The RAF ITL cannot always throw strait sixes. Air warfare is at the best of times unpredictable especially with the weather having differing influences on the different protagonists. Also the system is far from perfect and infallible. Whilst Fighter Command ITTL have more squadrons and materially better aircraft there is still the human element. ITTL as the battle goes on even though there are more OTU's there are more squadrons to fill so the problem of inexperience pilots is proportionally still there. Hence I have kept RAF aircraft losses comparable to OTL despite the improvements. In the long term the survival of more experienced pilots due to the earlier adoption of self sealing tanks and armour, even if they injured, will have a qualitive effect on Fighter Command.
As to the Night Fighters, ITTL they are well ahead of OTL but there are still major hurdles to overcome, however on occasional nights serous losses can be inflicted but not without losses to the RAF as well, return fire and the sheer problems of night flying will take a toll of the RAF aircraft and crew.
 
August the 25th

Day Slight activity in morning. Main Raids by Luftflotte 3 in afternoon on south west.

Night Continued widespread attacks. Main concentration the midlands.

Weather Early morning fair. Remainder of day cloudy. (1)

After the previous days herculean efforts on both sides of the channel this morning there was a distinct pause. The Luftwaffe flew some reconnaissance missions and spoof formations gathered over France to keep the RAF guessing as to where the next assault would be delivered. It was not until time for afternoon tea at five o’clock was a raid seen to be building.

The build up was around St Malo at the very limit of the range of the CH stations at Worth Matravers, Branscombe and West Prawle, as the raid came north to the channel island more aircraft were seen to join the formation until as it finally headed across the channel towards Weymouth the raid was judge to be one hundred plus aircraft, As the raid advanced the size was upgraded to two hundred plus as higher flying fighters were seen to rise above the bomber formations.

This was the largest raid yet faced by Ten Group and all three squadrons based at Middle Wallop were scrambled (238 squadron forward based at Warmell were the first off the ground). From Exeter 609 in their Spitfires were sent up the middle of the channel to get up sun of the raid and 213 Squadron were sent to orbit Lyme Regis in case the raid turned east. To the north one of the squadrons at Pembry was brought to cockpit reediness and the other two squadrons put on standby. AT Filton 263 squadron were scrambled to gain height and protect the Bristol Aircraft factory. To the east 601 squadron at Westhampnett was scrambled with both hurricane squadrons at Tangmere being put on standby.

With the raid now estimated at three hundred plus the three Middle wallop squadrons found themselves fighting at odds over Portland and the Dorset coast with an estimated two hundred enemy fighters. The Bomber got through to bomb Warmwell airfield doing considerable damage and leaving a round dozen unexploded or delayed action bombs to be dealt with. Some bombers broke off to attack Pembroke but were roughly dealt with by the Reapers vectored in from Filton, whilst the Squadron on cockpit readiness at Pembry clawed for height as they were sent to guard Pembroke. To the east an escorted splinter of the big formation headed along the coast to Fareham and was intercepted by 601 squadron and chased out to sea over the Nab tower. The final act of this raid was the Spitfires of 609 squadron swooping out of the late afternoon sun as the bomber formation headed south over Weymouth bay.

Less than hour later the Luftwaffe sent another one hundred plus aircraft raid from Cap Gris Nez heading for the Thames Estuary via Dover. Park ordered no less than eleven squadrons to intercept but not all got the chance to engage the enemy as the raid turned back short of the Thames. The controller had great difficulty in getting the Polish squadrons to return to base even though they would not have caught up with the German formation before they regained the French Coast. This incident caused Park to reiterate again is instructions regarding not fighting at a disadvantage of distance and fuel limits.

In the two large daylight engagements the RAF lost sixteen aircraft but more importantly nine pilots dead or missing, the Luftwaffe had lost an estimated fifty aircraft from the claims made.

The battle continued over night with some sixty five separate incursions being plotted. There were attacks from Norway and Demark on fighter airdromes in Scotland beyond the current northern boundary of the GCI network. Within the GCI network at sometime that night every station was handling an interception, conditions were not good for the night fighters with plenty of cloud for the bombers to hide in and dark skies to make it difficult for the night fighter pilots to visually acquire and confirm the enemy aircraft as such. Still four enemy aircraft were confirmed as kills with a further three damaged with one of them rated as a probable.

As the German bombers filled the night skies of Britain, across the North Sea eighty one RAF bombers headed toward Berlin. Despite intermittent cloud the majority of the British bombers managed to find the city and drop their bombs. This raid had been specifically ordered by Churchill as a reprisal for the bombing of London the night before. The RAF bomber force was a mixed bag of Blenheim VI’s, Wellingtons and Hampdens with a few of the bomber version of the Short Stirling thrown in for good measure.

Sir Phillip had opposed this raid when it was discussed in the war cabinet, stating that it was a mere statement and not material to damaging the German preparations for a cross channel invasion. However unlikely such an invasion might be, Sir Phillip was convinced that Bomber Commands priority should be targets directly connected to invasion preparations such as barge concentrations in Dutch, Belgium and French harbours and the Luftwaffe airfields from which cross channel attacks were being launched. Sir Phillip wryly noted the lack of support his opinion had elicited from Portal as head of Bomber Command.

Meanwhile every aircraft from Maritime Command capable of interdicting the barges and small coastal steamers as they moved west from the Rhine and ports further east, that could be spared from other pressing tasks was committed to the nightly campaign. With RN light forces making nightly forays across the southern North Sea and the Channel to inflict confusion and damage on the enemy coastal traffic the need to co-ordinate these attacks to avoid the Maritime Command aircraft attacking friendly naval assets was an ongoing dialogue between the services. One thing was a given though by the Maritime Command aircraft crews and that was that every blighter would fire at them in the dark of the night, recognition signals or not!

(1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster
 

perfectgeneral

Donor
Monthly Donor
Tornedo fuselage construction was of alloy frames with a stressed metal skin rather than the tubular skeleton and canvas covered construction of the Hurricanes and so new skills and methods had to be learnt. Those Tornedos so far completed to service standard were being held at Langley and used for trials, testing and training purposes, so that when the Tornado entered squadron service it would be a mature aircraft with as many flying and maintenance bugs worked out as possible
So the vibration problem will be reduced by a four blade prop. Four 20mm cannon with 200 rounds per gun. What fuel tanks can we expect? Between spar, leading edge, front of cockpit and/or rear of cockpit?

How long before lessons from the P-51 are applied? Tempest wings and a Merideth effect cooling system? Any interest in a naval version?

Will we ever see a heavy fighter with a (big) turbocharger, learning from the Jug/Thunderbolt and Lightning? Turbochargers offer better performance than Superchargers (even multi-stage) above about 22,000ft. Turbochargers need the special alloys that are favoured in jet turbine production, so is this greater demand an obstacle or a market opportunity?

How about 100, 130 and 150 octane fuels for higher boost pressures? Some plant for this near Derry might be just the ticket. Near for logistics, but not easy to bomb. Was Trinidad a better spot? Less tankers or less eggs in one basket?
 
Last edited:
ITTL Tornedo is powered by the Fairey Monarch H24 engine and has two three bladed VP propellers. in August190 this engine is running on 100octane fuel. with two sets of engine gauges and a double throttle much development work is going on to ease the pilot's work load. the twin engine Reaper has been in service for over a year and some of the pilots flying the Tornedo test program have experience on that aircraft. This means that they already have a sound idea of what sort of problems a pilot will face in combat vis a vis aircraft management. ITTL I am trying to think of a reasonable way to get Martin Baker involved in the ergonomics of the aircraft. in OTL the contract for the MB3 with the Sabre engine was signed in August 1940, ITTL the contract would be for a monarch engined version of the design. RR have been help Power Jets with special metals and machining so a turbo charger is not beyond possibility. Fuel layout and every thing else in the Tornedo is as OTL just a change of engine meaning that when the aircraft hits squadron service it will work as advertised.
 
10.21 The Losses Mount To Critical Levels
10.21.The Losses mount to Critical levels.

August the 26th

Day Airfields in Kent and Essex attacked. Bombs on Dover and Folkstone. Raids in the Solent.

Night Wide spread raiding, Targets industrial centres and airfields.

Weather Mainly Cloudy, but dry. Brighter in south but Channel cloudy.



As daylight pushed the dark of night aside Fighter Command and especially Eleven Group was expecting a renewal of the onslaught on the airfields the cloud cover predicted for the day would be considered favourable by the Luftwaffe High Command. RDF on the other hand especially the growing experience of the GCI/PPI stations in tracking multiple raids irrespective of cloud that obscured the view of the Observer Corps was giving the home defence a force multiplying advantage. Unfortunately the GCI/PPI stations were easily located by electronic direction finding and were vulnerable to attack. RAF High Command and the Air Ministry fully expected the stations in southern England to become a priority target of the Luftwaffe any day now. To counter this, rather than complete the coverage of Scotland and Northern Ireland these PPI/RDF units were being held as spair units to be rushed into replace any GCI/PPI station that was knocked out. Also a number or truly mobile systems were being completed, although they had less range than the permanent version and could handle fewer interceptions, they would suffice as gap fillers in the short term.

After the usual series of reconnaissance flights the main attack of the morning commenced around eleven o’clock when one hundred and fifty enemy aircraft took the short route to cross the channel at Dover with the main objectives once again being the sector stations at Biggin Hill and Kenley, Eleven Groups counter of seven squadrons was sufficient to break up the attack and send both the bombers and their escort scurrying for the safety of the occupied coast. In the early after noon the Luftwaffe came again this time with various elements gaining height then coalescing into three formation crossing the channel simultaneously, being reported as sixty plus, twenty plus and thirty plus aircraft from bases of KG2 and KG3, whilst some aircraft threatened Dover yet again the main weight of the attack was directed at sector stations of North Weald and Hornchurch. Various small elements diverged from the main raid to cause diversions in east London. Eleven squadrons were scrambled by Eleven Group in response and despite all four of the PAC spitfire squadron throwing themselves pell-mell into the melee the German bomber succeeded in planting over one hundred bombs onto the sector Station at Debden, despite the best efforts of the Controllers to place their squadron in advantageous interception positions. However good the plots from the GCI/PPI stations in cloudy conditions an entire squadron could fly past an enemy formation with out actually seeing it and by the time the plots were seen as divergent rather than closing, the opportunity for an interception had been lost. With the newer VHF radio system at least there were enough channels available to give the controllers discreet communications with each squadron but unfortunately not all squadrons could talk directly to all the squadrons and this could and did on occasion lead to friendly formation attacking each other despite the use of IFF. What the Controllers saw on the plot and what the airborne pilots saw around them did not always correspond.

The day light raids on this day concluded with a major high altitude attack of one hundred and fifty aircraft on Portsmouth, accompanied by a couple of small diversionary raids attempting to split the defence. Co-ordinating their defensive response eleven group scrambled five squadrons and ten group a further three squadrons. This raid resulted in a protracted and fierce engagement over the Isle of Wight and the waters of the Solent. The bombers from KG55 and their escort were intercepted short of their target and jettisoned most of their bombs into the sea. Within an hour the raid had been turned back but the descending smoke trails and parachutes doting the sky spoke of significant losses to both sides. Once again the pilots of Fighter Command had flown over eight hundred sorties the one engagement over Ports mouth had resulted in two thirds of the entire Fighter Command losses for the day, twenty defending fighters with four pilots dead and no less than twelve wounded to some degree. The Luftwaffe losses totalling fifty aircraft was not sufficient compensation for such a heavy toll.

The night brought attacks on the Midlands industrial centres with diversionary raids spread far and wide, principally targeting air fields. Despite the cloudy skies the night fighter continued to exact a toll of the intruders.

(1) Daily summary quoted verbatim from the The Narrow Margin by Derek Wood and Derek Dempster



August the 27th

Day Reconnaissance chiefly in Portsmouth-Southampton area.

Night Widespread activity industries and airfields from Lincolnshire to Portsmouth.

Weather, Central and east England light rain. Some cloud in Channel and haze over Dover straits. (1)

After the sheer pressure of the two previous days the respite caused by todays weather brought brief if welcome relief to everyone in Fighter Command. Hover there was still work to be done. Very necessary maintenance was undertaken on the RDF stations with some shutting down completely for short periods. These shutdowns had to be as short as possible and seemingly random, for if a pattern was discerned and the enemy could predict an imminent shutdown then a breach in the defence might occur. The lull also gave Sir Keith Parks and Sir Hugh Dowding time to confer and to plan the next moves in the defence of the UK. The continued high rate of pilots loss, greater at current levels than the supply of replacements was of course the most pressing cause for concern, for at the moment it meant that Fighter Command was a wasting asset and eventually would cease to be able to provide a viable defence unless the situation changed. One hope was that the proportionally greater losses inflicted on the Luftwaffe would cause critical damage to it’s ability to prosecute the current campaign strategy before Fighter command lost the battle of defence. One major problem highlighted by the actions of the previous day was the continuing problem of accurately getting the height of enemy formations on cloudy days when observer corps observations were intermittent. Though new dedicated height finding RDF sets were starting to be fielded there were far to few of them at the moment. Where practicable Anti Aircraft command were using their range finding RDF units to provide height data but again in cloudy conditions it was proving problematical to identify formations and get timely information to the plotting centres. To try an improve the information flow Parks issued an instruction that all intercepting squadrons should report the number height and location of an enemy formation when they Gave their ‘Tally Ho’ signal prior to engaging the enemy.

On the morning of the twenty seventh Douglass Bader had requested an interview with Sir Keith Parks. That afternoon Douglass Bader as humbly as it was possible for him do so requested that he be returned immediately to operational flying stressing the fact that every experienced pilot was needed. Sir Keith upon receiving Bader’s request for an interview had sought the opinions of the controllers he had been working with at Uxbridge, specifically if Bader seemed to have learnt how vital it was for the controllers to be obeyed. The response was a qualified yes, Bader however had remained critical of the instructions being given by some Controllers, who he thought lacked a grasp of the tactical element of interception process. However on talking about this to Bader, Sir Keith was pleasantly surprised to hear from the Squadron Leader that he could see that, the controllers instructions had to be followed explicitly, as the controller could see the bigger picture and most importantly the relative movement of all the defending fighters. Sir Keith agreed to return Squadron Leader Douglass Bader to the command of 242 Squadron with a dire warning that a breach of the trust being placed in him by Sir Keith would not be tolerated at all, there would be no second chance.
 

perfectgeneral

Donor
Monthly Donor
There would be no second chance.

I suspect reservations will return to the fore once Bader is operational once more. Ah well. Perhaps he will resort to a letter writing campaign. The losses put his posture into perspective, both for and against. It's important to get this right.
 
So long as he obeys orders letter writing can be tolerated within reason, at least for now. Once the crisis is over Bader may find himself posted to training squadron in Canada.
 

Driftless

Donor
So long as he obeys orders letter writing can be tolerated within reason, at least for now. Once the crisis is over Bader may find himself posted to training squadron in Canada.

I still like the idea of Malaya. Let him raise hell about the state of SE Asia air defence in late 1940.
 
Bader and his advocacy of the 'Big Wing' was in OTL used by senior officers hostile to Sir Hugh Dowding as a Cause Belleu in the ousting of Dowding from Fighter Command in November 1940.
IIRC due to his injuries Bader was deemed unfit for services in hot/humid climates (sweaty stumps could be problematical) so in the PAM if he misbehaves it is likely to be somewhere colder!
With Bader's pet MP silenced by being sent overseas Bader no longer has a conduit for his views to be spread to the powers that be. ITTL without Leigh-Mallory as his CO to promote his ideas Bader is voiceless Dogs Body. Park as his CO has stomped on him as hard as possible without a formal hearing.
 
Last edited:
My knowledge about Bader is limited, why's there so much acrimony towards him here?
A lot of people feel that he was an inveterate self-publicist, insubordinate, and part of a coterie of backstabbers who did in Dowding and Park (hallowed be their names) in order to promote erroneous ideas of how to fight the air war. Many others disagree.

But in general it amuses me how people come up with convoluted ways of getting rid of people on active service by sending them half way round the world, instead of five minutes for a conversation along the lines of “we have a very important task. It’s rather tricky and will need a lot of pluck, and we think you are just the man for the job!”.
 
Last edited:
Putting it nicely, Bader was a stooge (as a useful idiot) used by other more intelligent and devious RAF officers to pursue their own ends. Though I have huge respect for Bader for his achievements as an amputee, I think his ability as a RAF officer has been somewhat coloured by those achievements. As to serving overseas IRTMEP and also note that when working for Shell post war he did have problems with his stumps in south America and South Africa due to the heat IIRC.
 
Or if Bader falls in combat he's made a hero. A true patriot who despite his injuries gave his life to protect King and Country
 
Top