason, or set of reasons, behind it. In this particular case, that would seem not to be the case. I confess, I couldn't think of any, but that only proved I couldn't think of any.
 
Pet girls is not going to happen in a world with adult women present. Men have to sleep sometime, as Lorena Bobbit could tell you....
The Japanese used young girls as comfort women, and young girls are trafficked to this day. Though for this situation to apply to girls exclusively, that's probably not happening.
By "not necessarily wrong" I mean the practice might have a coherent reason, or set of reasons, behind it. In this particular case, that would seem not to be the case. I confess, I couldn't think of any, but that only proved I couldn't think of any.
By this logic, slavery is "not necessarily wrong". Uh, then again, what you propose kind of is slavery.
 

Strawberry

Banned
The Japanese used young girls as comfort women, and young girls are trafficked to this day. Though for this situation to apply to girls exclusively, that's probably not happening.

That's always been kept away from the women of the dominant class though. Pet girls being kept openly is not going to be tolerable to any female that has a voice.
 

Strawberry

Banned
The Japanese used young girls as comfort women, and young girls are trafficked to this day. Though for this situation to apply to girls exclusively, that's probably not happening.

By this logic, slavery is "not necessarily wrong". Uh, then again, what you propose kind of is slavery.

Kind of? I think the word you're looking for is literally.
 
The worst part about A Modest Proposal is that a lot of people just don't seem to twig that it's satire. It makes a distressing amount of sense if you take it on its own terms (which was, of course, the point).

By "not necessarily wrong" I mean the practice might have a coherent reason, or set of reasons, behind it. In this particular case, that would seem not to be the case. I confess, I couldn't think of any, but that only proved I couldn't think of any.

Having a coherent set of reasons behind it doesn't make it 'not necessarily wrong.' Ethnic cleansing, for instance, usually happens for a coherent set of reasons. There were also a coherent set of reasons (e.g. malaria) that led to the introduction of widespread African slavery in the Americas. Just because those coherent set of reasons existed doesn't make it 'not necessarily wrong.'
 
Kind of? I think the word you're looking for is literally.
Well, depending on how you interpret it, these "pets" aren't necessarily being forced to do any work. Though it's imprisonment against one's will at the very least. Also, what do you mean about women being outraged at men having pet girls? Do you mean they would become jealous?
 

Strawberry

Banned
Well, depending on how you interpret it, these "pets" aren't necessarily being forced to do any work. Though it's imprisonment against one's will at the very least. Also, what do you mean about women being outraged at men having pet girls? Do you mean they would become jealous?

Did you read the OP? In case you didn't, here it is...

The destination point in this challenge is a world superficially similar to our own, but in which men and (presumably less often) women of means (middle class or above) usually own pet girls, meaning teenage girls who are their legal property. I'm posting this here because I want to give as broad a range of PODs as I can, but I'm explicitly not looking for ASB scenarios.

Explain to me how one person being the legal property of another is only kind of slavery.
 
As a longtime lurker, this has to be the strangest thread I have ever seen.

Seriously, what sort of motivation would cause someone to even think about a world where teenage girls are treated like animals?
 
As a longtime lurker, this has to be the strangest thread I have ever seen.

Seriously, what sort of motivation would cause someone to even think about a world where teenage girls are treated like animals?

I think what would be funnier would be a world where animals were treated like teenaged girls. "Yeah, I've been trying to spend quality time with my cat, but all he does is sit around and text funny-human videos to his friends." "You've got it easy. My guinea pig borrows my car without asking, and when she returns it, there's never any gas in the tank!" :D
 

Strawberry

Banned
As a longtime lurker, this has to be the strangest thread I have ever seen.

Seriously, what sort of motivation would cause someone to even think about a world where teenage girls are treated like animals?

Thank you, I was beginning to think I was the only one. Creepy, misogynistic OP, made all the more so that he doesn't even call these underage girl slaves as slaves, but pets.

Its possible, of course, to own people as slaves, but its not possible to keep people as pets.
 
I think what would be funnier would be a world where animals were treated like teenaged girls. "Yeah, I've been trying to spend quality time with my cat, but all he does is sit around and text funny-human videos to his friends." "You've got it easy. My guinea pig borrows my car without asking, and when she returns it, there's never any gas in the tank!" :D

:D And that car must have really interesting controls.
 
Thank you, I was beginning to think I was the only one. Creepy, misogynistic OP, made all the more so that he doesn't even call these underage girl slaves as slaves, but pets.

Its possible, of course, to own people as slaves, but its not possible to keep people as pets.

I'd say it's a troll, but this is too detailed to be a troll.
 
Thank you, I was beginning to think I was the only one. Creepy, misogynistic OP, made all the more so that he doesn't even call these underage girl slaves as slaves, but pets.

Its possible, of course, to own people as slaves, but its not possible to keep people as pets.

I used to have human pet inside a tamagotchi when I was still ten years old... :D Chinese made tamagotchi who replace a dinosaur with a human baby (the case is obviously shaped like dinosaur egg)... still in good condition and yes, if I remember that again, that was quite creepy..
 

NothingNow

Banned
Its possible, of course, to own people as slaves, but its not possible to keep people as pets.

It would be possible, but by then, you're either talking about consensual fetishistic sex practices, or you've ventured so far down the dehumanization rabbit trail that there's no reason to do it save as a theoretical status symbol.

At least you can have slaves do something useful.
 

Strawberry

Banned
You're probably wise people to turn this thread into a massive piss take. The alternative is a thread which would end up being very popular among people searching for kiddie porn.
 

CalBear

Moderator
Donor
Monthly Donor
The destination point in this challenge is a world superficially similar to our own, but in which men and (presumably less often) women of means (middle class or above) usually own pet girls, meaning teenage girls who are their legal property. I'm posting this here because I want to give as broad a range of PODs as I can, but I'm explicitly not looking for ASB scenarios.
What the...

Have you utterly lost your mind?

I going to kick you for now, mainly because I don't entirely trust my judgement at the moment because I find this so reprehensible that it defies ready description.

Good God!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top