AHC: Permanent split in the Catholic Church post-1800

How can you split the Catholic church, on a permanent basis, after 1800, so that two (or more) separate churches exist?
 

Art

Monthly Donor
But the Roman Catholic Church. . .

Is split in 1054, from the Greek, Russian, and Bulgarian Orthodox Churches. . .
 
It happened IOTL: it's called the "Union of Utrecht" or "Union of Old Catholic Churches", and the split happened after Vatican I mostly on the issue of papal infallibility (there are other doctrinal issues). The official date for the slit is 1889. The UU is not in communion with Rome, but is in communion with the Anglican Church. Their approach is much more liberal than the Roman church's (celibacy is optional, women have been ordained and same-sex unions are blessed in church) and obviously they believe that the church doctrine should only be decided by church councils.

The UU is (sadly) quite small nowadays (the faithfuls are estimated to be around 90,000). It would be however possible to change things: there was serious opposition to the doctrine of papal infallibility in 1869 (mainly spearheaded by German theologians but also supported by major figures in the Italian church, including the archbishop of Bologna. A number of priests and bishops). Let's assume that dissent is a bit stronger and the council becomes polarized, so that there is no vote on papal infallibility. When Italy takes Rome in September 1870, Pius IX decides to leave the city (the possibility was discussed IOTL) and call the second round of Vatican I in France or Spain (OTL there were proposals to call a second round either in Trento or in Malta but both the British and the Austrians were very much against it). The second round will result in a stronger declaration of papal infallibility (with excommunications raining around) but the result of a deep and acrimonious split of the church will be there for anyone to see. ITTL the "Old Catholics" will be supported by national governments (certainly in Italy and in Germany, where Bismarck will see an opportunity for his idea of kulturkampf. Note that the doctrine of papal infallibility was not well received in Austria either, where the government wanted to keep a firm hold on the church). This will not happen immediately, but over the years I believe that there is a very good chance for the Old Catholics to become very well established and their numbers a century later might be really impressive.
 
Ecclesia Dei!

As noted the above post, there is a good chance in the Council Vatican II , if the division that happened in OTL, between the Ultramontanes, traditionalists who rejected the "modernity" from C.V. II and Rome.

If the Pope Benedict XVI did not lift the excommunication of the four consecrated bishops in defiance of Rome and followers of Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, who was appointed by the Pope John Paul II, more of two decades ago with a fulminated excommunication.

Which with their congregations and other from similar thinking, they formed the Ecclesia Dei...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecclesia_Dei#Followers_of_Archbishop_Lefebvre

http://w2.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/motu_proprio/documents/hf_jp-ii_motu-proprio_02071988_ecclesia-dei.html

If despite their relatively small numbers and influence ,in Otl, can obtain the explicit support of a national or regional authority, to influence their citizens to defy Rome and prevent implementation of the reforms, perhaps their influence and number of worshipers could increase.
 
Top