10.52 More Tactical changes from Keith Park as Goering Blusters
  • 10.52. More Tactical changes from Kieth Park as Goering Blusters.

    October 17th.


    Day. Fighter-bomber attacks on Kent and London.

    Night. Targets in No11 Group Area. Liverpool and Birmingham.

    Weather. Bright Intervals. Local showers (1)



    Once again today there was poor visibility in the morning however this did little to curtail the Luftwaffe operations that commence early. The coastal towns of Broadstairs and Margate were attacked by a force of around ninety bomb carrying Me 109’s and Me 110’s. Part of this force pressed on inland to drop their bombs on Stanmore in north east London. Whether the Fighter Command HQ at Bentley Priory was their intended target could not at the time be ascertained.

    The Afternoon attacks saw the Luftwaffe employing the full gambit of tactical variations with their fighter bombers. Some aircraft came in singularly, others in gaggles while another attack might be by a stream of aircraft on the same route. Some groups would fragment and then re-join, others were feints and turned back early. Some flew low weaving courses, others at mid altitudes, while still more crossed the channel at high altitude. All of these variations were intended to confuse and disrupt the defence as much as possible. In this the Luftwaffe was partially successful with the single most successful attack of the day being om Waterloo station where the automatic signal box was hit and put out of action. Despite these efforts Fighter Command pilots shot down fifteen enemy aircraft for the loss of three aircraft from which one pilot survived.

    Night attacks by the main Luftwaffe bomber force were split the cities of Liverpool and Birmingham as well as several airfields in Eleven Group. Once again the night fighter force was engaged on two very different kind of sorties. Those defending the airfields in Eleven Group had very little time to catch up with, identify and then engage the enemy. Whilst those night fighters tracking the enemy formations attacking Liverpool and Birmingham had to be vectored within RDF range of an aircraft within the bomber formation and then close in and engage it without being seen by any of the other bombers. To further complicate this chase the Night fighters in most cases had to be passed from one GCI controller to another as the raid travelled towards it’s target and back.

    As pilots and Controllers gained more and more experience this process was getting honed to a fine art. The continued expansion of the RDF network and the night fighter force however meant that not everybody was as yet as skilled as the High Command would wish.

    Once again from his Headquarters at Uxbridge Keith Park today issued another detailed set of instructions to all his Controllers and Squadron Commanders in his quest to master the attacks by the Luftwaffe as their tactics evolved and changed.



    THE ENGAGEMENT OF HIGH FIGHTER RAIDS

    The general plan is to get one or two Spitfire squadrons to engage the enemy fighters from above about mid-Kent, in order to cover other Spitfire, Defiant and Hurricane squadrons whilst climbing to operating hight at back patrol lines east and south east of London.

    Preparation

    Whenever the cloud conditions are favourable for high raids by fighters the following preparations will be made;

    1) Reconnaissance Aircraft: One or two reconnaissance aircraft to be kept on patrol near the Kent coast, height depending on the cloud layers.
    2) Readiness Patrol: A patrol by one or two squadrons to be maintained on Maidstone line at 15,000 feet, between 0800 hours and 1800 hours.
    3) Stand-by Squadron: One squadron at sector providing patrol at (2) to be standing-by during the peak periods- breakfast, noon and tea-time,
    4) London and Debden Squadrons: State of readiness of Hurricane and Defiant Squadrons to be advanced state whenever cloud conditions are suitable for very high fighters raids.
    Attack

    Immediately enemy formations are plotted over the French coast or Dover Straits, the following action will be initiated:

    1) Reconnaissance Aircraft: Dispatched to the area under GCI control to the area enemy raids are plotted, to locate, shadow and report numbers and type of enemy aircraft and if bombs are being carried.
    • Readiness Patrol: Ordered to climb to 3,000 feet on the Maidstone patrol line to cover other squadrons whilst climbing over base patrol lines.
    • Stand-by Squadrons: Despatched to operating hights over base and then to join the readiness squadrons at 30,000 feet.
    • Readiness Squadrons : Despatched to rendezvous over base at 20,000 to 27,000 feet, and when assembled, detailed to raids.
    • Squadrons at Available: Spitfires : to be brought to readiness, and if necessary despatched to assemble in pairs on back patrol lines at 25,000 to 30,000 feet, and the detailed to raids.
    • Squadrons of available : Hurricanes: brought to readiness, and if there is a second or third wave, assembled in pairs over back patrol lines so as to protect sector aerodromes and London area whilst climbing.
    • Hurricane Squadrons from Tangmere, Debden and Duxford: Despatched in wings or pairs at 20,000 to 27,000 feet according to time and weather conditions, of one of the following purposes:
    • To reinforce London sectors if there is a second or third wave of enemy raids:
    • To protect sector aerodromes and London area whilst the earlier squadrons are refuelling and rearming.
    • Close protection of important bombing objectives: If enemy raids are approaching aircraft factories, London area, sector aerodromes, etc, single Defiant squadrons if not assigned to pairs or wings should be detailed to protective patrols between 15,000 and 18,000 feet depending on clouds.
    Where enemy formations consisted of bombers escorted by fighters. The enemy formation is to be engaged in the following manner. The high fighter screen with Spitfire squadrons from Hornchurch and Biggin Hill half-way between London and the coast, ang so enable Hurricane and Defiant squadrons from North Weald, Kenley, and Northolt. To attack bomber formations plus close escort before they reach the line of fighter aerodromes east and south of London.

    The squadrons from Debden, Duxford and Tangmere (if disengaged) to be despatched and employed in wings or pairs so as to form a screen east and south-east of London to intercept third or fourth wave coming inland, also the retreating earlier waves.

    Spitfire Squadrons:

    Assembled at height in pairs on the back patrol lines, then detailed to engage high fighter screen at 30,000 feet.

    Role: To protect pairs or wings of Hurricane and Defiant squadrons whilst climbing up, also while attacking bombers plus escort. If the high fighter screen withdraws to the coast a proportion of the Spitfires may be detailed to attack the escorts to incoming bomb raids.

    Hurricane and Defiant Squadrons:

    Squadrons at readiness to be dispatched in pairs to back patrol lines covering line od aerodromes. Immediately pairs have reached operating hight, detail to bomb raids or to forward patrol line under Spitfires. Squadrons at available to be brought to readiness and assembled in pairs at operating height on back patrol lines covering sector aerodromes, and detailed to second wave of bomb raids.

    Whist gaining height the latter squadrons may have to be detailed to split raids by bombers that attempt to attack vital points on the flank of the mass of bombers plus escort.

    Hurricane and Defiant Squadrons from Flank sectors (Debden, Duxford, Tangmere and possibly Northolt):

    Dispatch in pairs or wings according to clouds to patrol mid-Kent patrol lines at 20’000 to 25,000 feet to engage:

    • Third or fourth wave attacks of bombers plus escort;
    • Retreating bomb raids of first or second waves;
    • To protect fighter aerodromes whilst the earlier Hurricane, Defiant and Spitfire squadrons are being rearmed and refuelled.
    Reinforcements from other Groups:

    Immediately the enemy numbers appear to be more than 150, request two to three squadrons to cover the northern approaches to London, or the south-western group of vital points near London, as directed in Controllers’ Instruction No 7, dated August 27th 1940. (2)



    Sir Hugh Dowding on receiving a copy of the latest instructions issued by Keith Park from Eleven Group had gone down into the Bentley Priory underground command bunker and from his lofty seat in the gallery perused the large plotting table below. Reading through the instructions he visualised the approaching attacks and the counter moves as laid out in the new instructions. Having already discussed the new instructions with Keith Park the night before this was simply an exercise in ensure that their were no glaring holes in the arrangements that had been missed by them and their staffs. From his desk he than phoned in turn the AOC Ten and Twelve Group to receive their comments as to how they would integrate the requested support into their own operational structure.

    Just before leaving the gallery Sir Hugh took a telephone call from Sir Phillip at the AM. Sir Phillip had called to voice his concern at the extraordinarily long hours Sir Hugh was working. For currently Sir Hugh was present in his HQ at all hours as he fought both the day battle and the night assault at the same time. Sir Phillip asked Sir Hugh when he had last spent an entire night at his house down in Stanmore, The reply was not within the last week. Sir Phillip then remind Sir Hugh that it would be a disservice to the nation and the RAF if he worked himself to a state of total collapse. Sir Phillip also stated that he and the Prime Minister were appreciative of the need to contain the night attacks, doing so was not worth the loss of Sir Hugh. Sir Phillip continued by saying that despite the intensity and difficulties of the daylight raids Keith Parks and the other Group Commanders were coping. Therefore if Sir Hugh was going to spend all his nights at his HQ trying to improve the night defence then perhaps he should trust his staff to manage the day to day running of his command and get some rest. That was about as close to an order as a minister could give to a serving officer under the circumstances.

    1. Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster
    2. Adapted from the instructions issued by Keith Park on this day OTL.


    October 18th.

    Day. Relatively quiet.

    Night. Raids on a reduced scale.

    Weather. Fog in Straits of Dover and Estuary; also in North Sea. Visibility poor. (1)

    Despite the relatively high level of bomber activity overnight the morning proved much queiter. The bulk of the days activity comprised high altitude incursion over East Anglia in mid-afternoon. To counter the thirty five separate raids the RAF Fighter Command mounted forty-five fighter patrols. Throughout the day the total losses to the Luftwaffe totalled nineteen machines for the lost of four British fighters.

    It would appear that the Luftwaffe wanted an early night for the last bomber cleared the RDF screen at the very early time of two Am. With only one hundred and sixty bombers recorded as crossing the coast the level of assault was one of the lowest for several weeks. For their efforts tonight in which they lost eight bombers to all causes and their earlier raids, Goering when addressing his forces on this day claimed on their behalf that:

    ‘In the past few days and nights (Goering said) you have caused the British world enemy disastrous losses by your uninterrupted destructive blows. Your indefatigable, courageous attacks on the heart of the British Empire, the City of London, with its eight and a half million inhabitants, have reduced British plutocracy to fear and terror. The losses which you have inflicted engagements are irreplaceable.’ (2)

    Whether the Luftwaffe Fighter pilots and the bomber crews who daily faced combat against the RAF agreed with Goering’s pronouncements were never recorded.

    1. Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster
    2. As OTL, published at the time.
     
    10.53 The Germans Keep Coming by day and by night
  • 10.53 The Germans keep coming by and by night.

    October 19th


    Day, Isolated patrols and reconnaissance.

    Night. London, Liverpool, midlands and Bristol main targets.

    Weather. Cloudy in Channel, mist in Northern France clearing later. (1)

    After another quite morning due to the weather but with conditions improving a large formation of Me 109’s gathered over the Pas de Calais before heading for Kent. In the prevailing conditions interceptions were difficult and most were fairly inconclusive as the German fighters dove for the cloud cover when intercepted. By the end of the day the RAF claimed seven fighters for the loss of two of their own fighters.

    The night fighters also faced trying conditions in their efforts to intercept the enemy bombers but success were recorded.

    (1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster


    October 20th

    Day, Fighter-bomber raids on south-east and London.

    Night, Heavy attacks on London and industrial centre in the midlands.

    Weather. Mainly cloudy in most districts. Channel and Straits cloudy, Hazy.

    Due to the weather the first of five waves of fighter bombers did not appear on the RDF screens till almost ten Am. In what was now becoming a well rehearsed and choreographed aerial ballet RAF squadrons rose into the sky to oppose the intruders. A total of almost five hundred sorties were flown, resulting in sixteen enemy aircraft destroyed for the lost of four RSF fighters.

    Whereas the day had been relatively quite the night time sky was in real terms as busy as ever. Three hundred bombers attacked London over night once again doing serious damage to the cities railway system. Further afield Coventry was bombed with Armstrong-Siddley being amongst the factories damaged. Whilst bombers were destroyed by both night fighters and guns the numbers were not sufficient to deter the Luftwaffe. However the attrition was steady and as more night fighter squadrons became operational the losses would mount.

    (1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster


    October 21st

    Day, Sporadic raids on capitol. Liverpool and West Country.

    Night, London, Wolverhampton, Coventry, Birmingham and Liverpool main targets.

    Weather. Mainly cloudy with fog and intermittent rai. Visibility poor.

    Making the best of the poor weather to day the Luftwaffe despatched multiple single raiders across the country, Whilst most attack were on London Me 110’s carrying bombs were used to attack targets in the West country and as far north as Liverpool. Large formations pf defensive fighters were not practical in the prevailing conditions so most interception were carried out by flights of four fighters under GCI control. For no loss to themselves the RAF fighters manged to shoot down ten of the daylight raiders.

    Night time targets were Liverpool, the midlands and London. Flying conditions again were not conducive to successful night time interceptions and the London gun zone was again given permission to fire at unseen targets by RDF prediction. If nothing else the sound of the guns gave Londoners some sense that they were being defended.

    • Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster


    October 22nd

    Day. Quiet morning and afternoon.

    Nigh, London, Coventry and Liverpool main targets.

    Weather. Widespread fog in the south, clearing to rain later. Visibility poor. (1)



    Poor weather curtailed almost all operations in the south-east of England. In Eleven Group only the stations in the west at Tangmere, Kenley and Biggin Hill were able to launch aircraft. As the fog cleared in the early afternoon to be replaced by drizzle and rain, some activity was recorded by the RDF stations of a raid building over France. The plots firmed up into three raids of thirty aircraft each and raids on Kent and London were expected, in line with the latest instructions of the AOC Eleven Group the controllers at Uxbridge brought squadrons forward and ready squadrons scrambled for height on designated patrol limes. There were no raids towards London instead the there formations headed for a convoy in the Dover straits and a departing east coast convoy in the Thames Estuary. The standing Patrol got to the convoy in the straits just in time to disrupt the attack and a readiness squadron from Hornchurch got to the Thames Estuary and by attacking without the advantage of hight managed to break up that attack as well.

    (1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster


    October 23rd.

    Day. Mainly reconnaissance.

    Night. London and Glasgow raided. Minelayer off Yorkshire coast.

    Weather. Low cloud and drizzle. Visibility poor. (1)



    The day was the quietest so far during the campaign with only ninety sorties flown in daylight hours.

    Most of the RAF’s six losses in the day were due to landing and take off accidents in the poor conditions. No pilots were killed but one was seriously injured. For the Luftwaffe it was a little worse they lost one aircraft in combat, two more crashed on landing due to battle damage and a further four aircraft were written of in various accidental ways.

    The night attacks were concentrated on London and the free fire policy for the anti-aircraft within the London gun areas. Though some kills were claimed by both guns and the few night fighters that did sortie in the conditions, none were confirmed by wrecks or other evidence. Further north in Scotland an attack was mounted from Luftwaffe bases near Stavanger on the port of Glasgow. With better flying conditions the night fighters managed to score two confirmed kills and in a rare success one bomber was brought down by barrage baloon.

    (1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster


    October 24th

    Day, Very quite.

    Night. London and Birmingham main targets.

    Weather. Overcast and hazy in Channel, clearing to starlit sky at night. (1)

    Another day of low activity due to the inclement weather. Enemy probing reconnaissance patrols kept the standby squadrons busy as due to the conditions standing patrols were not practical. Today also illustrated how far the GCI system had come and how the daylight fighter squadrons were getting proficient in making intercepts under their control. In this case an intruder was detected by the CH RDF station at Holy Cross in East Anglia, this contact was passed to the GCI station at Neatishead, The sector controller at Coltishall had scrambled a fight of fighters to intercept and handed them of to the controller at Neatishead GCI to make the interception. As the intruder headed for the Midlands, control was passed to Langtoft GCI and then onto Boarsecrofte GCI near Bedford as the raider turned south and was finally shot down hear St Neots in Huntingdonshire. In the afternoon there were series of nuisance raids which kept the eastern squadrons busy with a total of almost five hundred sorties flown. In total the Luftwaffe lost eight aircraft through the day without loss to the RAF.

    Through the night London was attacked by fifty bombers whilst another seventy attacked other cities, principally Birmingham. A number of the attackers were intercepted and shot down by the night fighters. One enemy bomber was seen to crash in flames into the of Beachy Head.

    • Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster


    October 25th.

    Day. Fighter-bomber raids on Kent and London.

    Night, Italian Air Force raids Harwich.

    Weather, Fair but overcast. (1)

    Early attacks this morning by formations of Do 17’s were met and repulsed by squadron strength formations of fighters. The only result of these raids for the Luftwaffe was to once again indicreminetly spray their bomb loads over the countryside, villages and occasionally the towns of Kent. These sparodic raids continued through the daylight hours and Fighter Command flew over nine hundred sorties, shooting down twenty five enemy aircraft for the loss of ten. Five pilots from the downed RAF fighters were safely recovered.

    One notable occurrence on this day was the first raid on the UK by the Itallian airforce. Sixteen BR.20S took off as night fell. Their target was the harbour at Harwich. As an entry into the conflict this was not an auspicious one, as one bomber crashed on take off and another two ditched due to running out of fuel!

    (1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster
     
    10.54 Enemies - Domestic and Foreign
  • 10.54, Enemies Domestic and Foreign

    October 26th.


    Day, Fighter-bomber raids on London and Kent.

    Night. Targets in London, the midlands, Manchester and Liverpool.

    Weather. Cloudy with local showers chiefly in the north and east. Bright intervals in the west. Channel hazy. Cool. (1).



    No Large daylight attacks today just a continuous stream of incursions by fighter bombers with escorts. By ten in the morning the raids were almost continuous in an obvious attempt to overwhelm the defensive formations. The dispositions by Park and the co-operation of both Ten and Twelve group managed to prevent any gaps in the fighter cover and no intrusion went un-opposed. This was however very hard on the RAF pilots and their aircraft as the duty squadrons were often only on the ground long enough to refuel and if they needed to rearm before once more taking off for their next interception. Once again bombs did fall on London and its suburbs with the counties of Surry, Sussex and Kent suffering their now normal crop of scattered bomb fall. In the shortening day light hours Fighter Command again flew over eight hundred sorties, inflicting a dozen losses on the Luftwaffe for the loss of two fighters and a single pilot.

    As night fell the night fighter crews girded their loins for a long night chasing maggots. Though the numbers were small each night, now the night fighter defense was exacting a steady toll from the Luftwaffe bombers. In Fighter Command no one was sure exactly how much damage they were inflicting on the German bomber force or what rate of casualties that force could sustain. Whilst German propaganda was making much of the damage and destruction they were inflicting, particularly on London the very influential paper, The New York Herald Tribune, ventured the following opinion about the effectiveness of the German night attacks:

    ‘ What appears to be happening ,’ it said, ‘is that the Germans have found the defenses too strong for their daylight attack, permitting accurate fire, and so are putting their effort into night attack. . . But against a people with courage it is unlikely to prove fruitful . . . and the is no doubt of British courage.’ (2)

    Both Sir Hugh and Sir Peter read copies of this commentary with interest and discussed whether the American reporter was mistaking stoicism with courage! Sir Hugh added that such traits were not unique to the British people and that indiscriminate bombing of German cities just for the sake of hitting back would have little or no impact on the Nazis ability to wage war. Sir Hugh ventured the opinion that for Bomber Command to have any real impact on the conflict it had to have the capability to attack important targets and destroy them. Whilst attending a meeting with the Prime Minister over the effectiveness of the German night attacks Sir Hugh took the opportunity to make the observation that half a dozen German bombs hitting the Power Station's a Bank, Battersea and Chelsea had caused far more disruption to war production and commerce than thousands of bombs falling on the terraced slums of the East End of London and it’s docks. Factories with their roof’s blown off and wall blackened by fire were up and running again in a matter of days or relocated to improvised premises. Sir Hugh had concluded that one of his most important tasks on taking up the post of CAS was to ensure that Bomber Command was capable of actually doing real damage to the German war machine. Churchill’s some what gruff response had been basically a suggestion that he “bloody well got on with it then.” So it was formally decided that whatever the state of Luftwaffe bombing activity Sir Hugh would step aside as AOC Fighter Command and that that the date of November the first was set for Sir Hugh Casswell Tremenheere Dowding to assume control of his beloved RAF.



    October 27th.
    Day, Mainly fighter and fighter-bomber sweeps.

    Night, Widespread raids with London the principle target.

    Weather cloudy all day except for a fair period in late morning. (1)



    With the weather forecast to deteriorate as the day went on the Luftwaffe were quick off the mark this morning with fighter sweeps and fighter-bomber attacks commencing before eight o’clock. This was another major effort by the fighter forces of the two Luftflotten who’s fighters had the range to reach targets in the southern counties with formations of up to fifty aircraft making coordinated attacks. By nine in the morning bombs had fallen on the docks and eastern London suburb but only in isolated and small numbers. These attacks continued throughout the day with Eleven group as usual bearing the brunt of the action. Once again the flexibility of the ‘Dowding system’ came to the fore and Eleven group were never over pressed as the neighboring Groups responded to the threat. Late in the afternoon this system of mutual support was reciprocated when fighter bomber raids attacked East Anglia and Southampton simultaneously . Twelve group countered the attack east Anglia and number ten group defended Southampton. The attack on London intended to keep Eleven Group Occupied was easily contained by aircraft from Biggin Hill and Kenley, This allowed the Eleven Group controls to use the Tangmere wing to reinforce Ten Groups defense of Southampton and the PAC from Duxford and Debden were vectored to block the retreat of the formations attacking targets in East Anglia.

    In todays daylight confrontation Fighter Command once more flew more than one thousand sorties. Despite the elusive nature of the Luftwaffe attacks the RAF destroyed twenty enemy intruders for the loss of ten of their own aircraft. Importantly only three RAF pilots were killed and of the seven others no less than five were ready to fly again in the morning.

    The night saw the continuation of the attacks on London but also saw attacks on Liverpool and Bristol. These attacks required the Luftwaffe Bombers to fly further through defended skies than the attacks on London and this gave the night fighters more time to intercept and engage the enemy. This was being observed in the statistical analysis of night fighter actions. Also these longer raids gave Eighty Group more opportunity to gather intelligence on the electronic navigation, communication and targeting system being used by the Luftwaffe. Every night aircraft from Eighty group as well as ground stations were listening and recoding the details of the electromagnetic signatures of the Luftwaffe. All this data was being used by the RAF and the scientists to design equipment and formulate stratagems to counter them.

    The reasons for there being a Ministry of Aircraft production was to a large extent a matter of public perception. The MAP was supposedly a separate entity from the AM and the RAF which was therefore meant to be able to organize aircraft and aero engine production without bias. The fear in government had been that if the aircraft production industry remained the fiefdom of the AM/RAF then supporters of the Navy and the FAA would always accuse the government that the Navy had been given second rate aircraft and had to fight for everyone they got. To some degree the high level of cooperation between the AM and the Admiralty on all things aviation laid the lies to any such accusations, whatever the perceived rivalries between RAF and the FAA. This arrangement meant that much depended on the relationship between the two Ministers, Sir Archibald Sinclair of the Liberal party was a political weather vane who tended to listen to the loudest voice in his ear. Sir Phillip made very sure that it was his voice in Sir Archibald’s ear that was heard more than any other.

    Ensuring that the MAP were making the aircraft that the FAA and the RAF needed was a joint endeavor and here the RAF’s Director General for Research in the Air Ministry and latterly head of the MAP Sir Wilfred Freeman had up until June 1939 been a pivotal figure. Persuading Sir Wilfred to stay on as Sir Archibald’s deputy and advisor at the Air Member for development and Production had been a priority for Sir Phillip. Here Sir Phillip counted his blessings that Wilfred Freeman was a most capable officer and a real asset in his dealings with the aircraft manufacturing companies and their relationship with the MAP as he understood their strengths and weaknesses as well as personally having got to know all the principal personalities since 1936. With Archibald Sinclair acting as the political figurehead of the MAP, Sir Phillip saw Sir Wilfred Freeman as a vital link and his liaison with industry which had become even more important with the establishment of the MAP. As the year wore on Sir Phillip was becoming more confident that between them, he and Sir Wilfred now had the measure of Sir Archibald Sinclair as Minister for Aircraft Production and that the political interference in the wartime aircraft production could be contained. As for the Ministry of supply that was another matter entirely and Sir Phillip found it a continuous struggle in his dealings with the various department within this most Byzantine of Ministries.

    Building a new working relationship between Dowding as the new CAS and the Ministry of Supply was going to be a task that would tax even Sir Philips diplomatic skills. Sir Hugh’s criticism of the Ministry of Supply regarding the delays and deficiencies in getting the all weather concrete runways for Fighter Commands airfields were legendry within the AM. As for the building of the underground control room at Bentley Priory the less said about the Ministry of Supply within earshot of Sir Hugh the better. Sir Phillip himself had had issue with the MoS, particularly over Iceland however he was very careful hold his temper and use ‘Whitehall diplomacy’ whenever necessary. There were plenty of other place keepers in white hall to keep Sir Phillip busy smoothing the road for the AM so to speak and rather to many of these obstructionist were actually still working in building as Sir Phillip.







    The committee the scientific survey of air offence had sent a request to the AM for access to all the records and analysis of the RDF night defense system since large scale attacks on British targets had commenced. Though some civil servants had queried the need for this as Fighter Command were already analyzing and studying the nightly results in all its minutia in attempts to improve the effectiveness of the night fighter defense system. One Whitehall Warrior who flew nothing more than a ‘mahogany bomber’ actually sent a memo back saying that this information had nothing to do with Bomber Command and anyway was restricted. Unbelievably to some it took the raising of this matter by Tizard at one of his regular briefings with Sir Phillip to get the information released. The C.S.S.O.A.O wanted to analyze the data themselves to see what lessons could be learnt as to when RDF was as it’s most ineffective as this would help to inform Bomber Command tactics when they eventually faced an organized RDF defense by the Luftwaffe. Another sub committee of the CSSOAO, was busy studying the effect of Luftwaffe bombing on the UK. This examination was looking at what damage was caused, what sizes and type of weapon caused the damage. How disruptive to war production was the damage? How easily was it repaired? By examining and understanding these criteria the committee were hoping to come up with bomb load and targeting proposals that would maximize the effectiveness of attacks by Bomber Command on German targets. Even though the night raids had only been going on for a relatively short time the committee were convinced that they had already found out some important factors regarding the effectiveness of night bombing and had started to analyze this against the data accrued over the summer regarding the daylight raids carried out by the Luftwaffe.



    (1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster
    (2) Quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster and other sources.
     
    10.55 The numbers tell the story and the defence stays strong
  • 10.55 The numbers tell the story and the defence stays strong

    October 28th


    Day, Convoy off Dover and shipping in Estuary attacked. London the main afternoon target.

    Night, Widespread attacks throughout the country.

    Weather. Misty in northern France. Fog over the Estuary and Straits, clearing later. Cloudy (1)



    The misty start to the day in northern France reduced the german morning activity to raids by single aircraft attacking coastal targets and shipping. The afternoon saw another major effort by the Luftwaffe withraids of forty and twenty aircraft raiding kent in quick succession and being duly repulsed by the duty squadrons of Eleven Group. Following this at four thirty in the afternoon another raid consisting of fifty aircraft consisting of a mix of fighters and fighter bombers attacked Folksstone whilst a portion of the raid hrade inland towards London. Intercepted and attacked by squafron sized formations in quick succession this incursion was again repulsed.

    Hoping to exploit any gaps in the defences caused by theis attack follow up raids totaling over an additional one hundred aircraft attempted to reach London. By rotating squadrons the controllers in Eleven Group always managed to have sufficient fully armed and fuels aircraft at altitude to intercept these raids. One again the contious RDF coverage afforded by the PPI stations showed their worth, as unless the intruders decended to tree top hight they could be tracked comtinously and the RDF operator and controllers were by now well practiced in their roles.

    As darkness fell the RAF tallies indicated a quieter day with a sortie number only in the mid six hundreds but a favourable score of thirteen enemy aircraft detroyed for the loss of two RAF aircraft and the death of a single pilot.

    Night time saw further attacks on London and the south east. Whilst the AI equipped night fighters were achieving a steady stream of success, a new tactic was tried by two reaper squadrons, these were 137 in Twelve Group and 263 in Ten Group. This new tactic consisted of sending standing patrols of the longer range reaper fighters to loiter around beacxons on the edge of the gun zones of major cities where if enemy bombers were coned by the search lights they could pounce and attack. It meant risking fighters within the gun zones but that was a rik the volunteer pilots were willing to take. Tonight a reaper fron 263 squadron based at Filton managed to intercept and shoot down a bomber over Bristol and in a separate incedent another reaper from 137 sqhadron of Twelve Group based at Wittering succeeded in shooting down an enemy bomber coned by the lights around the ROF, At Enfield.

    (1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster


    October 29th.

    Day, London and Southampton Main targets.

    Night, Heavy raids on the capitol and midlands.

    Weather, Channel overcast . Haze in northern France and Dover straits. Winds southerly. (1)

    Again today seemed to be making a major effort despite the haze in northern France hampering operations from bases there. The opening gambit was an attack towards London by a forec of some forty german fighters. Intercepted by multiple RAF squadrons over Kent a hanful of bomb carrying fighters manged to reach central London and drop their boms but then had to run the gauntlet of vengeful fighters to regain the safety of occupied France. Just after noon a further large incursion was received by a text book interception arranged by the controllers of Eleven Group. As this raid headed across Kent a duty squadron at altitude from Hornchurch was vectored to intercept. Whilst a further squadron on standby at Hornchurch was scrambled to gain altitude, A duty squadron from Kenley was vectored to make a climbing attack on the approaching raid whilst a further standby squadron from Biggin Hill was srambled to gain hight to the south of the raid track. All four squadrons were flying Spitfires which eased the complexity of co-ordinating their interceptions. So it came to pass that the enemy raid found themselves confronted by a 602 squadron from Hornchurch diving from altitude even as they were concentrating on repulsing the attack of the climbing 64 squadron from Kenley . realising that they were fighting at a disadvantage the enemy sought to break contact before Biggin Hill’s 603 squadron coming from the south and Hornchutch’s 74 squadron coming from the east completely blocked their line of withdrawl. Using the now familiar finger four formation and fighting in pairs the intial bounce by 602 squadron resulted in four Me 109’s falling to their cannon fire. The climbing attack by 64 squadron pinned the enemy fighters in a dogfight at odds, that saw a further two Me 109’s shot down. Having regained the altitude advantage 602 squadron commenced a diving chase as the enemy broke for the coast, this hasty retreat saw a further four Me109’s fall to the guns of 602 squadron, these four aircraft all crashed into the channel before 602 had to break off the chase due to the proximity of the French coast, lack of fuel and the exhausting of their ammunition. The Air Sea rescue services and Folkstone life boat recoverd two of these Luftwaffe pilots alive and the body of a third.

    This was not the only excitement of the afternoon even as this ariel battle was in progress further to the west, Luftflotte Three were taking the opertunity of what they thought would be the ditraction of the defence to the attack on London to make a concerted assault on Portsmouth consisting of a main group of some fifty aircraft and a second wave of a futher twelve machines. Ten Group responded by scrambling the entire Middle Wallop wing of three Hurricane Squadrons and calling in 263 squadron in their Reaper fighters from patrol over their base at Filton. Eleven Group also vectored 43 and 145 Hurricane squadrons from Westhampnet and Tangmere.

    Whilst the Ten Group controllers and the GCI/PPI station at Sopely concentrated in getting the Middle Wallop fighters into an advatageuos interception, the GCI station at Cricklade controlled the Reapers as thye came in at high altitude from the north west. Meanwhile the Tangmere sector controller was vectoring his two squadrons to swing around to the south west behind the approaching raids where they would have the advantage of attacking out of the afternoon sun. Sir Phillip visiting Fighter Command at Bentley Priory had a ringside seat for the afternoons deadly ariel ballet and was again impressed with the calmness of all around him as no less than three major engagements took place over southern England almost simultainiously. Here was the Dowding system living upto to the high expectations of its creators and it was a wonder to behold. Faced by a whole wing of Huricanes diving on them from the north the Luftflotte Three aircraft unceromonously jettesoned their bombs into the Solent, Spithead and in a few unfortunate cases onto the Isle of Wight. As they turned south to make their escape the tardy ones were bounced by the Eleven Group fighters even as the diving Reapers from Filton chased any stragglers across the channel towards the airfields of Normandy and the Cotlin Peninsular.

    Frustrated, the Middle Wallop wing could do little but loiter for a time before returning to their airfield. However even if they had not actually managed to intercept this raid, they had been effective in thwarting it, in its purpose as not a single bomd fell on Portmouth.

    What of the third attack, about as far east in Kent as you can get the Regia Aeronautica were mounting their first daylight raid on the harbour and town of Ramsgate. This raid consisted of fifteen BR20 twin engine bombers with an escort of seventy three fiat CR.42 biplane fighters.

    Three squadron from Hawkinge in their Hurricanes had been scrambled to intercept this raid and had excitedly informed their controllers that they were facing strange twin engine bombers that could only be Italian. Seventy four squadron in their Spitfires then just completing their climb towards the earler attack were re directd towards this new assault to their east. Hardly believing their eyes the twelve pilots, in their cannoned armed Spitfires, found themselves diving into a melee of over five times their number of biplane fighters that were trying to keep the Hurricanes of Three Squadron from destroying the Italian bombers. Making a fighting withdrawl towards Dunkirk the Italians retreat was marked by trails of smoke, patches of burning fuel and the white silk of parachutes dotting the water like large jelly fish. One damaged BR.20 made a forced landing on Manston airfield and discourged a crew of no less than seven airmen, resplendent in steel helmets and bayonets on their belts much to the surpise and bemusement of the RAF ground crew who having rapidly grabbed some small arms took the Italians surrender. The excited pilots of both Three and seventy Four Squadrons remarked to their intelegence officers that the Italian’Falco’ fighters were extrodinarilly manouverable and that they literally swarmed over the RAF fighters, whenever a Hurricane of Spitfire pilot atemted to get a bead on one of the Italian aircraft several others would be manouvering to fire at them. They did not miss the fact that the Italian fighters were lightly armed and seemed to be ineffectual against the armour and self sealing tanks of the RAF fighters. On the other hand if one of the RAF pilots managed to score hits with their 20mm cannon it was often devistaingly effective against what seemed to be rather fragile aircraft.

    Come nightfall the now customary heavy attack on London was mounted with the night fighters and guns again exacting their toll. A second attack on the Midlands also resulted in a couple of successful interceptions by the night fighters with one confirmed and one probable claimed.

    Today was a major success for the defence, with ten enemy aircraft downed from the London raid and seven confirmed Italian aircraft destroyed the days total tally was twenty one enemy aircraft for a loss of six aircraft with four pilots safe. For the Italians it had been a harsh introduction to the realities of a daylight attack by escorted bombers in contested skies.

    (1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster
     
    10.56 With a Whimper not a Bang!
  • 10.56, With a Whimper not a Bang!

    October 30th

    Day. Nuisance raids on a reduced scale.

    Night. Activity reduced,

    Weather. low cloud and continuousdrizzle in all areas. (1)



    There was a later start to the days raids as the RDF screens remained clear until almost midday. When some eighty raiders making a foray up the Thames Estuary were detected as another raid atempted to cross the coast around Dymchurch. The Eleven Group controllers alredy had ten squadron airborn on patrol lines. Of these six were squadrons were vectored onto these two raids. Due to the poor flying conditions interceptions were problematical but contact was made and some enemy aircraft destroyed. Activity then died down until late afternoon when Luftflotte Three sent several formations total around one hundered and fifty machines to again test the defences, some of these aircraft managed to reach and bomb the southern suburbs of London without doing any signifigant damage. Again engagements were sparodic and frequently inconclusive in the prevailing conditions, as darknes fell the last of the enemy fighters returned to their bases in France.

    Today it was gazzeted that Air Vice Marshall Keith Park had been made a Companion of the Most Honourable Order of the Bath.



    October 31st.

    Day. Fighter bomber and fighter sweeps.

    Night, Activity greatly reduced.

    Weather. Drizle in Channel, Haze in the estuary and Dover Straits. (1)



    Today the weather was the most important factor and ariel activity was greatly curtailed. Those enemy incursions tha did occur were desultory and not pressed home, October finished vey much on a whimper. However the changes in tactics by the Luftwaffe had ensured that the last month had put as much strain on Fighter Command as the massed daylight raids of earlier months. These tactical changes had forced Eleven Group in particular to abandon one of the founding precepts of the ‘Dowding System’ by employing standing patrols in order to counter the high altitude fighter sweeps. These standing patrols were problymatical in that they increased flying hours of both pilots and aircraft and it was a certanty thet eventually tired pilots would make a fatal mistake.

    Only later would historian determin that today marked the end of the arial campaign that was known as the ‘Battle of Britain’ for those at the sharp end in Fighter Command whilst the daylight incursions tailed of eventually to the level of nuisance raids, what was known as the ‘Blitz’ at night continued to intensify and gather momentum. At night the much vaunted pre-war adage of ‘The Bomber will always get through’ still had a ring of truth but there was also this rider ‘but not always bomb the intended target’ that should have been added .

    With the War Cabinet accepting at last that the immiadette threat of invasion was past and that there could in reality be no serious renewl of that threat till the early summer of 1941, now was the time for the British Goverment to decide their priotities on how Britains War aims were to be achieved.

    As he prepared to leave Fighter Command and Bentley Priory Sir Hugh refelected that having been AOC Fighter Command since July 1936 he had had the privalllage of shaping the command far beyond the normally expected tenure of three years. After over four years at Bently Priory and over a year since the start of the war, Sir Hugh could not but help feeling some sadness at the end of what had been a long but absorbing struggle to shape and build a command, that at the time of it’s inception was an unwanted orphan in the eyes of the devout Trenchardians then commanding the RAF. As Sir Hugh payed his farewells to the staff at Bentley Prioty he took pains to ensure that each and everyone of them was aware that however small it might seem to them, they had played their part in enuring the safety of the nation in its hour of peril.



    One of Sir Hugh Dowdings first tasks as CAS was to confirm the appointment of Sir Keith Park as AOC. Fighter Command. Though there were those in the AM and RAF who thought that they should have got the job there really was only one candidate. Not only had Sir Kieth just fought a brilliant defensive campaign as AOC Eleven Group but he had also served two years as SASO at HQ Fighter Command prior to taking command of Eleven Group. The promotion of Sir Keith after only eight months at Number Eleven Group had raised some eyebrows within certian circles of the RAF but having served as the Cheif staff officer at Bentley Priory Sir Keith understood better than most the intricate workings of the system, it’s strengths as well as it’s weaknesses and was in the eyes of Sit Hugh more than qualified to buildsa on the success achieved so far.

    It was the very nature of the battle just fought that in some circle made people whisper that just like his predecessor at Bentley Priory Sir Keith was not Offensive minded enough to take the war to the enemy. Sir Phillip considered these murmurings as complete dross having observed closely Sir Kieths conduct in the Batlle just fought he was keenly aware that not only was Sir keith and adaptable and adroit leader he was also a master tactitian who fostered a unique ‘Espirit Due Corps’ in any force he commanded. Sir Phillip and Sir Hugh had had a few descrete discustions in the previous weeks as to a reshuffle of the RAF command pack. There were a few officers who were just not up to the task they were now expected to do, others were a ‘shoe in’ for promotion in certain fields, whilst other officers were so valuable where they were that moving them would be detrimental. Balalancing all these factors and resolving the in service politics invoved was not something tha Sir Hugh was skilled at, in fact he Adhored ‘service politics’ and therefore was much relieved when Sir Phillip had suggested that they very much work together on as Sir Phillip put it ‘ rearranging the peices on the chess board’ some major appointments would need at least the tacit approval of the prime minister and the war cabinet.



    Sir Hugh was confident that the Command would be in safe hands when Sir Keith Park took over in a couple of days. Sir Hugh had already dicussed with Sir Keith that as CAS Sir Hugh would have to pinch some of the current Fighter Command Group Commanders for other appointments and that Sir Keith should consult with him as quickly as possible about his choices for filling the voids left.



    (1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster
     
    11.01 Not everything had been about the Battle of Britain over the summer of 1940
  • 11.01, Not everything had been about the Battle of Brittain over the summer of 1940

    After the fall of France even before the last RAF aircraft had flown to safety Sir Phillip had charged his Operational Research teams and his Brains trust to examine everything that had happened pertaining to the British Expeditionary Air Force and it’s role with the BEF, in the battle of France. They were to identify specific failures and short comings and to make recommendations as to remedies to be instigated prior to the RAF once again sending Squadrons to fight alongside a British Field Force.

    By mid September all the various reports and salient facts had been thoroughly dissected and reduced to a few recommendations. With the Battle of Britain and the threat of invasion receding into the very recent past Churchill was already demanding more offensive action by the RAF, Partly to show that Britain was serious about prosecuting the war against Germany and partly to invigorate the peoples of the occupied countries by demonstarating that the Germans were not having it all their own way.

    Having now had time to diccuss this matter with Sir Hugh Dowding as the CAS, Sir Phillip had with Sir Hugh to try and find ways to implement those changes and new ideas despite the institutional inertia still prevalent through out the British Military and Civil Service establishment. Once again Sir Phillip knew he was going to have to rock some very stable boats and slaughter a few sacred cows held dear by some military minds.

    Sir Phillip had already made it clear to the Prime Minister, who was also now the Minister of Defence that the AM would expect his unconditional support at pushing theses proposed changes through with speed so that when the army next called upon the support of the RAF it was actually capable of rendering that support. Sir Phillip had explained to Winston that the RAF in the Field would follow a doctrine in all essence based on those avowed by Lord Trenchard when he commanded the RFC in 1917 and later the RAF in 1918. Prior to 1919 Lord Trenchard had stated that the following, were the tasks for an Air Force at war: reconnaissance, ground support, air cover across the battlefield and artillery spotting, with the accent on a coordinated effort in co-operation with the Army. Sir Phillip remind Winston that as the Air Minister in the imiadiette post war period, he had seen and read all of Trenchard’s writing’s on RAF doctrine at the time and these principle were still fundamental to the deployment of the RAF in the field in support of the British Army.

    Starting at the highest level the principle recommendation was that the Senior Air Officer Commanding such an air component must have his headquarters integrated into the Armies theatre headquarters, and so on down the Army chain of command so that there were RAF officers advising the Army decision makers as to the availability and use of air support. This was to go down as far as having forward air observers just as the Royal Artillery had. Here was a possible problem as these liaison officers/observers and controllers would require their own transport and communications as well as their own security details. Here the problem could have become a turf war between the RAF and the Army but the debacle in France had starkly shown the need for rapid response to a changing situation and several ad-hoc solutions had been improvised during the campaign in France. Building on this it had been tacitly agreed that RAF teams attached to army units would be carried on that units OOB and provided transport, drivers and logistic support, however specialised RAF equipment such as ground to air VHF radios would be supplied by the RAF.

    Another important change was the recognition for the need for dedicated ground attack aircraft and pilots in squadrons assigned to that roll. The effectiveness of these had been shown by the few squadrons of Henleys that had participated in France. When given the opportunity to be used as ground attack aircraft rather than as light level bombers their effectiveness had been clearly shown also the old lessons from the Great War were having to be relearnt, in that war both the “Harry Tate” R.E.8 and Armstrong-Whitworth F.K.8 reconnaissance and light bombers had been fitted with both forward firing machine guns and a rear cockpit weapon. Likewise the highly successful “Brisfit” Bristol F.E.2 fighter had the same armament distribution.

    When modified to have the outer wings of the Hurricane with it’s eight machine gun armament coupled with a of Vickers K gun in the rear cockpit the Henley had proved remarkably capable in this role. However it was noted that in airspace contested by frontline fighters these aircraft were still vulnerable and would require escorts. Now since mid October it was being noted how difficult it was for Fighter Command to interdict and counter the German Me 109’s now being fitted with bombs. The PAC had long been advocating what had been called the Hurribomber and had in effect one squadron of Hurricanes configured for that role as part of their preparations for attacking any German invasion. These developments had been noted and trials on behalf of the RAF had been carried out, coupling this with the development of the three inch air to ground rocket had resulted in recommendations that Army support squadrons should comprise aircraft carrying forward firing cannons and capable of carrying bombs or rockets depending on the target. Whilst the air battle over southern England was the dominant concern of Fighter Command and the RAF little could be done by the Air Ministry to implement these innovations. Once the threat of invasion receded and the intensity of fighter operations with their attendant losses subsided, then resource would be made available, in the meantime preparations could be made and various actions taken to ‘prepare the ground’ so to speak so that as little time as possible would be lost.

    To permit a high intensity of operations in support of the Army in whatever theatre of operations that might be, the RAF would need a robust and efficient Logistics system. This would require both service and supply bases as well as the manpower to run it.

    To adequately discharge its role in support of the army in the field the RAF would require mobile forward air fields. These in themselves would need to be protected both from Air attack and ground assault, which may vary from simple looters to all out direct assaults by enemy units. This need for local defence would be, in the opinion of the Air Ministry better provided by an indigenous RAF force rather than relying on siphoning off scarce resources from the local Army Commands. The recent events on the continent and the concerted attacks as well as the threat of Airborne assault on the RAF bases in the home counties had drawn attention to this need, whilst the Home Guard had enthusiastically risen to the task of helping to defend and guard RAF establishments the problems of the army finding sufficient forces from local commands had proved problematical. The task now was for the AM and the RAF to raise a suitable force, equip it and get it into the field. To this end a number of Airfield Defence squadrons would be raised using the existing RAF Armoured car Companies based in the Middle East as a model. Sir Phillip was not sure how many men would eventually be required for this task but suggested that the Airfield Defence Squadrons who would be trained in AA defence and infantry tactics would eventually form several Wings and maybe even Groups. One option Sir Phillip had been appraised of was to offer men and Officers who washed out from aircrew training and other RAF trades the option of joining the Airfield Defence squadrons rather than being drafted to another service.

    . Sir Hugh had suggested during discussion over these proposals that when they were submitted to Churchill copies of Trenchards memo’s should be attached , as well as a copy of J. C. Slessor’s book ‘Air Powerer and Armies’. Whether Churchill read them or not, these document would illustrate that the proposals were based on lessons learnt from the previous Great War as well as the current conlict and how the ideas and practacise promulgated by Slessor’s book had informed the AM amd the CAS’s recommendations.
     
    11.02 Fighter Command, Strengths and Locations of Units by Sector as of 6pm on 30 September 1940
  • 11.02 Fighter Command, Strengths and Locations of Units by Sector as of 6pm on 30 September 1940



    As of the thirtieth of September Fighter Command had sixty three operational squadrons of day fighters. In Discusions through October Sit Hugh and Keith Park had discussed what changes should and could be made in the imeadette future to the organiseation of Fighter Command. Sir Hugh had suggested that as soon as the day sortie rate dropped it would be time to actvate No 9 Group, by allocateing it operational squadrons. Kieth Park had responded that he would prefer that No 9 group was not activated until he had taken over as AOC Fighter Command and Sir Hugh had official taken over as CAS. Sir Hugh concurred and suggested that as AOC Fighter Command He should present his proposals as soon as possible. He also warned Park that he was likely to loose several experience squadrons from his command quite soon and also some of his senior staff officers. Therefore he should think about whom he wanted and where as replacements.



    Sector stations marked *

    No 10 Group, Headquarters Box


    234 Squadron Spitfire Mk II St Eval

    85 Squadron Spitfire Mk II St Eval

    609 Squadron Spitfire Mk II Exeter*

    87 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Exeter*

    213 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Exeter*

    92 Squadron Spitfire Mk II Pembrey*

    605 Squadron Defiant Pembry*

    73 Squadron Defiant Pembry*

    263 Squadron Reaper Filton

    421 Squadron Beaufighter NF Filton

    501 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Middle Wallop*

    238 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Middle Wallop*

    1 RCAF. Squadron Hurricane MkIc Middle Wallop*

    No5 OTU. Hurricane MkIc Aston Down

    No13 OTU. Bisely NF. Bicester.





    No 11 Group, Headquarters Uxbridge

    56 Squadron Hurricane MkIc North Weald*

    307 squadron PAC Reaper NF Marltesham.

    151 Squadron Hurricanes MkIc North Weald*

    602 Squadron Spitfire MkII Hornchurch*

    74 Squadron Spitfire MkII Hornchurch*

    152 Squadron Spitfire MkII Hornchurch*

    600 Squadron Reaper NF Biggin Hill*

    3 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Hawkinge

    603 Squadron Spitfire MkII Biggin Hill*

    32 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Biggin Hill*

    306 Squadron POC Spitfire MkII Debden*

    308 Squadron POC Spitfire MkII Debden*

    302 Squadron POC Spitfire MkII Duxford*

    303 Squadron POC Spitfire MkII Duxford

    64 Squadron Spitfire MkII Kenley*

    504 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Kenley*

    111 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Croydon

    1 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Northolt*

    257 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Northolt*

    43 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Tangmere*

    145 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Tangmere*

    601 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Westhampnett

    12 Group, Headquarters Watnall

    249 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Church Fenton*

    616 Squadron Spitfire MkII Leconfield

    253 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Kirton-in-lindsey*

    222 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Kirton-in-lindsey*

    46 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Digby*

    611 Squadron Spitfire MkII Digby*

    266 Squadron Spitfire MkII Digby*

    29 Squadron Reaper NF Digby*

    23 Squadron Reaper NF Wittering*

    229 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Wittering*

    137 Squadron Reaper Wittering*

    247 Squadron Defiant Wittering

    66 Squadron Spitfire MkII Coltishall*

    242 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Coltishall*

    123 Squadron Defiant Coltishall*

    96 Squadron Reaper NF Coltishall*

    No6 OTU. Spitfire MkII Sutton Bridge



    13 Group, Headquarters Newcastle

    141 Squadron Defiant Turnhouse*

    245 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Turnhouse*

    54 Squadron Spitfire MkII Aklington*

    72 Squadron Spitfire MkII Aklington*

    235 Squadron Bisley NF Aklington*

    41 Squadron Spitfire MkII Catterick*

    219 Squadron Spitfire MkII Catterick*

    604 Squadron Bisley Beufighter Catterick*

    232 Squadron Defiant Unsworth*

    310 Czech Squadron Spitfire MkII Unsworth*

    312 Czech Squadron Reaper Church Fenton

    607 Squadron Defiant Usworth

    808 Squadron FAA Fulmar Castletown

    No18 Polish OTU. Spitfire MkII Prestwick

    No54 OTU. Reaper NF. Church Fenton.



    14 Group, Headquarters Inverness

    79 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Wick*

    615 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Dyce*

    610 Squadron Spitfire MkII Dyce*

    65 Squadron Spitfire MkII Drem

    19 Squadron Spitfire MkII Dalcross*

    17 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Dalcross*

    305 squadron POC Hurricane Mk1d Milltown

    85 Squadron Hurricane MkIc Lossiemouth



    25 Squadron Reaper NF Banff



    264 Squadron Defiant Lossiemouth









    Aircraft strengths by squadron type in each group

    Group, 10 11 12 13 14

    Hurricane MkIc 5 13 6 1 3

    Spitfire MkII 4 6 4 5 6

    Defiant 2 1 2 3

    Reaper 1 1

    Reaper NF. 2 3 1

    Bisley NF. 2

    Beaufighter

    Beaufighter N.F 1



    Totals by Group 14 22 16 11 10
     
    a useful summary
  • This is a repost of my earlier one with corrections, My apologies for the inconsistencies in the earlier version and my thanks ro those who drew my attention to them,

    A quick comparison between OTL fighter command OOB and ITL,
    OTL on the 30th September 1940 Fighter Command OOB was:

    Spitfires, (8Mg) 19 squadrons,
    Hurricanes (8Mg) 33 squadrons
    Defiants (4Mg in turret) 4 squadrons,
    Blenhiem (6Mg fighters) 5 squadrons
    Gladiator, (4Mg) 1 flight.
    61 squadrons (no dedicated night fighter squadrons).

    ITTL. on the 30th November 1940 Fighter Command OOB :
    Spitfires (2 cannon, 4Mg) 25 squadrons.
    Hurricanes (2cannon, 4Mg) 25 squadrons.
    Defiants ( 4 cannons) 8 squadrons.
    Reaper (4 cannons) 3 squadrons.
    Reaper NF. (4 Cannons) 6 squadrons.
    Beaufighter NF (4 cannons) 1 Squadron.
    Bisley NF (2 Cannon, 4Mg) 2 squadrons.
    70 squadrons, (9 dedicated Night fighter squadrons.

    ITTL there are Sixty one day fighter squadrons which is the same as OTL. ITTI all day fighters are armed with at least 2 X 20mm cannon. So in fire power the ITL squadrons are much greater than OTL. The night fighters capability is greatly enhanced (about 18months/2 years ahead of OTL). In ITL as of 30th September there are nine operational RDF fitted night fighter squadrons compared to OTL when there were zero. With ITTL GCI/PPI Radar coverage over most of the UK this is a huge advance over OTL. This advantage in Radar over OTL, will equipment wise, be eroded down to almost parity to OTL as centimetric radar is introduce only a few months earlier than OTL. However the greater experience gained with the earlier mass production of AI radar and it's use will continue ITTL to give the PAM an advantage over OTL in the night battle.
    Pilot wise ITTL there are proportionally more pilots who have survived the BoB (about 10%) plus more pilots coming out of the training program. Aircraft losses have been about parallel to OTL but production especially of Spitfires up to 01/11/1940 have been substantially above OTL, principally due to Castle Bromwich spamming out Spitfire mark II since Mid 1939.

    I hope that is a useful summary.
     
    11. 03 The Right equipment in the right place?
  • 11. 03 The Right equipment in the right place?

    Discussions between Sir Phillip and Sir Hugh in the proceeding weeks had been wide ranging and Sir Hugh had concurred that with the end of the current daylight campaign over Britain and with the proposed major rearming of Fighter Command to all Spitfires, now would be a good time to send reinforcements abroad.
    The last batch of Hurricane and Spitfire mark ones had been sent out before the end of May and by now those aircraft that had survived this long where becoming harder and harder to keep operational. The Government and the AM decided the first priorities for fighters should be Malta and the Middle East. The AM was proposing to send Hurricanes to Malta to be followed by Spitfires as soon as possible. The Defiants would go to the Middle East Command.
    With knowledge that operation Compass was due to start in early December, it was acknowledged in the AM that any such reinforcements needed to start being sent sooner rather than later.
    Sir Hugh’s next proposal caught Sir Phillip completely by surprise. Sir Hugh suggested that the Entire PAC, currently consisting of the five single seat fighter Squadrons and one night fighter squadron be joined by the two Polish Bomber Squadrons No's 300, and 301 (at this time converting to Wellingtons). Should subject to the agreement of the Polish Government in Exile be transferred as a complete unit to the Middle East Command in Egypt.
    This would give this command an independent but powerful force to act in support of the Army in theatre as it sort to eject the Italians who had recently invaded Egypt. Sir Hugh did add the proviso that that 307 squadron PAC would need to convert from the night-fighter Reaper to either the single seat version the Reaper or the two seat Beafighter as the RDF equipped Reaper NF was required for UK defense and was not yet cleared for overseas service.
    At this juncture Sir Phillip had sounded a word of caution, in that Sir Arthur Longmore, the Current AOC Middle East, had upset the Prime Minister for continually requesting reinforcements and that Sir Hugh’s plan might be seen as supporting Sir Arthur Longmore rather than the Prime Minister. Sir Hugh had responded that he was proposing to recall Sir Arthur and to send out Air-Vice Marshall Arthur Tedder as his replacement. That would of course have to be agreed by Churchill as would the relocation of the PAC if the Polish Government in exile authorized it as well.
    When Sir Phillip as AM asked Sir Hugh as CAS why he was advocating taking six of the most successful squadrons away from Fighter Command and at the same time taking two squadrons of bombers from Bomber Command. Sir Hugh’s reasoning was simple and understandable. The PAC was a self contained unit and could be relocated as such. Further rather than having Poles sitting in the UK getting bored and doing mad things through the British winter it would be advantageous to send them where their propensity for attacking anything in the air or on the ground could be used to it’s best advantage.

    Discussions with the Admiralty, had prior to Sir Hugh taking over a CAS resulted in the plan for reinforcing Malta being brought forward to dovetail with ongoing Naval operations, this resulted in Operation White being folded into the complicated MB8 plan of operations.. To that end a total of Eighty four Hurricanes had been sent to Glasgow for loading, crated, onto ships for delivery to Gibraltar on the first part of their journey to Malta. Eighty four aircrew were also despatched though not all of them would stay on Malta once the aircraft were delivered.

    Currently there were three operational Wellington squadrons in Middle East Command with two more working up to operational standard. Sir Hugh and Sir Phillip considered that attacking the Italian convoys taking troops and supplies to Italian North Africa should soon become a priority for the bomber force based on Malta. The proposal was to reinforce the two existing Wellington Squadrons currently there with additional maritime patrol and attack aircraft. In the expectation of an adverse reaction from the Italians the proposal also contained a commitment to continue reinforcing the fighter defenses of the Island of Malta was also placed on the agenda.
    In discussions with Sir Keith Park, Sir Hugh had enquired as to which of his current Group Commanders he would recommend as the next AOC. Malta. Sir Hugh had explained to Sir Phillip that he considered it essential that the officer commanding the air defense of the island had had experience in commanding an RDF based defense system and therefore promoting a Fighter Command group leader would be the correct action.

    Operations against the Italians in East Africa were on going and the need for replacements for the aircraft in that theatre was becoming more and more urgent. Back in early June the decision had been made to have the Curtis Hawk aircraft that the British Government had procured from the French orders shipped directly to East Africa for the reequipment of the South African squadrons serving in that theatre, as of the end of the first week of November one hundred and thirty Mohawks had been delivered. For continuation purposes Curtis P-40’s with the Allison in line engine were being purchased by the British Purchasing Commission and would be again be shipped directly to Egypt where self sealing tanks, amour and other modifications would be fitted prior to the planes being sent to the squadrons. There had been much discussion over whether the Mohawks should be replaced by either Hurricanes or Defiants shipped from the UK. However the longer range of the Warhawk was seen as being advantageous in the East African theatre of operations.

    The shipping of aircraft from the USA to Britain and The Middle East had caused some sharp correspondence between the AM and the Ministry of Supply. In discussions with the AM and the MOS. The Canadian Government had agreed in 1939 to set up production plants for the following aircraft.

    Hawker Hurricane,

    Short Stirling

    Avro Anson

    Both the Anson and the Hurricane were now in production, this required engines to be shipped to Canada for fitting to the airframes. After much discussion the decision was made that Ansons for Canadian use would be fitted with American engines and that if necessary Hurricanes would be shipped without their Merlins.

    With the prospect of large numbers of Packard Merlins coming off the production lines by the end of 1941 the MAP had sought a change in production from the Canadians. Whilst the Anson would remain as is and continuing Hurricane production would use Packard engines. With the production line for the Sterling yet to be set up the MAP was advocated that the Canadians changed to building the new Avro Lancaster, the prototype of which would be flying soon. The principle advantage of this change would be that the Lancaster would use four Packard Merlin engines which would save the shipping of four Fairey Monarch engines to Canada for each Stirling built, as well as allowing those Merlins used on Canadian built Lancasters to self deliver by air to the UK as part of a complete aircraft. The last component of the new plan proposed that the Canadians would start building the new De-Haviland Mosquito. As this could be constructed form Canadian sourced wood ( though Balsa wood would still need to be imported from south America via the pacific coast) and again use the Packard Merlin thereby also freeing up scarce shipping space on the transatlantic convoys. Once these advantages had been explained at some length to the men from the MOS, shipping Balsa wood up the Pacific coast to Canada would not only be safer than shipping the timber to the UK but it also reduced the shipping load on the Atlantic convoys as would the self delivery of the Lancaster and Mosquito aircraft by air. This self delivery of aircraft had the further advantage of being able to use Canadian/American trained aircrew hence saving their passage space to the UK. All in all the AM considered such a production plan to be, as one of the Americans from Packard had put it to Earnest Hives of RR a ‘win, win outcome’
     
    11.04 Under new managment
  • 11.04 Under new managment

    Having attended his first War Cabinet meeting Sir Hugh as CAS now had a far better understanding of the dynamics of how the government was fighting this war. Back in late May Churchill had formed a government of national unity, involving both the Labour and the Liberal Paties. This meant that Churchill had appointed a Labour politician as his deputy and a number of senior Labour MPs as ministers. For the Liberals, Churchill had appointed Sir Archibald Sinclair as the Minister of Aircraft Production under the AM. This gave Sir Archibald a cabinet seat but not a place on the War Cabinet. Sir Phillip as AM was on the war Cabinet and as CAS Sir Hugh would normally attended as would Heads of the other armed services.

    This War Cabinet meeting had seen Churchill congratulate Sir Hugh on his promotion and welcomed him to the War Cabinet and almost in the same breath demand of Sir Hugh his plans for stopping the night blitz and an exortation that the RAF be seen to hit back at the enemy. Sir Hugh speaking in measured terms had told the War Cabinet that he was confident that Sir Keith Park as SAO of Fightert Command was doing everything possible with the resources available to counter the enemie’s night bombers. As to the RAF retaliating for the systematic and indiscriminate bombing of British cities Sir Hugh reiterated that as CAS he was reviewing the current bombing operations of the RAF and would be making recommendations to Churchill as the Defence Minister as to the deployment of offensive assets as soon as Sir Phillip and himself were satisfied with their planning. Looking Squarely at Churchill Sit Hugh had added that this was as they had agreed at a meeting with him back in September.

    Sir Hugh continued stating that a thorough review of all he RAF Commands both domestic and foreign was being carried out and the results of that review would inform Sir Hugh when he came to formulate plans to fullfill the war aims and strategic objectives set by the Goverment. Having weathered the invasion threat of the summer after the fall of France it was now he opininioned only right that such a review be done so that of those of the nations resources allocated to the RAF could be best assigned and deployed to prosecute the war against the countries enemies as effiecently as possible.

    Then with a nod from Churchill Sir Hugh proceeded to brief the War Cabinete regarding the proposed re-equipment of Fighter Command and the re inforcement of Middle East Command . Whilst not giving specific details Sir Hugh outlined the upcoming joint operation with the RN, where Hurricane Fighters would be carried to within Ferry range of Malta before flying off to land on the island. Reinforcements for Egypt would be delivered as crated aircraft to Freetown and would then fly the newly established southern ferry route up into Egypt. This route would also be used by Blenhiems and other bombers. Staging bombers through Malta was diccussed briefly but the use of the limited aircraft fuel available on the island for that purpose was not justifiable. The proposals regarding the Polish Air Contingent resulted in much discussion around the table. Churchill stated that he and the deputy prime minister would be seeking a meeting with the Polish Goverment in Exhile at the earliest opertunity.

    Having weathered that first storm, Hugh took this occasion to enquire of the War Cabinate as to their intentions regarding the growing pressures in the Far East. Whilst Britain was at war with Nazi Germany and her allies it would, he ventured be imprudent to igore the gathering storm clouds further east. The latest demands apparently being made by the Japanese of the Vichy Goverment regarding basing rights for aircraft and the transit of troops through French Indo China, where in his opinion a serious development that threatened directly the safety of Malaya and Singapore. Whilst the Goverment of Thialand were supposedly neutral Sir Hugh enquired as to what garantees were there that they do would not bow to Japaneses pressure and permit Japan to base troops and aircraft there further threatening British interest.

    Sir Hugh had served as an army officer in India and had a good understanding of the effect such moves would have upon the strategic vunerability of Burma and even India itself. Churchill seemed slightly non plussed at first that Sir Hugh as CAS should be talking about the far east and Japan when the country was still at peace with that nation and not concentrating on defeating Germany.

    Sir Hugh responded by stating that he would be failing in his duty to King and country if he did not remind the Goverment that the RAF and the other armed forces still had a duty to defend the entire empire not just prosecute the current conflict. Sir Phillip had interjected at this point that he had discussed these issues with Sir Hugh and was fully surportive of his stance and that in the very near future the AM would be presenting their recoomendations to the Prime Minister and the Waer Cabinate for reinforcing the RAF in the Far East as a precautionary measure.

    Later Back at the Air Ministry Sir Phillip voiced his concern that Sir Hugh might be sailing a bit close to the wind in putting strategic matters to the War Cabinet before seeking clearance and agreement from Churchill as Prime minister and Minister of Defence. Sir Hugh’s responce was that, having been charged as CAS, with the rersponsabilitie of ensuring that the lives of the men and women trusted to his care were not wasted he would not merely be a ‘yes man ‘ for Churchill and would act accordingly. Sir Hugh finished by baldly stating that if Churchill did not like that then Churchill could always sack him but the air defences of the Far East were currently being neglected and that had to be redressed. Tacitly Sir Phillip had agreed with Sir Hugh but suggested that more diplomatic and sensitive ways of manouvering Churchill would probable prove more successful in the long run.
     
    11.05 Bomber Command, Definitely a work in Progress (Version two rewrite)
  • 11.05 Bomber Command, Definitely a work in Progress (Version two rewrite)

    Looking at the current order of battle for Bomber Command was in Sir Hugh’s eyes a very sobering task. Whilst a total of forty operational squadrons and no less than eleven operational training units plus an additional four non-operational squadrons, looked impressive on paper in Sir Hugh’s opinion it was very much a toothless paper tiger and had not grown appreciable fangs since the start of the war. In Sir Hugh’s eyes that had to change. Whilst the ability of individual bombers to navigate to their intended target and to bomb at least the correct city had been greatly approved by the new navigational methods and instruction introduced pre-war, bomb aiming point photographs (when they were actually taken) proved the lie to the claimed accuracy of the bombing. As far as Sir Hugh was concerned that fault lay with the command and not the Aircrews. In far too many cases crews were being sent out night after night in obsolescent aircraft that in Sir Hugh’s opinion were little more than death traps. Currently Bomber Command were flying five different types of bomber air craft.

    Sir Sir Edgar Ludlow-Hewitt had been done a steady job as SAO Bomber Command and had fought hard to establish more operational training units to improve the standard of crews arriving at operational stations, whilst many Trenchardists within the RAF had voiced objections about this Sir Hugh could see that this would bare fruit as the increased numbers of aircrew to man the big new bombers coming into service started to roll of the production lines in ever greater numbers. Despite Sir Hugh’s tacit support, due to political pressure Sir Edgar Ludlow- Hewitt had been replaced by Portal as AOC Bomber Command

    Discussing the Bomber Command with Sir Phillip, Sir Hugh voiced the opinion that there was no need to change the leader ship there at the moment. Sir Hugh suggested that as he was now CAS, Portal would have greater support and stronger guidance than he had had under his ineffectual predecessor .



    Sir Phillip had asked Sir Hugh why he had called Bomber Command a Paper Tiger, in response Sir Hugh had set out some simple statistical facts, prepared for him by the Committee for the Scientific Survey of Air Offence (CSSAO). Of the forty operational squadrons in Bomber Command, those in number one Group, were flying Fairey Battles that were basically obsolete and of no practical worth to a strategic bombing force. Not only were they short of range to hit targets in Germany but also they carried a paltry one thousand pound payload of bombs. In daylight raids they were death traps for their crews and at night they were little better. So out of a force of Forty Squadrons, six were completely unfit for purpose, so as far as Sir Hugh was concerned Bomber Command only had thirty four operational squadrons.

    Looking at number Two Group things were little better, this group boasted no less than thirteen squadrons, with two hundred and nineteen bombers and thirty six reconnaissance aircraft. However these aircraft were all Blenheim light bombers, though they had a much greater range than the Fairey Battle they only carried the same bomb load of one thousand pounds. Further the Blenheim only had a twelve miles an hour advantage in cruising speed over the Battle.

    Statistically looking at it another way nineteen of the forty operational bomber squadrons could, if they actually reach the target deliver a total of three hundred and twelve thousand pounds of bombs. This bomb load meant hazarding nine hundred and thirty six airmen to deliver it.

    In contrast number three group with its eight squadrons of Vickers Wellingtons could deliver a total bomb load of five hundred and forty four thousand pounds. Almost a third more than that of the combined capacity of One and Two Groups. Having a crew of five meant that to deliver this increased bomb load only took six hundred and eighty aircrew. The Whitleys of Number Four group held a similar advantage, the ninety six aircraft in six squadrons of this Group could also deliver a four thousand pound bomb load each for a total of three hundred and eighty four thousand pounds again out weighing the combined efforts of both One and Two Groups. Only four hundred and eighty aircrew were required for this Group. Finally there were the seven Hampden squadrons in number Five Group, again each aircraft was capable of delivering a four thousand pound bomb load. So this group could deliver a theoretical total of four hundred and eighty thousand pounds. This group required four hundred and eighty air crew . Sir Hugh new that this was quite a simplistic analysis as bomb load varied with range and required fuel load but as an illustration, as to the utility in doing harm to the enemy, it served as a reasonable metric. As did the bomb load per aircrew risked show in basic terms the potential human cost of delivering this bomb load. Of the three medium bomber types in service the Wellington was considered the best, whilst slower than the Hampden it had much better self defense capability and had a growing reputation for getting its crews home. Whilst being the fastest and the smallest of the medium bombers the Hadley Page Hampden was from the crews perspective, a cramped and uncomfortable aircraft and a nightmare to get out of if hit by enemy fire. As for the Whitley it was adequate but did not shine in any particular aspect.

    Now when considering the three new bomber types about to enter service the contrast in bomb load capability was even more apparent.

    The New Machester could carry a bomb load of some eight thousand pounds, this was double the load on any bomber then in service. The capability increase with the other two types was even more marked. The Stirling could carry no less than fourteen thousand pounds of bombs and the Halifax could almost match this with a thirteen thousand pound bomb load. All these aircraft had a standard crew of seven , so their bomb load per crew was at least comparable to any other bomber in service.

    After some delay due to the priority of getting the LRMP version built in Belfast the production line in Rochester was now producing Stirlings bombers in a regular stream. Unfortunately the design of this aircraft had not been optimized for unit construction or even ease of construction so it would take time to really increase production signifigently. However despite the attacks on the factory at Rochester there were now sufficient aircraft available to enable three squadrons to start to convert to this type. Meanwhile Avro were really getting into their stride with the Manchester. Avro were on target to deliver their first Wings worth of Manchester’s by the New Year. Here the design being optimized to some extent for ease of construction on the production line was evident. The third big bomber, The Hadley page Halifax was also preceding apace, having ceased production of the Hampden in August so as to clear the line. English Electric in Preston were meanwhile maintaining production of Hampdens. As Hadley Page concentrated on getting the unit production system for the Halifax working with the various subcontractors both their factories at Cricklewood and Radlett were working to capacity.

    With all three of the new big bombers in series production and the first of each type now arriving at squadrons for conversion training the destructive power of Bomber command was about to be multiplied.

    It was at this juncture that the opinions and plans of Portal as head of Bomber Command and Sir Hugh as CAS clashed. Portal had put forward a plan to the AM that Bomber Command would keep all squadrons flying the current bomber types (except Group One in their Battles who would convert to Wellingtons) and the new big bombers would go into new wings and new groups to expand both the squadron numbers and the bomb capacity of Bomber Command at the same time. Portal as a confirmed Trenchardist in respect to the war winning capabilities of the strategic bomber was arguing that his command should have total priority of industrial and personnel capacity over all other services in the British armed Forces. Sir Hugh on the other hand was not convinced that bombing on it’s own could win the war. It could shorten it and reduce the toll, especially on the army but force the Nazis to surrender, no, Sir Hugh saw no evidence for that conclusion. As CAS, He would advocate a more measured expansion of the bomber force, from the current forty squadrons in Five Groups to Forty Five squadrons in five groups, each group having three wings of three Squadrons. If Practical, all squadrons in a Group would fly the same aircraft type. If this was not possible it would be done at least at Wing Level. Sir Hugh’s target was that by the end of 1941 Bomber command would have the following order of battle based upon current aircraft production capacity.

    One Group, Wellingtons

    Two Group, Manchesters,

    Three Group, Wellingtons,

    Four Group, Stirlings,

    Five Group, Halifaxes.

    With the intention that as production and losses permitted the Two Wellington Groups would convert to the newer aircraft types. Having been briefed about the promising work being done by De Haviland on the new Mosquito aircraft Sir Hugh had added a proviso to his plans that at least one additional group or an expansion of existing groups could be possible to utilize the bomber version of this promising aircraft. Once the five groups had been reequipped as per the Dowding plan, then the forty five squadrons in Bomber command would be capable of theoretically delivering a total bomb load of six million one hundred and ninety two thousand pounds of bombs in a single raid using every one of the seven hundred and twenty aircraft. The total crew for these aircraft would number four thousand eight hundred and forty eight. So even Sir Hugh’s more modest scheme of adding five additional bomber squadrons would with the advent of the new bigger bombers result in almost doubling the aircrew from the current two thousand five hundred and seventy six. The important thing in Sir Hugh’s opinion was that the maximum possible weight of ordinance delivered against enemy targets would rise by over three and a half times. This was the root of Sir Hugh’s proposition improve the quality of the attack not just increase the headline number of aircraft and numbers. Sir Hugh was aware that with Sir Phillip’s assistance he was still going to have to convince Churchill that this was the optimum scheme.

    Sir Hugh and Sir Phillip were aware that persuading Portal that Sir Hughs’s plane was the right way forward for Bomber Command might not be possible. Unless they could be sure that they had Portal’s full support they would inevitably have to replace him as AOC Bomber Command by an officer who was totally committed to implementing the planned reforms. The last thing Bomber Command needed at this juncture was another change of leadership. Sir Hugh was aware that Portal did hold views regarding the targeting of the German oil production and transport that were commensurate with his own and he hopped that this common ground would enable them to forge a good working relationship.
     
    11.06 Operation MB8: Whose Mare Nostrum Is It?
  • Operation MB8. Who’s ‘Mare Nostrum’ is it?



    When Sir Hugh and Sir Philip sat down to discuss the naval operation MB8, Sir Hugh ventured that the Naval plan seemed very complicated if not overly so. Would adding the resupply of Hurricanes to Malta the final straw? A conference was quickly organised at the Admiralty to finalise the RAF part of the plan. At the start of the briefing Admiral Sir Arthur Dowding explained the objectives of all the interlinked operations and how they formed a diversion or smoke screen for the main objective, of an attack on the Italian fleet at Taranto.

    The plan had originated during the Abyssinian crisis of the mid nineteen thirties and had been regularly updated. The aircraft carrier Glorious and her air group of Fairey Swordfish had trained and practised for the attack in 1939. Since the entry of Italy into the war in Late June the RN had been preparing to carry out the plan. With the Italians sending regular supply convoys to Italian North Africa the Italian fleet based in Taranto had been reinforced and was acting as a ‘fleet in being’ and thus tying down valuable RN resources that were needed elseware. With Operation Compass being planned to start in December the time to strike would be in the correct moon phase in mid November. As part of the deception plan the Navy were keen to do a major aircraft re supply run to Malta. Three aircraft carriers seen filling their decks with land planes in Gibraltar, by the Germans Spanish friends meant they were highly unlikely to be part of an attack on the Italian fleet!

    Aircraft resupply trips into the Mediterranean had become known as ‘Club Runs’ and this was planned to be the largest yet. With Glorious, Courageous and Furious all participating in what was known as Operation White. This would deliver some eighty four Hurricanes in one go. Courageous and Glorious would carry their full complement of Folland Fighters and Fairey Albacores. Furious would retain only six of her Follond falcon fighters for self defence and they would only be usable once all the Hurricanes had flown off.

    Operation MB8 would now consist of seven interlink elements, these being,

    Operation White, Glorious, Courageous and Furious, delivering aircraft to Malta.

    Operation Coat, reinforcement convoy to Malta. The convoy includes the battleship HMS Barham and the heavy cruisers HMS Glasgow and Berwick. They are accompanied by HMS Ark Royal.

    Convoy MW 3 Three empty merchant men bound for Malta then sailed on the 4th November arriving 10th November escort including cruiser HMS Coventry

    Convoy ME 3 Four Merchant ships in ballast with heavy escort, Including Battleship HMS Ramillies and HMS Coventry Sails on the 11th November from Malta arrives Alexandria 13th November

    Convoy AN6 Four slow tankers to Greece escort includes Cruisers HMS Ajax and HMAS Sydney as force B delivering materials and men to Crete. HMS Orion a light cruiser carrying RAF personnel to Greece forms Force C, on the night 11/12 November force B and C will combine as force X and make an offensive foray into the Otranto Strait.

    Operation Crack, Aircraft from HMS Courageous, HMS Glorious and HMS Furious Attack airfields and Facilities around Cagliari on Sardinia as they return to Gibraltar form operation White

    Operation Judgement. Consisting of the carrier HMS Illustrious, with the battleships HMS Warspite, Valiant and Malay were to be joined by the battleship HMS Ramallies from convoy ME 3 and the heavy cruisers HMS Glouster and York plus three destroyers from Convoy MW 3. The final element of the operation Judgement force would be the Aircraft Carrier HMS Ark Royal joining from operation Coat.

    The Three aircraft carriers taking part in operation White would leave Gibraltar after the Operation Coat Convoy and catch up with it before Cape Bone. Here it would come under the protection of aircraft from Ark Royal whilst the RAF fighters were flown off to Malta. Once their decks were clear Furious, Courageous and Glorious would provide air cover for the Operation Coat Convoy until Malta based aircraft could take over.

    This would permit Ark Royal to team south and east around Malta to join operation Judgement.

    Furious would cross deck some Fairey Albacores from both Courageous and Glorious so that when they had finished providing air cover to Operation Coat they could launch bigger strike more quickly to hit the airfield and other facilities at Cagilari on Sicily. To further cause the Italians confusion the Aircraft attacking Cagilari would bear squadrons codes for HMS, Ark Royal, Courageous, and Glorious.

    Despite the maritime ballet required and the complication of movement each element served a purpose and made the core of the entire enterprise, the attack on Taranto possible.

    That attack would be undertaken by Twenty four albacores flying from HMS Invincible and a further twenty four from Ark Royal. Twelve aircraft from each carrier would comprise the first wave. Six would carry torpedoes , two would carry flares and four bombs of 250lb each. The final four would carry one fifteen hundred pound ‘longbow bomb’. This long thin bomb that fits in place of an 18 inch torpedo and had an explosive content of fifty percent. Though not designed to be armoured piercing it has a relatively thick nose casing and has dual fusing, having both time delay and solvent fuses. In operation Judgement it was intended that with the shallow sea bed a near miss with a ‘Longbow’ would do nearly as much damage as a direct hit by stoving in the hull. Ark Royal’s torpedo aircraft would attack from the northwest of the harbour and Invincible, aircraft from the south west. The latest photographic reconnaissance picture showed all six Italian Battles ships anchored in a group in the Mar Grand close to Taranto town with three heavy cruises lying together further offshore.

    Flares would be dropped on the east of the Mar Grand. The flare droppers then using their two hundred and fifty bound bombs to attack the oil storage tanks. The eight other bomb carrying aircraft were detailed to attack the heavy cruisers in the Mar Grand and Mar Piccilo First wave torpedo aircraft were instructed to attack the six battle ships in the Mar Grand as their primary target. Each pair was assigned a ship to attack identified by its location from the latest reconnaissance photographs.

    The second wave scheduled to arrive half an hour later had the same composition but slightly different instructions. Their primary target s were any undamaged Battle ships, secondary targets were the heavy cruisers. The flare dropping aircraft had the same instructions as the first wave. The four aircraft from each carrier carrying ‘Longbow’ bombs were given the destroyer and light cruiser trots in the Mar Piccolo as their primary target and the docks as their secondary one.

    Discussing all this with Sir Arthur , Sir Hugh and Sir Phillip asked what the navy wanted from the RAF. Sir Arthur suggested that an attack by the RAF Wellingtons dropping Aerial mines commencing just as the flare dropping air craft completed their runs could very well distract the Italians enough to improve the chances of the torpedo carrying aircraft. . There had been some discussion over whether the Aerial mine was the best ordinance for the job, whilst in its sea mine mode it could do serious damage to a battleship, the chances of one being triggered was slight and the falling mines might not really be noticed by the Italians and therefore provide little or no distraction. Sir Hugh suggested that the Wellingtons could carry two standard fifteen hundred pound Mk I-IV mines and that if half the bombers in each squadron carried a full load of mixed AP and HC bombs this would enhance the distraction and might obscure the location of the mines when dropped, this was agreed in principle with a second wave of two squadrons timed to arrive with the second wave of FAA aircraft carrying the same ordinance load.

    The final decision was that the first RAF attack would use two thirds of the aircraft carrying five hundred pound bombs and the other four using Aerial Mines. The second wave would carry Aerial Mines only, with eight being tasked with mining the Mar Grand and the other four tasked with hitting the Mar Piccolo and the dock yard.
    There had been some discussion as to whether the first two operational squadrons of RAF Bomber Command Stirlings could also make a worthwhile contribution. They had the range to do a shuttle attack from the UK to Egypt via Taranto and could deliver eight thousand pounds of ordinance. Whilst very tempting as an idea Sir Hugh, ventured that the Squadrons were not yet operationaly mature enough to carry out such a mission, even with the best navigation training and the use of the brand new mark fourteen bomb site the chance that they would hit anything of importance would be unlikely. Basically the potential losses were not proportional to the probable damage to the enemy.
    Sir Arthur noted at this point that some FAA officers were predicting losses of around fifty percent in this attack. However he was of the opinion that two squadrons of Wellingtons flying from Malta and two squadrons flying from bases in Egypt would be a significant addition to the alarm and despondency caused the Italian Navy by this operation. The attack on Taranto had originally been planned for Trafalgar day on the twenty first of October but the entire operation had been delayed due to problems with the dropping of torpedoes in such shallow water using the Albacore aircraft. When the attack was first muted the FAA torpedo aircraft was the Swordfish, the torpedoes had been modified for dropping from the Swordfish. When the Albacore replaced it and new tests on shallow water torpedo dropping had been carried out on a live torpedo training run the majority of the torpedoes struck bottom causing a hasty redesign of the additional appendages used for shallow water drops and an enforced delay of the attack date.

    Both Sir Hugh and Sir Phillip had followed the opening gambits of Operation MB8 with great interest and some trepidation. When the bulk of the Hurricanes arrived safely on Malta there were audible sighs of relieve.

    On the Morning of the twelve of November Sir Hugh was relieved to get the casualty returns from the four squadrons involved in operation Judgement, Only two aircraft had been lost on the operation. One had aborted on the way to the target due to engine problems and one other been written off in a bad landing on Malta. Stone walls and Wellington bombers do not make for a good ending. All in all not as bad as Sir Hugh had thought probable. As to the FAA He had not yet heard from the Admiralty and the reconnaissance Maryland from Malta had not yet returned.

    Late on the twelve Sir Hugh Dowding was informed of the triumph of the navy at Taranto. Basically the heavy units of the Italian navy had been wiped out as a fighting force for some time. Initial analysis of the reconnaissance photographs from Malta had indicated that of the six battle ships anchored in the Mar Grand at Taranto, One was capsized, one was awash and listing heavily to port. Another was heavily down by the bow and aground. Of the other three two were surrounded by large oil slicks and appeared either to be bottomed by counter flooding or riding very deep. The last one appeared to be undamaged though the photo interpretation people were waiting for prints to arrive in the UK as they were intrigued by the shadows cast by this ship in the early morning light. Off the three heavy cruisers in the outer harbour, one showed serious bomb damage aft and another one was listing to starboard, the third appeared untouched. In the Mar Piccolo damage assessment was made difficult by palls of smoke rising from the dock yard and the vicinity of the Destroyer trots. In any event it was an amazing result and no doubt Sir Hugh and Sir Phillip would hear the full story in due course. Sir Hugh had enquired of his brother how bad the losses were, with an audible smile in his voice Sir Arthur replied that only five aircraft of the forty five that actually took part in the raid had been lost and there was a good chance that some of the fifteen missing airman had survived.

    The icing on the cake was that force X had intercepted an Italian convoy in the straits of Otranto and had sunk all four of the merchant ships in it and one of the escort without receiving any significant damage in response.

    Later intelligence analysis would clarify just how much damage the Italian ships had suffered but on an initial perusal, the photographs led the Admiralty to the conclusion that they had total superiority in the Mediterranean for a least three to four months and that as many convoys as possible should be pushed though to both supply Malta and to transit the Mediterranean so as to hurry supplies and materials to Egypt to support operation Compass.
    Analysing the effectiveness of the four Wellington Squadrons was more difficult. However in Both Malta and Egypt senior FAA officers visited the Squadrons involved with sufficient naval rum for enough tots to well and truly splice the Main Brace.
     
    11.07 Defence and Offence (two sides of war)
  • 11.07. Defence and Offence, two side, of war.

    As the recent raid on Taranto had shown it was not just the weight of bombs dropped and where you dropped them that mattered, it was also important to have available the right ordinance to do the most damage to the specific target . Under the auspices of the CSSOAO a number of sub committees had been set up. The Bombsight Committee was chaired by Patrick Blackett, the Bomb Damage Assessment committee, The Bomb Fusing committee and several others were all working on making Bomber Command more effective, whilst some of the Committees analysed enemy action for lessons learnt, others examined practical and scientific opportunities fo improvement, The secret minutes of these committees were circulated to the chairs of all the committees, in this way cross pollination of both thought and effort was maintained. A scientific mind completely dissociated with the problem under consideration often came up with a crucial insight. This kind of cooperate analysis had been a corner stone of the work at AMRE Bawdsey Manor, from the start of the RAF research effort in Cheltenham what had become, the Telecommunications Research Establishment, continued that ethos which had been epitomised by the ‘Sunday Soviets’ and discussions on and around the boundary during cricket matches at AMRS Bawdsey Manor. Upon arrival in Cheltenham in the late summer of nineteen thirty nine ‘Taffy’ Bowen and others had been delighted to be invited to play cricket on the College Fields.

    In the summer evenings of 1940 it was not uncommon to see one or two games in progress in front of the school cricket pavillion with casual observers walking past having no inkling of the secracy of the discusions taking place on the boundry, Here a group might include Alec Harley Reeves, “ Frank “ Edgar Jones, Ronald Victor Jones, discussing Nickerbine and radio navigation, whilst nearby Bernard Lovell, Joan Elizebeth Curran, Samuel Crowe, James Sayers, ”Mark” Olithant and others. Who might be discussing magnatrons, proximity fuses or a myrid other related technicsl subjects. When Sir Phillip visited the TRE, He was unfailingly impressed with the intelectuall talent that had been mobalised from the scientific community . Now in late autumn as the days grew shorter the work on perfecting many of these new systems continued with a quite intensity.

    Shortly after becoming CAS, Sir Hugh had been whisked off to Cheltenham to attend a number of presentations on the work being done at the TRE. Later behind locked doors Sir Phillip and Sir Hugh sat in the office of ‘Taffy Bowen’ whilst R.V. Jones, passed his transcript of the ‘Oslow’ letters to Sir Hugh to read. Having read them Sir Hugh had enquired as to the veracity of their content, Here Sir Phillip stated, was the problem, within certain circles of the British intelligence community, the ‘Oslow Letters’ were seem as being too detailed and wide ranging in their scientific detail of Nazi research and development to be true, these people had therefore dismissed the letters as a plant to mislead the British into wasting time and effort chasing phantom projects.

    R.V. Jones countered by saying that he had as a scientist come to the opposite conclusion. In that the science within the letters, particularly on RDF and other electronics was fundamentally sound. Further all the scientific information was consistent with working practices and methodology of known German scientists and institutions. Summarising the letters R.V. Jones said that the British had been given by a disaffected German scientist a snapshot of German electronic secret research as of early 1940 and that it was being officially ignored by the Intelligence community. In the TRE however it certainly was not being ignored it was informing a lot of the work carried out by 80 wing and at same time the PRU were when possibly try to get photographic confirmation of the activity at some of the sites noted in the letter. As Sir Phillip commented in a war of ‘move and counter move’ having a crib sheet of your opponents moves could be invaluable.

    R.V. Jones concluded, that in his capacity as the Goverments Advisor on Scientific Intellegence it was issential that as the, CAS, Sir Hugh should fully appraised of the contents of the Oslo Letters and the importance of this information, hence the briefing. The discussion then turned to use, by the Luftwaffe of Lorence based electronic bombing aids, these were known as ‘The Beams’ so far the scientists working at TRE and the RAF flying in 80 Wing had managed to identify the frequencies used and had worked out the methodology and expected accuracy. The crudest counter measure available was to simply jamb the tramitters with electronic noise. This would only serve to alert the Gremans to the fact that their wave lengths had been compromised,

    The more sophisticated counter measure was to ‘spoof’ or bend the beams. The beam system known to the Germans as Knickerbien utilised a track beam with its transmitter near Kleve and a cross beam transmitted from Stollberg near the Danish border. By sending a series of dots synchronised to the original German signals it was possible to widen the track beam to such an extent that bombers would fail to lock on and wander on a curve away from the track. As Knickerbien was known as ‘headache’ to the British the counter broadcast system was code named ‘Asprin’.

    The Oslo letter had contained details of a newer and more accurate guidance systems and the scientists at TRE and 80 Wing had been urgently seeking evidence of this new system that bore the name X-Gerat (X-Aperatus). The first use of X-Gerat had been on December 20th 1939 and since then much data had been collected, the new beam frequency had been found at 1500/2000Mhz, this was much higher than the original Knickerbein system at 60 Mhz, therefore giving a far more accurate and narrower beam. Intellegencce intercepts had confirmed that this new beam from a transmitter near Cherbourg had the code name Wesser, with the three cross beams being also named after rivers, namely the Rhine, Oder and Elbe. The Rhine cross beam was the preparety warning line approxemetly thirty kilometres before beam Oder, which was the clock setting line, five kilometres later was the Elbe beam line wich was the clock rundown start line and five kilometres later was the automatic bomb release point. Unlike Knickerbein, X-Gerat was not fitted in every bomber and top secret traffic analysis had confirmed that a bomber unit called KGR 100 was a specialised bomber Kampfgruppe set up to use this system for precision bombing of targets and to mark targets for following bombing waves. By early November much intelligence had been gained, a analysis of a raid by KGR 100 on Birmingham had shown that the majority of the bombs had fallen within a band one hundred meters wide centered on the Wesser Beam with a length spread of just over a furlong, accuracy almost unobtainable by the RAF even in daylight. This came as a shock and revelation to the RAF.

    Having located the guide beams transmitter near Cherbourg the RAF and AM intelligence analysed the band variance for major targets in the midlands. Francis Chichester had made the point that spoofing X-Gerat during attacks on easily located targets such as Liverpool and the Whirrel on the coast would be pointless, but attacks on the industrial complexes around. Wolverhampton. Birmingham, Coventry and Castle Bromwich could be more easily spoofed convincingly by using decoy fires and flares. A number of sites to the south of these targets were selected and quickly prepared as decoys utilising the same equipment and methods as the already existing QF sites for decoy airfields, The spoofing system used to counter X-Gerrat, was to broadcast an artificial and early Elbe signal Only one kilometre after the Oder signal and hence causing the bombs to be automatically dropped some eight kilometres short of the target. For the British the biggest problem here was the Luftwaffe had learnt from the successful jamming of the Knickerbien system, due to how early it was turned on, and were now delaying the transmission of the Rhine, Oder and Elbe lines as long as possible. This therefore gave the counter measure teams a very short time to identify the true Elbe line and Spoof it.
    On the 6th of November the RAF had an intelligence coup, a bomber from KGR 100 was brought down by a night fighter and crash landed on the beach at West Bay near Bridport. Despite the wrecked aircraft being submerged by the rising tide an RAF intelligence recovery team managed to salvage the X-Gerrat equipment. Examination of the apparatus at the TRE quickly confirmed that the working frequency was filtered to precisely 2000Mhz and any jamming signal had to ne very accurately tuned.

    To counter the use of X-Gerrat during the next major raid on the midlands a comprehensive defense scheme had been planned. As soon as intelligence, being signals analysis or intercepts’, indicated that KGR100 were preparing for a raid and the Wesser transmition was detected in the Birmingham target area then the plan would be activated. The Night fighters would be concentrated on the lead element of the raid, this was to intended to disrupt KGR 100 and inflict casualties on it.
    General Pyle at AA command had concentrated as many guns as possible south of the Birmingham Target area to help convince the German bomb aimers that they were truly approaching their designated target, Guns to the north would remain silent unless the true target area was breached. The next phase was general jamming on the 2000Mhz frequency to disrupt the X-Gerrat signal and make accurate bombing more difficult. This Jamming would hopefully also disguise the false Elbe signal and make it harder to counter. Finally false flares, fires and explosions on the ground under the false target point would be set off in a further attempt to convince the following attacking bomber waves to attack the decoy target. The last two kilometres of the bombing run would be on a known track along the beam at a constant altitude. General Pyle organised all the AA guns in the area of the spoof target with the range to engage aircraft on the track to do so. These guns would be director controlled using the new 25cm tacking and ranging RDF systems with their distinctive parabolic aerials designed by Bernard Lovell and his team.

    Sometimes in warfare there is a synchronicity of events that if wtitten in a novel would be decried as unbelievable, the bomber raid on Coventry was one such event. The plan to spoof X-Gerrat had only been finalised on the eigth of of November. All of the various elements already existed and the recovery of a complete X-gerat unit two days earler was the icing on the cake.

    So it was that the raid on Coventry on the night of the eleventh and twelve of November would see the next major confrontation it what had become known at the TRE and in the AM as ‘The Battle of the Beams’
     
    11.08 Springing a trap
  • 11.08 Springing a trap



    It was eight pm on the 14th of November that a Flamingo of Eighty Wing flying up the channel from Lyme Regis to the Needles got a fix on a Wesser beam just east of Swanage , turning north and centering on the beam the team on the Flamingo gathered their data and plotted the aircrafts track, looking at the air chart the navigator was quickly able to strike off a lot of potential targets, the course of four degrees east of true north missed all potential targets until it crossed slap over the middle of the industrial town of Coventry. Unfortunately the beam also crossed the middle of Derby some miles further north. Flying north the Flamingo crew transmitted their findings to it’s controller. Hoping all the time that the Germans would turn on the Rhine , Wesser and Elbe beams early so that they could confirm the target. At fighter Command Keith Park alerted the defences for both cities and started preparing their defense. Eighty Wing tasked two more Flamingoes to patrol lines east of Coventry and Derby to search for the timeing beams so as to try and get as much warning as possible.

    As the location of the Wesser Transmitter was fixed, taking a line from the centre of any potential target bach to the transmitter location would provide the RAF with the attack track for any given target. By using these known tracks RAF QF sites had in the previous weeks been moved so that there was one on the track line of most the principle targets identified. The QF site for Coventry was just a couple of miles north of Warick and the one for Derby was in the Trent Vally to the East of Burton on Trent. Bentley Priory had sent a reddiness message to all RDF stations and night fighter units. Signals intelligence had enambled the location of the airbase from which KGR 100 was operating to be found and the RDF station at Ventnor was tasked with watching for activity at that location. A little after eight pm the Y service reported interception of radio transmitions from AGR 100 aircraft on a bearing consistant with their air field in France. By quarter past eight CH Ventnor was reporting a raid of twenty plus building over the Bay of Sein.
    The two GCI stations at Sopley and Sturminster Newton promply vectored the four night fighters each was controlling to the southern boundry of their RDF coverage over the channel. The intention was to get as many of the night fighters as possible in amongst the AGR 100 aircraft. Park had considered that the biggest problem would be the fear of frataside by the RAF night fighters and clear instructions had been given to positively identify the target aircraft before engaging.
    To the north Cricklade GCI station also moved their four night fighters south to orbit the southern GCI stations. Generally those GCI stationtrs close to the Wesser beam but not having coverage over it prepared to send their fightesr south to feed in behind the initial interceptors as they moved north. Co ordinating no less than eight night fighters via two GCI stations onto a single twenty aircraft formation was a daunting task. A method had been worked out and practiced beforehand. Sopley would feed in it’s first fighter from the East of the target track, Sturminster Newton would then feed in it’s first fighter from the west one minute later, then another minute later Sopley would feed in it’s second fighter from the east, So in the space of eight minutes all the fighters would be closing on the enemy formation. However if the enemy formation was making around two hundred and forty miles an hour (a fast cruising speed for an HE 111) they would be crossing the GCI station area at some four miles a minute, with an average cover of one hundred and twenty miles diameter, this gave the GCI operator at most half an hour to achieve interception or hand the night fighter onto the adjacent GCI unit.
    The Fighter Command OR had also been working hard with the GCI operators to devise the most effient way to feed new fighters into an attack on a single formation of a bomber stream. Tonight the initial assault was being treated tactically as a single unit attack but the follow on bombers coming in behind KGR100 would be attacked as a bomber stream. This would be a test of these new operational procedures. As in the daylight battle park was willing to innovate in the field in order to gain advantage.

    Back at Bentley Priory Sir Keith Park was sitting on the gallery watching the attack unfold on the big plotting table map below and occasionally making comments for one of his aides to either make a note of, or pass on to someone else. Within twent ymiutes the first bombers in KGR 100 were approaching the Cricklade GCI boundry. One fighter fom Sturminster Newton was in contact with an He 111 and preparing to open fire, just a litte to the east a flash of cannon fire showed where a Sopely controlled NF was engaging, a second Sopley fighter was being handed off t Cricklade control as it closed onto its assigned contact. The third Sopely controlled NF had broken of it’s attack when it’s IR transponder malfunctioned and a Sturminster Newton NF started stalking them instead off the He111 it was being vectored onto. Luckily the lack of IR response from the Sopley controlled fighter was noted quickly enough by the GCI operators there to warn both crews to disengage.

    As KGR 100 entered the area controlled by Cricklade GCI there was a flurry of activity at Bentley Priory as tapes were stretched across the plotting table from the German ground station emitting the cross track beams. One of the Eighty Wing Flamingoes had got the scent and with the second one vectored south to confirm the beam bearings, they were now being plotted on the situation map at Bentley Priory. The newly plotted beams crossed the bomber track to the south of Coventry indicating that that city was the target. On Park’s instruction the relevant radio units of Eighty Wing began their part of the nights operation by broadcasting their fake cross track beams. Meanwhile the QF sites near Warwick were alerted ready to respond to bombs dropping in their vicinity.
    Here there had been a disagreement within Fighter Command as to the right tactic to employ if none of the KGR 100 aircraft bombed on the false beams, were the QF sites to activate any way to try and confuse the following bomber stream. One school of thought was that the QF site in these circumstances should wait until KGR 100 did drop their flares and bombs, as then the QF sites would be able to mimic the flare colours. There was the risk that this delay would mean that the first of the bomber stream aircraft had already past the Q sites before the decoys were activated. Keith Park at Bentley Priory had listened to the arguments and had decided that unless he gave the order based on the track plot being kept at Bentley Priory the QF Sites would only activate if KGR 100 dropped on the spoof beams. If only part of KGR 100 dropped on decoy site then the QF site would Mimic the flares and keep them burning.

    Sir Hugh and Sir Keith were keenly aware that the concerted effort to baulk this raid would almost invariably cause the Luftwaffe to realize that, like Nickerbein, X-Geriat had been discovered and countermeasures taken. In keeping with Sir Hugh’s long held dictum that ‘the bomber must not get through’ Sir Kieth Park was committing all the resources of Fighter Command including Eighty Wing and the development flight of TRE into the nights operations.
     
    11.09. Bombs, Bombers and the Bombed
  • 11.09. Bombs, Bombers and the Bombed

    Maud Settle had headed off for the short half mile walk to her night shift in the Coventry Ordinance factory in time to be there for the start of her twelve hour night shift at eight that evening. She left her younger sister Rose sitting at the kitchen table doing her home work and revising hard for her exams. Maud had hardly reached her work bench and started assembling the first of her quoter of six inch shell fuses, when the air raid sirens started their dreadful wailing. With a muttered ‘not again’ Maud quickly replaced her tools in their storage places and headed for the works bomb shelter. Maud hoped it would not be a long raid as she ducked through the blackout screen and into the dank concrete shelter.
    Back at the house in Strathmore Avenue Maud’s parents and sister also heard the wail of the siren. Both Rose's parents had only just got home from their shifts her father was an engineers with English Electric and her mother worked in the doping shop making wings for Anson aircraft. Grabbing their things all three headed into the garden, Roses father , listened , not hearing the un-synchronised throb of German bomber engines He suggested to his wife and daughter that they had time to make the public shelter a couple of streets away rather than use the rather damp and unlit Anderson shelter in the garden. As they walked quickly down the avenue they saw the flash of AA fire in the sky to the south off them, something they had not seen in any of the earlier raids on Coventry. Just as they reached the shelter the sky a few miles to the south was illuminated by strings of flares shortly followed by the sudden flash of exploding bombs.
    Pausing to watch the explosions Rose glimpsed a string of flashes crossing the sky between her and the flares, as quick as they appeared the flashes were gone, but there remained a faint glow that slowly transformed into a flaming streak that painted a curving course earth-woods. As Her father uttered “that's done for one of the bastards”, Rose watched in fascinated horror as the aircraft with its doomed crew of men probably little older than her, silently prayed that some had got out. With the sound of aircraft engines now clearly audible the family hurriedly entered the shelter and settled down to wait the raid out. All around them were other family groups who were similarly making the best of it.

    Rose struggled to concentrate on the textbook she had brought with her. She was not helped by the dimness of the light and the occasional tremor from an exploding bomb transmitted through the earth . She was thankful that tonight at least there were no bombs falling close enough to their shelter to really shake. Being only half a mile from the city centre and in a area surrounded by war industries , railways and of course the major London road made here feel very vulnerable. Despite this fear Rose later fell asleep and only woke when her mother shook her and told her that the ARP wardens had announced that the all clear was sounding. Exiting the shelter in the predawn dark Rose noticed the glow of a couple of fires to the north near the city centre. Turning the other way to look south there were more indications of bomb damage but it all looked fairly small compared to the fires they had seen in Birmingham to the west just a couple of weeks earlier. Heading home to try and grab a couple of hours proper sleep before she had to go to the Grammar school, she new the boys would be full of all the nights alarms and explosions.

    Some miles to the south as that dawn broke the men at the QF sites finally stood down, Most had spent the night in their shelters but some had had to venture out out to set fires on adjust the fuel supply to make more or less flames. Others were watching for marker flares and then trying to mimic them with the ones they had ready. One man laughed at the dark humour expressed by his “Oppo” in that very few other people considered that the more bombs that fell on them the better their work had been! By that measure they had had a very successful night as every where they looked was pockmarked with craters of the black scars on incendiary bombs, A copse adjacent to the QF site had been half flattened evidence of one of the large Luft-miens the Luftwaffe were using.

    Not far away on the other side of the copse was an AA battery that had also had a busy night. There they were counting their blessing as thy stacked the empty shell cases that the Luftmein had been no closer, as it was the site had been buffeted hard by the blast. That blast wave had caused the RDF boffins to carefully check their aerials and equipment for damage. ‘Taffy Bowen might have banned his fellow scientists from flying trials, only permitting more junior technicians to do so and only if the equipment used had already been replicated. This was to prevent the loss of vital and possibly unique prototypes and of essential scientific personnel. When test flights were permitted then only a single observer and maybe a junior scientist were authorised. However on the ground there were no such restriction and on this night a team from TRE, who being based at Cheltenham did not have far to travel had arrived by arrangement at the AA site the day befor with a lorry fitted with a new version of the twenty five centimetre tracking and ranging RDF units bur more importantly as far as Bernard Lovell was concerned was the fact that the unit was fitted with the latest of his parabolic, and cheese slice aerials. By setting up close to the Batteries RDF unit they would be able to directly compare the effectiveness of this new system with the Batteries existing one point five meter wave length one. By having scientist observing both sets of RDF instruments, taking notes and talking to each other by headsets much data was gathered. Getting some of the Batteries RDF operators to use the new system under operational conditions was a really important part of the exercise and had been proposed by the Operational Research Team when they first got an inkling that Lovell was going into the ‘Field’ so to speak. At TRE the expression “going into the field” had special meaning, as it was not just a statement of fact but of expectation, as it harked back to the successful Daventry experiment early in 1935 from which all RDF development had sprung.

    Benard Lovell and A.D. Blumlein were not the only TRE people busy that night. Down at Staverton airfield earlier that evening a team had been fussing around an unusual black painted aircraft. It was not just its tricycle undercarriage that made it different from the other night fighters on test there.The G for Guard painted on its’ matt black fuselage marked it out as something special. The Aircraft was a North American Havock, originally ordered by the French as a medium bomber but taken over by the RAF when France fell. One problem with these early Havok ones was that being ordered by and built for the French Armee D L Aire, all their instruments were in metric units and their throttle levers were reversed, so that the pilot pulled them back for more power. The TRE test flight had in this case solved that problem by simply using a Polish pilot who had flown in France. The fact that prewar “Ski” as he was known had been a wireless technician was helpful as well. It was however one of the technical people from TRE ,a lover of Shakespeare, who had named the aircraft ‘Wardog’ which was now proudly painted on both sides of the nose. It was the nose that really made this aircraft special for it housed behind a Plexiglas dome the first airborne axially scanning antenna on a twenty five centre meter waveband AI set. Nestling in the bomb bay with their barrels passing either side of the front undercarriage were the four 20 mm cannons with which the aircraft was armed. Alongside the RDF sets in the fuselage was the aircraft's truly secret weapon, a receiver designed and built to locate the X-Gerait beams. This receiver was on loan from 80 Wing and came complete with its own operator. The plans was to sortie when 80 Wing found an active beam and fly out over the Channel, there the Ventnor Chain Home would talk them onto the Luftwaffe bombers as they approached the beam line. Being able to follow the beam line using their of X-Gerait receiver the plan was that the twenty five centre meter would then be able to pick up and guide them onto an enemy bomber in the bomber stream. an important addition to the aircraft's electronic suite was a IFF receiver that should prevent them from attacking one of their own night fighters. All the PPI stations had been briefed about “Wardogs” flight plan were therefore aware that if they got a second ‘Crown of thorns’ on their PPI screens closing on one of their own night fighters then they would need to warn the crew of “Wardog” or the other fighter as necessary. One of the objects of the nights test flight was to investigate if this was a viable tactic for getting more night fighters into the bomber stream than could be sustained by the GCI/PPI system on its own. The Pilot of “Wardog” had named this tactic ‘Widdog’ which in his native Polish translated as ‘dziki pies’ which to his English comrades sound like he was saying “dizzypies” so that was the term they used for this sortie type.

    Analysis of the RDF traces and of “Wardogs” crews debriefing and flight records showed that they detected no less than five potential targets in the stream once they had got into and were embedded in the bomber stream, They had fired on two contacts, one hastily as the target bomber had fired at them, the other was a more deliberate attack and hits were claimed but no visible evidence of damage done was observed. Two of the other contacts were persuade but lost and one was broken of when Cricklade GCI/PPI informed them that they appeared to be stalking one of their own fighters. Real positives from the nights efforts were the range at which the twenty five centimetre set was able to lock onto the targets aircraft, the minim range was also better than the one point five meter AI Mark IV.The real star of the night had been the cloned X-Gerait receiver that had enabled the Eighty Wing technician to bring them into the bomber stream time and time again without outside assistance.

    Though much damage had been done to Coventry, there was no wholesale destruction or great fire as there had been in the east end of London. The Historic old city centre had got off lightly with some important buildings destroyed by bombs. The Cathedral had some of its ancient stained glass windows blown in by a Luft Mien that landed a couple streets away. Luckily no incendiaries actually landed on the Cathedral and those that did land within the precinct were dealt with by ARP Wardens and the Auxiliary Fire-brigade who stayed on fire watch throughout the raid. Civilian casualties had been unfortunately high due to a direct hit on a street shelter.

    Back at their house in Strathmore Avenue, Rose was getting ready to walk to the Grammar school as her parents were getting ready to leave together for their shifts. Maud had not come home yet and Rose surmised that she was doing some overtime to try and help recoup some of the production lost due to the air raids.
     
    11.10 Training and Preperation or even the lack there off
  • 11.10 Training and Preperation or even the lack there off.

    Next on the agenda for aircraft allocation was Training Command. Here again they reviewed the aircraft currently being used, what future requirements might be and how to fulfil them.

    Current training aircraft composed the following single engine types (in the UK)

    De Haviland Tiger Moth abinitio

    Miles Magister abnitio

    Miles Master, advanced trainer

    Miles Kestral, Advanced trainer, fighter.

    Twin engine training aircraft.

    Airspeed Oxford, Twin engine trainer, navigation, radio and bomb aiming

    Avro Anson, Twin engine trainer, gunnery, observer, radio, Army co-operation and OTU’s.

    Ansons were currently being shipped to Canada for the Empire training scheme but a note on the file stated that construction in Canada was being set up and he first aircraft from this new production source should be ready by early 1941.

    North American Harvard trainers were being supplied from the USA for the Empire Training schools in

    Canada, thereby replacing the demand from the UK for the Miles Master. The question of which aircraft to send to South Africa and Rhodisia as an advanced trainer was a bone of contention. Miles at Miles aircraft candidly stated when asked, that production of \miles Masters and derivatives from it for UK usage would use up all the production capcity they had. Exporting masters to Africa would probably result in the need to ship Harvards to the UK in their place. Also Miles stated that until trials were conducted he was no able to confirm if the wooden structure of the Miles Master was suitable for use in the climate of South Africa and Rhodesia. Based on these observations and after talks with the Ministery of Supply the decision was made to ship Harvards directly to South Africa and thence on wards to Rhodesia as required.

    Progress had been made since the start of the war with all the ad-hoc and obsolete aircraft types pressed into service during the period of rapid expansion prewar having now been replaced with purpose built training aircraft.
    However there was still a shortage of aircraft and the further transfer of obsolescent aircraft to Training Command would be a way of alleviating those shortages in the short term.
    The last few months had seen a great expansion in the number of OTU units, Particularly in Bomber Command where the new four engine aircraft and their larger crews had been putting a strain on the operational Squadrons as they had found themselves having to supply ‘on the job training’ to the new crews joining them. This insistence on more OTU’s by Ludlow Hewitt as AOC Bomber Command had not been well received by Churchill. Careful briefing by Sir Phillp as AM and now Sir Hugh as CAS was beginning to bring the Prime Minister around to the fact that this investment in the future of Bomber Command was a necessity would bear fruit in time.

    It was just not Pilot training that had expanded rapidly, aircraft were required for Navigation training, Bomb aiming, Air to air Gunnery, and many other skills. Training Command was also responsible for ground training of aircrew and all other trades within the RAF. Training Command additional had the task of providing the training for Sixty Group, which meant accommodating a whole new branch of training. Here an additional problem was the secrecy surrounding RDF and the tendency in the early days of RDF for recruiters to tour the various Training Command electronic and radio schools and siphon off the very best pupils! With suitably pragmatic approach from Sir Hugh Dowding SAO of Fighter Command an accommodation had been reached beweent Training Command and Sixty Group that smoothed 'ruffled feathers' and in future avoided ‘Toes being stood on’.

    Just as Sir Hugh Dowding took over as CAS another urgent training issue occurred and that was for RAF Bomb Disposal officers. The primary organisation for the defusing of un-exploded bombs were the Army's Sappers but both the RAF and the Navy required their own Bomb Disposal Teams, The RAF were principally responsible for bombs that fell on airfields and those left on crashed aircraft, the Navy tackled bombs on ships and Admiralty installations as well as mines (whether or not they were on land) with everything else left to the Sappers. The pressing nature of the problem was brought home to both Sir Phillip and Sir Hugh when they were informed that in September 1940 no less than two thousand un-exploded enemy bombs were reported in the first twenty days of September. Such numbers totally overwhelmed the existing Bomb Disposal teams of all three services and rapid expansion was necessary. Also with at this time the life expectancy of a Bomb Disposal Officers in the field was a scant ten weeks replacement were always required.
    The need for better training and equipment was manifest and urgent. Here Training Command had helped to fill the breach by instructing Sappers in bomb disposal at No1 Air Armament School, RAF Mamby in Lincolnshire. Between the formation of the first twenty, Sapper bomb disposal sections in May of 1940 these had grown exponentially to two hundred and twenty sections by the end of July. All these men needed, not only training and equipment but also organisation into Company units of ten sections, each section consisting of, an officer a Sargent and fourteen other ranks. Sir Hugh had admitted to himself that as the Air Minister he had failed to appreciate the necessity for a properly trained organisation to deal with un-exploded bombs or UXB’s as they were called. All the indicators had been there in the reports coming back from Spain, where it was estimated that one in ten bombs did not explode . Sir Phillip had remarked to his permanent sectary that if one tenth of the preparations made for a gas attack had been spent on Bomb disposal then there would not have been such a panic.

    The disruption to production transport and daily life was in many ways greater due to un-exploded bombs than that caused by the ones that did exploded. Since the early days of the war one of the most feared un-exploded bombs was the Luftmine.

    On the 17th of November after attending meetings at Castle Bromwich Sir Phillip had stopped in Coventry to see the damage for himself. Whilst there he had also visited a Bomb Disposal unit at work. Walking past the large UXB sign at the end of the street had sent a shiver down his spine but that was nothing to the effect of the large black mass of the Luftmine hanging off the gable end of a half ruined house, that he observed through a pair of binoculars from what was deemed to be safe distant. The sight of the Naval Bomb Disposal Officer calmly removing the fuse from the one ton mine, left Sir Phillip speechless with admiration. Looking around Sir Phillip had noted that the Army Bomb Disposal teams trucks carried the legend ; Inspectorate of Fortifications and Directorate of Bomb Disposal, shown as IF&DBD painted on the vehicle doors. It was from this that the army bomb disposal teams got their nickname of the ‘Ifs and Buts’ .
    Sir Philips last stop of the day was at the QF site and AA battery to the south of the city. There sight of the blasted wood left little to the imagination regarding the destructive power of the large German Luftmines.
     
    11.11 They who contol the Sea control the World
  • 11.11. They who contol the Sea controlsthe World.

    Maritime Command.

    In order o carry out the myriad tasks assigned to this command the requirement was for a wide variety of aircraft.

    In the long range maritime patrol role were the following types:-

    Short Sunderland, flyingboat, Short Stirling, land plane. Blackburn B20, seaplane/flyingboat. Supermarine Stranraer, flyingboat Consolidated Catalina, flyingboat

    Medium range Maritime patrol aircraft.

    Vickers Wellington, Armstrong Whitworth Whitley. Supermarine Walrus, De Haviland Flamingo, Lockheed Hudson. Dutch Fokker TVIII float planes.

    Strike Aircraft,

    Blackburn Shark, Fairey Swordfish (on loan from FAA). Bristol Beauforts.



    What was immediately apparent to Sir Hugh was the lack of offensive aircraft to carry out attacks on enemy shipping, whilst all the patrol aircraft were armed this was primarily with anti submarines weapons. Whilst he Beaufort was a competent torpedo carrying aircraft it was limited in its weapon load and lacked the speed and manoeuvrability to survive in contested airspace. Further due to the commitment of Bristol aircraft to the production of the Blenhiem and the Beaufighter, as well as the fact the the Alvis Pelides had to be substituted for the Bristol Taurus, when that engine was cancelled, the Beaufort had been seriously delayed into production and was now very much a Cinderella aircraft in regard to the allocation of production resources. In the short term a substitute aircraft was required to make up the numbers until a dedicated maritime strike aircraft was available.

    Sir Hugh noted that the performance of the Hadley Page Hampden was not far off that of the Beaufort and also that the Torpedo school at Gosport and Lee on the Solent had recently finished torpedo dropping trials and operational parameters for the Hampden. So as an expedient Sir Hugh Suggested that some if not all new Hampdens be built fitted for torpedo dropping and allocated to Maritime Air Command until more suitable strike aircraft could be procured. Also of note was that the Beaufighter was currently undergoing trials at Gosport as a torpedo carrier and the certification for fitting rockets to the same aircraft would soon be completed. These developments had led to a request from the AOC Maritine Command for an allocation of Beaufighters as a strike aircraft as soon as was viable, As CAS Sir Hugh had endorsed this request and after further consultation with Sir Phillip, he had also confirmed that the priority with the MAP for LRMPA for Maritime Command.

    The Royal Canadian Air Force were providing aircraft where possible. Most notably a Squadron of Supermarine Stranraer aircraft currently flying from bases in Nova Scotia. Other Canadian maritime squadrons were being raised. The obsolescent Stranraer aircraft would be replaced by the Consolidated Catalina seaplane as they became available.



    Maritime command Order of Battle as of November 1st 1940


    1 November 1940

    No. 15 Group RAF (GR), under command of Air Commodore R.G. Parry, DSO

    Squadron Type of Aircraft Station

    No. 48 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Hooton Park

    No. 209 Squadron RAF Blackburn B20 RAF Pembroke Dock

    No. 217 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF St Eval

    No. 236 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF St Eval

    No. 321 (Dutch) Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Carew Cheriton

    No. 502 (Ulster) Squadron RAF Short Stirling RAF Aldergrove

    No. 10 Squadron RAAF Short Sunderland RAF Pembroke Dock

    No. 16 Group RAF (GR), under command of Air Vice Marshal J.H.S. Tyssen, CB, DSO[10]

    Squadron Type of Aircraft Station

    No. 22 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF North Coates

    No. 53 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Detling

    No. 59 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Thorney Island

    No. 206 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Bircham Newton

    No. 220 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Thornaby

    No. 235 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Bircham Newton

    No. 500 (County of Kent) Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Detling

    No. 608 (North Riding) Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Thornaby



    No. 17 Group RAF , under command of Air Commodore T.E.B. Howe, CBE, AFC[10]

    Squadron Type of aircraft Station

    Torpedo Training Unit Bristol Blenheim RAF Abbotsinch

    No. 2 Operational Training Unit Bristol Blenheim/Avro Anson RAF Catfoss

    No. 3 Operational Training Unit various RAF Chivenor

    No. 1 Coast Artillery Co-operation Unit Bristol Blenheim RAF Detling

    No. 2 Anti-Aircraft Co-operation Unit various RAF Gosport

    No. 1 (Coastal) Operational Training Unit RAF various RAF Silloth

    No. 3 School of General Reconnaissance De Haviland Flamingo RAF Squires Gate

    No. 4 Operational Training Unit various RAF Stranraer



    No. 18 Group RAF (GR), under command of Air Vice Marshal C.D. Breese, CB, AFC

    Squadron Type of Aircraft Station

    No. 42 Squadron RAF Bristol Beaufort RAF Wick

    No. 98 Squadron RAF Short Stirling RAF Kaldadarnes

    No. 201 Squadron RAF Short Sunderland RAF Sullom Voe

    No. 204 Squadron RAF Short Sunderland RAF Sullom Voe

    No. 210 Squadron RAF Short Sunderland RAF Oban

    No. 224 Squadron RAF Lockheed Hudson RAF Leuchars

    No. 233 Squadron RAF Lockheed Hudson RAF Leuchars

    No. 240 Squadron RAF Blackburn B20 RAF Stranraer

    No. 248 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Dyce

    No. 254 Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Dyce

    No. 320 (Dutch) Squadron RAF Blackburn B20 RAF Reykavick

    No. 612 (County of Aberdeen) Squadron RAF De Haviland Flamingo RAF Dyce



    No. 200 Group RAF (Coastal), under command of Group Captain A.D. Rogers, CBE, AFC

    Squadron Type of Aircraft Station

    No. 202 Squadron RAF Blackburn B20 RAF Gibraltar



    As off this time Maritime Command has thirty two operational squadrons and six OTU’s
    Sir Phillip and the Air Ministry were only too well aware that Maritime Command would need many more squadrons to fulfil all the tasks expected of it.
     
    11.12 Sheep Dogs do not have to Kill Wolves
  • 11. 12. Sheep dogs do not have to kill wolves
    The Blackburn B20 Buccaneer was lying moored to a buoy in Reykjavik harbour as the RAF launch sped towards it, the aircrew huddled in the cabin sheltering from the biting wind conversed as well as they could in their native Dutch, over the roar of the launches engines. Ahead of them sat the Blackburn B-20 flying boat of three twenty (Dutch) squadron RAF with it’s distinctive hydraulically retractable central hull float and the vertical ‘stickleback’ aerials of the ASV RDF system on top of the fuselage. Within minutes the launch was alongside the pontoon float as the launch’s crew used boat hooks to hold it in place. The aircraft crew quickly disembarked from the tender onto the aircraft pontoon, walked forward and climbed the ladder under the cockpit, below which was painted the aircraft/s name; ‘Notenkraker’.
    As the launch stood by a few yards away the crew sorted themselves out and prepared to start the two big H24 Fairey Monarch engines. With both engines running and the counter rotating propellers now nothing more than a dark whirling blur, the front gunner-bomb aimer scrambled down the ladder and cast off the buoy before scurrying hurriedly back up into the fuselage. After the pilot had waited for the aircraft to drift clear of the mooring, he slowly opened both throttles and taxied the seaplane towards the tender. The coxswain of the tender led the aircraft out into the harbour, to that section used for take offs. Opening the launches throttles the coxswain took the tender down the take of run whilst all hands on deck scrutinised the water for flotsam and jetsam or any other obstruction that might impede or even cause serious damage to the big aircraft. As the launch got far enough away to clear the take off run, a green flare was fired to signal the all clear and to also warn all other craft that an aeroplane was about to take off.

    With both throttles wide open the B20 surged forward in a burst of spray that receded as she rose onto the step and planed across the water. Even with a full load the aircraft was soon airborne and the float was retracted back up to the fuselage where it was locked in place. Climbing steadily the aircraft headed almost due south for the long run out to the patrol area.
    With a cruising speed of two hundred and fifty miles an hour and a top speed of over three hundred miles an hour the advantage of the aircraft's design was evident. Today’s patrol would take them some five hundred miles out into the Atlantic where they would fly a patrol pattern around an out bound slow convoy for four hours before turning back for the long run home. The engineer would have a busy time of it, transferring fuel from tank to tank or changing which tanks were being used to keep the trim of the aircraft within reasonable limits.
    Later as the aircraft got lighter and they arrived at their patrol area the engineer would be shutting down one side of each engine in turn to conserve fuel, which is why either the mid upper gunner or the tail gunner would give him a spell from time to time. As they approached their assigned search area the crew settled down to their tasks with the Navigators constantly updating the dead reckoning position on the chart, the radio operator scanning the convoy frequencies and the RDF operator watching for returns upon his oscilloscope screen. Meanwhile all the gunners would be scanning the water and horizon with their binocular, looking for those things that the RDF could not spot, wreckage, oil, life rafts and ships boats even, or the wake of a submarine.
    This far north in November the days were incredibly short, so daylight was not to be wasted, later as darkness encompassed the crew they would have to rely upon the unseen magic of the RDF in their hunt for the elusive u-boats. The young Dutch RDF operator sat in front of the cathode ray screen of the ASV MkII LR set as the aircraft climb away from Iceland and tuned the set using the shipping around the harbour as targets to adjust the gain and other settings, first using the forward antenna to search for a target ahead in the aircraft’s track, soon he had got a response on the Cathode ray screen, A spike appeared on the left hand side of the axis line that went vertically up the screen from the sea clutter at the base line, This afternoons sea conditions were good so the sea clutter was nor swamping the screen and the target was acquired at a good range. Measuring up from the base line the operator calculated the range at close to nine thousand yards. On the intercom the RDF operator asked the skipper if he had a small steamer or warship fine on his port bow. With the aircraft now climbing gently at one hundred and eighty miles an hour it would take barely more than a minute and a half reach the target. The pilot confirmed that they were overtaking an out bound corvette so the RDF operator responded that he would now calibrate the side scanning aerials. On either side of the fuselage were a set of transmitter aerials and along the dorsal crest of the fuselage a single set of receiving aerials on aerodynamically shaped posts. It was these support posts that gave this system its nickname ‘Stickleback’, when their instructors had told him where the name came from the RDF operator had thought that it was typically British.
    With the side scan turned on the transmission of the one point five meter waveband alternated from one side of the aircraft to the other, sending pulses out capable of detecting a ship to a range of twenty or thirty miles but really only capable of detecting a surfaced submarine at around ten miles. As he adjusted the dials the young man mused over how important those figures were, for as they flew around a convoy at a range of ten miles they searched a perimeter twenty miles wide around it, theoretically that was wider than a surfaced submarine could cross before the aircraft completed the circle and made another sweep. He also thought the this ASV MkII LR, the LR standing for long range as it had an improved transmitter with a more powerfully output than previous sets, was also easier to maintain as it was split into separate sender and receiver units unlike the monolithic mark one sets he had trained on. Though still marvelling at the ingenuity and skill of the British scientists who had created this electronic marvel the young Dutchman felt a surge of pride when he thought of the Phillips valves made in his hometown of Eindhoven which made the whole apparatus possible. Having got the RDF set calibrated the young man settled down for long hours of concentration upon the little glowing oscilloscope screen.

    After four hours circling the slow moving convoy, the skipper turned the aircraft north for the long flight back to base. Nothing had been seen by the crew except the occasional reading of the distant convoy on the RDF screen but they knew that their very presence over the convoy was an important part of their task in securing it’s safety.

    The aircraft the Dutch crew was flying in was not the aircraft that Blackburn had first designed, when specification R. 1/36 was first issued for a seaplane capable of cruising at over two hundred and thirty miles an hour most companies declined think that the range and speed requirement was unobtainable. Saunders Roe’s response was to design a conventional deep hulled monoplane but fit it with the two most powerful engines that they could, Despite much promise the ‘Lerwick’, as the aircraft was called, had proved absolutely awful and virtually un-flyable, leading to its immediate cancellation. Blackburn had developed their hybrid design that was half flying boat and half float plane, when compared to the slab sided Lerwick or the bigger short Sunderland, the Blackburn B20 looked like a motor coach beside a double-decker bus.
    In fact in the wind tunnel tests carried out by Blackburn had shown that their design exhibited a fuselage drag some twenty five percent less than the conventional designs proposed. To further reduce drag the wing floats had been designed to fold up and form end plates on the wings. The first prototype had been built fitted for but without both the front and dorsal gun turrets. Also at the design stage the two Rolls Royce Vulture engines of the original proposal which delivered a combined three thousand four hundred and forty horse power had been exchanged for two heavier but more powerful Fairey Monarch engines delivering a combined four thousand horse power. The increase of around twenty percent in the horse power of the engines had more than offset the extra weight. The first prototype, despite some early problems with ere
    aireolong balance and flutter had proved to be very quick and nimble, however the second prototype had lost significant performance due to the increase in drag caused by the fore turret and particularly the dorsal turret. The dorsal turret also caused another issue due to the need for the vertical aerial array for the ASV RDF set interfering with the firing arcs, After much correspondence with the AM and further testing all subsequent production B-20’s were built with a single MG on a ball mount in the nose and removable MG mounts either side of the fuselage in lieu of the dorsal turret, the four gun rear turret was retained. The main offensive armament carried were eight two hundred and fifty pound depth charges in the wing bomb cells. The aircraft the Dutch crew were flying had as always suffered an increase of weight due to extra operational equipment being fitted, again however the performance loss had been mitigated by the use of one hundred octane fuel raising the engine power by about ten percent.

    Just days ago the skipper and crew had stood and watched as the first of the big new Stirling LRMPA’s of ninety eight squadron flew into the newly completed air base at RAF Kaladarnes. They knew that these big aircraft with their very long range and many hours endurance would be a very significant part of providing what was planned as a continuous air cover over the Atlantic convoys. Over the last few weeks as the winter nights had got longer the success of the U-boats now sailing from bases in western France had increased till alarming number of ships were being sunk. Here now with the B-20’s, Sunderland’s, Stirling’s and Flamingos being operated in ever increasing number was a tangible response to that threat. So far the aircraft of Three twenty Squadron had twice made visual or RDF contact with a U-Boat but both attacks had proved unsuccessful. However the crews were honing their skills all the time and were confident it was only a matter of time and perseverance until they managed to sink a U-boat.

    The Young Dutch RDF operator had every intention of getting a tour of one of the Stirlings of Ninety Squadron as soon as he could. He had heard on the grape vine that they were fitted with the very latest 0.25m waveband ASV sets and he really wanted to see what the fuss was about.
     
    Order of Battle of RAF Maritime Command at 02/11/40 tidied up
  • Order of Battle of RAF Maritime Command at 02/11/40 tidied up.

    Coastal Command 02.11.40 List.png

    I didn't include the second-line units in No. 17 (Training) Group.

    This is a summary.

    Coastal Command 02.11.40 Summary.png
     
    11.13 Not Just Bombers and Fighters
  • 11.13 Not Just Bombers and Fighters



    Transport Command, this command had up to now in the current conflict been very much a Cinderella organisation. Now with Churchill, since May, calling for the raising of a large Airborne Force requiring aircraft both for parachutists and glider born units there would need to be a redistribution of resources within the RAF to provide Transport Command with enough air assets to discharge it’s obligations. Again Sir Hugh was aware that Transport Command and getting resources for it, would be a balancing act, which would need to be ‘sold’ to the Ministry of Supply and the other services, as they would in all probability see Transport Command as a low hanging fruit and so easily plucked by denying it resources on the basis that it was not critical to winning the war. He was therefore heartened when he was given a file by Sir Wilfred Freeman On proposals for the supply of aircraft to for Transport Command, the synopsis made for very interesting reading.

    The preamble in the file set out the situation regarding the needs for and potential supply of aircraft for Transport Command.
    In late May and again in early June Churchill had requested the formation of a paratrooper force of at least five thousand men and charged the AM with arranging the transport aircraft for this force. It was obvious from the start that the setting up of a parachute training school for the soldiers would need to be a joint effort by the RAF Training Command and the army. Transport Command would be responsible for the air lift capacity both of parachutists and glider borne troops. Sir Phillip had an immediate problem on his hands and that was that the other commands especially, Bomber Command which was fighting any plans that diverted resources from them to any other command, let alone to what the AOC Bomber Command considered a non-combat command.

    Being aware of this antipathy towards the airborne force Sir Phillip had requested that Freeman seek from the Army the types of aircraft they thought they needed including gliders and training aircraft. Once that exercise was complete then a set of very broad operational requirements could be drafted. After some discussion it was decided to send these OR’s to literally every aircraft constructor with one strict codicil, that any work undertaken on drafting designs to fulfil these OR’s must firstly not interfere with work on any other projects that that company might be currently working on, Secondly any aircraft designed could not use any material including engines that were critical to other aircraft projects. Thirdly production of any of these transport aircraft or gliders could not adsorb any aircraft construction capacity already allocated.


    Those restriction not withstanding Sir Phillip had been surprised to hear from Wilfred Freeman just how many companies and expressed an interest in working up proposals. By early September the Army and the AM had managed to firm up their basic transport aircraft requirements. These were,

    Heavy Transport Aircraft capable of Delivering thirty Six Paratroopers.

    Medium, Transport aircraft capable of delivering twenty four Fully equipped Paratroopers.

    Training Glider Capable of carrying out all stages of glider pilot training.

    Glider Capable of delivering no less than Fourteen fully equipped air landing soldiers or one and a half tons of equipment including small vehicles.

    Glider Capable of delivering no less than twenty eight fully equipped air landing soldiers or three and a half tons of equipment including small vehicles.

    Glider Capable of delivering no less than Forty two fully equipped air landing soldiers or seven tons of equipment including medium size vehicles or one small tank/two Bren gun carriers.

    Any other innovative projects within the original constraints could be submitted for consideration.

    The number of submissions had been surprising. Only a cynic would venture the opinion that fact that this particular requirement had the full backing of the Prime Minister Winston Churchill had anything to do with the number of responses.

    Wilfred Freeman and his team which included the aircraft designer and aeronautical entrepreneur William Stancliffe Shackleton and Dr. Roxbee Cox, who both worked in the Directorate of Scientific Research at the Ministry of Aircraft Production, where they were now assigned to oversee the development of troop- and cargo carrying gliders, had split the submissions into several categories.

    These were; New aircraft, sub divided into Gliders and powered, New aircraft and those based on modified existing designs, Repurposing of obsolescent designs already being built and lastly the seemingly Crackpot! Some company’s had submitted a single proposal and others several covering a number of the OR’s issued. Most of the proposals in the third category of repurposed obsolescent aircraft came from Freeman’s office at the MAP.

    Starting with the T.24/0 Training Glider Submissions had been received from; Slingsby and General Aviation, the Design chosen was from GA and a specification was issued to them for detailed design and production of a prototype. The X.25/40 small glider design chosen was by General aviation disappointingly this was a pure personnel carrying aircraft without a door or ramp for freight. Due to GA being committed to other production projects the construction of the prototypes was given by the MAP to the Slingsby Sailplanes Company. Submissions for the X.26/40 Medium glider had come from several manufacturers but the choice had finally come down to Airspeed A.S.51 or the Miles M. 32 designs. The Airspeed design was chosen for prototype construction partly due to Miles being fully occupied with other powered designs. The large glider design chosen to fulfil the X.27/40 specification was another design by General Aircraft and designated the GAL.49. As this was the largest glider yet specified or designed in the UK it was considered prudent to build a half scale test aircraft, the GAL.50 as a proof of concept.

    It was noted that the scale effect meant that the X.25/40 design had a wingspan of eighty feet and a length of fifty six and a half feet for a capacity of fourteen whereas the X26/40 carried twenty eight on a wingspan of eighty eight feet and a length of sixty seven feet. As the X25/40 was intended as a standby design if sufficiently powerful tug aircraft for the X26/ design were not available it was proposed at this stage to only build four Mk1 aircraft for flight testing only. There was however another intriguing proposal from the Hawkers Group, their proposal was that with the rundown of Hurricane production coming there would be a lot of redundant machinery that had been made to produce the steel tubing and joints used in the steel framed lattice of the aircraft fuselage. Hawkers proposal was to use this machinery and the existing skills base to build a glider for the X25/40 OR. As this was the largest size aircraft practical with the tube sizes used in the Hurricane/ Henley aircraft. Their initial design was for a boxy shaped glider with a thin plywood skin attached to the steel tube frames. The plywood would be covered in canvas/linen and doped. This would help to stiffen the structure and keep it aerodynamically as clean as possible. The high mounted wing would be constructed in the same way and would have a single aerofoil shaped strut from the fuselage base at the undercarriage fitting point to the wings mid span. For cargo carrying it was proposed that the whole tail assembly swung clear to the starboard side. This could be achieved by releasing a series of over centre latches with safety locks and two safety bolts on the port fuselage side. Not a very quick process but achievable in a couple of minutes. Hawkers proposed this glider as they considered it suitable for towing by aircraft such as the Flamingo, Henley and Battle which by their calculations would be unable to cope with the X26/40 size of Glider.

    Hawker X25/40 proposed dimensions and weights.

    Length, -50ft.

    Wingspan, -85ft.

    Hight,- 16ft.

    Wing area, - 900sqft.

    Empty weight,- 4,000lb.

    Useful load, 4,0000lb.

    Max Speed.-150mph.

    Stall speed, - 50mph.

    Whilst being very comparable in size and load to the GA/Slingsby submission the Hawker glider proposal was of interest partly because it would have an estimated towing speed some twenty MPH higher than the Slingsby Glider. This one hundred and fifty mile an hour maximum towing speed would be the same as the two bigger gliders which would greatly simplify formation flying and planning. For these reason Hawkers were given the go ahead to complete detail design work and produce a prototype. There was a strict proviso from the MAP however that they would be monitoring Hawker’s production and any negative effect on production of the Hurricane MkII or the work on getting the Tornado into production would bring instant sanctions on the Hawker Management.

    For powered aircraft Bristols had come up with a project based on their previous Bombay aircraft but with a simplified wing structure and twin Hercules engines. With fixed undercarriage for rough field operations and a big set of clam shell doors at the front the machine could function as a behind the front line transport aircraft or carry forty two paratroopers for which two aft doors were provide for the quick dispatch of the troops. Bristol’s proposed that these aircraft would be built at the Northern island shadow factory. The guiding purpose of the design was for low maintenance in the field and ease of operation, plus the use of as much existing jig and assembly structure from the now disused Bombay production line. Like other Manufactures building front-line aircraft the MAP put stringent conditions upon them regarding their participation in any transport aircraft project,

    Airspeed tendered a powered version of their X26/40 design that utilised a pair of Bristol Mercury engines.

    Likewise GA. put forward a powered version of their X27/40 design but in this case would use a pair of Alvis Pelides engines.

    Miles aircraft submitted plans for no less than three powered aircraft.

    The first was a twin engine aircraft capable of carrying fourteen paratroopers or one ton of cargo. The aircraft had a pod and boom layout with the rear of the pod swinging open to allow loading of cargo and small vehicles into the very boxy fuselage. Powered by twin Gypsy Queen engines of two hundred and fifty horse power each on a span of sixty foot. The second aircraft was an upscaled version of this design with twin Rolls Royce Kestrel engines on a span of eighty five feet. This air craft could carry twenty eight paratroopers had two doors aft of the wing and a clam shell rear section of the pod type fuselage.

    The largest aircraft was based on their X26/40 specification with twin Alvis Pelides engines. Unlike it’s two smaller cousins this aircraft had a more conventional fuselage but with a ramp fitted at the aft end of the load compartment. There was a high set tail plane with twin fins and a fixed tricycle under carriage. Whilst the two smaller aircraft were of mainly alloy construction the larger one was based on tubular steel and plywood. The MAP requested Miles to do a redesign of the two smaller aircraft to build them without using strategic materials. It was accepted that there may be a loss in payload or performance due to a probable increase in weight.

    Existing deigns of powered aircraft that could repurposed for use by Transport command in support of airborne operations as either glider tugs or paratrooper carriers were considered by the AM, these in size order were:-

    The DH Flamingo, troop carrier or tug for X25 size Glider.

    AW. Whitworth, troop carrier or tug for X26 size Glider.

    AW. Albemarle, troop carrier or tug for X26 size Glider.

    HP, Halifax, troop carrier or tug for X27 size Glider.

    Short, Sterling, troop carrier or tug for X27 Glider.

    The big problem for the AM and therefore the MAP would be balancing the production capacity against the needs of the various competing branches of the RAF and the strategic needs of the nation.

    There were additional submissions from several manufacturers for either adapting existing designs as specialised transport command aircraft.

    Armstrong Whitworth put forward no less than three proposals,

    First they proposed reopening the Ensign production line in a shadow factory, this aircraft would fill the roll of a long range transport aircraft capable of carrying up to forty paratroopers in a single lift. The Four Pelides engine used would increase the load capacity and the aircrafts utility as a glider tug.

    Secondly they proposed that it was possible to alter the Whitley with a revised fuselage that could carry up to twenty four paratroopers this was based on adapting the fuselage design of the existing W.23. bomber transport adapted to utilise as much of the Whitley production jigs and extant material as possible. Again, subject to availability this aircraft would be fitted with either RR Merlins or Alvis Pelides engines

    The third proposal was to do the same to the Albemarle but to add a rear access ramp for the loading and unloading of cargo. This aircraft could also swap the Hercules for Pelides engines so as to have a single engine type for use by AW aircraft in Transport Command.


    Hadley Page had proposed a revised version of their Harrow transport aircraft but had withdrawn it on the basis that their resources would be better used by exploiting the unit production system of the Halifax to build specialised transport versions of the aircraft concurrent with the other versions without losing production numbers.

    In the crackpot department were a couple that seemed worthwhile of additional investigation, one of these was the Rotochute a form of one man autogyro instead of a parachute proposed by the Austrain designer Raoul Hafner, to permit the precision insertion of attacking soldiers. Another suggestion was for a modified Westland Lysander being fitted with a Delanne type enlarged tail plane. This would provide fifty percent of the main wing lift and enable the aircraft to fly with a relatively large variance in the CoG. This scheme was to investigate the rapid unloading and the effects of discharging cargo in flight. Both of these proposals were to be investigated and prototypes built.
     
    Top